Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Pros and cons of your lathe

Posts

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#26

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe Robust 25x28

Phil Powell

>I have a Robust 25x28 and I truely think it was a great buy. I looked at OneWays, Vicmarcs,

Stubbys, Powermatics and a couple others. After a lot of thought I purchased the Robust

for several reasons. It came with a powerful 3hp Leeson motor, a tilt away tail stock (that I

wouldn't work without) stainless steel ways and a sliding headstock that locks at both ends.

The Lathe has a wide foot print and adjustable height legs. To cinch the deal Brent English

(Robust owner) is a great guy that worked with me on my special needs. No one has a better

guarantee AND it's truely an American made machine.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#27

Re: Use a link belt

john lucas

>Powermatic uses a flat belt. Link belt won't work

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#28

Re: But, when you order your

Allen Neighbors

>Nova chuck, you just specify the 33mm X 3.5 threads of the Oneway, and that's what you get. The only con to this is making it fit another lathe with different threads.

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#29

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

john lucas

>I was hoping you would chime in here. I thought about the Vega earlier and wanted to say some things about it, but I don't feel confident enough on the specs to speak about accurately.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#30

Build it...

dwr

>Cost of a good lathe was an issue for me. I wanted to focus on bowl/face plate work and the better lathes were anywhere from $3,500 to $8,000+ delivered.

I decided to build one.

I now have a bowl lathe with:

1. 5HP Leeson motor NEW

2. Poly Groove J10 belt NEW

3. Custom 6061 Aluminum Pulleys NEW

4. Custom 4140 Precision Ground 2.25" spindle with through bore and 1.25 x 8 threads on both ends NEW

5. 1.875" double roller bearings front and rear NEW

6. T.B. Woods X2C 5HP VFD controller NEW

7. 1/2" solid steel upper and lower housings CNC plasma cut

8. Polished Stainless Steel Spindle Housing

9. Powder Coated inside and out

10. Custom, expandable and adjustable Tool Rest and Tail Stock

By doing the design work in AutoCAD, sending RFQ's to various metal working forums, some patient judicious buying on Ebay, and some work from friends in wiring the controller, I have been able to develop a lathe with greater capacity than the mega thousand commercial units, with a budget of less than $2K over the last year or so.

If money were not an issue, a VB36 would be a great lathe for me and my congenital back defect. But funds were not there, so I used what I had available and spent a lot of hours designing and bidding out the processes and searching Ebay and now have a lathe that will handle a 95" diameter blank before hitting the floor.

With the relationship I have developed and lessons learned, I am in a position to build another lathe that will be even better than this current one, for less money... but want to enjoy this one first!!

Anyone that wants to build his or her own lathe can. It's easier than you might think.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#31

Re: Build it...

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>I have been interested in building my own lathe and wonder if you could post a picture or 2 of the one you built.

Thanks,

Wayne

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#32

That was me

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Only because it would be nice to have the extra bed length.....you never know. Hollowing, I sit on the ways and would have done the same had I ordered the longer version. Like you I have the CS version and absolutely no complaints....oh wait, I didn't like the fact that I had to remove 4 screws to open the headstock to change pulleys. Removed the screws and put four rare earth magnets in their place, opens and closes with ease. No complaints. Wonderful, powerful, smooth and quiet lathe. Won't replace it.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#33

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Bob Fawcett

>Powermatic footprint is 24" x 50.5" for the main bed.

Add 12" for the motor with the headstock all the way back.

Add 18" for the short bed extension.

This means I can setup in space 24" x 80.5".

You will need to leave some space at the tailstock end for turning with the headstock all the way at that end of the lathe.

You also need another 10" at the headstock end for knockout bar clearance. This is in addition to the 12" for motor clearance. You could just slide the headstock and knockout the center, so this is not a must have.

I don't know the footprint of the Oneway, but I am sure someone could measure for you.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#34

Clay, I don't doubt...

Bob Fawcett

>your assertion that other lathes don't line up for the full bed length, but how would you measure that??

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#35

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Allen Neighbors

>I haven't measured it exactly, but the OW1640 is between 75 and 80 inches in my configuration. I'll get exact measurements, if anyone wants me to. I have the bed extension mounted on the headstock end, for bowl turning.

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#36

Re: Clay, I don't doubt...

Allen Neighbors

>Remove the live center from the tail stock, and the chuck from the headstock, and run a long piece of allthread or some such item through each. It will be easy to tell if either is out of kilter.

Just my guess. :o)

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#37

I thought you might chime in.

Bob Fawcett

>

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#38

Re: PS: Speed Changes

Allen Neighbors

>Speed changes are easy with the VS. To change from Higher to lower speed ranges involves removing the upper cover (I keep the set screw hand tight, so I don't have to have a wrench), and the lower cover (which has no mechanical fasteners). It takes all of 15 seconds to change speed ranges.

Most of my turnings are done completely on the lower range.

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#39

Sounds like a great lathe...

Bob Fawcett

>I too, would love to see pictures.

I am sure there would be a lot of interest if you wanted to write up your experience and post or publish it.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#40

Re: Sounds like a great lathe...

Allen Neighbors

>You're right, Bob. It would make a truly interesting article.

I vote for the pics and a write-up. :o)

Allen

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#41

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Bill Howatt

>I also have the 26020VD and I love it. It looks like a bomb would bounce off it.

I pretty well agree with your comments and I know if I hadn't bought the gap-filler I would have wished I had.

I thought the different inboard/outboard spindle sizes was strange but it hasn't caused me problems. Even if they were both 1-1/4" wouldn't there still be a RH, LH thread issue so you couldn't use the same accessories/adapters anyway?

I didn't like where the speed pot was such that I had to reach in front of a rough bowl blank to adjust it. I remoted my on/off pushbuttons and speed pot.

Oneways are nice but they cost twice as much as the General.

Bill

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#42

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Barry Turner

>I have had a Stubby 750 for about a year and a half. For a large lathe, it really does not take up all that much room unless you extend the bed to turn longer stock. The speed control is impeccable. It is heavy, smooth quiet and has all the power I need. To move it into my shop, I had to disassemble and reassemble the lathe. There is not a better way to get acquainted with the construction of a new machine. If there were any corners cut, they are few. Few things in this life work as well as this lathe. I have had absolutely no second thoughts about the purchase.

Before that, I had a Jet Mini. (Actually, I still have it.) It too was smooth and quiet, though not heavy or powerful. Power was adequate for the lathe's capacity. For the money, one would be hard put to find a better lathe. I still use it for winestoppers, ornaments and similar small stuff.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#43

In the works...

dwr

>I have a diary or log/journal in the works, as one of my friends recommended I post the history of the lathe. Anyone that is interested, if you e-mail me, I will add you to a list to notify once the journal is complete and ready to post, so you will be sure not to miss it. I need to figure out how to submit an article to WC...;)

Here is a picture of the motor and spindle mocked up...

I will try to get the journal updated and posted soon, so stay tuned...


img

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#44

one more before the journal posting...

dwr

>... okay, one more picture of the construction from my archives... Guess I need to get busy and finish the journal. Only thing left to do is some minor wiring, test everythig, and then off to the powder coating... still wrestling with what color to powder coat it... so many to choose from... Suggestions?


img

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#45

Re: Sounds like a great lathe...

dwr

>Bob,

Here is another in process picture, a profile shot.

Look for the write up...

... sorry about the size, I have not taken time to really do this posting right...


img

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#46

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

Keith Tompkins

>HI Bill, the Oneway adapter I have for my chuck has both right and left hand threads in it....if both spindles were the same size, it would be convenient. now, to save time, I use two chucks, one inboard, one out. I agree, the pot is really not in the best spot.

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#47

Re: Bright red?

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#48

Jet 1642

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I figured I'd chime in here about my Jet JWL-1642.

Cons:



  • The tailstock shaft has a tendency to get plated and clogged with debris. Even with a strict cleaning regimen. When this happens, the handwheel will become hard to turn. After a while, the set screws marr the shaft. Then out comes the emory paper to renew this surface! I've had to perform more maintenance than I would have preferred on this. I also would prefer some type of feature that would allow you to adjust the alignment. (Maybe a a set screws and phenolic wear pad type of arrangement?) I would have preferred a design like the new Powermatic 3520B. Speaking of which, I wonder if they're compatible? And if they are, I wonder if the same could be said for the Powermatic's Tool rest? Hmmmmmmmm......food for thought


  • The "tool basket" underneath is a complete and utter waste of space. The same can be said of the wire cage "safety guard". Why not use the money wasted on these "accessories" for something more useful. Like a real spindle lock or index plate? (see below)


  • While I seldom turn huge bowls or hollow forms, I sometime wish I had waited and purchased the 2 HP version (see below)


  • The "spindle lock/index mechanism" is chessey at best. A shop built one works fine. But having one designed into the lathe would be a big plus


  • No provisions made for outboard turning other than that overly expensive cast iron stand (Come on! $300 or more for a cast iron tripod with a hole in top for your tool rest?). A value priced extension bed and tool rest would have been very welcomed. Maybe some type of "outboard turning" kit?


Pros:



  • The Variable Speed Drive works flawlessly. In the 4 or so years I've owned this lathe, it hasn't failed me yet. I really dig the RPM readout!


  • The cast iron legs were a bonus feature that really added mass and stability to this lathe. The ribs cast into these legs also makes adding a ballast box easy


  • The cast iron bed is very well made and is worlds better than that used on the old Jet 1236. It's nice and heavy and works well with the cast iron legs to provide a stable work surface and to dampen vibration.


  • I really like the sliding headstock. When working on hollow forms, I love the fact that I can slide the headstock closer to one end so I can work on the piece "head on". I also like to slide the headstock towards the center when working on small stuff like pens and bottle stoppers. It just adds versatility to the overall package.


  • This lathe is value priced (about $1800)for those of us that couldn't afford the extra $700 (or more) it would cost for a Powermatic 3520B


  • While all of us love "MORE POWER", I have to admit that the 1 1/2 HP motor has handled all that I threw at it. Attribute me wanting a 2HP to me just being a bit greedy!


  • The hollow cylindrical "handle" on the outboard side of the headstock is perfectly made for receiving a rotary union for vacuum chucking



See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#49

Re: My Stubby 1000's Problems

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Well.

For one, it's reeeely heavy. Took 4 guys and ropes to safely move the base section down to the basement.

Two, it's so quite, I tend to forget about it and just concentrate of the spinning wood.

Three, I had to wait a reeeely long time to get it. The night sweats were wicked.

Four, well, um . . . . . it's gray, yeeee-ah that's it. It's reeeeely gray.

Um, it does bowls as well as hollowforms (jars, actually) and spindles, but I had to sell my lathe saddle 'cause I didn't need it anymore. Took a real beating on that saddle.

|;-}}

Re: Pros and cons of your lathe

#50

Re: Clay, I don't doubt...

Clay Foster

>A low tech but fairly reliable method is to put a piece of wood about 2 feet long and about 4 inches in diameter on a faceplate and put it on the lathe. Flatten the tailstock end of the wood. Turning the wood by hand or powered at very low rpm so centrifugal force doesn't cause the wood to deflect, slowly bring the tailstock point up to the wood. If it draws a single point, the head stock and tailstock points are in alignment at that distance from each other. If it draws a circle, they are not aligned, probably because the bed is bowed or twisted.

This was the first test I did on a Stubby lathe the first time I tried one at JJ's studio. Even after unlocking everything and moving it in every direction, everything came back into perfect alignment after it was moved back into place and locked into position.

Stubbys and Oneways will reliably pass this test. Many brands are hit and miss. Sometimes misalignment is caused by the lathe resting on an uneven floor, causing the bed to twist. Bolting the lathe to a very stiff but twisted stand can also cause misalignment. Cast iron will flex.

Alignment may not matter to some people, but I've found it to be desirable for many methods of reverse chucking, and a good indicator of overall lathe quality.