Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Poll

Posts

Re: Poll

#26

Re: Woodturning as an ART medium...

Jamie Donaldson

>....has started to find it's own voice among collections during the recent past and present, and where it heads in the future is up to the innovators working now. Many of us are content to enjoy the process as entertainment, while others are striving to beat new pathes and may use the lathe as a small part of the creative process. The combination enriches the enjoyment we all can derive from the process, whether we are looking for our own voice or listening to the echos of our past.

Re: Poll

#27

Re: Poll

Herman de Vries

>Steve, I don't know if your comments were referring to WoW, which is, of course, a moderated site. I suppose some would equte "moderated" with "censorship", but that is not true in the case of WoW.

I started WoW back in Novemmber of 2001 primarily to provide a place where woodturners could put photos and comment on each other's work. Back then, unless a turner had her or his own website, there was no way to see their work.

I was active on rec.crafts.woodturning (RCW) and was frankly, sickened by the trolls and flamers. A perfectly innocent or valid question would usually morph, quickly, into a war or a personal rant. I felt anonymity was the cause for much of that.

I longed for a place where people could not hide behind anonymity and where people would treat each other with respect, and where new and seasoned turners could get together and comment and share on all things woodturning. My personal family's experience with a family site had been positive, and it seemed like it might work for a "family" of woodturners, too.

Moderating is not an easy task. The most stringent rule on WoW is to avoid personal attacks. Criticise the art or the woodturning if comment is requested, but personal barbs at the artist are out of bounds. Most people don't have a problem with that, but most people, especially woodturners, are polite, generous people.

Sorry to be long, but I felt I had to explain that. Today is the first time I've posted on WoodCentral and I'm doing so because someone referred me to this thread.

Re: Poll

#28

Re: "finding one's own voice"

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, John; now I know what to look for. :o)

I think. :o)

Allen

Re: Poll

#29

Re: Woodturning as an ART medium...

Keith T

>Most interesting thread...my take..If one aspires to create a place for themselves in the world of woodturning (or any other field) they must strive to find their own voice. Something uniquely theirs, a recognizeable style.

I think too often, we have a myopic view of our craft, studying with known masters of turning while ignoring the big picture of what's happening in the rest of the world, while also

failing to study the history of turning. Too many times, a direct influence can be seen....for instance, a turner spends a week with Bin Pho. As a result, the turner takes a completely new direction in his work, neglecting what he's done before. By creating thin-walled pierced turnings, is he now closer to finding his voice? I don't think so....Bin's work was influenced by his life experiences; how can mimicking his style help find your OWN voice? No wonder the topic of plagiarism won't go away.

I would suggest to anyone striving to find their "voice": examine where you are in your turning career...where are your strong points, and what are your weak points? Are you doing professional quality work, and applying perfect finishes? If not, I would suggest perfecting your work before proceeding to seek the "voice" thing.

I am in the position to see this phenomenon time after time...students come to me, needing assistance moving on to the next level in their work. Yet, their work contains many flaws, from torn grain, poor proportions, poor finish, etc.. You KNOW from my previous posts what I'm going to say...Go back, and eliminate the problems before going any further.

I think what Terry is noticing is a result of the things I've listed. Too many people wanting to be recognized as an artist without putting in the time and effort to build a good, solid foundation.

Re: Poll

#30

Re: Poll

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Ah, there's the catch. You have to be a member just to look at WOW. That just rubs me the wrong way. So I've never bothered to look at WOW.

Re: Poll

#31

Re: "finding one's own voice"

Bill Stehman

>John,

I couldn't agree with you more. I thought the piece and inspiration were well thought out. Although I was saddened and disappointed in his first reply saying he should have used bloodwood to better represent body parts. However, that is probably because I am a disabled veteran that left body parts on a foreign soil. I did not chime in because that would have made it personal.

I believe you might have missed my original point, when one injects other elements into his art or craft ie: made up video clips demeaning any commander in chief (or anyone else) and that person is in a "leadership roll" of an organization then a fine line has been crossed in "my view" and that orginazion also has the right to agree or disagree, acept or reject that leaders message in his art.

This is why I hope he posts on the AAW site.

Re: Poll

#32

Strong analogy to pottery / ceramic art

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Recently I've been reading a book called "A Potter's Companion". It's filled with essays and snippets about the role of traditional pottery in a field where "ceramic artists" seem to be getting all of the attention.

Change the words "potter" to "woodturner" and "throwing" to "woodturning", and it pretty well describes the situation that Terry has noticed.

Oh NO!!! We're plagiarizing the potters and ceramic artists!!

Re: Poll

#33

Exactly......

TDaniel

>Well said Keith. But how often do we see a nice classical piece featured in the AAW mag or how often do we see articles on tool control or other basic skills? I think we need more balance in the mag....stepping stones if you will. The English turning mag has projects for beginners as well as advanced. They have good articles on "how to". Maybe we could combine the AAW with the English mag.........? I think a good balance would be 1/3 for beginners, 1/3 for intermediate, and 1/3 for professionals. We should emphasize skills and techniques and back off on all the enhancements a bit, not totally, but a bit. I certainly do not want to see people afraid to display a well made, well finished, classical bowl or vase.

Re: Poll

#34

Re: Exactly......

Ron in Drums PA

>You are right about AAW.

It's why I'm no longer a member.

Re: Poll

#35

Re: Exactly......

Bob Fawcett

>This is similar to what I was going to say.

I am too busy as a beginner trying to learn to worry about a "voice". I have a long way to go before that is an issue.

I sure wish there was more for beginners in the magazines.

I've bought videos, magazines, books, etc. They all help a little, but I keep looking. There is something missing.

The local AAW chapter starts meetings again this month (they take the summer off). Maybe that will help.

Re: Poll

#36

Re: Poll

georgetroy

>I don't have any voice I just do like I have for the past twenty years.GT

Re: Poll

#37

Dick Hines

Re: Poll

Dick Hines

>I don't know if I am trying to find my "voice" or not but I like to turn hollow forms and bowls. All sizes. From large to minis. I go out of my wat to not copy what someone else has done. It is a hard thing to do since most things have been tried one time or another in the last 2000 years.

As far as adt is conserned I don't think of my self as an "artist". I was at a show last fall and a lady saked me if I was the atrise. The answer I gave her was, "No, I an the wood turner." She thought that over, picked up one of my pieces and bought it. I don't know if she is calling it art or not but I hope she somes back this fall.

Re: Poll

#38

My take on this

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have been turning for about 4 years now and still consider myself a novice, although I have made strides toward learning the basic techniques required to turn good pieces. I find this WC and WOW a valuable resource for my learning experiences.

Having an art background, I am particularly intrigued by the creative process. Because of this, I have always sought my "voice" in every medium I have worked in. My other avocation is infrared photography. I am told by others that my work is rather good and that my photos show a unique outlook on this world.

I'm now getting to the point where I want to expand my horizons in the world of woodturning. Step out of the box, so to speak. I am currently working on my first piece that will be outside of that box. Hopefully, it will be a beginning of an adventure and create more questions for me to be answered by another piece, and so on.

While I am taking this step, I continue to love to look at both traditonal and non-traditional turnings. There is always more to learn and one of the best ways to learn is to look and see.

Sorry this is so long, but I wanted to share just where I am coming from in the discussion.

keithz

Re: Poll

#39

Steven Antonucci

If you look at WoW I think you might know my POV.

steve antonucci

>

Re: Poll

#40

Steven Antonucci

Another person using the word censorship, huh?

steve antonucci

>

Re: Poll

#41

Steven Antonucci

My voice is about form...

steve antonucci

>I continue to work on developing good shapes, and I don't think of most of what I'm currently doing as art, unless you can eat popcorn out of it?

Seems that you can't be an artist unless you make someone mad at you.

Then, I've reach the pinacle of the art world.

Steve

Re: Poll

#42

Re: I agree Ron

john lucas

>Wilford Art doesn't have to be political. It fact is really doesn't have to "speak" at all. It can simply be beautiful. What's fun about "art" is it can be all things. I can make a political statement, religeous statememt or simply make a statement about the human body (see Lyle Jameison's work) or for that matter Michealangelo.

In fact woodturning can be all these things and more. It can simply be a hobby or you can carry it as far as you want. In my book it's simply another piece of woodworking. By that I mean the lathe is just a tool, like a plane or sander. I can use it as part of the process or use it entirely to produce the piece. In some pieces the turning may be a very small part of the original. It's all woodworking.

Re: Poll

#43

Re: Exactly......

john lucas

>I find this interesting because they have had a beginnner type project in almost every issue. This one had plans to make an angel ornament. They do publish some classic forms. You have to remember that they can only publish what is submitted. If they don't have any top notch classic forms submitted then Carl will publish what has abeen submitted. This month had a wonderful article on segmented turning and had some very classic forms in this group (including one of Mark Kauder's)

You have to remember that this magazine also caters to the intermediate and serious advanced turner as well. I think Carl and the AAW board have really improved the magazine in the last few years. Still like any woodworking magazine it isn't for everyone.

Re: Poll

#44

Re: Yep, me too.

john lucas

>Allen That's what it's all about. Having fun. Charles Alvis who was a former president of the AAW always asked at the beginning of every meeting. Why are we here? The response, to have fun. So whether your making your umpteenth wine stopper or doing your best to use woodturning to speak to the world. Just as long as you have fun.

Re: Poll

#45

Re:Steve- would you care to explain...

Jamie Donaldson

>... the reason and relevance of this statement??

Re: Poll

#46

Re: Poll

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>As they say, "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder", and that might be extended to "Art is in the eye of the beholder". HOWEVER, I think that today for many woodturning artists - "Art is in the mouth of the Creator". That is, if I call it Art and give some "Voice" to it - especially some mysterious, inspiration for the work, it will be considered Art my the Glitteratti, and therefor command more money in the gallery. I have felt this for several years and expressed it to many of you well before the current controversey over on WOW.

I much prefer to work on my hobby, try to improve my craft, hope to be considered a passible craftsman by my friends, and if someone considers something I do to be Art or Artistic - that is up to them. I don't have a Muse wispering in my ear - I do have an idea every now and then.

Mark

Re: Poll

#47

Re: Another person using the word censorship, huh?

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Steve,

The WOW site is Herman's he can do as he pleases. I as much to "Blame" for the mess of that thread going on over there now as anyone, and frankly, I think that Papa Herm has been very tolerant. His rule, just don't get personal.

Mark

Re: Poll

#48

Re: Poll

Herman de Vries

>Brian, You can be a guest member. You still need a username and password, since the site is a part of myfamily.com, and each family site has to be restricted to that family. For example, the de Vries family site is restricted to de Vries family members. It is not a public site.

There was no other way for WoW to exist. It was set up as a "family" of woodturners and the site is restricted to the family. If that is a barrier to you, it's too bad because the wealth of information on the site is unreal.

Re: Poll

#49

Re: Exactly......

Keith T

>Terry, You bring up a point that I've mentioned many times. How many well-executed finials do we really see posted? Not many, as the focus is not towards spindle turning. HOw many windsor chairs do get featured in any turning mag? I can't remember any recently.

Try to get a well-turned bowl published...nearly impossible. Yet turning an excellent bowl is not an easy task. I'd guess less than 10% of all turners can produce a bowl worthy of publication.

I sometimes wonder if a split is inevitable in the turning world...craft v art?

Re: Poll

#50

Re: Exactly......

Russ Fairfield

>As usual, I have a different opionion.

While there isn't much balance of things for all skills in any individual issue, there is a pretty good balance to the AAW magazine over a period of a couple years. There have been times when there was an overabundance of beginner articles, and the issue that devoted 5 pages to gluing a quarter in the bottom of a bowl was the high point of that excess. The mid-year issues are always devoted to the "art" work because that is the time of Symposiums and exhibitions.

Then there is the fact that they can only publish what is submitted to them. If we want to see more bowls, then we have to send them a bowl article. But, I would ask before writing it because there have been a lot of bowl srticles over the years. Going through the back issues might be a better source.

If we want beginner and how-to project articles, we should be reading Woodturning Design. It does a good job of providing inspiration and instruction to the beginning and intermediate woodturner.

If I were in charge, the AAW whould leave the beginner and how-to articles to Woodturning Design, and concentrate on making the Journal an "art show" because that better suits the new slick color format. The last few issues have shown that they can put together an excellent "coffee table" gallery.