Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

You guys and your guns just lost me.

Posts

You guys and your guns just lost me.

#1

You guys and your guns just lost me.

Russ Fairfield

Thanks to all of the gun packers for identifying yourselves. Now that I know who you are, I know who to avoid. I don't trust people who feel they have to carry a gun, and I chose to avoid people who have the potential to kill me. Saying you will never use the gun doesn't make me feel any safer being around you.

Sorry guys, but you lost me on this one.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#2

I'm lost too

Jerry Hall

Sport is one thing, packing is another. Was well trained in the military, but as a civilian got thru most of eight decades without ever wishing I had been carrying. In tough towns and good. Clearly others mileage must have varied. Never met any one tho who felt they had been saved by packing. I am sure it has happened tho. I try to pack common sense wherever I go. Fear can be a frightening thing :\

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Mike Stafford

I wish it were the case that I did not feel the necessity of carrying a gun but where I live crime is the local sport.

I have the unfortunate distinction of having known six people who have been murdered including an uncle who was only 2 years older than me. I have seen the devastation that results from being a victim. I witnessed the murderer's execution. He had been in prison 13 times previously. Life imprisonment does not mean life imprisonment. Recently almost 200 lifers were determined as being worthy of release after only 20 years in the penitentiary. My uncle is dead forever.

I have been the victim of property crimes twice and mugged once. In the case of the mugging the muggers went to the hospital. Our church has been burglarized and its heating system destroyed for $20 worth of copper.

Unfortunately we have people who practice home invasions as a sport and have shootouts in the mall. People are attacked in public places for looking in the wrong direction at someone.

If you are fortunate enough to live somewhere that is safe consider yourself lucky. That is not the case in many areas of the South. And the criminals do not have registered or permitted guns. And sometimes they murder people with spare tires, their fists, knives, and razor blades that they carry in their mouth.

People who legally own guns and learn the proper way to use them are not the problem. Saying that guns cause crime is like saying my keyboard is responsible for my misspellings. I do not intend the be a willing victim.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#4

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Russ, I have an enormous amount of respect for you, and I have to say I am confused about your statements. What about me has changed now that you know I carry? Absolutely nothing. Have you read in the paper where I killed people at my last class, or went on a rampage in my town? No, you haven't. The gun has nothing to do with it. I could run you through with a bowl gouge if that was my intent. I could take you out with my bare hands for that matter. I know how to do it. Last time I checked, that has never happened. But to come on here and trash a whole group of people just because you are afraid of an inanimate hunk of steel and plastic just confuses the heck out of me.

I've been checked out over the years by the PA State Police, sheriffs in two counties, the BATF, and the FBI. I am squeaky clean. My rap sheet consists of two speeding tickets in 35 years. I've taken numerous classes in safe handling, marksmanship, the law as it pertains to people who carry, decision making in social situations, etc. I probably have more range time than most cops, and I know I have had more safety training. I'm a certified NRA instructor! What makes you think I am going to suddenly snap simply because I have some extra metal in my pocket? I'd really like to know.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#5

it happens

bob davis

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#6

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Dave Moore

I didn't get the sense that Russ was in any way "trashing" anybody, Bill.

Seemed to me he was very careful to restrict his comments to how he personally feels about guns being carried in his presence. that's not the same thing.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not anti-gun at all, I hunt almost all the meat that gets eaten in this house.

If you have the legal right to carry and choose to do so that's entirely your business, but Russ equally has the right to describe his feelings about that.

I do have to say too, though, that your posting of a photo of yourself armed and with a Bible, accompanied by a reference to something said (boneheadedly imo) by our President went well beyond any discussion of personal safety issues. If we're going to be honest here you were clearly making a political point of some kind, even if possibly tongue in cheek.

What any of this has to do with woodturning escapes me. I'd say this discussion belongs on another board somewhere, but that's just me.

best

d

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#7

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Russ Fairfield

I guess I am fortunate to live in the wild west where all of the states are red, pickup trucks come with a gun rack and a chainsaw as stock accessories, crime is low, and the only animals we fear are 4-legged ones with big teeth.

I'm not trashing anybody. Just making a statment. I have had people shooting at me in 3 wars with intent to kill. I am just choosing to make sure I'm not around should the bullets ever start flying again. One way to do that is to stay away from people carrying guns.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#8

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Dave, he wrote, "I don't trust people who feel they have to carry a gun, and I chose to avoid people who have the potential to kill me." That is pretty strong. So after all the time I have known Russ, corresponded with him, talked on the phone, and such, now all of a sudden I am not to be trusted. And anyone has the potential to kill anyone else. Read Mike's post.

And yeah, I was making a statement when that picture was taken. I'm allowed to do that. We get inundated with all sorts of political "art" in the woodturning world, so it is refreshing to see other people with a point of view similar to my own. As to what this has to do with woodturning, it is a conversation with other woodturners. I go all over the US for woodturning events, and we talk about other things as well. No one is forcing you to participate in any given discussion here.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#9

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Michelle

Wow Russ, I will identify myself to you if I ever run across you in public, as I carry a gun daily. I notice few women joined in this discussion, but I have no idea how many women visit this site. As a person who chooses to carry a gun, I do not have to explain it or justify it. It is my right under the constitution. I can also carry a knife if I choose. But I do not as I don't want an attacker to be that close to me. I will tell you this: as a woamn I feel threatend by most men on a daily basis. Whether I see a gun or not. Lucky that you are a man and feel safe in this world. Maybe if you were me, you'd see it differently.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#10

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Doc Green

I'm not in this discussion on one side or the other because I keep any views I may have to myself when it comes to politics and religion. However, ...

I liked the picture of Bill with the oversized gun, and a bible to match. Can't help but think he has all bases covered. :)

I just hope this discussion doesn't generate any hard feelings that may get in the way of discussing turning and things relating thereto. That 'twood be a shame.

On a different note, I tried using my skew as a negative rake sheer scraper. It worked. Worked good, in fact. But it took the edge right off my skew.

~Doc

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#11

Ellis Walentine

If I may weigh in here...

Ellis Walentine

These two threads about guns are still here because, for the most part, the discussion has been civil, and, as I mentioned to one of our esteemed visitors via e-mail, I don't find it overtly political. The laws are what they are, and talking about our various reasons and rationales for our choices is not out of bounds as far as I'm concerned, although it's definitely Off Topic when it comes to turning. Maybe we need an OT board for this kind of discussion.

Ellis

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#12

Mike Stafford

But did it work, Doc?

Mike Stafford

On a lighter note our very own Jamie Donaldson once was pulled off a plane to explain where the barrel was for the gun he had disassembled but was obviously carrying.

The evidence the security people had in hand was the Wolverine Vari-grind jig he had in his luggage. Obviously it was designed to hold a gun barrel....

I always feel safe after being screened in the airports...particularly when they confiscate my floss picks because they are sharp....

"Turn this plane around and head to Cuba or I will floss your teeth!!!"

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#13

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Dave Moore

OK Bill, I hear you.

Lots of folks feel strongly about this, and other things too. No problem.

I know it's a discussion between woodturners Bill, and I know that woodturners talk about all kinds of things. I know that because I am one too.

I see now that I worded my point badly. It would have been clearer if I had said " how this discussion helps any of us to be better woodturners escapes me."

As for this though;

"I go all over the US for woodturning events, and we talk about other things as well. No one is forcing you to participate in any given discussion here."

That tastes a little bit like "I'm the one with all the experience and seniority here, so if you don't like it, take a hike, newboy." Perhaps that's not what you meant, but it's been a while since anyone talked to me like I was a five-year-old.

Disappointing. I'm outtahere.

:)

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#14

Not and OT board...........

Ruth Niles

Ellis, I don't think there's a need for an OT board. That would only encourage knock-down, drag-out conversations about all sorts of things, it would mean having to click the mouse and go to another whole page and download that page and ....... sort of kidding : )

Seriously, if visitors and members don't like the guns threads, they are very clearly marked so they should not read them. It totally escapes me why people read a thread that is about something they are not interested in. Just skip it and let those who are contributing enjoy their conversation.

I can't imagine these same people walking through a room at a party and stopping conversations they don't agree with or want to hear.........they walk on and join a conversation they do like.

One woman's opinion.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#15

Re: If I may weigh in here...

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

Had I known my question would create a controversy, mild as it has been, I would have refrained from posting it. If it has caused people to feel differantly about others based on their answers, I apologize and will be more careful in what I post in the future.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#16

Thanks everyone for being so polite-seriously

John Lucas

I know this is a hot topic and people on both sides are very firm in their beliefs. Only by discussing it can we affect any change. As a gun person It's just difficult for me to believe that I endanger anyone.

I was discussing this with a friend the other day. He said the same thing Russ said. That I don't trust gun people. I asked him why and he said they are just dangerous. I asked him if he thought I was. He said no I've never thought of you as a dangerous person. I think you are quite sane and comfortable to be around and we've been friends for a long time.

At this point I showed him my carry permit and lifted my shirt to show him my gun. I told him that I had been carrying since they passed the law and had been to many events that the two of us attended and not once did I make him uncomfortable. In fact he never knew I carried a gun until then. He didn't really know what to say.

I still contend, We, the legal gun owners are not the problem. The crazy people out there who will carry a gun illegally not matter which law you pass are the problem and the danger.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#17

Re: Not and OT board...........

George Guadiane

Hoping this doesn't make me a "woman," not that there is anything wrong with that, I LOVE women!

I agree with Ruth. I have been thrown off of more than enough sites for having a "less conservative" perspective than many, and for DARING to ask questions that might call into question the logic and/or ethics of the thoughts of others on other OT boards. Politics and Religion don't go too well with woodturning. I've already lost perfectly good friendly relationships and killed any chance of fostering good relationships with numerous others for failing to drink THEIR particular brand of Kool-Ade, so PLEASE no OT board.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#18

Ellis Walentine

I agree, George

Ellis Walentine

The idea of an OT board has come up often in the past eleven years, and the prevailing sentiment has always been *not* to do it. My contention has been that OT posts are okay anywhere on WoodCentral, so why bother with another board? We're all woodworkers at some level, but we're not one-dimensional, and, like any community, we need to be able to relate on other levels besides woodworking.

Gun laws and gun control are hot buttons in our society, though, and any given community is going to have people on both sides of the fence. As long as it doesn't become a debate about anyone's rights, I don't mind hearing respectful folks discuss the sides of the issue civilly and intelligently.

Ellis

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#19

Steven Antonucci

Gun carry laws from state to state?

Steven Antonucci

Not being a "gun person", some convenience questions came up in reading this:

If you live in a right to carry, do you have a right to carry (concealed/shouldered) in another state? If you cross a state line, do you potentially incur some risk because of law differences?

If you are visiting a friend at their home(non-gun person), do you tell them you are armed? If they are uncomfortable with this, how do you secure your weapon? (My BIL is a cop, and he never brings his weapon in my MIL's house because she got rid of the gun safe and we've got kids running around)

If you enter a public space with a metal detector (more and more common these days), how do you handle it? (I know schools, all federal buildings, lots of corporate office are all installing them)

Have you ever been held at gun point by law enforcement who didn't recognize your right to carry a firearm?

Seems like a lot of cost for the benefit?

steve

Support your right to carry a gun, but not sure I understand the need...

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#20

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Dave, if my response to you came across as talking down to you, please forgive me. I am passionate about just about everything, or so my wife tells me, but one thing I work very hard at doing is not talking down to anyone. It is hard since I am taller than most people. :b But in all seriousness, I did not mean to come across as telling you to take a hike. I participate on a large number of discussion boards, woodworking and otherwise. There are often discussions going on where I am not interested in the topic, or the topic is offensive to me. So I pass them by. That was all I meant by that.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#21

Re: Gun carry laws from state to state?

Dan Donaldson

Not being a "gun person", some convenience questions came up in reading this:

If you live in a right to carry, do you have a right to carry (concealed/shouldered) in another state? If you cross a state line, do you potentially incur some risk because of law differences?

It depends. Many states have reciprocity with other states. It is normally with states with similar laws and requirements. Two states, Illinois and Wisconsin do not allow concealed carry under any circumstances. If there is reciprocity, it is the responsibility of the permit holder to understand any differences in the laws of the other state and follow them.

If you are visiting a friend at their home(non-gun person), do you tell them you are armed? If they are uncomfortable with this, how do you secure your weapon? (My BIL is a cop, and he never brings his weapon in my MIL's house because she got rid of the gun safe and we've got kids running around)

I would normally not carry if I knew it bothered them. That said, concealed means concealed. If people can tell, it is not concealed.

If you enter a public space with a metal detector (more and more common these days), how do you handle it? (I know schools, all federal buildings, lots of corporate office are all installing them)

Most of those would be posted for non-carry, so you would not try to carry there

Have you ever been held at gun point by law enforcement who didn't recognize your right to carry a firearm?

No

Seems like a lot of cost for the benefit?

The only significant cost is the hoops that the local county makes you jump through to get the permit. It will take at least $400 and two days time, plus in my case, they would make you go to the main courthouse in the center of downtown Detroit on two separate occasions (with a $10 parking fee each time). Oh, also, they only take cash, no checks or credit cards, but don't tell you that until you are there ready to pay, in which case you have to leave, go to the bank, go back and wait in line again. Oh, also, you have to go to a local Sheriff's office to get fingerprinted (with a $25 fee) and they only do it during a 2 hour block once a week in the middle of the day so you have to take off work to get it done.

steve

Support your right to carry a gun, but not sure I understand the need...

One last thing. Take a look at the Brady scores. They annually score the various states on the gun control laws they have on the books. The more and stronger the laws, the higher the score. If you look at the scores, there is an inverse relationship between the scores and the crime (particularly murder, armed robbery and hot burglaries) The states with the most stringent laws have far and away the highest crime rates.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#22

Re: Gun carry laws from state to state?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Steve, you can find the pertinent law for most states, or most laws for all states, at www.handgunlaw.us. It is important to know what the laws are for your own locality. New Jersey is easy. If you are not a cop or in the Mafia, you don't carry legally. Period.

I have a PA License to Carry Firearms (LTCF). It is recognized by a number of other states such as NH, WV, VA, KY, TN, NC, GA, and FL. Two years ago I obtained a UT Concealed Weapons Permit, allowing me to carry in states like OH, DE, and AL. UT has the most stringent requirements for obtaining a permit, so it is recognized by more states than any other. In addition, UT runs its entire list of CWP holders through the federal instant check system every 24 hours, so if I am a bad boy, they are going to know long before most people and act accordingly. For the most part that would mean revoking my CWP, but I am still in the legal system. I can ride all the way down to FL to visit my daughter and her family now and except for 12 miles in MD, I can carry all the way. We avoid SC, since that avoids going through Atlanta, and the ride through AL is nicer anyway.

Inadvertently carrying across state lines is usually a very bad thing, especially around here. The only states I can hit directly are WV, DE, and OH. It is a felony for me to possess a handgun in MD, NJ, or NY except under very limited circumstances. It is enough of a hassle that I try to avoid those circumstances whenever possible. For example, on my 1200 mile trip to FL, when I get to the MD border, I unholster, unload, and lock up my gun separately from the ammo. When I get to the border and cross over into WV, I can reverse the process and continue on for the rest of my trip. Carrying into MD is an automatic two year jail sentence.

Most people know I carry, since I carry openly. There are times I have been asked to conceal or leave it in my truck. I have a lock box for that. But it is amazing how many people who know I carry think I don't have it with me if it is concealed. Out of sight really is out of mind.

Schools and federal are already off limits. It is a crime to even possess a gun on federal property, like a post office. That includes post office property, like parking lots. So if I have to go to the PO, I choose one where they do not own the parking lot, and lock up the gun while I am in the building. I open carry on a regular basis into my own bank, and in several others. There has never been a problem, although in a couple of the others there have been some wide eyes.

I have never been held at gunpoint, although I have some acquaintances who have. A number of us are politically active, pushing the envelope by obeying the law. Through our efforts, the training program for all police in PA has been changed to make cops aware of what the current law is. They are not allowed to enforce what they think the law is, or what they would like it to be. I have had numerous conversations with cops. All of them were good except for the Philly airport cop who insisted I was breaking the law. Still, he could not find time to arrest me, although talking to a friend of his seemed to be the extent of his immediate activity.

Since you seem to be against gun ownership and carry for at least yourself, I sincerely hope you never do have to come to an understanding of why those of us who carry do. If you are in a situation that will cause that kind of an epiphany, it is very likely it will be your last situation in this life.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#23

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Dave Moore

No problem Bill.

It did strike me a little that way to be truthful, so I said so, but I'm no sensitive little flower, and anyway as I said I did suspect it was not so.

I participated because the topic does interest me, both as a citizen and a gun owner, and I don't find it offensive at all. I don't doubt you have more guns than I do, but perhaps not twice as many. Then again maybe you do. ;)

I taught both my son and daughter to shoot, and in short order she became a better shot than me. Still is.

Just as I was tempted to read more into your words than was actually there, I thought you read a little more into Russ's words than was in them.

I should know better at my age than to butt in like that, and godknows Russ is able to speak for himself after all, but it read to me like he was talking about his feelings, and not making any declaration about your personal trustworthyness.

I think folks speaking their mind on this issue is valuable (on any issue come to think of it) but it can be awful tricky as we both know. Some folks feel passionately that guns are a problem and they are unsettled by their presence. I don't share that view, but I do feel an obligation to honor their feelings in the matter.

We might not be on the same exact page, but I think we're on the same chapter at least.

Now I really am outtahere. (the discussion I mean)

:)

best wishes

d

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#24

Re: I agree, George

Fred Bearman (Port Huron, Michigan)

I enjoy being able to pick and choose which threads I read and/or contribute to, and some threads, like the gun thread, are interesting to visit just to observe the various points of view. Not only does this allow me to better know people that I am familiar with only through WoodCentral, but gives me pause to re-examine thoughts I hold.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#25

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Scott Hurley in N VA

I went deer hunting a couple of months after I got home from Vietnam. As we were walking into the woods, a bullet hit a tree about 10 feet from us. I looked at that and decided that after a year of people trying to kill me, I wasn't going to let someone with bad aim (a nice word for it) take me out by mistake. I walked out of the woods and spent the the day sitting in the car while the rest of the guys had a fruitless day. I haven't touched a gun since, and haven't felt a need for one. Just my 2 cents.

Scott