Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

Posts

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#51

ditto for the screw chuck

Dave Moore

>The others I have work OK, but nothing, I mean nothing, bites like the old Glaser screws. They're perfect.

I'd buy one right now in fact, if I could.

I like Doug's gouges a lot, and will get more one day soon. I prefer unhandled anyway, if I didn't make a handle now and then I'd forget how to use a skew.

:)

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#52

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT???

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Orlando,

Maybe you are not aware of all the different flue designs Doug has developed by listening to US, I never was aware of Jerry offering this options, but above all what has been his ace is AVAILABILITY, what good is a perfect tool if nobody can buy it? first because of the high price and then by disappearance?... Think about it.

Jorge Castaneda

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#53

UNFAIR TREATMENT

O. Navarro

>Jorge,

You are right about availability. I think it was smart of Doug to offer tools in a time where CET could not supply. But he offered Glaser replacement tools. He even suggested that people could replace their Glaser blades with his blade and keep their handles and pay less.

I have been to a lot of shows and been part of panels where people discuss plagiarism in woodturning. To me he has plagiarized Jerry Glaser in a time where this CET company could not produce. You must agree that they deserve the opportunity like everybody else to come back. After all,the winners here are us the woodturners.

This is my opinion and nothing else. How can anyone disregard Jerry Glaser's accomplishments? I visited their site and if CET gets their act together they will offer a lot of variety which again will be good for woodturners.

As I said Jorge, only time will tell. Reading Glaser's website, he started in 1966 and since then, the accomplishments are incredible.

If he is behind CET and Paulo Marin, it can only mean one thing... He believes them.

So, lets all applaud their quest for a great comeback.

Orlando

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#54

What???

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Who are you O,

No more BS, The plain truth is, Doug is delivering the goods, and everyone I know is really happy about that.

Really!! colors and flute shapes. Do you work for Paulo? If not, you must be the only one who has recieved a gouge from Paulo in a couple of years.

The more I hear this crap, the worse it becomes. Can we just all agree that Doug makes a great tool at a great price and is concerned about his customers. That's all it takes to do well in the woodturning world.

Result talk... well, you know the rest. :)

Dave

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#55

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT

Gordon Seto

>Orlando,

Lighten up.

Nobody is disputing that Jerry Glaser is a legend in woodturning. Jerry started using exotic alloys in turning tools. I would say the respect for him won�t be less than Rude Osolnik.

The Thompsons were sold unhandled since day 1. It was as far away from misleading woodturners that they are the Glaser as they could be. Doug started making tools using the same commercially available A-11 for himself and gave the rest away. But the heat treatment cost was so high per batch that he turned his hobby into second job to recoup his cost. He fills a void in the market by words of mouth. That market void was not created by Doug. If there was no demand, I think Doug�s tools might not even have a name, and these experiments might have ended with the 3rd or 4th batch.

You haven�t seen the handles yet, I believe it is a little premature to call them copy cat simply because you saw my post that the material would be aluminum with lead shot. In that sense, every automobile is a copy of each other because their main materials are metal and plastic.

I have made some moulds of the various bowl gouge flutes and have posted them in WoodCentral around June 2008. You can see in the picture that a Thompson V flute is obviously different than the original Glaser bowl gouge. I have seen some of the prototype bowl gouges that Doug has made and experimented on. He may not have the scholar credential, but he is a woodturner. He made the gouges with various depths, curvature and he compared them side by side. He settled on his V shape bowl gouge. He solved the clogging problem of some V shape bowl gouges. His V gouge also has more mass under the flute, therefore more sturdy. He is using the same A-11 steel from Crucible Steel, but the flute is his own design.

I believe the trade mark should be protected in perpetuity. The spirit of a patent ends someday. Companies have to push the envelope for new innovation and technology in order to advance. Jet, Grizzly & Harbor Freight almost launched their Tormek look alike at the same time. I have lost count of the Fein Multitasker clones. I buy some of my medications in generic. I am glad I have those choices.

I think Doug Thompson would be remembered as �Wal-Marted� the A-11 turning tools. They can be affordable to the less than elite turners.

As a consumer, I welcome competitions.

I don't think you can have it both ways. On one hand, you praise what Jerry Glaser has done in the turning tools. On the other hand, you rave the new changes in flute shapes, the finishing and the totally new screw on handle design after he has sold the company.

Getting the facts straight goes a long way in convincing people.

Gordon


img

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#56

I LOVE IT!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Now that every post about a Glaser tool has my name in it and this first post by �O� is downright rude I have to respond.

Remember everyone - the three guys of the new Glaser , Paulo, Larry and O never had a minute to visit this web site before let alone help out a single person but they have time to run others down� matter of fact two of them never posted before today. This is a place we share information, ask questions, learn and socialize. this is not the place for a company to try to run another company down.. It�s ashame to look good you have to trash talk the competition, is this the way you want your company to be known?

I can see from this last post I must be doing something right when it comes to tool making� for a company to send the top management and O to analyze , twist and distort the facts on my home site I had to do something right.

I must make some GREAT TOOLS!!!

With help from thousands of great people a hobby did turn into a business, I won�t give out numbers but let�s put it this way� the market is flooded with tools made from A11. I will always be the lowest priced manufacture of tools made from A11 steel on the market... I'll make it a common priced steel.

If Jerry still owned the company Thompson Lathe Tools would never have been created...

I have a smile from ear to ear but STOP WASTING OUR TIME!

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#57

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Orlando, you said "I think it was smart of Doug to offer tools in a time where CET could not supply"

And now after 5 years should I crawl under a rock? LoL

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#58

hey, stay away from that rock

John K Jordan

>I hope you don't hide, I'm waiting for some 1/4" detail gouges!

JKJ

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#59

About time Doug!!

Brent Smith in Montreal

>

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#60

Brad Vietje

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT

Brad Vietje

>Thanks Gordon,

Good info on the flute design -- I'd never seen that comparison before. I am very glad Doug Thompson is manufacturing tools, and I'll be glad when the Glaser tools are available again, too. I don't get the impression that the Thompson tools are a copy of anything -- I would say a personal refinement, perhaps, like the various signature bowl gouges and scrapers out there. If you like the Glaser/CET tools better, buy 'em; if you prefer the Thompson tools, likewise. Many turners will end up with some from both sources, which might be even better.

Maybe the biggest examples of near-copy-cat manufacturing in wood turning would be the Jet Mini and Delta Midi lathes that are so popular. They are basically copied from the Vicmarc original, and are almost exact copies. BUT, to avoid being complete knock-off's they reversed the tailstock so it leans away from the headstock. They claim its a great feature that increases spindle capacity (length). Unfortunately, it also takes a rugged, stable, engineered design and makes it weaker and flimsier, but they seem to be pretty popular anyway. Is everyone shouting from the rooftops that Vicmarc got screwed (and I suspect they did)?

Fair competition is good. I don't think Doug Thompson is ripping anyone off, just providing high quality tools at good prices. He's also been making high quality tools available while Glaser and/or CET was unable to meet the needs of the market. When I move into my new shop, I plan to buy a few new tools, and appreciate the choices available.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#61

Brad Vietje

Sorby? Hamlet? Crown? Henry Taylor?...

Brad Vietje

>Hey -- they're all making the same thing: sharp pieces of different metal alloys that we use to cut wood. Some in handles, some not. All offer M-2, and many offer 2030, 2060, V-11, powder metal alloys, and cryosteel, etc...

Are OneWay, Michael Hosaluk, and JoHannes Michaelsen breaking the rules by offering interchangeable handle systems a heck of a lot like McNaughton does? I sincerely doubt it.

Last time I checked, every major automobile manufacturer offered interval wipers, fuel injection, air bags, and anti-lock brakes. Plagiarism? Hell no -- market trends, consumer preferences, and legislation.

I appreciate the variety of choices on the market. I hope CET has a successful launch this spring, and look forward to seeing their products in the catalogs.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#62

Re: What???

russ faifield

>Nopbody knows who he is, but he has done a good job of trashing what little credibility Paulo may have still had with the readers of this forum.

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#63

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT

fredbear34

>Let's see - Doug Thompson offered tools that could be used in Glaser handles. Such a sin! Particularly since NO ONE was making any attempt to support Glaser tools, which had been unceremoniously dumped to the highest bidder by Mr. Glaser. And to say that CET tools have to be great because Mr. Glaser has his name associated with them is ridiculous - they paid him well for his name and designs, what is he going to say?

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#64

Re: UNFAIR TREATMENT

fredbear34

>Unfair treatment? BS! Even if the V-flute and aluminum handle with lead shot were patented (and I'm not aware of such patents), my guess is that those patents were filed quite some time ago, and the following applies:

"In the United States, under current patent law, for patents filed on or after June 8, 1995, the term of the patent is 20 years from the earliest claimed filing date. For patents filed prior to June 8, 1995, the term of patent is either 20 years from the earliest claimed filing date or 17 years from the issue date, whichever is longer.",

and thus are most likely now in the public domain.

But the interesting thing I that I find about your post is that you show up out of the blue, and that you have several CET tools - must be an awfully close relationship that you have with Mr. Marin to get those, or are you indeed Mr. Marin posting under an assumed name on a gmail account, thinking that this gives you more freedom to trash others?

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#65

Inappropriate comments!

Ed Moore in SW VA

>Sir, I suggest that you read my post below, entitled "Let's not choose sides!!"

You last paragraph is absolutely irresponsible and childish. You have accused Paulo Marin of inappropriate behavior and you don't have a clue what you are talking about. It is this sort of trash talk that causes problems and does nothing to help anyone. Doug Thompson and Paulo Marin are nice guys and neither needs this sort of "support" or denigration!

Think back to the ugly mess that we had when the hollowing rig/arm, Elbo legal hassle was going on. Irresponsible comments caused a lot of trouble then and I would hate to have that happen now.

You owe Mr. Marin an apology!

Ed

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#66

Bottom Line . . . .

russ faifield

>4 years and a lot of wasted talk and broken promises have passed through this forum since the last time I could buy a Glase tool. I still can't.

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#67

UNFAIR TREATMENT TO PEOPLE

O. Navarro

>Should I say the same about you??? Doesn't the same apply to everybody who vouches for Doug?? Doug called me "O" and yet you spot a name of fredbear34...ingenious...

What happened to free speech?? Is this the kind of venue that people cannot express their opinions??? Did you know that in this country people are free to burn the flag if they wish to do so?

I expressed my feelings... and to say that I have too many glaser tools or cet tools is ridiculous in a hobby where everybody have more tools that they need... I have been buying tools for 30 years now..I have tools from EVERY manufacturer. So what??

Frebear, keep in mind that this is a site where people also vent their frustrations and mine is that you all spend too much time creating stories.

Unless Ellis Valentine tells me NOT to post my comments anymore, you can be sure I will continue to express my opinion, because it is exactly that... MY OPINION!

Orlando Navarro

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#68

Ellis Walentine

Warning to all!

Ellis Walentine

>I let Paulo's opening statement ride, because there has been a fair amount of speculation regarding the Glaser tool line, and at least Paulo is telling us useful information. He's obviously quite passionate about his tools and trying very hard to overcome what is undeniably some bad press and PR over the past few years. That's okay.

Doug has been a gentleman, and though he may lose some of his newfound market share to an old competitor, he's not making a big fuss about any of this. But some of you have let your emotions get in the way of your civility. Flaming is strictly prohibited on this and all our forums, and some recent posts have gotten to that point, so it's time to lighten up. You're all entitled to think what you want. (Personally I think all this is a tempest in a teapot. The market will decide whose tools work best and are the better value. Further, this is not an either/or situation. You can buy anybody's tools you want.)

So, this is it. I don't want to have to archive this entire discussion but I most certainly will if necessary. Out of respect for me, this forum and the other visitors, I ask each of you who are so exercised by this discussion to relent. Think about what you're saying. Is anybody so darn correct about everything that nobody else can have their opinions?

'Nuff said. I appreciate everyone's cooperation. The flaming ends here. Now.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#69

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

Cyril Griesbach

>Post away, Orlando, but I'm done reading this thread. And, I'm still buying by tools from Doug.

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#70

Re: Warning to all!

O. Navarro

>Mr. Valentine,

I thank you for the opportunity to express myself. I believe in good competition and wish the best to Paulo Marin and his company as I hope that Mr. Thompson finds his own path.

I also believe that we should all pay homage to Mr. Jerry Glaser his accomplishments are incredible.

Orlando Navarro

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#71

Um..it's NOT "Valentine"

Carole Valentine

>it's "Walentine"

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#72

Re: Warning to all!

PAULO MARIN

>Ellis, all I can say is WOW!

How passionate people can get uhn?| I just tried to update a little of my life.. Never thought things could get so out of hand..

TO ALL PEOPLE ON THIS THREAD.

I wish everybody well. I will do my very best to supply good quality to those who will buy our product and assist those who will not. There are no sides to take here. Just buy what you like and your pocket can afford, but most importantly enjoy yourself. Just remember that things could be worse... You could have been visiting Haiti few days ago..

I wish Doug Thompson and his family the best and I am available to Doug anytime as I am sure he will be for me. There is too much controversy in the world today. The last thing we need is to get upset about a turning tool. Instead, we should give more, love more and turn more..(and brew more beer... my new hobby). You should check my new club out: www.maltosefalcons.com. Boy we have been making great beer.

Happy New Year to all of you. Got to go back to work.

Paulo Marin

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#73

a newbie opinion ...

Grant Wilkinson

>for what it's worth.

I've not been turning long enough to know anything about Glaser other than what I've read on the net. I've never owned his tools. When I started turning, it was on pens, and I bought what I believed were decent tools from Lee Valley.

I took a two day course with Bill Grumbine a couple of years ago, and when I was there, he took delivery of a couple of Doug's tools and he recommended them to me. When I got home to Canada, I had an email exchange with Doug, asking for, and getting his advice on what I would be best buying. I bought two and so far have only used one of them. I love it.

It's fascinating to read all the emotion in these posts. To me, I'm afraid, it's more about the advice and service than it is about the tool. I'm positive that the tools that I buy from Doug will be capable of far more than my meager talents ever will be. (I'm sure that is also true of Sorbey, Hamlet and many others.)

I'll buy from Doug because he took the time to answer my questions, he clarified my confusions, and he ships to Canada for cost. Oh, and he also makes an excellent tool. What else could I possibly, reasonably, as for?

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#74

i think aaw still has some

bob davis5098

>

Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?

#75

Another Bottom Line?? Amazing !!!

O. Navarro

>Even after Mr. Walentine (sorry for the previous typo there Mr. Walentine) has asked for civility, you all keep bashing CET and Jerry Glaser tools with your "botton line" posts. I wish you could read his warning again and realize what you are doing. I wish he could ban this criticism against these people

What has this company done that is so bad to all of you?? All I know from everything I have seen is that they had a hard time... that's ALL. Haven't we all had that at one point or another?

I was at the AAW 20th show and all I saw was that they gave things away and tried to display a good image. They were even giving away Jerry Glaser pictures and tools to kids. Then at the dinner, they gave away money to the AAW and then they gave away tools to kids again. Was that so BAD folks?

Still none of you can wish them good luck and if they never make another tool again, still you will continue to bash them.

Shame on You Russ for your comment. It seems you want to be heard last to pledge your allegiance to Thompson tools. I am done with this subject hoping that you people have a heart and let other people try to work and make tools for us turners. If you cannot afford the best tool then as Gordon Seto said, go to the walmart of tools and buy a thompson. I am sure you will turn with it ANYWAY. The answer lies on the turner. I know people who have 4 tools only and they are Benjamin's Best... So what?? I don't see people bashing Benjamin's best here. And these people, are able to sell their work anyway, because there will always be a buyer who will look at that piece and fall in love with it, even if it was turned with a screw driver (yes... there are people who sharpens them and use them too). As Ed Moore said on his post.. apologize to the man and wish him the best..

Orlando Navarro

�Any fool can criticize, condemn, and complain but it takes character and self control to be understanding and forgiving.�

Dale Carnegie