Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Woodcraft Grinder

Posts

Woodcraft Grinder

#1

Woodcraft Grinder

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have been using this grinder for several years along with the Oneway balancing system. Yesterday the wobble that started the last time I used the grinder got much worse. During the process of trying to figure out what was going on I discovered the motor was wiggling on the base. I had to undo the bolts which were holding the grinder to the table for proper position when using the Wolverine system. I then had to remove the base plate to get to the nuts holding the motor to the base. All of the nuts were loose which to me indicated shoddy work. My last grinder never did that. So instead of spending my time turning I had to fix something that should have never happened.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#2

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

john lucas

>True, but then if you spent $300 on a baldor you may have missed buying a new tool. :D I guess everything has a trade off. I would love to have a shop full of high quality tools. I've spent way too much time fiddling with my table saw. However the top quality ones are twice the price and although I'm sure I would love one every time I use it, the money just isn't there.

The Woodcraft grinder is a good buy but certainly not perfect. I had to spend a good while getting the wheels to run true. However I've gotten about 5 years out of it so far. I'm sure when it dies I'll look real hard at a Baldor. Maybe I'll get lucky the the money will there. This is one of the most important machines in the workshop to save time and aggravation. However I started using a sanding disc on the back of the headstock and this beats the hell out of that.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#3

Don Geiger

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Don Geiger

>I have four grinders, but my favorite is the Delta 23-725. This is a hefty 3/4 h.p. machine and comes with machined bushings and cup washers. It was about $180.00.

The very best improvement you can make to any grinder is to true the wheels. Once the wheels are concentric to the axle it will rid the grinder of vibration and your tools, when applied to the surface of the wheels, will not bounce and vibrate. Also, making the wheels concentric to the axle eliminates the need to add a wheel balancing kit.

This can not be accomplished easily or efficiently using a hand held dresser.

Don Geiger

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#4

$300 Baldor Grinder?

Tommy Holmes in NW FL

>I've checked the prices on Baldor grinders several times and the cheapest 8" one I've seen is over $700. Is the $300 for a 6"?

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#5

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Don Evans

>John: normally I agree with you on things but THIS I've just got to say is wrong wrong wrong!

That complacency and acceptance of this type problem is why the problem continues.

It's very important that you understand what I mean here, cheaply made tools are one thing BUT engineering a machine so the bolts will loosen up with use just has NO place in our world.

It's one thing to make a electric hand drill with bushings in it and charge less for it instead of using good quality bearings verse it literally coming apart in your hand....

If people would stop excepting these things and complaint and return then it will be slow but it will stop. The manufacturers will still find a way to make tools in your price range I'll bet the farm on it so don't think by exceptance you are helping to keep inexpensive tools on the market.

Example: I wanted a better set (quality wise) of forstner type bits. I saw Woodcraft come out with their Woodriver brand a 16 piece set for $85.00. I went to their store and got one, brought it home and looked at them more closely. The cutting edge on them had chips broken out and very rough bur that should not be there. I could have then taken my own time and honed them with diamond hone and hand sharpened them but I said enough is enough and took them back. Interestingly got a flyer from them in mail 2 days later showing these bits at half price.

I ordered an exact set of these bits from Freud and they are excellent bits, it's true they cost more. In fact double but I'm not gonna finish producing stuff for these people.

If you look at it that way, you have gone to work for the manufacturer for free when you fix NEW stuff for them.....

I don't know what the grinder cost that Barb is talking about, but I purchased one of the high speed Delta grinders for $100 or so and it has been an excellent machine. I liked the fact that it weight was almost a hundred pounds too.

I don't intend to walk into a Woodcraft store again by the way.

Don

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#6

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Don Evans

>Barb, I couldn't agree more, see my other message........

I refuse to work for free for these manufacturers.

Don

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#7

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Barbara Gill

>Don, the vibration was not because of untried wheels or unbalanecd wheels. As I said I have the Oneway balancing system. It would have been foolish to dress the wheels when the whole motor was loose.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#8

Re: balancing wheels

Don Evans

>I totally disagree with your statement about not needing a balancer if you do the other things mentioned.

Taking white AO wheels as an example: These wheels by nature of the aluminum and binding mix while settling in the mold makes them heavier in one spot than another.

It's just like the tires on a car, they can be perfectly aligned and still bound due to rubber being heavier or the wheel in one area when compared to the same area 180 deg away.

In addition to the things you say, they still MAY need balancing. It just depends on the wheel and what it is made of.

My Oneway balancer proves this, when you put a wheel on it you have eliminated the grinder from the picture, but the wheel, especially white wheels will show they are heavier on one area than other area's.

Don

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#9

Re: $300 Baldor Grinder?

Fred

>Used you can find a $300 grinder but if you do, GRAB IT!!!!

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#10

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Barbara Gill

>Don I couldn't agree more. One of the reasons I don't buy Delta is so much of their stuff is crappy (learned from experience).

Nuts that loosen like those did is just poor design. Or they were counting on the user not discovering the problem.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#11

Re: $300 Baldor Grinder?

john lucas

>I pulled that number out of my head. The last time I looked at them seriously was years ago and they were out of my league then. I think at that time they were $300 but most cheap grinders were in the $39 to $50 range. I had no idea they were now $700. Still out of my league apparently.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#12

I Agree 100%

Barbara Gill

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#13

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

john lucas

>Don While I agree with you on most points, in reality there are a lot of these grinders out there and this is the first time I've heard of the loose screw problem. Well OK, I've been told I have a few screws loose but thats another problem. These grinders do have a problem coming from the factory with wobbles and unbalanced wheels. That sucks, so buy one from a dealer who will swap it out if it's that bad. I would guess that by now Woodcraft has probably complained to the makers about this. If enough machines are returned then something will probably be done.

I definitely agree that the good quality stuff is worth the money. I bought a taiwanese set of Forestner style bits for $79. They cut a hole, not a clean hole and I've had to sharpen them but they work. When one of them got bad I purchased a high quality bit for $39. It cut great. However that was half the price of my whole set and replacing this set with drills that expensive is simply not an option so I keep resharpening the others and hope to win the lottery some day.

It seems that most woodworkers I meet fall into 2 categories. The ones who have a really nice income and can buy top of the line tools and the ones that really scrounge to by a $500 table saw and then have to grit their teeth to buy a few blades for the thing. I've been lucky in that I have been able to make just enough money at my hobby to pay for it but unfortunately not enough to buy state of the art tools. However it I had to I would still enjoy it if I only had my workbench, planes, saws and carving tools.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#14

who else has had this problem?

bob davis

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#15

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Don Evans

>John, I'm not totally sure that I got my point across, maybe I did, don't know.

Your example on the forster bit I understand very well. There was a time in my life when I had a Taiwan set also but that Taiwan set HAD a good cutting edge on them.

What I'm trying to get across is that in this example the cutting edge is most important part of the tool and there is just NO bit worth any amount of money if the edge that was on those woodrivers were let out of factory defective. Every set they had in store was like that AND HERE IS MOST IMPORTANT PART, their are people that will buy them, take them home and redo the edge for Woodcraft..... It will never get better if people continue to do that. Now let throw in another example of a problem with the bits, say the bits had a very good cutting edge but the diameter they cut is off by .1 percent. That is a different story in my book. You purchase them for $39.00 and to a wood worker that tolerance probably makes no difference. To a machinist it would though.

See the difference in what I'm trying to get folks to do, lets stop putting up with this, stop being complacent and saying well I got what I paid for. In my opinion I didn't, they didn't cut worth a you know what but they are suppose to cut that's their purpose.

I'll drop this, part of my problem is I feel like life is getting much much shorter and like Barb said, instead of doing what I or she wanted to do we are fixing tools for these folks and they are laughing all the way to the bank.

No more ranting.... thanks for putting up with me John...

Don

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#16

Right on ...John

bob davis

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#17

Don Geiger

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Don Geiger

>I agree. Fix the problem with the grinder or replace it.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#18

Re: Woodcraft Grinder returned

Carol Reed

>The wheels did the two step from side to side in perfect tandem. It was the last one the store had - a display model. Manager said they would not be getting any more in, that they were being discontinued. He was less than gracious about the return, but he did communicate very clearly to me that Woodcraft did not need any more on my money.

Message received. And I don't even feel slighted. I'm with you, Don. I won't go back. FWIW I have the same problem with Rockler. It may be a store to store thing. The San Diego store was a great place, but that is nearly 500 miles away now!

Just plain snotty customer service. Like John, I have to watch pennies. Rather than put up snotty service, I'll keep watching those pennies until I have enough of them to get a quality product from an appreciative vendor.

And I still need to buy a grinder. :\

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#19

Re: Woodcraft Grinder---LONG

Galen Vetterick

>Barb

Guess my mind set is just not geared to buying high quality for the times I use some items. With that, I have learned to think twice before I just use anything without looking them over. I got the Woodcraft grinder in 11/08 ($74.99 and free frieght) and before I ran it I took it apart and put it back together. Wanted to be sure the wheels and guards were right before they ran at 1750 rpm in my face. Has worked well for sharpening my lathe tools since.

Last week I purchased a cheap 8 piece set of Porter-Cable forstner bits at Lowes. Cleaned the oil off them and dressed a few with a diamond stone before ever using. They work fine for my needs so far.

Early lesson I learned from was buying a garden tiller from Ace Hardware they had put together and serviced. Told me EVERYTHING was ready to go. Got home and started it up. Looking down I realized the tines were on the wrong side and presenting the dull side to earth! Shut it down and went over ALL the nuts, bolts and engine service.

My list goes on: Ford Mustang I bought new stopped only to fined extra screw in the distributor that ground the houseing to dust and shorted things out. Buick that had grinding sound in brakes driving in the moutains, only to find extra backing plate nut in the drum. Sure never expected to take apart two new cars to see if they were right but got me wondering about my life purchases early on.

Do you feel better about your grinder??????

Galen

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#20

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Nick Tuzzolino

>Ditto what Don Geiger said. For the money, the Delta 23-725 is a beast well worth the extra bucks. Mine is about seven years olds and still going strong.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barbara, I'm going to take a different approach to this problem. First, vibration, even a small amount, will loosten anything over time. Even though your wheels were balanced, they are probably not perfect, since there are two ways your wheels can be out of balance...side to side as well as just heavy on one area. Next time you have your car's wheels balanced, watch how the tech does it. You will notice that weights are placed on both the inside and outside of the wheel, and that the results are checked while the wheel is spinning (dynamic balance). Vibration can be subtle...you car may shimmy only at 60mph, but be perfectly smooth above or below that speed. Vibration is what caused your grinder base to loosten up. Same reason people post that their lathe has begun to make funny noises...set-screws on key-ways loosten up, etc. from vibration. I use a CNC router at work...too heavy a cut, vibration loostens the bit in the collet, no matter how tight the bit was installed. The answer in your case is to remove the bolts that secure the base to the grinder, and apply loc-tite to the threads, then reassemble. End of problem.

No matter how well engineered a product is, it will still require routine maintenance. Checking bolt tightness, checking shafts and keyways, lubrication, etc. I am amazed how many OneWay lathes I've seen where the banjo won't slide smoothly across the bed, and won't stay put while being used because the whole thing needs to be taken apart and cleaned and lubed. In that case it's not the lathe, it's poor maintenance. You were fortunate that you noticed the problem before anything fell apart....that's a good thing.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#22

Re: $300 Baldor Grinder?

robo hippy

>My 1 hp Baldor cost me about $600 4 years ago, and I got a whole sale price, much less than I could get it for through Woodcraft. It has been worth every penny. It doesn't have to be bolted or clamped down to the bench it runs so smooth. I have one of the Woodcraft grinders that is more like 10 years old. It is an okay machine, but not high quality.

Like some one on some forum said, "Buy a good tool, cry once. Buy a cheap tool, cry every time you use it."

robo hippy

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#23

I have mixed feelings about this....

Barry Irby

>Many things have changed since I was a kid. In the early 1960's I went to buy my first chisel. Nothing fancy, but a name brand chisel for the day. It did not even pretend to be sharp. The end had a visible flat on it. All of them did. The guy in the store explained to me that that's the way it was, you sharpened it the way YOU wanted it yourself. I vaguely remember a number of things that were not ready to use right out of the box.

When I was little kid "Made in Japan" meant Really cheap junk, not so much any more. I suspect the Chinese will follow suite. Nova chucks are an example. My understanding is the Chinese will make anything you want. If you want really cheap, they can do that, but if you insist on quality, they can do that too. My understanding is that the chuck form China are of about the same quality they used to make in New Zealand.

Almost any tool we go to buy is available in a range of qualities and prices. Why would you expect the bits in a set of ten to be of the same quality as a single bit that costs more than the set?

I have read many complaints on this board about the WoodCraft grinder and the wheels. I bought one, took it out of the box and mounted it on a base and have been using it for about ten years. The wheels are exactly as they were when shipped from the factory. Smaller from wear, but the same. I am pretty sure I could stop it if I pressed hard on the wheels, but you should use a light touch anyway. If a new Baldor is about $700 and I paid about $70, I can not imagine what I would get for ten times the amount of money that would really do anything for me.

I, like John have never had a lot of expendable cash to sink into my tools. I can't tell whether I like to scrounge and make things for myself or I do it because I have no other real choice. I just saw a guy on TV use a cutter head on a big TS to cut tongue and groove joints. My contractors saw probably would not do that very well, but on the other hand with the money I saved on the TS over a Unisaw, I bought a shaper.

Every time I see a reference here to the WoodCraft Grinder it is referenced as being cheap. Why would you be upset to find out your cheap bit was cheaply made or not totally finished. I just would not expect my cheap forstner bits to be as well made or to cut as beautifully as one that I paid many times as much for. I have a set of about 18 that I paid about $20 for. They are just not the same as the ones that are $20 or $50 each and I know it, but I still enjoy them.

I would not be surprised to learn that the guys over on the Hand Tool Forum would tell you that the first thing you do with your new chisle is to sharpen it. So, if the bolts fall out of my cheap grinder my reaction will be either...Well, it wasn't a Baldor...Crap, wish I had enough money to buy a Baldor.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#24

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

Barbara Gill

>Kieth you are right about things working loose. In this case what worked loose was not easily reached. It would never have entered my mind to remove the bottom plate to investigate how the base was attached to the motor. I have not had this grinder very long. The first grinder I had was a Woodcraft; it gave good service. Hopefully others will learn from my experience and check the nuts before mounting their grinders.

I wouldn't even consider buying a $700 grinder.

Re: Woodcraft Grinder

#25

Re: Woodcraft Grinder returned

john lucas

>Carol I hate that you had problems at Woodcraft. I have 3 Woodcraft stores all almost exactly 100 miles from me. They have all been very gracious and worked with me on anything I bought. Granted I have not had to return anything but I'm pretty sure they would do their best to help out. I've known the managers at all the stores and seem to really try to help out the customers.

I do know of some customers who try to take advantage of them. I've heard some real horror stories. I'm sure your not one of those.