Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

You guys and your guns just lost me.

Posts

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#26

You women and your guns...

John K Jordan

>....I notice few women joined in this discussion

One of the most vocal advocates I know for protecting one's self is a local woman. She became an instructor and teaches the course required by our state for a carry permit. While others charge a significant fee for the course, she teaches it without cost to any woman or any man who brings a woman to the class. Her stated goal is to see every woman in the country carry a firearm for protection. Can you imagine how that would affect the horrible crimes against woman that are unfortunately so common in our society?! This woman didn't say if her motivation was driven by a personal experience but one can imagine.

Strong feelings against self protection seem odd to me. I know people who spend a great deal of effort protecting their cars and houses and tools with security systems but seem unconcerned about protecting themselves or their families. Some of these people put in security systems only after having a break-in. Some people change their minds about carrying a gun after having become a victim or knowing someone who was a victim.

There was a recent surge in interest in self-protection among some people I know after a beautiful young woman and young man from our church were carjacked, tortured and horribly brutalized for days, set on fire, stuffed in a trashbag to suffocate, and shot in the head by a group (male and female) just out to have a little fun and score a little drug money. With each of the sequential trials of the criminals, the young couple's families are forced to relive every detail of their agonies, complete with full-color photographs and detailed descriptions of who did what to who and when. Knowing these victims and their friends was enough to get my attention.

JKJ

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#27

Re: If I may weigh in here...

NickTuzzolino

One more vote against an OT board. The OAK started one a few years ago and it turned out to be a venemous pit. Tirades like I couldn't believe from previous "gentlemen" . Thank you for your open mindness.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#28

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

Jerry Whitaker

If we all live long enough and our government keeps on screwing up our lives, we may find that we will need guns to defend the Constitution.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#29

O.T. Guns

bill crommett

Guns as opposed to rifles and side arms are those big things on battle ships ( So the Sergeant told us on the first day of rifle practice) This has been very interesting, but because I have been involved in many heated family discussions which resulted in no conversions,no change of position, and nothing but hurt feelings and loss of community feeling, I will not engage in involvement in this discussion. I hope you will not think less of me for my stance.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#30

Re: O.T. Guns

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Bill, you won't get any of that from me, regardless of which side you come down on. We all have the right to do or think what we want. I respect those who are not comfortable with firearms or carrying them. What I don't get is why a lot of them can't seem to respect me for my choices. Some do, but a lot don't.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#31

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

bill nixon

I agree. I thought this was a place to discuss wood turning.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#32

Steven Antonucci

Thanks-well thought out

Steven Antonucci

I am really not anti gun, but I do not frequently find myself in situations where having a gun would improve my odds. It just doesn't happen. I'm also not anti-hunting, but I don't really see myself ever shooting something to eat it either (I do fish, and its been a few years since I cleaned one...) It's just not something that I worry about (being killed/attacked in my daily life).

I'm not making fun of your right to carry, but while you were driving? What are the odds that someone would carjack you at 70MPH on I95? What happens if you forget about the law one day or miss the welcome to Maryland sign because you were tired? The gun that is protecting you has now caused more damage than good. You've traded one kind of risk for another.

If I was hiking in grizzly country, I'd sure want a gun. If I am at the ShopRite, and there's a post office next to it, do I want to google to see who owns the parking lot? Or have to explain to a cop about my rights (they really, really enjoy that conversation...) at gun point? Why not confine it to a more controlled recreational activity like shooting at the range, since you probably have a world of s*** come your way if you unholster your weapon in a public place anyway?

Personally, I'd be more worried about the rent-a-cop security guard seeing your gun and shooting you thinking you were about to cause an issue than your right to carry. I wouldn't want the extra scrutiny I would endure for the freedom I am protecting.

Just the other side of the discussion.

Steve

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#33

Barb Siddiqui

I'm a woman, and I'll bite...

Barb Siddiqui

to say I don't currently own a gun, but I may one day, if I decide to. One thing I know for sure: if I am ever in a shopping mall and see a private citizen take out a gun to bring down a psychotic killer, I'm going to say, "That was Very Impressive. Thank You."

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#34

A little humor please

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I am taller than Bill G. and just about as big. We are good friends, however, although I own guns, I do not carry a gun. I carry my cane. It is legal in all 57 states and all the territories. It does not require any permits or training. I can take it on trains and planes. It is allowed at my grandson's school and the post office. I can legally conceal it in my coat during the winter. In the last nine years I have used it to protect myself three times. A tap on the shoulder, a poke in the stomach, or a threat to knock a RAM ornament off of a brand new truck has served me well! When I go up to a walk-up ATM, it is cocked and ready to shoot (I mean swing)...especially at those that are surrounded with bushes. I killed a large snake with it that was killing one of my chickens.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#35

Steven Antonucci

Statistics and lies (or two of the same thing :-)

Steven Antonucci

Brady scores aside, I would bet that the states with the most stringent laws that have the most crime also have urban areas that drive these numbers up. Correlation between all of the relevant facts is something that would take a hundred supercomputers a million years to model. Drop Newark, Jersey City and Camden from NJ and what does it say? Sussex County has had one murder in the last 15 years- but a couple of hunters accidently kill another hunter.

It just seems to me that you need to be a laywer to avoid a bad situation for a right that you have but really don't need 99.9% of the time. If I enjoyed shooting sports, I'd want to do it in a controlled, safe environment like a range. If I felt like I needed to carry a gun for protection, I'd move somewhere else.

Still not against guns, just can't understand why anyone would want a loaded firearm on their person day to day?

S

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#36

Re: I'm a woman, and I'll bite...

charlie belden

Barb:

You do realize that once the shooting starts, everyone with a gun in their hand could be the shooter and therefore may be shot by another good intentioned citizen who is �carrying�. And not every round fired will hit its intended target. When a round misses its intended target it will keep going until it strikes something - or someone. In a crowded mall there are plenty of potential stray bullet stoppers.

When the shooting starts even trained law enforcement officers miss. We've lost two police officers in our city - killed by friendly fire during a street shootout.

Just something to consider when you happen to be in a crowded public place that has armed civilians in the crowd.

Now about that teflon coated bullet proof vest piercing ammunition . . .

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#37

Exactly!!

Bill Howatt

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#38

Barb Siddiqui

yes, I realize

Barb Siddiqui

anything can happen. But what I said was "when I see a private citizen Take Out a crazy gunman..." I will definitely thank him or her. Life offers us no guarantees.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#39

Re: Statistics and lies (or two of the same thing

Dan Donaldson

The interesting thing is that you can have two cities of equivalent size very close together, but in separate states and the correlation still holds. I won't argue that the urban areas do up the crime rates, but even take countries. England basically outlawed guns and their gun crime rates and hot burglaries have increased significantly. In the US, gun sales are at all time highs and yet the crime rates have been dropping even as the number of guns in society increases. I cannot remember which government office it was, (I can find it if needed) but they are the one responsible for tracking this kind of stuff, and they conclude that increasing gun control does nothing to reduce crime. This is from a group that would love to say otherwise, but cannot back it with numbers.

It still appears that there are somewhere in the millions of defensive uses of firearms each year. (does not include police numbers). For those people, there was a definite advantage to having a gun. Many would be dead if they had not. The problem is that you never know when you may be one of those people. How many times have you seen something to the effect that "something like that just does not happen in my town, neighborhood, etc.", but it just did.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#40

Re: O.T. Guns (LONG)

George Guadiane

I did a little research and in a year by year Google search: Including 2000 to 2010, at least on police officer was shot and killed with their own gun (and I'm sure that you could go back decades and find this to be consistent). In theory, these are well trained conscientious law enforcement officers, trained on firearms and in hand to hand combat, TRAINED to be aware of their surroundings and prepared to respond instantaneously to any situation... And they were shot TO DEATH with their own guns.

I didn't bother to check and see if there were any additional deaths or injuries (innocent bystanders) resultant from these circumstances, but I feel assured, as in the Courthouse situation in Atlanta in 2005, there were additional injuries and/or loss of life that resulted.

I am a former Florida handgun owner. I took courses, practiced using all three of my handguns, taught my sons about gun safety and taught them to shoot. I had a concealed weapons permit from the time they became available till I elected to not renew. I never had any reason to even CONSIDER using any of my weapons, so I can't speak to the state of mind one might ACTUALLY enter, BUT, these police deaths demonstrate that even well trained handgun carriers make mistakes that cost lives...

I said all that to say this:

This is a top line quote from one of the Google pages I looked at: "It's one too many when it happens," Brady said. "But if you look nationwide, the frequency of a police officer's gun being taken by a suspect is extremely rare."

The reason that I (and I will only speak for myself) am uncomfortable around handgun owners, particularly those who project a certain bravado (having been one) is that they/we are no less subject to the laws of averages. I don't care who has the gun. I don't care how much training they have. I don't even care how "sure" they are that they can take care of themselves and/or their family "in any situation," If they have a gun, in my presence, I'm nervous. Bill, in your case, I've been on the receiving end of your discontent, and I could see how someone could take you REALLY wrong. I don't have any idea if they could take you "wrong enough" to want to do something about it, but knowing you have a gun, and knowing that THEY probably know, I don't want to take the chance of being in the room in that situation. Even if you kill an attacker and I get harmed, I'm going to be unhappy. Heck, I'm going to be unhappy looking at a dead body, no matter who's it is.

Like with cigarette and cigar smokers, it's not a lack of respect for you and YOUR rights, it's a concern for my own well being and MY rights, based on the (POTENTIAL) danger you and your arms bring to me if we are in the same place at the same time. I'm not looking for a conversation, or an argument, you wondered (allowed - in writing) why some of us don't "respect" your rights. I'm telling you, that in my case, the question is WAY off the mark.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#41

Re: I'm a woman, and I'll bite...

Dan Donaldson

Just one point. (your city may be unique) In general, civilian permit holsters are better trained and better marksmen that most police officers. They shoot a LOT more and in the instances they have fired, have less collateral hits than the police officers do. This is not a hit on the police officers. They do a very difficult job under a lot of stress and while a citizen may end up involved, the officer has to go toward the problem. The issue is that many jurisdictions do not have the money or facilities for good training. Ammo costs. For many officers, they will only fire their weapons once a year when they qualify. I know a couple of civilian permit holders that might fire as much as 30,000 rounds a year in all kinds of situations and many that will fire 5-10,000. Who has the best chance of hitting the target?

With some exceptions, Police officers are really not exceptionally well trained with their weapons. (through no fault of their own) If they want to shoot a lot, it is on their own dime.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#42

Just a question

Dan Donaldson

Does this mean that you are nervous and do not want to be around Police officers? From what you say, it would follow from your words.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#43

Re: Just a question

George Guadiane

Yes, actually, I'm also nervous around police officers too, for those reasons, especially when they are in courthouses and "enforcing the law" in my vicinity. I'm also more than a bit nervous when I'm one on one in a traffic stop on a lonely road. I may be a bit over concerned, but with traffic stops, I've had a bad experience... I got a ticket for something that I didn't do and the officer (with the gun) told me he was doing me a favor.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#44

intent to go armed

john lucas

Bill In Tennessee they have a law that roughly states if you have the intent to go armed then any thing could be considered a weapon and confiscated. This was designed to cover things like Ball bats, night sticks etc, but as is usual they wrote it so loose that if you carried a Tuna and they could convince a jury that you intended to go armed, then you could be held.

Now if you just took up cane fighting which is the latest fad among senior citizens. I saw one today that would make a great weapon. It was a pool cue with an 8 ball on top. Nice an heavy. Would put a great dent in someone's skull.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#45

Re: Just a question

Dan Donaldson

OK, then based on that, would you advocate disarming all of the police officers in your city/state?

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#46

Re: Just a question

George Guadiane

I don't know if the English Bobbies are still without fire arms, but they were (as a kid I thought that to be cool on the one hand, but really stupid on the other).

Don't be ridiculous. That's not what I said or even what I inferred.

Bill Grumbine wrote:

"I respect those who are not comfortable with firearms or carrying them. What I don't get is why a lot of them can't seem to respect me for my choices. Some do, but a lot don't."

I'm not uncomfortable with firearms... Neither am I uncomfortable with carrying one... I'm just uncomfortable with people who feel the need to carry and more with people who do carry and demand that I/we be OK with it, as if legally that goes along with their right to carry.

I wasn't clear about one poin: It's not rights I "don't respect" it's attitude. It's fine to say one respects the rights and opinions of others, it's another thing all together to demonstrate that respect. That's the respect I don't see gun owners demanding of themselves, while they routinely demand it of the uncomfortable.

I have not joined the NRA, but I could own 1000 guns and never join that club. Neither have I suggested, rallied for or voted for any gun control legislation, and likely will never do that either.

I used police deaths to show that even trained figures of authority have found themselves on the wrong end of their own weapons. I even said that this is a fairly rare occurrence. Without doing a search, I'm sure that, on the one hand, there are lots of success stories about private handgun owners defending themselves, I'm equally sure that there are stories like the ones on police I dug up in seconds... I don't know, but proportionally, I'm willing to bet that the incidents of harm by their own weapons is higher in the private sector than in police/military.

I said I am a former handgun owner. I didn't say why I decided to stop carrying (good private/personal reasons), but neither did I say that others "SHOULD NOT." I said I'm uncomfortable with gun toters.

I then went on to say that the bravado that comes with many gun ownerships, is among other things, a specific concern.

AND, I added that like the effects of second hand smoke - the OLD "global warming" of our time, I'm worried about my personal safety around people who "have rights" and carry guns. It seems that they think any reason others have for wanting ANY kind of control is a personal affront and an infringement on them PERSONALLY. People who feel threatened ("personally") are more likely to take SOME KIND of action. Threatened people with guns have the opportunity to make decisions that could impact me badly, even as an innocent bystander. That makes me nervous.

Police need to carry weapons. Military need to carry weapons. There are circumstances where I would be glad to be able to acquire firearms again, if need be.

Like colonoscopy, I'm uncomfortable with people who carry guns (myself included) and their reasons for carrying. It doesn't mean I'm against them carrying or that I have no respect for their rights.

If it's legal in your state, whoever you are, and you want to, go ahead and carry a gun... I'll still be uncomfortable, it's still my right. You have the right to carry, but do you have the right, or really NEED to get each of our personal approval before you feel OK about it?

I hope this clears up any misconceptions you might have had and truncates the path you seemed to be trying to take me down one question at a time.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#47

Mike Stafford

Re: intent to go armed

Mike Stafford

My son lives in England and when he went to buy a flashlight, you know one of the brands with an aircraft aluminum case he had to sign a statement that he was not buying it as a weapon.

I had to laugh. Everything is a weapon if you want it to be. Locally we had a woman killed with a spare tire. She was beat to death with it.

Most men know that cast iron frying pans are weapons particularly if you come home with lipstick on your collar....

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#48

Re: intent to go armed

Carol Reed

Men swing cast iron frying pans as well, especially when they're drunk. BTDT. It's why I am single.

I don't pack heat. Makes lumps in my clothing.

My chief defensive mechanism had always been running like the wind.

But, alas, the hinges in the middle of the legs don't tolerate that nonsense any longer.

I have learned that personal safety is necessary, sometimes even in the home. Should I be armed and ready to defend myself? Yes, but not necessarily with a gun, though a I own a few and know how to use them. My favorite still is the shotgun. Hard to miss. Works well on slithery and smelly critters, including the 2 legged kind.

I am considering a cane! I like the cue ball idea. Those things are hard!

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#49

Re: A little humor please

John K Jordan

That's the reason I almost always carry a stick when out walking. Swinging a stick once chased off a vicious dog intent on sinking his teeth into me and my young son on his bicycle.

Re: You guys and your guns just lost me.

#50

police statistic

John K Jordan

>...police officer was shot and killed with their own gun

When considering this statistic, remember: unlike the general public, police officers routinely go into situations ON PURPOSE where they are in close contact with people crazed by drugs, intent on doing violence, robbing and stealing, and extremely intent on not going to jail for their crimes.

The average woodturner does not seek out dangerous situations except where sharp tools and rapidly rotating chunks of wood are involved.

JKJ