Re: Pros and cons of your lathe *LINK*
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Brian,
I have been busy, so only saw the Subject of your last post about this, and did not get to read any of it.
I read most of this thread. The one problem that I see with every lathe suggested (except the VB36) is the footprint. I have a 12''x24' shop. When I was searching for my first big lathe (not Jet Mini), I had the opportunity to buy a Jet 1642 from TD for our club, and had to have it in my shop for a couple of weeks. It completely dominated the shop space. As much as I love most of the other lathes, I realized that I did not want a full bed lathe. I so bowls. If I need to do spindles, I can pull out the Jet Mini with that bed extention. Besides, after turning bowls for years on the Jet Mini, I liked being able to stand in front of the bowl (open end) and not have a lathe bed in the way. Yes, most of the suggested lathes offer the ability to move the headstock or have attachement to allow this, but while you are using it this way most of the time, you have another 30"-40" of bed out there taking up shop space.
I could not afford the VB36.
I saw, and settled on the Vega 2400 (now the 2600). The footprint is about same size a refrigerator. Read my review that I did not long after buying it. After using it for a couple of years her is my pro and con list.
CON:
1) No spindle lock (Vega is working to produce one, in the meantime, I do not mine using a tommy bar)
2) No indexing, but then I never wished I had one since then. I do have an indexing chuck and an indexing plate I can use if I ever need one)
3)Only 17" or so of bed - can be a problem when making a hollow form over 15" tall. But since then, I built a proto-type of a bed extension, and Vega started producing them. You can unbolt it and store it away in a minute or so.
4) Only 17" max between centers. This is only a problem if you are using a captured hollowing tool that needs a secondary tool rest. To solve this problem with my new Jamieson hollower, I just built a pedestal to hold the back rest. I can put that in a corner when I do not need it.
5) Odd looking at first glance. (BTW see the pictures on the home page of Vega (not the ones on the 2600 lathe page - those are dated)
PRO:
1) It takes up little space.
2) Price. Contact Vega, but not as much as a PM3520. $2800 w/ shipping.
3) Wide footprint. It makes it very stable, more so than other lathes in its weight range. I put my on a moble base and have never regretted it.
4) Adjustable spindle height. 37" to 42"
5) Quiet
6) All American made (OK, maybe not the Controller).
7) If you need help, you can call them and talk to the owner if you need to - not a call center or a secretary).
Since I got it, I have NEVER had lathe envy again. I turn on most every lathe there is at demos around the region, and I still do not wish to change.
Buy Bill Grumbines new video, he uses the Vega in the video. Bill has one and really likes it.
I don't think I know a single person that just does bowls that has one that wishes he had not bought one.
Email me if you have questions.
Mark
http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=reviews&file=articles_503.shtml