Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

You guys and your guns just lost me.

Posts

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#51

Re: Just a question

Dan Donaldson

I apologize. That was not a very nice thing to do. Many times, in conversations similar to this, it is with people that are irrationally afraid, or hate guns and any means of self protection, and I can get a bit carried away.

One thing that I find is that if I am carrying, I tend to be much more alert and more careful to avoid any situations that might cause me to have to use it. I am not hero, and unless I was directly affected, or someone else was in immediate danger of being killed or seriously injured, I would stay out of it and let the police handle it. There are some of the "macho" types out there and unfortunately they tend to be vocal and give the rest of us a bad name.

I can see where you would be nervous, but at least in my case, it would be a case of "I will do this now because if I don't, we will be dead in a few seconds". It would truly be a last resort, and I would hope that I would be able to leave the situation long before it got to that point.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#52

Steven Antonucci

Funny timing

Steven Antonucci

I went to bed last night and caugh the end of a news story. Some kind of high speed chase with the police and shots fired. The cop that was shot in the leg was hit by another cop, not the perp...

All of the range time and training is basically useless in a life threatening situation. While you would like to think that shooting a paper target with tight groupings prepares you, the paper target isn't shooting back at you, forcing you to hit it what both of you are moving.

I have no issue with anyone owning a gun in their home. Most gun owners I have met fall into two categories (oh, no not more categories!): responsible and irresponsible. My uncle had unregistered guns, no training, nowhere to lock his gun safely. I doubt he could have hit the ground with a bullet on most days. Others, like my BIL (the cop), takes his range time seriously, has a safe, carries on the job but not at family picnics. I'll admit that I am always worried when I am around anyone with a gun- but not because I doubt their intentions.

I happened past the scene one day in Bedminster where my BIL patrols. Lo and behold, he's standing there talking to a guy outside his pickup truck, so just let him do his job. When I saw him that weekend, I mentioned it. He said, "Oh yeah. That was the guy who blew his hand off with a shot gun. We were looking for his fingers." He had an accident with a gun he thought was empty and it discharged. Hunting- in a semi controlled environment- where you wouldn't expect carelessness. Didn't do anything to ease my discomfort around guns...

It's not a black and white issue, but it's been a very enlightening discussion. I think it's underscored that we are all different and value different things, and that's what makes America and WoodCentral great.

Steve

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#53

VERY well said, Fred.

Ruth Niles

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#54

This has been a really thought-provoking ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

thread. While I have firearms, I am not sure where they are. And I hide the ammo in different places so that I won't do something stupid.

I believe that my barber is armed at all times and he claims that two-thirds of the county is armed. This is Franklin County, Virginia, MOONSHINE CAPITAL OF THE WORLD. And I have heard it said that there is as much moonshine now as there was during Prohibition.

Your comments make me wonder if I am being naive by not carrying protection in the vehicles. I have always assumed that the only reason for me to carry a weapon would be so that an adversary would have one available to use on me if he wanted. :\

I think that I am most surprised by the number of people on this forum who feel the NEED to carry a weapon. In almost 8 years that we have lived here I have never felt threatened and said to myself "I wish I had a gun with me.". Now when we lived in Prince George's County in Maryland that was not the case. Having visited Mike Stafford at his nice home recently, I was sad to read Mike's comments about his environment in Rocky Mount, NC, which I believe that he described accurately from my own observations.

There are certainly two sides to this issue and there is clearly no easy answer that works for everyone.

Ed

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#55

Re: police statistic

John Lucas

John I looked last night and could not verify that statistic. There have been a lot of officers shot with their own gun but it was because the gun was taken from them, not an accidental discharge. I'm not saying that there have not been accidental discharges, that does happen.

I'll be more people have been hurt in the Toyota gas pedal fiasco than officers killed by accidental discharge of their weapons.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#56

Re: O.T. Guns (LONG)

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

George, there are several things in your post I would like to respond to, mainly because you mentioned me by name. Otherwise, I would have continued to ignore you as I have done for a long time.

Cops are woefully under trained. This is a matter of record. Despite Hollywood, cops are not super trained combat experts. Range time for quite a few of them consists of qualifying once or twice a year. Qualifying means taking your pistol out of its holster and shooting some holes in paper. If they all get within a certain area, they are good for another six months or whatever. For many cops (not all) this is the only time their gun ever clears its holster.

Second, shooting in a stress situation reduces accuracy to at best 50%. I know this, and the information above, having participated in classes taught by the same people who instruct cops. These two facts combined illustrate why a police officer can fire 60 rounds and only have a few hit. First there is lack of practice, second there is stress, and third, the bad guy has a tendency to not hold still while someone is shooting at him. As much as I do not like bad guys, I can understand the perspective. I seriously doubt I would hold still while someone took careful aim at me either.

As for your personal reference to me, and being on the receiving end of my discontent you are right. Back in the days of the AAW OT board, you just could not let things drop, and got nasty on several occasions with me. I don't need that from you or anyone else. You have alluded to your own lack of control in this very thread in regard to an OT board. Do me a favor and don't project your own problems onto me. There are plenty of people who are friendly who I can spend time with. I don't need them to agree with me, and in fact many of my friends disagree with me on a number of things. My persona behind the keyboard is exactly the same as it is in person. I know that because literally hundreds of people have told me so upon meeting me and spending time with me. I am up front and blunt about what I think and why. But since I am sitting here in my own office, perfectly free to come and go as I please, it should be fairly apparent that I do not use violence or bullying to prove a point or interact with other people. There are laws against that you know, even in Pennsylvania. So for you to express some sort of fear that I would somehow snap and start capping people left and right over a disagreement is disingenuous, and to my mind, bordering on slanderous. You are, of course, welcome to any fear you choose to harbor. But I really do not care for you maligning my character publicly like this. It is comments like yours that get threads like this shut down and deleted. And it only confirms that I was right to disassociate myself with you years ago.

Furthermore, your comments about people who "tote guns" not wanting any control are inaccurate. I am an NRA certified instructor. I spend many hours teaching gun safety and proper handling to people who are new to this, as well as give refresher courses for others. I take refresher courses myself. I promote and encourage gun safety, as do many who own and carry. Despite being an instructor, when I come into a new place where the people do not know me, I do not blare out that I need no instruction like all new people get, I take it quietly because I know how important it is.

I put up with insults all the time. I am putting up with them from you right now, although I am expressing my opinion about that. That is another "right" I have you know. If someone offends and insults me, I just go away, as I did with you a long time ago. Your comments about gun toting people wanting to "take some kind of action" just don't stand up to any sort of scrutiny, unless you are talking about people from the hood. Well George, I'm not from the hood, so even though you have taken opportunity to dis me once again, I have expressed my thoughts on it and that is as far as it will go - again.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#57

Re: But did it work, Doc?

Bob Macgregor

Yeah, and I assert that a Bic pen is a more dangerous weapon than a nail clipper, but guess which gets confiscated?

BOB

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#58

Ladies and Canes

Stuart Johnson

Many years ago in Denver on a cold rainy day I was walking along a slick flagstone sidewalk and saw an elderly lady with a can having some trouble going up some steps. I walked up and asked if I could help her. She damn near beat me to death with that cane. Agile little thing keep beating and screaming at me to get away until I thought surely I was going to be arrested. Thankfully she wasn't packing.

I've many fond memories of Denver in the early 60's when long hair and beards weren't common.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#59

Re: O.T. Guns (LONG)

George Guadiane

I really don't need to address the training thing, because, on the one hand, I agree. Police officers should be well paid to be in top condition to serve and protect, they are not and it's a shame. Since everyone in live fire situations is under unimaginable stress, and accuracy goes out the window for everyone, you certify my ill-ease for anyone carrying a weapon.

The last time you emailed me, at the end of a well written email you practically invited me to not drop it with some kind of insult about me needing to get in the last word. I chose not to respond and did not think about it or mention it till now.

So, I actually can "let things drop." I waited as long as I could on these threads while people posted from their perspective about how they feel without making comment, other than that I didn't want an off topic board. People who thought like me were being attacked and misrepresented, so I went to their/OUR defense. Making that additional comment brought the dogs on me. I have found that contrasting points of view are often misrepresented and/or reinterpreted to paint a picture that helps them contain people like me.

I'm sorry if it didn't read well, but let me make this clear: The picture that I tried to paint was of someone coming to attack you and you responding, not of you, in any way, at any time taking the first action. If you really understood me to be saying you would/could be the first actor, I apologize.

You may not think so, but your authoritative demeanor appears to others (whether they say it to your face or not) as bullying. You DO have strong feelings and the penchant for being blunt. That can come across as bullying, or so I have been told.

Sadly, I'm sure you ARE a great guy. Till we got into the political arena, I had the utmost respect and admiration for you. And I need to say, I respect your right to your ideas and opinions, like you toward me, I object to how you represent them. We probably nave more in common than you would like to believe - even outside woodturning.

I would like to be able to find some common ground and walk with you on it.

About the NRA; they seem determined to prevent any kind of gun legislation... From my experience through a couple of surprising telephone polls from the NRA, it's clear to me that they are using the slippery slope approach to gun laws... ANY/ALL gun laws will lead to the government coming to take our guns. That was all I was talking about I know that they teach gun safety, etc. (which is excellent), but on balance, I don't favor the organization.

I don't think I questioned, in any way your desire to, your intent to and/or your actions to be as well prepared and safe a gun owner as possible... Other than seeming to take pride in your gun ownership, I have no issue with you or anyone owning guns. I brought up specific points about that. I'll be responsible for that. How you interpret it, in general and as you think it pertains to you isn't mine.

I'm sorry you see my alternate point of view as insulting, but factually, and specifically, if I have told a lie or made a significant misrepresentation about you personally, I would like to know what it is so that I can apologize for that.



To everyone else
, when Russ started this thread, I advised him against it in an email - for exactly this reason. I didn't set out to insult anyone, any more than I felt insulted by some of the remarks. There is no easy solution to this.

Those of you who want guns and want to carry them are within your rights. You don't, however have the right to (MIS)characterize or define how we (who would rather not have guns in our day to day lives) feel, so I talked about that.

To ME, when people who exercise their rights to carry tell me (more than once) that I am wrong to have another perspective, it seems like they are bullying me, and...

They have guns.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#60

Re: A little humor please

Bob Macgregor

I've been out of the states for nearly twenty years, so I may have fallen behind the times a bit...are there really 57 states now?

I left all my guns, and my hunting bow, with friends and relatives in the US when I moved to Canada since my province has no hunting to speak of and very little violent crime. I count myself lucky for this.

Now, maybe if I whack a trespassing snowmobiler or ATV'er with a stick they'll get the message to clear off my land!

BOB

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#61

Re: police statistic

Stuart Johnson

The thing I find bothering is when highly trained police do need to use their weapons the number of shots fired is so much greater than the number of hits. I can't begin to give any solid numbers or facts but my wife and I have commented several times that the officers involved should be spending more time on the range. I'm certain these are very stressful situations that would leave me a quivering hunk of jello but all of those bullets are going some where.

Now take a situation like the Luby's cafeteria shooting. What would have happened if ten qualified canceled gun owners had started shooting at the gunman? It is sort of a no win case, shot down like a dog by some sicko or shot by a stray bullet. Dead is dead but if I've got to go I would choose the stray.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#62

Re: Just a question

George Guadiane

Thank you for the apology, I accept.

I want to take a TINY issue with the word "irrational." For some, not being able to adequately articulate their feelings on this might come off as irrational.

Let me apologize if I came on too strong. I get very defensive about MY rights, I guess it's the flip side of the same coin.

I really tried to stay out of this thread, suggested that it not be left and waited till I just couldn't wait anymore.

Baring some personal attack, I'm figuring this thread and I are done.

Thank you for taking the time and thought to read what I wrote and respond to it.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#63

Bullying

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I will stick up for BIG BILL G. When you are as LARGE as he and I, people perceive us as bullies. I have a three year old Chihuahua that I raised from a puppy. She has never been spanked or seriously scolded. She fears me. She jerks when I touch her. I only weigh 83 times as much as she does. She thinks I am a monster. She is feed daily.

When I am in public, little boys that are not with their parents, look at me with FEAR. I often wonder what stories their parents have told them. I do not wear a beard because it would add to the grizzly bear look.

Bill and I talk loud, we are huge. People think that we are bullies when we are relaxed and being friendly. I have dealt with this perception since I was in the seventh grade. Bill, a true full-time woodturning pro, knows what he knows because of true experience. He has earned the right to speak with authority. Sit with him in his Sunday School class and you will know that he is a gentle man.

Bill in the WNC mountains adding the next snow

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#64

Re: A little humor please

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Our president thinks there are that many, at least he said that during the campaign! DUH?

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#65

Mike Stafford

Re: A little humor please

Mike Stafford

We lived out in the country. So bike riding was the primary means of transportation. When I was 14 a dog ran out and took a chunk out of my right thigh while I was riding my bicycle.

I jumped off the bike and positioned it between me and the dog. When he came after me I beat the dog with the bicycle and somehow managed to hit it in the head with the pedal and managed to kill it. That old Western Flyer sure packed a punch.

I walked home with blood streaming down my leg. My mom took me for stitches.

That night the dog's owner showed up wanting my dad to pay for the dog. It was not a pretty sight as my dad showed him the way to the street. I was 6 feet tall when I was 14 and topped out at 6'2" but that made me the runt of the males in my family.

After that I carried D cell batteries in my basket which I pelted dogs with as they made their approach.... Very few dogs like being hit in the head with a D cell thrown by a kid who was good at throwing. We were not the smartest kids around because we had dirt clod and rock fights so throwing was a practiced skill. Somehow we managed to survive with all of our eyes and only a few scars. Today we would be locked up as juvenile delinquents I am sure.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#66

Re: A little humor please

Carol Reed

You are of the generation when juvenile delinquents were locked up. That hasn't happened in some decades. Now they even let convicted felons loose. Times, they are a'changing. Mike.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#67

Re: Bullying

George Guadiane

I'm 60 years old, bald and six foot and just under 300 pounds myself, I also talk loud, etc.

We have difference of opinion, that's all.

As you point out, big people like us create a certain amount of dis-ease for some, just by being.

Mahatma Gandhi was a small and VERY gentle man... He was also a gigantic bully. Size really has little to do with what I am talking about. It's about the way that a person asserts themselves.

Terry Scott wrote:

I have guns for sport or for putting down a sick Animal on the farm but I have to say if i had to carry or have one in my shop sorry folks I am out of here to greener pastures . I couldn't and would live like that

Bill Responded:

Tery, just wondering - do you have a fire extinguisher in your shop? I do. I've never had a fire in my home or shop entire life, don't do things that could cause one, and don't intend to start. But I have fire extinguishers handy.

I did have one dangerous fire, but that was the gas grill catching the tank on fire and that was outside. So I don't count that as a house or a shop fire.


In my opinion, the response was an attempt to convince, justify, whatever you want to call it Terry that he (Bill) was right and that Terry was wrong... As if Terry who was not talking directly to Bill didn't have the right to his opinion. This is a consistent behavior and not just from Bill... TO ME, that comes off as bullying, regardless of size, volume or intention.

In that context, and for the purposes of this conversation, because I am repeating myself, AGAIN, I am bullying about not being bullied. I hope you understand.

I am about to promise not to talk about this any more on this board.

EVERYONE, please accept my apologies if I offended myself while trying to defend myself.

I really am done now.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#68

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolutely true story

Keith Tompkins

I once ran a business in Poughkeepsie, NY with my brother. 12 hour days were not uncommon....like many other cities, the neighborhood was in continual decline. We had barb-wire fencing around the building, and lights were always kept on. One night, as I worked late alone, I was startled to see someone climbing in one of the windows...he must have climbed an 8' fence and covered the rolled wire at the top. I shouted "Get out of here!" He replied...."F%&# You!" and headed straight for me, obviously intending to do me bodily harm. Although I'm not a big gun advocate, I know how to use one. And, my brother's (Marine Corps expert) 410 single-shot shotgun stood in the corner where he had placed it against my protestations. I picked it up, and pointed it directly at him. "No, F*&$ YOU!" He went out the window, and over the fence, which sat on a four-foot ledge, faster than you can believe. By the time the police arrived, nearly every window in the building had been smashed out, and now more that one person was trying to smash my front door in. I had to escorted out by the officers, while a gathering gang of neighborhood thugs menaced me.. one brazen individual actually pushed me as I passed him. I have little doubt concerning my continued existance had I not had the shotgun there. Absolutely true...take it for what it's worth.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#69

An impossible proposal (long)

Scott Crumpton

I�m going to jump in here as a neutral bystander. I don�t own any weapons. I know many people who do. Every now and then I consider getting one or more for the coming apocalypse. But each time I think about it, I decide that I really don�t want to dedicate the time and effort required to get the level of training that I think is appropriate for weapon ownership. Someone in this thread mentioned the nervousness aspect of being around someone who�s carrying. That�s what gets me. How do I know that they are competent to carry that weapon? I don�t. It sounds like Bill G has the kind of credentials I�d respect and knowing that would I have no problem in his presence, likewise for one of my coworkers. I�ve thought about this issue a lot. I believe in the second amendment, I just don�t think everyone is qualified.

Let me propose something that is just too rational. So rational that it could never be implemented in our political system. Please read the entire idea before jumping to any conclusions.

All weapon owners must be qualified for the weapons that they own. They must take full safety courses - real ones, not some 3 hour really only 1.5 hour evening class. They must be qualified/trained/proficient in the use of the weapon of choice for the purpose that it was intended and other possible uses. For example, in the case of a hand gun you must, in addition to the basic gun safety, take a serious class in using the weapon for self defense. The course should include such items as friend/foe identification, clearing an area, and shooting under stress in simulated situations. I�m talking serious training here. Hunters too, they shouldn�t be shooting their friends in the face.

So, how do I know that you�re qualified to carry that weapon? You should have to be licensed and the license carries the qualification endorsements. You should not be able to buy the weapon without the license. To buy a weapon for which you are not qualified should require delivering the weapon to the training agency. Some will cry foul at the license/registration aspect of this and all the classes. As to the classes and their cost - guns aren�t cheep and neither are the effects of improper gun use. Existing gun owners would have some grace period during which they would have to become licensed/qualified or be considered illegal.

As to the license/registration and the idea of the government knowing what you have, there�s a solution for that. With computer tech the way it is now it�s quite possible to build one-way databases where you can have a record of all your qualifications and a dealer can check your qualifications online, but only if you present your license because it has the key that unlocks the database for query. This is just basic crypto. And who do we put in charge of all these classes and licensing? The NRA of course, along with an independent auditor of some sort. I actually feel that the NRA is trying to do what they believe is �the right thing� within the practical limitations of the current political environment. If the environment were to change, they would adapt their tactics.

So, that�s my impossible idea. Sure, it still doesn�t mean that the guy with the gun didn�t acquire it illegally. But it does at least improve the odds that he�s qualified and that�s about all we can ever hope for anyway. It would certainly make legitimate gun owners safer.

---Scott.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#70

Re: VERY well said, Fred.

Fred Bearman (Port Huron, Michigan)

We have a very interesting, diverse group here - all walks of life, a multitude of life experiences, and an amazing amount of talent and knowledge in woodturning. For me, life is most days confined to my home and short periods of time in my shop, but WoodCentral gives me some contact with other people and often presents some challenges to my few remaining gray cells. There are so many people here, including you, that I would love to meet in person some day - maybe that's in the cards, maybe not, but I will still enjoy the virtual neighborhood.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#71

And should he or her miss and hit . . .

charlie belden

The statement was

"when I see a private citizen Take Out a crazy gunman..." I will definitely thank him or her.

Let�s begin by using the term �kills� rather than �take out�. And let�s also agree that when one must shoot at another person, fire at the middle of the chest - bigger target, more vital organs - not at the hand holding the weapon, or the head. The intent is to kill.

Barb, your statement begs the question

"and if he/she misses, or the round goes THROUGH the crazy gunman (why is it ALWAYS gunMAN, shouldn't it be gunPERSON, or the more gender neutral "shooter"?) and wounds or kills an innocent bystander - maybe a kid - or a pregnant woman - would you still thank him/her for trying?"

As for the correlation between how many rounds one fires per year at an unarmed, non human, non threatening target - and how quick and accurate one is in the midst of chaos and pandemonium - while being fired on, probably for the first time ever - with adrenaline pumping - and One Shot One Kill or a tight shot group . . . I doubt B.R.A.S.S. (Breath, Relax, Aim, Slack, Squeeze) will be followed, or less than three rounds will be fired in quick succession.

Emotionally, carrying a firearm, may make you FEEL safer - you ACTUALLY aren�t - IF - you don�t have the time AND space AND intent to use it - to kill. And if you have the mindset to be willing to kill, without hesitation - we see the world very differently.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#72

BIG Dudes

charlie belden

BIG dudes usually go out of their way to avoid having to use their size and strength. Most have lost their temper ONCE and don't want to do THAT again. Gentle and Giant seem to do together, at least from my experience.

And often preconceived notions are wrong.

When my first wife had to have her upper wisdom teeth extracted and developed complicationis - and i was required to work a LOT of overtime that week - it was a HUGE biker, with tatoos, scars and gravel voice, who stopped by two or three times a day to take care of her - fixing ice packs, making sure she took her medication, emptying a barf bucket and wash clothing her face and saying calming things. Most people knew him as Nasty. We knew him as Mark and always had pink lemonade in the fridge because he loved pink lemonade and we weren't at all surprised that his favorite song was Paul Simon's "My Momma Loves Me". The 357 mag he wore at the small of his back was only a concern if it scratched furniture or could damage upholstery.

Don't judge a book by its cover, especially if it's a BIG book ; )

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#73

Re: O.T. Guns (LONG)

Barry

Bill, I still respect you, even after learning that you carry.

I don't carry, but possess a Glock 17 and a Springfield Armory .45 ACP and a half dozen or so long guns. I have friends with guns and without. Like you, I find them indistinguishable, absent their firearms.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#74

Re: And should he or her miss and hit . . .

Barry

Might I suggest that we just refrain from arguing: religion, gun control, abortion and politics? After a short while, there seems to be little logic left to discuss.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#75

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

David Churnega

Thomas Jefferson (An American Genius)

"An armed society is a polite society"