Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Don Orr
>Good to hear from you and that you have not given up on us. Will we see you in Hartford, CT for the AAW symposium ?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Don Orr
>Good to hear from you and that you have not given up on us. Will we see you in Hartford, CT for the AAW symposium ?
Glaser/Cryosteel Gouges
Paulo Marin
>Don!
I do not believe I will make it for the show, simply because I am focusing on producing inventory. There is a major difference between producing a batch of tools and thousands of tools. Just imagine what I went through when my first tool order was 1,000 gouges for the 20th Anniversary of the AAW (http://www.woodturner.org/info/glaser/). It was not easy to laser engrave 1000 tools and serialize them. Also, I have finalized exclusive distributorship for Germany, Austria and Switzerland and that requires for us to produce the entire tool line (miniGs (www.miniglaser.com), Glaser Screw Chucks, Glaser Gouges, Scrapers, skews and so on and so on). Not to mention finalizing the redesign of CryoSteel and our exclusive "quick disconnect" system with Jerry Glaser and my son Jesse, who is a breath of fresh air. At least I can claim I have a graduate mechanical engineer on board and not a "wanna be". I can tell you it is great to see Jerry talking to my son Jesse about engineering principles. The young learning from the old... quite a sight...
Not to mention making tools for some well know turners, which is complicated due to their individual grinding requirements.
I am also privileged to have the guidance of Allan Batty... and that my friend is also quite an experience.. what an incredible woodturner Allan is... Imagine the people who have been guided by Allan, Mike Mahoney, Jimmy Clewes... to name a few.
Thanks Don... Good wishes is what I need.
Paulo
Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges
Paulo Marin
>John!
I appreciate the kind post...I have been keeping to myself to focus on my task ahead.. With our new facility, I will be able to concentrate on quality and expedience as well as superb customer service.. emails will be answered the same day they come in and orders and phone calls will be returned promptly.. Ultimately, you will get a quality tool, with proven performance and a great name.
Also, it is absolutely demanding to provide professional woodturners with their own tools.. CPM10V manufactured by Crucible (by the way, they almost went bankrupt and were sold to a group of investors from India... if they can feel the pinch, imagine me...) is a superb steel. Jerry tested it enough to establish its capabilities, but a major component of a tool to a professional woodturner is their technique and grind. A fine example is my dear friend Eli Avisera,,, I have been designing a tool line for him. He told me of his surprise when he encountered tools bearing his name with an unrecognizable grind on them. This is a difficult dilemma to be solved...
As for regular customers and woodturners, you sell a tool with a factory grind and obviously it is gone as soon as the customer needs to re-sharpen the tool. I have been asked a lot if I could just sell the tool with a blunt edge and let the customer decide. As a matter of fact it would be good to hear what people feel about that..It is not easy to grind a tip on a recently ground blade made out of CPM10V that has just arrived from heat treatment (right Doug??)
I would like to thank Ellis Valentine for kind indication of our return and for the opportunity to post my thoughts on his website.
Regards
Paulo Marin
"Remember... nothing in the world can take the place of persistence..."
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Chen Lee
>Do you export your product?
Chen
Glaser/Cryosteel Gouges
Paulo Marin
>Chen,
I would like to know to what country you are inquiring and obviously what kind of volume. Feel free to email me at pmarin@atcinc.us with perhaps your phone number and information.
Thank You for the interest!
Regards
Paulo Marin
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
John Lucas
>Paulo I have watched your company and your responses for years now. I am very impressed with your cool head and level thought out responses. You've taken some pretty good punches on some of the posts but keep coming back cool and collected. I wish you the very best and some day hope to get some of your tools.
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Paulo Marin
>John!
I am flattered that you have been keeping an eye on me.
I appreciate your positive thoughts and will do my very best to provide quality and to keep manufacturing in the USA.
I have had plenty opportunity to manufacture goods abroad, but I refuse to think that American ingenuity and manufacturing is dead.
Whatever I can do for you and your club (if you belong to one) do not hesitate to contact me.
Woodturning is a fantastic hobby and it should be supported.
The tool you see here was designed for Christian Delhon, after a visit he paid to our club in California. Delhon lives in France.
Thank You
Paulo Marin
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Gary Ljostad
>I look forward, with great anticipation, to the return of the Cryosteel/Glaser line of tools. As said by others competition is a good thing. I see only benefits to the woodturning community from the re-introduction of these tools. I wish only the best for Paulo in this venture.
Glaser/Cryosteel Gouges
Paulo Marin
>Gary,
Thank you for your best wishes! And you are absolutely right! I welcome the competition and offer support to Doug in whatever he might need from me. Perhaps together we can make sure that woodturning reaches new heights and that more people can take up this wonderful hobby...
That offer also applies to you and your club. Let me know if there is anything I can do for you.
Happy New Year and Good Health!
Paulo Marin
Welcome back
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>First of all welcome back.
Woodturners are very supportive to manufactures because we are such a small group, like I said before we need competition so the products continue to improve and the prices are in line. Jerry Glaser made his mark in woodturning, his history is carved in stone� nothing will ever change that. When you bought out Glaser in �05 you started your own history, the change in handle design and flute shapes to a Stu Batty design is your history. Personally I think the American way is to do like you did buy a company out rather than start one from scratch it�s much easier. I�m glad you made this post but I almost thought the picture of Jimmy Clewes was an endorsement � a phone call to Jimmy assured I�m still making his signature tools. Good luck and if you need any help just call 440-241-6360
Re: Welcome back
Paulo Marin
>Thanks Doug!
I am glad that Jerry is still around to correct any issues created by my past associations. I can assure you that when you buy an existing legendary company and name such as Jerry Glaser it is no easy task to live up to the standards that he instituted for the past 60 years, so I hope to continue carving on his stone and with his blessing to implement a little of my own vision. That is why we are busy working toward building a better structure.
So, the solution was to go back to basics... and that is exactly what I did. The acquisition of the company was to insure that production continues and constant meetings with Jerry to ensure that his vision and technical expertise is followed. I have also Dr, Jerry Wright, ph.D. on our side to advise us on A11/CPM10V and 15V properties as well as some new and proprietary formulas we want to test. Dr. Wright was the Vice President of Technology of Crucible Steel, now retired. With a company of this magnitude the workload is tremendous and double of the responsibility.
As for Jimmy's picture, I have known him for quite a long time and having received him at our plant with his lovely wife Mary, was an absolute delight. Please do not view it as an endorsement... Consider it like a friend visiting, like Avisera Allan Batty, Delhon and others that have stopped by to wish me health and good luck.
Thanks Doug! Happy New Year to You and your Family!
I will call you to chat one of these days.
Regards
Paulo
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Larry Miller
>For those of you who believe that Galser and Cryosteel has gone by the wayside, I can assure you nothing could be further from the truth. I am a "silent partner" in CET and can assure you that Paulo Marin, with whom I am in contact on a regular basis, is producing tools at this time. Quality tools are not the result of mass production; a superior product requires careful planning and every step of production must be completely controlled. Our company has been severely hurt by promises that were broken and expectations that were not delivered. Any persons who have contributed to the delay in production of Glaser and Cryosteel tools have now moved on, of their own accord and our reorginization of priorities are completed. CET is the only company authorized to produce authentic Glaser tools. The production of these tools is constantly under the observation of Jerry Glaser. We look forward to offering Glaser tools, the real thing, to the turning world, at a reasonable price, in the very near future. We are deeply sorry for the delay in production, due to circumstances completely beyond our control. Thank you for your patience.
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
JamieD
>... CET and the rebirth of Glaser tools since AAW Symposium in Louisville, and the only way that CET can hope to establish a viable presence in the turning world is to now back up that talk with superior product and service.
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
Donna Banfield
>I was the first to respond to Barry's post that started this thread a while back, and my reply was that the gold standard, in my opinion, was Doug Thompson's tools. I stated that I had (and still have and use) several Glaser gouges. I also have several of Doug's tools now, and use them as well. I know that spending good money on superior tools or equipment is a wise investment -- I will only cry once, and thank every day afterward that I have a superior tool or piece of equipment that is simply a joyful pleasure to use.
I stand by my orginal statement, that right now, Doug's tools are still the gold standard. Doug's tools are superior, AFFORDABLE and AVAILABLE. Unless you are one of the top 1% of the world's woodturners, it's not an easy way to earn a living. The majority of us can't quit our day jobs, and/or need a very supportive AND understanding spouse or significant other to pay the bills. So if you want to buy superior equipment, the cost cannot be out of line to what is otherwise available for less money.
Right now, Paolo's tools are not available to me, so I have nothing to compare. But competition is good, because the average woodturner will ultimately benefit. I look forward to making a very shrewd comparison between Doug's and Paolo's tools, when the day comes that they are available. My comparison will factor the cost in addition to all the other factors important to me as a woodturner. Until then, Doug will have my business, along with JoHannes Michelsen, who uses Doug's tool steel to make his line of HannesTools.
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
Bill Blasic
>I hope that CET and the Glaser tools make their way back to the market as I've heard Doug say that it would be good for all woodturners. I personally don't see it making a difference on my purchases as Doug has from the beginning done a lot more than just sell his tools. There are things that Doug has done that do not see the light of day for my clubs and others I'm sure. As some of you know I have helped Doug sell his tools at a couple of venues and I've done this specifically because of what he did for my club (I also like being around woodturners). I have purchased a lot of Thompson tools and will continue to do so as they are to me the best bang for your buck that you will find.
Bill
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
fredbear34
>As I read through this thread, I can wish Paolo and his company well for those that are interested in their tools. Once upon a time I was interested, but have moved on and intend to invest what money I have available for tools with Doug Thompson for a simple reason - all of the quality with none of the attitude (and great customer service). Sorry, but the sniping by Mr. Marin absolutely turned me off on even trying his tools, and I suspect this is what prompted Larry Miller to also post, and I appreciate his sincerity and humility.
Fred Bearman
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d
>Fred I feel exactly the same as you. Thanks for the good post.
Let's not choose sides!!
Ed Moore in SW VA
>There are two nice guys, Doug and Paulo, who are in the tool-making business. Each has something to offer. No one questions the quality of Thompson Tools. No one questions the quality of Jerry Glaser tools. Let's be happy if both are in production and providing the woodturning community with their excellent tools. We are all winners if that happens.
Do you remember the hollowing tool legal hassle of a year or so ago? IT WAS UGLY!! No one won, and possibly we, the woodturning community, lost. Everyone was choosing sides in the manner of an elementary school playground. Let's not go there! Let's be pro-active and supportive of both in all this.
Only a few people know what really happened at CET. A few more may know the tip of the iceberg. But none of us "regular" guys and gals have an accurate picture. So, rather than make assumptions that are likely to be erroneous, let's aim for a little maturity and wait and see what happens. I want the best for Doug and for Paulo, BOTH!
Let's keep a positive attitude, avoid being sycophants, keep our eyes on the prize, and cheer them both on. If they both succeed, then we all win.
And of course, respect the bandsaw,
Ed
Re:There has been lots of talk about ....
Barbara Gill------WebKitFormBoundarypTwA+e87REJF0d
>Donna, both of your posts also reflect my feeling about Doug's tools.
Re: Let's not choose sides!!
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>There will always be a Ford vs Chevy and like the auto companies these are both made in America so we're ok. Once again I will say we need more companies and products for "us" the consumer. Over the past few years A11 steel went from being a expensive top of the line steel to one that is affordable. Selling tools without a handle brought the cost down so this steel is in most shops today... woodturners will always keep buying tools so there is a market for everyone. Larry, from your order you can see why Jimmy Clewes tools work so well. Good luck...
Re: Glaser/CET/Cryosteel Gouges ? ? ?
Keith Tompkins
>Larry, I don't have a horse in this race, but the bottom line is: business is business. Someone made promises they couldn't deliver on? Happens all the time. Move on...find another, more reliable supplier or vendor. I cannot help but wonder...Didn't Jerry have sources for materials and components for his tools? After all, it was a viable enterprise with a global reputation. I will give Doug Thompson credit...he has no board of directors, no major corporation to fall back on, no PhD to advise him on what steel to work with, yet he singlehandedly delivers a quality product to the woodturning community at a reasonable cost. I'm afraid it's going to take a long time to restore the damage done to CMT's reputation.
UNFAIR TREATMENT
O. Navarro
>I have been reading some of these posts about CET, Paulo Marin, Glaser tools and Thompson tools and would like to say that I am discussed with people's reactions and their bashing of CET.
I own several Jerry Glaser gouges, and several CET/Glaser gouges and I can say that I was impressed with the tools produced by CET. All I read about these comments is how Thompson Lathe tools are great, so I decided to do a comparison. A friend of mine let me have some of Doug's tools to do a comparison test.
First I looked at the appearance of the tool. I noticed that Jerry Glaser old tools were capped at the end of his handle with an oil plug. That makes it difficult when you remove the blade to replace it. Most of the time you have no control where that lead will go.
His handle had a dull burgundy/red color anodize and I noticed on old Jerry Glaser tools, the flute did not have a clean sweep all the way to the back. It seems that the grinding stopped at one point, leaving rough material at the end.
New Glaser tools have a red powder coated handle, where Jerry's signature is engraved (nice touch...). I also like the Made in America engraved in the back. Also they added a screw-on hex polished aluminum button, which allows you to unscrew and safely remove the lead.
At this point, Thompson lathe tools do not come handled. I have read from another turner on this blog named Gordon that Doug is currently working on an aluminum handle with lead shot.. What???
Aluminum handle with lead shot???? That is sounding more and more like a copy of Glaser Tools... He even offers a V-Shape tool, which was conceived by Jerry. Well whatever...lets just continue.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Old Jerry Glaser gouges do not have a nice finish all the way up the flute. It seems that the grind stops at a certain point. It looks like whoever was making Jerry's tool did not have the capability of continuously cleaning that flute all the way up.
------------------------------------------------------------------
My new Glasers have a beautiful finish all the way to the end where the flute ends.
DT> Doug's tool also is clean all the way up, so my conclusion was that these days with the advent of new equipment, whoever made the tools in the past did not have the ability to grind that end slope.
------------------------------------------------------------------
After testing all these gouges for performance, I can say I prefer the old and new Glasers simply because they are a COMPLETE TOOL..they are the REAL THING. As a unit, they perform much better than a Thompson tool, because you have an entire system at hand comprised of lead filled handles, great handle design (cold sometimes, but I can take it). At the end it is in my opinion the Mercedes of tools. I do not believe all this talk about changing Jerry' flutes, grinds etc.. I know they had a bad experience with Stuart Batty, but he is no longer there and it seems they moved on (from what I read from Larry Miller). I do not believe Paolo's post was offensive AT ALL. As a matter of fact, I have followed his posts and all he can say is how he wishes Doug the best. Besides, I am positive Jerry Glaser just did not sell his company and stayed away from everything. I am sure he still overlooks his tools.
To simply say that Thompson's tools are better because he uses the same material Jerry Glaser has been using for decades I think is preposterous. Even the fact that Doug's tools have a gun metal finish like Glaser tools, tells me that he basically copied from Jerry Glaser and added his own touch to it. Why not make them black or gold Doug? So what has Doug Thompson created or implemented on his tools that make them so special?
After researching his website about his triple tempering, cryogenics and so on, I decided to call a local heat treating facility around the Washington area. I was told that heat treatment procedures should follow the manufacturers guidelines, so triple tempering and cryogenics are customers choices for that specific material.
So, since Jerry Glaser has been cryogenically treating his tools for decades and probably has more experience with it than anybody in woodturning, I believe Doug did not create any new procedures that justifies a claim of uniqueness.
So what is good about a Thompson gouge?? Well, the answer is price. If Doug can make a tool cheaper (it seems he is a one man show) than he is simply giving CET price competition. Plus the fact that I understand he is a nice guy and his service is great.
Well, he should be a nice guy and his service should be great, because that is what competition is all about. I received good service from CET and Paulo Marin was very nice to me.
I appreciate the fact that Doug Thompson is trying to make a mark for himself, after all, this is America, but he cannot claim he designed or created anything new, because at the end of the day, Doug Thompson did not design these flutes from scratch or implemented new procedures that would make him unique.
Ultimately folks, this is no rocket science we are talking about! When was the last time you went to a party and said...I just talked to David Elsworth and people said: Really??? You talked to David Elsworth??? Oh my God, I envy you.
I believe that you buy what you like and what your pocket can afford. I will always buy a Glaser tool, no matter who makes it, because nobody can deny that Jerry Glaser is a legend! There are no tool makers alive today that have a reputation like him, and the day Jerry Glaser goes, it would be just like losing the Sam Maloof of woodturning. Glaser tools have been around for a pretty long time. I wish Doug the best, but only time will tell if he will able to create a legacy as enduring as Jerry Glaser.
As for CET/Paulo Marin, I congratulate you sir. At least, you have been been given the chance to continue Jerry's tradition. I wish you the best. I have witnessed how giving you were to the AAW and other clubs and how nice you are to people.
You have some pretty big shoes to fill and hopefully you will be able to do a good job to carry Jerry's name.
Orlando Navarro
�People love chopping wood. In this activity one immediately sees results.� Albert Einstein
I hope Paulo brings back the Glaser screw chuck
John Cotten
>I have owned one for years, and use it to begin nearly every bowl I make. Excellent tool.
Very well said!
Rik
>
Ed - I agree 100%!
Rik (WI)
>