Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Poll

Posts

Poll

#1

Poll

TDaniel

>I have just reviewed the photos on Wow for the first time in several months. I see a few nice pieces but I also see an awful lot of what appears to be efforts to "find one's own voice". I remember the days of fins on cars in 57 thru 60 and though some worked, most did not. Are we in this same trend now? Are we getting too determined to find our own voice that we are throwing all tried and true forms out the window?

TD

Re: Poll

#2

Re: Poll

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I have seen WOW mentioned several tines on Wood Central and am not sure what it is. I assume a wood working site and WOW is Woods of the World. I can't seem to find it Can someone give me the website?

Thanks

Re: Poll

#3

Re: Poll

john lucas

>Terry I can't speak for everyone else but I simply don't enjoy making hollow forms and bowls. There's nothing wrong with these things it's just when I make a bowl or hollow form it looks like everyone elses. They are pretty and they sell but I just want to add my own little touch to it.

When I was learning woodworking I built a bunch of the roll top bread boxes from Issue no 1 or Woodsmith magazine. After that anything I built from a magazine I changed. I took the basic idea and skills and added my own touch. I do the same thing in woodturning.

I find the work on WOW quite refreshing. Some do use classic forms like JPaul Fennnel And Art Leitsman. Others prefer to look at new forms. I see how they are stretching the limits of woodturning and it's fun. Granted, some fail but we are having fun trying to see where woodturning can go. I can make things that will easily sell but I find it boring. It's much more interesting to make something new.

I guess I'm more drawn to the work of Clay Foster, and Garret van Ness than David Ellsworth. That may just be me.

Re: Poll

#4

Re: Poll

Barry Irby

>Ken you almost got it. It World of Wood, I think. I go thee but have never really managed to navigate the site, so I just look at the endless usually pretty pictures. You have to be invited to join and I would send you an invitation, but I don't know how. Post a message asking for an invitation to WoW and someone will come through.

PS. I find it slightly annoying that WOW is members only to keep the riffraff out and to cut spamming and phishing or whatever, but they have no compunction about sending me E-Mail about there other site on genealogy. Otherwise, its a great site.

Re: Poll

#5

Re: Poll

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Ken, I sent your name into WOW. You will hear from the site. WOW is a great site also. You see a lot of weird and wonderful stuff. To each his own.

I like the traditional stuff but can appreciate most of the other.

Norm

Re: Poll

#6

Re: Poll

Jim Swank

>I think people searching for their voice find more kindred spirits at WOW. There's certainly a higher proportion of innovative (not traditional form) work there, while most folks at WC seem more interested in evolution of traditional forms by comparison.

Re: Poll

#7

"finding one's own voice"

Bill Stehman

>It appears Malcolm has found his voice. I hope he will post the exact same word for word including the video on the AAW site so the full membership can see what happens when a leader of the AAW injects politics into woodturning. Just food for thought.

Re: Poll

#8

World of Woodturners

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Poll

#9

Re: Poll

Raymond Overman in SC

>I like to look at the pics over on WOW occasionally but it seems that because of lack of activity, I can't log on.

I think there are two ways to look at wood turning. You can see it in a classical light and turn bowls, vases, hollowforms, and boxes or you can use woodturning to create more contemporary art pieces. It seems that there has to be a discussion about which one we should be pursuing when we should be thinking about our own journey and talking about and sharing in each other's journey through this and other forums.

The sculptural work that includes turning does not diminish the classic work in my opinion.

Re: Poll

#10

Re: Poll

Stuart Johnson

>Terry, I turn for enjoyment and sometimes it seems to increase my frustration. The majority of my work goes toward smoking a brisket or turkey as I don't do craft shows or have any intention of contacting a gallery. As a result I have no desire to find my "voice".

It does seem to me that many find their voice and from that point on all of their work is the same. A different wood or size but still the same shape or feel. When a comment starts off "I knew that was a (insert turner) as soon as I saw the thumbnail" you can say that turner has found their voice. You can also say in most cases they are no longer being original. They are making copies of their prior work.

I have a large file for photos of work that I want to copy. None of the turners that have found their voice need to worry about me taking bread off their table.

Re: Poll

#11

Re: Poll

Ron in Drums PA

>There are some wonderful work posted on WOW, some that I really admire. Along with some accomplished turners that I highly respect.

But there is also work on WOW that just I can't seems to grasp. Sometimes it's listed a "political art" but to me it looks juvenile at best. I was amazed at how many people fawned over a few piece of turned horse manure, to me it looked like crap. Pun intended. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should, and calling it art is a far reach for poorly executed work.

I'm not really interested in wood sculpture and I see allot of it on WOW. Nothing wrong with it, just not my cup of tea.

There is some really innovative work going on by some very highly accomplished artists. The direction some have taken is truly amazing. I would love to own a piece or two from some of the big names on WOW.

There is also work that is posted which I feel has no place on WOW. But I'm not the owner of WOW, so I respect the right of the owner to allow what he feels is appropriate. I rarely visit WOW anymore.

The bottom line is, I like traditional turnings. I guess I'm just boring.

Re: Poll

#12

Re: Poll

Ron in Drums PA

>Boy did you hit the nail on the head, "finding one's voice" would sure lead to boredom for me.

Re: Poll

#13

I agree Ron

TDaniel

>You stated it pretty much as I would. I took my son to an antique car show recently and there was a 60 Plymouth there along with a 57 Chevy and a 57 Ford. We talked about the "fins" that made it and the ones that did not. But even the ones that made it like the 57 Chevy quickly disappeared from the auto design world. No car today has "fins". Some styles stay, some do not; some come back and some die. Will our art do the same? I personally think so.

Re: Poll

#14

Ron, I agree also.

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>

Re: Poll

#15

Re: "finding one's own voice"

john lucas

>Bill As woodturning moves more toward art you will definitely see politics and religion in the work. Look at the way the other art forms have gone. I've seen a lot of political statements in ceramics and fibers, not so much in Glass and metal but you do see those kinds of work.

I don't mind this kind of work. I don't have to agree with thier politics but it's just like free speech. They have the right to say it and it does promote discussion of the topic.

Re: Poll

#16

Re: "finding one's own voice"

Allen Neighbors

>John, what are y'all talking about? Politics and woodturning? I've missed it, I guess. :o) I guess I'm too dense...

Just keep turning.

Allen

Re: Poll

#17

Re: I agree Ron

Wilford Bickel

>Terry,

I agree that the "art" will be a passing fad. Love of our traditional turnings will continue as long as we want to produce them. My biggest concerns are the pieces that have more time spent on them with the piece still rather than spinning. I have a hard time considering these "turninings".

I never have understood why art has to make a political statement. If you have a political statement to make to me then please do it in words so that I can understand you views. If you want to present art to me then do it for my enjoyment - not to try to make me guess at a political meaning.

Re: Poll

#18

Re: Yep, me too.

Allen Neighbors

>I love to turn. I love to turn hollowforms, vases, and bowls. I don't do any of either that could be called exceptional. Some I sell, some I keep, and some I hide in the woodbox 'til winter. :o) But I sure do love to make the curls fly!

Some types of woodturning, I'm not interested in doing, but I surely do like to see them, and am amazed that some of them came off a lathe.

I don't want to do pens, but I would love to own one made by John, or Jim, or Jen... Their's are some of the most beautiful pens I've ever seen in my life... I just don't want to make any.

I guess I must be both, dense and boring. But, man alive, ain't this turning fun!?!?!

Allen

Re: Poll

#19

Re: Poll

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Received your email and invite. Have gone there and registered. I am into genealogy and am fully aquainted with the host of My Family.Com. I viewed a few photos and agree that at first glance it is a great site. I won't comment on their genalogy segment, though.

Thank you again,

Ken Oakley

Re: Poll

#20

Re: Poll

Wally Dickerman

>I regularly visit 2 websites. WC and WoW. I compare viewing the work I see on WoW to visiting the instant gallery at a large symposium. Nearly all of it is very well done and some it is quite amazing. With some it I don't really care for the finished piece but I do have to admire the inspiration, skill and ingenuity that went into creating it. When you've been around woodturning for a long time it's surprising how much of the work there is where when one can identify the turner. Many of us have developed a recognizable style. The same is true with other kinds of artwork.

It has been said that there are some 15,000 photos posted in the various albums on WoW, many by well known turners. Some of the albums have hundreds of photos. They are there for any member to view. Where else could you find a better place for inspiration?

Wally

Re: Poll

#21

Re: Poll

Steve Mushinski

>Not sure what makes it right or wrong to make what ever one wants to. What might work for one doesn't work for another. Should one wish to display their work, then I encourage it. To answer your question no I do not see there is a problem.

WOW is an outstanding picture gallery of turnings. The only reason it is at MyFamily.com is so that real names are used at all times. One thing that seems to amaze me as of late is how little regard there is for someone else's opinion. This happened here about a month ago also. None of us have to agree with his or her opinion and have the full right to disagree. But for me or someone else to say you are not allowed to speak your mind about "your piece of work" - art or craft to me speaks of censorship. When comments are asked for and someone says they do not like it for this or that reason, that is fine. Same goes for a turning that tries to convey a personal feeling that asked for comments. You always can disagree with another person.

To tell someone they have no right to feel that way is just plain WRONG!

This includes all matters of personal beliefs or of politics. Having an opinion doesn't mean it is the right one or the wrong one- but it is yours.

Re: Poll

#22

Re: Poll

Mike Nelson

>I believe it is difficult to force politics into a turned bowl to begin with but to add politically controversial clips etc. in the description goes beyond (imo) the purpose of the site. Without the description and links you would be hard pressed to guess the political intent of the piece. There was some lively discussion though and much more civilized than most blogs. A couple of the responders should have their own weekly column. :)

Re: Poll

#23

Re: "finding one's own voice"

john lucas

>Allen We don't see it much here but on some sites there are a few turners who make pieces that are designed t make a political statment. Some are really great, some quite funny and some really hack you off depending on your point of view. It's quite interesting. Garret Van Ness and Malcolm Tibbets do some intersting work along this line. There are others that produce work that is much more subtle in the statement. Some only by title and not the actual work. Todd Hoyer's work is very deep but you would never know it until you hear him talk about it. I didn't like his work when I first saw it but after hearing him talk about the influences I started to see where he's coming from and now find it very interesting.

I know without photos and descriptions this is hard to understand. maybe someday I can put something together.

Re: Poll

#24

Re: Poll

Gil Jones

>If I ever do "develop my own voice", I sincerely hope that I am able to understand the language.

Re: Poll

#25

Re: Poll

Herman de Vries

>Raymond, I did have the WoW site send you a new username and password but you have not logged in. I just sent you another email and I'm letting you know here just in case you don't get it.

Herm