Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Pros and cons of your lathe

Posts

Pros and cons of your lathe

#1

Pros and cons of your lathe

Brian McInturff in SC

>I posted this in the lathes subject below but most probably didn't see it. Please take a few minutes and post to help a fellow turner out.

This has been great seeing what everyone has. Since I'm looking at upgrading to a more Heavy Duty lathe(I have a Oneway 1018) how about giving your own Pros and Cons of your lathe. Especially those with the Powermatics, Stubbys, Oneways, Vicmarcs and Robust. These are the ones that I've been looking at.I'm still several months from the actual purchase but it takes time to make the decision I turn bowls and would like to get into true hollow forms which I just can't do on my Oneway 1018. The kicker here is my shop is only 12x16 but I can dedicate another 12x16 building just for my lathe, wood and accessories. Turning on each of these isn't something I'll be able to do(some I can) but even then I know I won't spot all the inconveniences that may arise from use over time. So, here's a chance to really brag about your lathe and or talk about the problems you wished weren't there. Thanks and yes I continue to research the various archives.

Brian McInturff in Myrtle Beach, SC

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#2

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have the Oneway 1640 and am unable to think of one negative thing about the lathe. That means everything is positive. :-)

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#3

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

john lucas

>Powermatic 2035A. No indexing, the 2035B does have this. The spindle lock could have more positions Although 2 isn't bad. I love the sliding headstock but it has it's problems. Turning off the end of the lathe is better than swinging headstocks because the lathe is more stable. The downside is that just like swinging the head, the tool rest isn't always where you want it. For most things it works well but if you decide you want to turn something bigger than the lathe capacity then you have to build a free standing tool rest. The 2035B has a lower bed extension mounting hole that should solve this problem.

Space. Working off the end of the lathe requires that you have a good 4 or 5 more feet of space on that end of the lathe. I have the bed extension on my lathe so it requires a lot of space. This is where the Stubby really shines. It gives you a short bed lathe but will still let you turn fairly long spindles.

Big lathes have heavy parts. My tailstock is 57lbs. You don't want to pick up that much weight carelessly. That's why I'm a big fan of Robust. I like the way they did the rotating tailstock. A swinging tailstock would still be in the way for some tool movements. If you turn a lot of small stuff moveing the big tool rest around gets tiring. It does slide easily but is still heavy. I turn small stuff on my mini lathes for that reason. Same is true for tailstock movement. It slides easily but is so heavy you can't move it quickly in and out of position.

It would be nice to have speed control on the optional on/off switch. That shouldn't be hard to rig up and I may do it someday.

Moving the machine. Oneway was smart. The leg set works great. On a really smooth concrete floor you can slide the powermatic but I only weigh 160lbs so it's hard to move it this way. I built a set of wheels that I can set the powermatic on. I jack it up with a rolling hydraulic jack and set it on the wheels. Then I can move it around the shop if necessary.

Ideally I would like to see the headstock redesigned so there was more room around the nose of the spindle. Most lathes don't have this. The Oneway has done it a little and I haven't turned on the Euro/silverdrive lathes but they look like they might have more room between the faceplate and headstock body.

All in all I'm real happy with this lathe. Most of the things I'm talking about are small problems easily worked around.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#4

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Brian, don't leave the VB36 off your list. As a bowl lathe, it's unsurpassed. If there's a negative, it's the shortness of the tailstock assembly, but that's not much of a problem. Great machine.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#5

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Allen Neighbors

>Like Barbara, I have a Oneway 1640. Now I'll tell you right off: Because I wanted to turn bowls and hollowforms, I would have bought a VB36, but I couldn't justify the extra 4 Grand of the price, and the extra weight on my wooden floor, so I bought the Oneway 1640. I added the Bed Extension, 2436 Toolrest, and Tailstock Riser.

Pros of the 1640: Quiet; smooth; 2 HP (option) powerful; Headstock design gives plenty of room between the headstock and the turning; height adjustable; Heavy enough to not walk around if it's not bolted down; Stainless steel ways; Designed by turners, so it's easy to blow shavings off; Smooth movement of toolrest and headstock, and lock downs are awesome; Indexing system (48 position, I think); 2 position headstock lock; 17 inch bed extension on headstock end makes it 24" capable (there aren't that many 24" bowl blanks around here, but I use this end for a lot of bowls); I could go on, all day, but there isn't enough room in the forum for all my prattle. :o)

Cons of the 1640: None. Absolute satisfaction.

Let me end this with some Bill Crommett advice: Don't settle for second best. Sell your firstborn, if necessary, then make enough bowls to buy him back! (shortened, but close) :o)

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#6

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Oneway 2436 3 hp VS

Pro

By adding the the 48' dia ways on the headstock end

you can turn outboard on that end

you can set up a second jaw chuck

you can start inboard between centers and move directly to an outboard jaw chuck to finish the inside

the bigy QUALITY

cons

none that I know of

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#7

Richard Allen

Oneway 2436

Richard Allen

>Pros:

Large swing, even larger with outboard attachment (36" over the banjo 48" over the bed).

3HP loads of power.

Smooth running.

Simple easy to understand and easy to use controls.

Solid easy to use banjo with well thought design and quality manufacture. The hole for the toolrest post is oblong with the curve opposite the locking is round with a nominal 1/2" radius. This give a solid lock to the toolrest yet provided easy adjustment of the tool rest when the locking lever is released. There are many many many such engineering choices made in this lathe which make the lathe a joy to use. Be sure and ask the manufacture (if you can talk to the manufacture) why certain features are the way they are. I did this with the lathe you mentioned and Oneway was the only manufacture who had reasons, other than money, for the features like shape of the bed, design of the banjo, hedstock design...

Service. If you have any questions about my Oneway lathe I talk with the owner, designer, builder of the lathe.

Constant improvment to the lathe. The basic 2436 lathe made today is better in several ways than the 2436 made five years ago.

Oneway is making additions to their lathes which expand the use and safety of their lathes. Tailstock riser fot the large outboard bed, dust hood, bowl steady...

Brass acents for several of the handles.

The company is backed by a larger castings company so I can expect Oneway to be around as long as Kevin want to run the company. Serious Lathe made very nice lathe with a lot of the positive attributes that I have listed above. But Bernie didn't have the backing of a larger company and he eventauly was forced to give up. The same thing happened to Poolewood, Stuby, Woodfast, Nichols, Conover. Sure you can still get parts and support for some of these thats but nothing that would compaire with the service you will get from Oneway.

Cons:

Cost, the Oneway 2436 is an expensive lathe.

The Nova line of chucks don't support and insert to fit the 33mm spindle of the lathe.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#8

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

David

>I have a 3-hp Vicmarc VL300 and I think it is an outstanding lathe. I had a 1-1/2 hp Nova 3000 and while it was a good lathe to gain experience on, I eventually wanted a larger swing and more power. The VL300 can be configured in different ways, and I got mine from Craft Supplies because it came with a 1-1/4" X 8 tpi spindle and I could use all the faceplates, chucks, and my vacuum setup from the Nova. For me, this was one of the key factors that swayed the decision to Vicmarc, because cost is a strong consideration. For the other lathes I was considering-Oneway and VB36, I would have had to get adapters for most of my accessories. I considered a Stubby for a while, but there are only a few in Hawaii and I never got to see one close up much less work on it. I got the VL300 shortbed, and I like being able to go around the end to hollow bowl shapes. Another deciding factor was like slamming the door when you look for a new car-the sound it makes. A fellow club member showed me his VL300 and just switched it on. The sound was so smooth and quiet! This combination of factors for me added up to the best value in a lathe, and have not regretted my decision. I heard one person remark that he should have gotten the longbed version. For me, there are no downsides. I recently spent some time with Neil and Liz Scobie when they were in Hawaii. Neal has a Vicmarc, and he said it was the best lathe around, and I certainly had no disagreement with that!

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#9

Want to try a PM3520b

Bob Fawcett

>I see you are in Myrtle Beach. I have a PM3520b and live in Savannah, GA. If you would like to try it contact me. Remove nospam from my email above.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#10

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Russ Fairfield

>I have never used a lathe that didn't have something I didn't like. But, we learn to live with, ignore, or work around the problems. I have been a Oneway owner for over 10 years, lathe No-16, so I am long past that point where its faults have dissappeared from memory.

My personal opinion is that the Oneway 1640 is the best lathe we can buy. It costs $1500 more than a 16" Jet and $1000 more than a 20" Powermatic, and that can be an issue.

My reasoning is that the size and horsepower to do almost everything we want from a lathe. If we ever want to turn bigger things, we can add the extension to the outboard side and have a respectable 24" bowl lathe, and Oneway now has an optional riser-block so the tailstock can be used on the outboard side.

You can buy a cheaper lathe, but there are two (2) other advantages to the 1640 that are often overlooked. The first is that any lathe with a sliding or swiveling head will have to be realigned every time it is moved. The accuracy of the realignment, or whether it is done at all, will depend on how accurate you will be turning. Accuracy becomes important if you are drilling deep holes, or making boxes or things where accuracy is important. Add to that the fact that the best of the locking devices on the headstock is never 100% secure, and that vibration or heavy intermittent loads can move the clamped headstock. The Oneway is aligned one time, at the factory with a dial indicator, and they include the readings in the instruction manual. They are the only manufacturer who does this. That is important to me.

The other factor is the location of the controls, levers, handles, and the direction they turn. This wouldn't matter if this were your first and only lathe. However, since you already have a 1018, there is an advantage to having all of the levers and handles in the same place and turning in the same direction. Believe me when I say that this can be at the least a constant aggravation, and at the worst a safety hazard, when there is more than one lathe in the shop.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#11

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Sean Troy

>Powermatic 4224. Heaviest lathe of the majors, thickest ways. 3hp motor. Cost value. Long bed. I see no short commings.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#12

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

john lucas

>Russ Can't argue with anything you say except the alignment of the sliding headstock. I've used bunch of powermatics and the headstock and tailstock align perfectly and have stayed that way on my lathe and the ones at school. One of the reasons I changed from the Nova was the swiveling head which required using the double morse taper to get everything realigned. I've also never had a problem with the headstock locking down and not moving. I've even turned long spindles that required I hang about half the headstock off the lathe. It still stayed locked.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#13

Brian, as I posted earlier....

TDaniel

>I have 2 VB-36 lathes and a VL300 and VL100 Vicmarc. I told you earlier that I was happy now with my VL300 but only because Kevin at One-way made me a banjo and toolrest to replace the poorly designed one that came with the VL300. One-way has the best toolrest and banjo assembly on the market and nothing on the lathe gets moved more than the toolrest. A toolrest that slips can ruin a $200 burl in a split second. You can buy an almost good lathe and then make a hybrid out of it to get rid of problems or you can spend a few dollars more and get an excellent lathe right out of the box with service to match. My advice to everyone is to spend, even if you have to get a note at the bank for a year or two, whatever you must to get a lathe tht does not frustrate you. The One-way 1640 is adequate for most turners and the price is reasonable considering what you get. A step up would be the One-way 2436 but in most cases that is overkill. As Malcolm stated, if your interest is primarily bowls and hollowforms do not overlook the VB-36 which is an awesome machine also. Since you don't have much room the VB may be your answer because it has a very small footprint in bowlmaking dress.

TD

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#14

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Russ Fairfield

>I will concede that you could be right and that Powermatic has improved their locking mechanisms on the head and tail, but I havent used one of them yet. Having secure locks hasn't always been true for Powermatic, and there are still a lot of the old machines being sold at lower prices. The new buyer would have to make sure that they were getting the latest model numbers.

The smaller Jet versions of the same lathe still suffer from inadequate locks, and the triple wammy of having both sliding and swiveling headstocks and sloppy fits. Most owners would never know the difference.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#15

Re: Brian, as I posted earlier....

Brian McInturff in SC

>Terry,

One thing that seems as a negative on the VB is the height of the spindle. I see most build a platform to stand on. I still plan on coming over and checking out the lathes. I let you know when I confirm dates. Thanks, Brian

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#16

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Brian McInturff in SC

>Russ,

I too wondered about alignment with a sliding headstock or swiveling one. I'm not even considering a swiveling head. Of course like many I like the price of the Powermatic but I love my oneway. The 1640 is really at the top of my list but I'm concerned about the footprint with the outboard attachment. The Stubby, Robust, and Aussie VL300 are my other considerations right now besides the Powermatic and Oneway. Service and support are also being weighed and the Stubby and VL300 could fallout of running due to that. This will be my last lathe I buy so I have to be certain of my decision and not wish different afterwards. Brian

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#17

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

OB O'Brien

>Brian; I have a Stubby 750. I went from a Craftsman tube lathe to a Stubby and haven't looked back. It has a small footprint, the stand is adjustable in height and together weighs about 800 pounds. Is stable and great to turn large and small items on. It's easy to get in tight for the inside of bowls and the bed extends to do spindles and table legs. As far as service I have had one occasion that I needed the controller. Lightening got it. John jordan had a new one on the way the next day. The new owner of the Stubby dealership, Bill Rubinstein is equally effective responding to to the few problems that I have seen come up on the Stubby forum. I would highly recommend it as your last lathe. Good luck in your choice. OB

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#18

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

john lucas

>The early powermatics had several problems. Fortunately they have been listening to someone and correcting most of them. Of course they are still trying to keep them in a certain price range and for that reason they still have minor problems. I think the Jet 16 and the Powermatic 2035 are the best lathes in that price range.

I sure won't argue against Oneway. Those lathes, and especially the service are superb. Unfortunately most of us are on a budget and that often drops them out.

I'll also agree with Terry. Taking out a small loan to buy a better lathe will be worth it in the long run. I've upgraded 4 times now and each time cost me money. I went mildly in debt to get the Powermatic and haven't regretted it. Wish I could have bit the bullet and gotten a 2436 Oneway. I'm pretty sure that would do all I want to do.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#19

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Clay Foster

>Brian,

I've had a Oneway 2036 for 10 years, and I haven't found anything about it yet that I would change. It would be number 30 something, except it is a signature model. I've also never had a single problem with it. Even if I did, Oneway is famous for their customer service.

I've had the opportunity to use just about every lathe that is still currently on the market except the VB. I think for the hobby turner the Oneway 1640 is a terrific choice, for the same reasons that Russ listed. The 2036 would be a good choice if you can spend a little more money. I've known a lot of people who got a 2436 thinking they would have the capacity to turn something big if they ever wanted to, but after finding out how much labor is involved in big pieces (and how small the market is for them), they never do it again, and spend the rest of their life pushing around that big heavy tool rest and tailstock.

The Oneway and the Stubby lathes are the only ones I've found that the headstock lines up exactly with the tailstock the whole length of the bed. Some lathes will match with the tailstock up point to point with the headstock, but the further away the tailstock is moved, the further out of alignment the points get.


img

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#20

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Hooligan

>Biggest con of my oneway, working over the ways, no matter what I am doing. Drives me nuts. Oh, and early in my ownership of it, there was a sharp edge somewhere, and it laid my arm open to the tune of 36 stitches. No idea how, just one of those freek things.

Pros of the OW, its stout, and plenty of room to work around the headstock. I've filled it, so that is almost zero vibration. All in all, its a good lathe.

Though, for the money I'd rather have gotten two powermatics. The more I turned on the oneway, I started to go back to the powermatic for more and more. It just made sense. Sliding headstock, made it easier to wok on anything without having to straddle the ways. The 4224 is heavy enough that I can stick a 24" log on it that is out of balance, and spin it.

I am actually going to have to get a new lathe, because I sold the shop, and it will no longer be my profession. I think that I am going to go to a 1642, and a 3520. Most likely I will go 3520, until the 1642 becomes a necessary evl.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#21

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I agree about the alinment of the Powermatic. It is excellent. If alinment is a problem with a aliding headstock then why isn't it nessesary with a sliding tailstock? I see no differance. I have a Powermatic 3520A(best valued lathe)and a Oneway 2436 (best quality lathe).

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#22

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

robo hippy

>I have a 3520 A, and love it. The only reason, other than price that I can see for opting for the Oneway or one of the other bigger capacity lathes is if you are going to be turning bowls in those ranges, and from my 9 years of selling at shows, bowls over 16 inches are getting into a specialty market. They are more for parties, and big groups, not every day family use. The sliding headstock gives you the features of a bowl lathe; short bed so you don't have to lean over the ways to turn (which is a huge back saver) and you don't have to switch to outboard. It also is an excellent spindle lathe. I would like the standard bed to be a bit longer as a 30 inch table leg just squeeks in on the lathe, but they do have a bed extention. The only change I would make to the PM is to make the headstock spindle an assembly that can be unbolted and removed. I did wear out one set of headstock bearings (I turn a lot of bowls from chainsawn blanks, and don't use the tailstock), and had to haul the whole headstock down to my repair guy. Now, I have a belt that is wearing, and would replace it except that I have to remove the spindle bearings and all to do it.

robo hippy

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#23

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Brian,

I have been busy, so only saw the Subject of your last post about this, and did not get to read any of it.

I read most of this thread. The one problem that I see with every lathe suggested (except the VB36) is the footprint. I have a 12''x24' shop. When I was searching for my first big lathe (not Jet Mini), I had the opportunity to buy a Jet 1642 from TD for our club, and had to have it in my shop for a couple of weeks. It completely dominated the shop space. As much as I love most of the other lathes, I realized that I did not want a full bed lathe. I so bowls. If I need to do spindles, I can pull out the Jet Mini with that bed extention. Besides, after turning bowls for years on the Jet Mini, I liked being able to stand in front of the bowl (open end) and not have a lathe bed in the way. Yes, most of the suggested lathes offer the ability to move the headstock or have attachement to allow this, but while you are using it this way most of the time, you have another 30"-40" of bed out there taking up shop space.

I could not afford the VB36.

I saw, and settled on the Vega 2400 (now the 2600). The footprint is about same size a refrigerator. Read my review that I did not long after buying it. After using it for a couple of years her is my pro and con list.

CON:

1) No spindle lock (Vega is working to produce one, in the meantime, I do not mine using a tommy bar)

2) No indexing, but then I never wished I had one since then. I do have an indexing chuck and an indexing plate I can use if I ever need one)

3)Only 17" or so of bed - can be a problem when making a hollow form over 15" tall. But since then, I built a proto-type of a bed extension, and Vega started producing them. You can unbolt it and store it away in a minute or so.

4) Only 17" max between centers. This is only a problem if you are using a captured hollowing tool that needs a secondary tool rest. To solve this problem with my new Jamieson hollower, I just built a pedestal to hold the back rest. I can put that in a corner when I do not need it.

5) Odd looking at first glance. (BTW see the pictures on the home page of Vega (not the ones on the 2600 lathe page - those are dated)

PRO:

1) It takes up little space.

2) Price. Contact Vega, but not as much as a PM3520. $2800 w/ shipping.

3) Wide footprint. It makes it very stable, more so than other lathes in its weight range. I put my on a moble base and have never regretted it.

4) Adjustable spindle height. 37" to 42"

5) Quiet

6) All American made (OK, maybe not the Controller).

7) If you need help, you can call them and talk to the owner if you need to - not a call center or a secretary).

Since I got it, I have NEVER had lathe envy again. I turn on most every lathe there is at demos around the region, and I still do not wish to change.

Buy Bill Grumbines new video, he uses the Vega in the video. Bill has one and really likes it.

I don't think I know a single person that just does bowls that has one that wishes he had not bought one.

Email me if you have questions.

Mark


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=reviews&file=articles_503.shtml

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#24

Use a link belt

Bill Howatt

>

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Brian, I turn on a General, 20", VS. This is a long-bed lathe, which works out perfectly for me, as I turn spindles as well as bowls and hollow forms. The long-bed allows the use of a captured rig for hollow-forms, and I can turn long spindles as well. I have an attachment for turning outboard, (Thanks, Jamie)which allows me 28" unrestricted capacity. Frankly, anything over a 20" capacity is overkill for most turners.

The General is probably the most dated design on the market, which has its good and bad points. I like this machine...it LOOKS like a lathe, and it's very comfortable to operate. It's become an old friend. The design is bulletproof, benefitting from over 50 years of service. 2 HP Baldor motor is more than adequate, and this lathe is among the smoothest running lathes available. The tailstock still lines up perfectly with the headstock after several years of service, and the headstock is fully adjustable if needed. the speed control is also well designed, allowing for "O" spindle speed and precise adjustment. The lathe is equipped with indexing, which is a requirement for me.

Since the design is dated, it is in need of several updates: inboard and outboard spindles are different sizes, and the gap-bed design should be scrapped. The spindle sizes should be the same, and a groove for a set-screw would be appreciated. A proper factory outboard attachment would be a welcome addition. I'd like to see a new belt drive system, as well as a modular bearing set-up for easy maintenance. I would like to see longer travel in the tailstock, which should be hollow. These things don't affect the operation of the lathe too much, but would modernize things greatly.

I've had no trouble with the banjo or toolrest, although the one-way is more substantial. I've turned on every lathe except the VB, and this machine compares very well with them all, especially considering the cost. When, and if I decide to upgrade, I'm keeping the General.