Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Poll

Posts

Re: Poll

#51

Re: Poll

Juergen

>I've been on WOW since its inception and have never rec'd and Email from MyFamily. Should my feelings be hurt?

Re: Poll

#52

I Don't Think so

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Barry I really don't think that you are receiving e-mail from World of Woodturners.

Re: Poll

#53

This Reminds Me Of The 60's

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>People kept trying to "find themselves". It was difficult for me to relate to that since I never lost myself. I feel the same way about any art form. Some artists will branch out and discover different approaches some get pleasure out of the traditional. Some do both.

Re: Poll

#54

John, you confirmed

Wilford Bickel

>my point. If you only use the lathe for a minor part of the piece then it would be woodworking. A piece that is done with the lathe on spinning - is called woodturning! A number of the art pieces left woodturning a long, long, long time before completion! I may not know "Art" - but I know what "I" like and that is the traditional "WOODTURNING"!

Re: Poll

#55

Re: Poll

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Brian, that is your loss. Just because WOW is "private" should not be a reason for reverse snobbery. It is a wonderful site. I have learned a great deal there and enjoy my every visit. So what if I don't care for every post that is made there. Try it you will like it. :-)

Re: Poll

#56

Well Said!

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Poll

#57

Don't remember the 60's I was there.

john lucas

>I never found myself. I'm not lost, I know exactly where I am. I just don't know where I'm going. Won't ask for directions either.

Re: Poll

#58

Steven Antonucci

I've been banned from expressing my opinion

steve antonucci

>by HDV (re: a Gerrit Van Ness's piece) because he felt that my opinion attacked GVN "personally". HDV also deleted a bunch of posts (more than just mine) that were "non-constructive or explicitly about woodturning."

I've been thrown out of better places. He can hide behind his "Terms of Service" agreement all he wants, but when GVN is allowed to offend me with his opinion, and I am not allowed to express my offense with my opinion, there's something amiss.

It is the definition of the word censorship.

Sorry, I don't need WoW bad enough to compromise my principles.

Steve

Re: Poll

#59

Thank you for the explanation

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Herman,

Thank you for the explanation. What I perceived as "snobbery" on the part of WoW is actually only the result of the rules for myfamily.com.

I've been tempted to join your "family" a couple of times but "reverse snobbery" always held me back. Your explanation has changed my opinion and I'll send you an e-mail.

Thanks again for clearing that up for me.

Brian

Re: Poll

#60

Steven Antonucci

I see your point, but I disagreed...

steve antonucci

>I believe that you are correct in saying that WoW is his site, and he can do as he pleases (legally).

I disagree that he morally retains that right when he runs a public forum. I find it offensive that some people are given the right to post their unedited opinions on this public forum, while contrary opinions are deleted or surpressed.

I saw your opinion re: Malcolm's piece early on before I was banned from posting, and I thought it was well thought out, well constructed, and well worded. I also thought that of Malcolm's opinion. I respect both of your rights to both of your opinions, regardless of my position on the topic.

I have no idea what the thread has turned into, but based upon my experience with GVN's piece, contrary positions to "Attaboy- nice work" are not welcome. When HDV allowed GVN's piece to be displayed with the open invitation for commentary, I believe that you take all comments equally and respect peoples RIGHTS to their opinions, warts and all.

Allow me to express my outrage at HDV for his belief that he has the RIGHT to surpress my opinion about work posted at WoW. I'd guess I'm not alone.

HDV has graciously allowed me to still have "viewer access" to WoW... maybe I should go over there and see what all of the fuss is about?

Steve

P.S. I did mostly agree with your initial post on WoW, but I also understood MT's POV. I never clicked the link to the video or the Jackson Browne song. "Running on Empty" about does it for me with his stuff... :-)

Re: Poll

#61

Re: I see your point, but I disagreed...

Herman de Vries

>It had to happen, Steve. You took this public.

For the record, and to clear up confusion, I have continually stated that "personal attacks are not allowed".

Steve, you called the artist stupid, anti-American, and a bigot and a few other inflammatory things. Not only that, but you did it in FIFTEEN posts on one piece of art. All I asked you for was some restraint in your personal attacks and you attacked me instead.

I moderate, I don't censor. I try to stick to the rules of the game. If you do the same, you are welcome back at WoW.

Re: Poll

#62

Re: WOW is too snobby??? Then .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....how snobby can a current posting be when a WOW member is showing how to peel a pumpkin on his lathe! With a spokeshave!!!

Re: Poll

#63

Ditto that, Jamie!

David

>

Re: Poll

#64

Re: A split between art and.....

Jamie Donaldson

>......craft turning could never happen, because there is no known way to draw the line! There is no way to define the difference between what is art and what is craft, and this applies to most other mediums as well. And who would deside???

Re: Poll

#65

Sorry

Bob Fawcett

>Sorry, my comments were not directed at the AAW magazine. I don't have my first issue yet, and would be totally unqualified to comment on it.

Re: Poll

#66

Steven Antonucci

Ask the folks at Sears if I've ever come back Herm

steve antonucci

>You can twist my words and the facts any way you'd like, but it doesn't make you right. Facts are as follows:

Gerrit made a piece of "art" that offended me and others. Many asked him to clarify our understanding and reassure us that we had misinterpreted the work. He didn't.

As the moderator, you could have stricken the entire thread, since several folks besides myself found it offensive. You didn't. You only struck comments that you believe were directed at Gerrit's as personal attacks. Censorship is when you control perception of painful thoughts, regardless of who made them or their intent.

I don't know exactly who died and left you King, nor do I know the current state of the thread. Anyone that wanted to form an opinion on the topic is now forced to view only the comments you deemed "worthy".

Just like I told you the other day, I'm done with WoW. You can pretend like you're the good guy here, and that it's MY privelege to be a member of your site, but you'll fall over dead before I go back to WoW without your public apology. (I'm not holding my breath, nor do I care...)

Steve

All fired up while trying to make pickles from AJ's Messages recipe...

Re: Poll

#67

Re: WOW is too snobby??? Then .....

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>A sign on the front gate saying "Members Only" and a guard on duty usually means an exclusive (public not wanted) organization. Since I'd never been inside the gate, I'm not qualified to comment on what goes on behind the closed doors, nor was that my intent. I was only commenting on my feelings about the view from the outside.

As soon as I post this, I'll log into WoW and see what it is like for myself. I'm betting I'll find a lot of good people and good information!

Re: Poll

#68

Re: "finding one's own voice"

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Bill, I rarely visit the WC site; I just don�t have the time to spend on multiple sites. A friend alerted me that my name had come up on this posting, so I visited to see what was going on.

First, I found it interesting that a WOW member of over a year, who had never once posted a comment on my work (or anyone else�s work), was commenting on my work at another site.

Second, I don�t see how my political views or my style of woodturning has anything to do with my position as an AAW board member and I certainly didn�t volunteer to dedicate many hours (days) of my time serving the AAW membership, just to promote my political viewpoint. Do I need to include a disclaimer with all my work that it is not sanctioned or approved by the AAW?

Third, before seeing your message here, this morning, I had already posted a photo of my piece, �Men in the Shadows� on the AAW site. I�m certainly not afraid of displaying my work, even if a few people find it controversial or even unacceptable. I didn�t include �word for word� my description as posted on the WOW site, but I did refer to the Jackson Browne song lines that provided my initial inspiration. Lengthy photo descriptions on the AAW site do not seem to be encouraged or the norm. For the record, the video clip which you mentioned was a very minor part of my inspiration and I stupidly provided the link so people could hear the lyrics, not realizing how upset a few people would be because of the very anti-Bush sentiment in the video. I�ll not make that mistake again.

Lastly, you seem to be saying that if the AAW membership were aware of my views that �something would happen�. Could you not be so vague?

Re: Poll

#69

Re: Sorry

john lucas

>Bob I understand your frustration. Imagine those of us who started with almost no books, magazines or videos available. (Russ and Wally learned from reading slates) :) It was challenging and frustrating. I drove 100 miles to the nearest club. Now we have 5 or 6 magazines avaialable, 4 in the US, 2 in England and one in New Zealand. Those are just the english versions. All are pretty good but of course any given issue may or may not have what you are looking for. I go through the same thing with regular woodworking magazines. Some issues don't have much to offer me and some have some really great articles. Woodturning is the same thing but with fewer magazines there are fewer choices.

My suggestion is to Write the editors and express what you would like to see. They are listening and if enough people call or write in they will try to find such an article. Heck if there's something you really want ask me and If I can I'll write one and submit it.

Re: Poll

#70

Little did I know....

TDaniel

>I had no idea there was a debate going on at WOW when I started this thread. I merely commented on the photos I saw posted, I did not read any of the critiques. As always there were some very nice pieces posted, some very poor ones, and some that were ok but just not my cup of tea. There are still no voices in my shop but I do have one bowl that has faces:)

TD

Re: Poll

#71

Thank You For Responding-PM SENT

Bill Stehman

>

Re: Poll

#72

Re: Little did I know....

Ron in Drums PA

>If you start hearing voices, will you let us know?

Re: Poll

#73

Re: Faces!!??More than one face....

Jamie Donaldson

>... means it may have a "split personality!" Time to reach for the CA glue?? ;-))))

Re: Poll

#74

Re: Won't ask for directions. LOL

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Poll

#75

Well said

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Mark,

You wrote:

"I much prefer to work on my hobby, try to improve my craft, hope to be considered a passable craftsman by my friends, and if someone considers something I do to be Art or Artistic - that is up to them."

I liked the way you put that! Pretty much summed up the way I feel.

By the way, congrats on your work getting featured in American passable Journal! I remember when you were working on those two pieces. I knew they would be memorable. And just for the record, any one that knows you also knows that your more than just a "passable craftman". Your work speaks for itself!

See ya around

Dominic