Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

You guys and your guns just lost me.

Posts

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#76

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

robo hippy

Support your right to arm bears!

robo hippy

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#77

Hey Hey Hey

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"So fork over that pic-a-nic basket, Mr. Ranger! Cover'em, BoBo!

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#78

Not Thomas Jefferson

wilbur

That quote was from Robert Heinlein.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#79

Re: Not Thomas Jefferson

David Churnega

Thanks for the correction.

Still an unalienable right I will retain.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#80

Re: Not Thomas Jefferson

Bob Macgregor

Its not quite as inalienable as you might think. From Bill's description, Maryland has put some pretty serious restrictions on bearing loaded arms. Also, I'm pretty sure that even the NRA doesn't object to certain limits on firepower...say, hitting the freeway with your full-dress Sherman tank with 30cal and 50cal machine guns and 75mm main turret gun, to help encourage smooth traffic flow, er, defend against potential tank-jackers or (other) people with road rage.

At the time the right to bear arms was put into the US constitution, muzzle-loading muskets and pistols were state-of the art (since cannon were too bulky/heavy/awkward to "bear"). Science and technology move on, however, but the wording of the constitution in this regard is both inflexible and generic; it doesn't attempt to specify any restrictions on type of arms that may be borne.

Firearms technology advances create seriously dangerous weapons that inevitably end up in the hands of bad guys. Sure, a pocket knife, a bowl gouge or a tire iron can be a lethal weapon, but, if you want to defend yourself against somebody armed with a projectile weapon, especially a semi- or fully-automatic one, you'd really better not count on using a tire iron. On the other hand, if you are accosted by somebody with a club or knife, its nice to have superior weaponry at hand; I don't think fairness and equality (a level playing field of armament) are legitimate concerns in a self-defense situation.

Its an inevitable arms race that the framers of the constitution couldn't foresee, but really (IMO) couldn't have done anything about even it they had been able to forsee the course of weapons development...so its been up to legal challenges and the Supreme Court to decide where it is legitimate to draw the line in bearing arms.

Arming bears is whole 'nother issue which I think is (so far still) outside the purview of the Court.

BOB