We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>There have been a good number of learning opportunities this year. In the Southeast alone there have been a lot symposiums and I know there have been many others in other parts of our country. Some of the things I have seen or heard are these:
Provo was good, classes were appropriately sized, good demonstrators, etc. Our club had 7 members there and they all had good words about it. The only negative I have heard is the lack of vendor participation.
AAW National. The exact opposite of Provo. Actually the only good things I have heard were the vendor areas, the Instant Gallery, the Auction, and the critique.
Souther States Symposium. I skipped this year. Members of our club and some from WC who attended did not think it was as good as previous years. The most common complaint I have heard was with the line-up of demos. The noise factor kept many away from the SSS though I did hear it was better than last year.
My question is: are you getting what you want when you go to the various symposiums? Is there something that would make you like them better? Is there something that prevents you from going?
I only mentioned a few events here but the rest can be included also.
>Terry there are a lot of minor complaints about the AAW symposium but my impression is that most people that went really had a good time. The two gentlemen that went with me sure had fun. The demos were a little crowded but all that I went to were excellent and I didn't have any trouble getting in. You could meet just about anybody in turning there and the instant gallery and vendor area are unsurpassed. I think improvements can be made to make the demo situation better but all indications are that the size of this symposium was a fluke and probably won't happen again until Richmond, if ever. By then they will probably have a better handle on what to do. The only thing I found inconvenient was the hotel check in. Even that wasn't bad. I met some great people while standing in line so I think it was kind of what you made of it. It isn't the same as a smaller symposium. When you get 900 to 1000 people together there is a different synergy. If you make the best of it, it will pay you back.
I didn't get to the southern States this year but have always enjoyed it in the past. Sometimes it's a little hard to hear (some guy with a VB36 was always turning) :). That's the major complaint that I hear and they have improved the speaker system a great deal. You do have to concentrate on what's being said because even though you can hear the demonstrator clearly you can still hear the others in the background. The vendor area is sometimes lacking but I usually spend money anyway so I must enjoy something. The instant gallery has always been good.
The TAW symposium has always had good speakers and it's small enough for everyone to hear. The vendor area has gotten smaller the last few years. Hopefully we can work on that. The instant gallery has always been small but very excellent. Since it is smaller it's easier to talk to friends and meet new people.
I hear nothing but good things from Provo. It's just simply too far away for me to go.
The reasons I don't go are usually either money or timing. Sometimes I simply can't get off work, such is the case with the GAW symposium. That's my busiest time of the year. The other is simply money. It's not cheap(at least from my standpoint) to go to these things. The smaller symposiums are less expensive and I can go.
What I miss at the smaller symposiums are the intellectual discussions. Thier all how to use a bowl gouge, skew, spiraling tool etc. I've seen all that. I'm looking for inspiration, discussions on woodturning and the art from surrounding us and new ways to apply some of the techniques. The smaller symposiums don't have that.
>I'm curious if anybody knows what the out of pocket cost for putting on the AAW symposium is? At $245 per person X 1800 attendees...that's some serious $$. I'm sure it's not cheep to put on.... But if there's one thing that keeps me away...or I should say will keep me away from Portland is that by the time I pay the entry fee, and fly, and pay for hotel/meals....I'm tapped out. Louisville was only an hour and half away so even the gas to get there was cheep...relatively speaking. Ha!
Any ideas on what it costs to put one of these shin-digs on? Is there wiggle room for lowering the entry fee with so many people coming to these?
>I attended the Provo Symposium last year, my first and only one so far. I now realize that the lack of vendor participation is by design, but I wish I knew that beforehand, because I was disappointed that I could not see several lathes in operation and 'in the flesh' because I was trying to decide which replacement lathe to purchase. After all, I have an additional 2400 miles to travel than most people. Little has been said about the fact that the Utah Symposium predates the AAW, and they really do a fantastic job of making things comfortable for the attendees. At the closing ceremony last year they said that they realize that they can handle no more than 450 persons comfortably, and when you see that Louisville had in the neighborhood of 1,000 what a contrast that is. I see the support that the symposium receives from Craft Supply, and it is reasonable that vendor participation is limited if your primary purpose is to learn from the presenters. It also may have been a factor that 90 percent of the demo lathes were Vicmarcks--I did end up getting a VL300. For most people, the parking lot swap meet would have satisfied the need to part with some of their funds. If I could drive to Provo, I would probably try to get there every year. It was a great experience and I was inspired by all the presenters. For me the problem is primarily the cost. I will try to got to Portland for next year's AAW Symposium, because it is closer, less costly to fly, and I can also visit relatives in the area. If cost were not such a big factor, I would have enjoyed the relationships fostered in a small gathering like at Ellijay. For me it is not so much the presenters, but meeting fellow discussion group individuals that would be the draw. The turning would be the icing on the cake.
>Over the last four years, I have attended a bunch of symposiums, all worthy enterprises. My reservation is the amazing cost of most, particularly AAW when you factor in registration, hotel, air fare, and my amazing propensity to spend money on the "next best thing". I have experienced a "diminishing return" for the price I pay and the demos I attend. I am thinking that I have seen and heard a lot over the past few years. Also I am blessed to be a member of GAW which hosts a number of excellent hands on opps. I'm just trying to be smart with my dollar. I do miss the chance to gather with fellow turners but have to justify the cost. I think Terry's question is a good one in terms of how we all figure out new and inventive ways to gather, not necessarily in the large configurations of a convention or symposium. Thanks for asking the question Terry. I am looking forward to more response.
>Jenn, I too am looking at the cost/benefit ratio of these events. Where can I go and learn the most for the least amount of money? I know that most vendors cannot afford the cost to display their goods at a small show so I do like the bigger shows simply for the opportunity to see new items. There are also a lot of hassles for vendors at small shows. Large events have other problems but these should be fixable. I don't have the checkbook either but I would think that there are enough attendees and venders to put on a good show.
>I am somewhat amazed that there have not been many turners from around the country who attend the SouthWest Association of Turners (SWAT) in the past. It is being held in Temple, Texas this year on Sept. 29/30 & Oct 1. Lead demonstrators are Clay Foster, Dave Hout, Antre Martel, David Nittmann, and Andi Wolfe. This cast, along with twelve Regional Demonstrators promises to provide a show for everyone. The Instant Gallery is second only in size to the AAW. All this for the low cost of $80.00. Yep, that's EIGHTY bucks. And that includes catered lunch for two days. Now, why are there not more of you planning on attending? This is the second largest symposium in the country folks, so give it some thought. This will be my seventh year and I can hardly wait!
For info, go to www.swaturners.org
Sorry. As I re-read this it sounds like an advertisement. It's not intended to be that, just encouragement.
>I agree totally David. It's really the social event that draws me to the AAW Symposium. I honestly learned more at TD's gathering than I have at the symposiums. Perhaps a smaller symposium would be different and I'd take more in? But the smaller gatherings really are wonderful for not only the slower pace and getting more quality gab time with friends from the forums, but also to get hands on help and learning time. I highly recommend them for anybody. And the price is right too :)
Keep your eyes peeled form more info on the Central Indiana Octoberfest!
>The symposium can be divided into two categories:
1. the crowd
2. the symposium
Yes, there was a crowd. That may be interpreted as a central location will draw more people. It may be time to consider the merits of a permanent symposium location...possibly four regional city rotations. We are a growing organization, so this should be anticipated in the future. Sites should be selected that will benefit the largest amount of turners, NOT someone's pet location.
Despite the crowd, I believe this was my favorite symposium ever. The city was absolutely lovely..and lots of places of interest. The slate of demonstrators was possibly the best ever assembled. The instant gallery was stunning....many newbies could be seen standing with their mouths agape. This is the BIG ONE...receiving a critique at the national level will possibly boost your turning career into orbit. If your work is critiqued here, you probably won't remember much of it. Even after you recover from the shock. There was much to be learned; there were great, up close demos in the vender area as well as in the demo rooms. In the evening, there were groups of turners everywhere, I was made to feel welcome at every one. I still had the feeling of excitement as I was driving away. Two thumbs up.
>My wife and I attended the Florida Symposium, TD's gathering, and we added our grandson for Louisville. All three events had their own flavor. Florida had some 300+ attendees. We both took a hands-on bowl class. Vendor area was sufficient even though the big boys weren't there. It was a wonderful escape of cold NC mountains in January. We made several friendships that were renewed at AAW.
Although our schedule and my big mouth, that would not stop talking, kept me from seeing a complete demo at the Gathering, we had a wonderful, learning experience. The social comraderie was better than all the other events. This can be much better than lots of demos.
Louisville had many problems, many were the fault of the hotel and 500 late registrations. We were crowded out of only one of our chosen demos...we took the one next door on Safety. This demo should be REQUIRED attendence for all newbies. We are members of Carolina Mountain Woodturners, we get ten world class demonstrators yearly. This relieved some of the personal pressure to see all the best demos at the AAW. We saw Stuart Mortimer for six hours, one week before Louisville and we get Grahme Priddle this month. The vendor area and IG were awesome. I could have spent much more time with the vendors. Money ran out before I was ready to leave. I think the AAW should have the same number of demos over four days to allow for more time to relax, talk, make friends, learn about the latest toys, etc. etc.
We are planning to attend all three again...TD are we doing the gathering again in 2007? We are also going to Arrowmont in the fall. Unfortunately we can't afford four events a year. We feel like sponges trying to soak up all the educational opportunities available.
This is something that should be discussed and I thank you for bringing it up.
I attended the Ohio Valley Woodturners Symposium last year, and it was excellent. Top notch turners from all over the world. Small enough to enjoy it, and the accomadations and food(3meals served each day) were great. The AAW was a good experience, but fairly expensive. The accomadations were horrible(at least if your were in the part of the hotel that they haven't fixed up yet) The get together at your place sounded like a great time. I recently watched a DVD titled "Beyond Wood" and they showed a turners get together at a place Called Emma Lake, Canada. It looked awesome. Many people came together to create and everyone was doing a projectlike carving, burning, blacksmith, turning and there was total sharing of ideas. It lookesd as though they were staying in these rustic cabins on a beautiful lake an it was very informal. Your get together seemed to be similar. I wish I could have made it.
>Amen, Jim. The WC lunch was special. I think that Ellis looks about ten years younger in real life than in his pictures. I don't believe I would have recognized him otherwise.
>........Yes, there was a crowd. That may be interpreted as a central location will draw more people. It may be time to consider the merits of a permanent symposium location...possibly four regional city rotations. We are a growing organization, so this should be anticipated in the future. Sites should be selected that will benefit the largest amount of turners, NOT someone's pet location.
I agree with Keith on 4 regional city locations. A few well benefit greatly but all will benefit to some degree. I will never to to Rhode Island or to Washington State or anywhere in California or any other far away place from deep South Texas. I did go to Florida in 2004 because I was going to Disney World anyway.
SWAT, being a regional symposium, rotates between Temple, TX and Wichita Falls, TX. Both facilities are virtually free except for around $200.00 in electrical costs, and the cost of a couple of security officers for 3 days. The facilities are offered free of charge due to the number of hotel rentals, gasoline and groceries purchased and shopping done by a lot of the wives in attendance. That is the reason that SWAT is so reasonably priced. We do not have to make a lot of money to continue year to year. We have had a drawing for a PM3520A lathe for the past 4 years and this year it will be a PM3520B. Everyone who fills in a SWAT evaluation sheet by noon on Sunday, will have a chance to win a Jet Mini Lathe along with all the other raffle items. At the Saturday night banquet, there will be between 30 and 40 donated turnings for that raffle. The tickets for all raffle winners at the banquet will be put back in the hopper for the PM3520B drawing on Sunday. All of the turnings in the raffle are ones that anyone would be proud to own and everyone wants to take a chance on winning a turning by the national and international turners. This year they are Dave Hout, Andre Martel, David Nittmann, Andi Wolfe and Clay Foster. When all added up, the combined turnigs are worth thousands of dollars. This is why 95% or more attendees go to the banquet which costs only $20 if registering before the deadline. Hope to see a lot of you there.
>and laid back. We had fun, we turned, but mostly we made friends. I have asked our club if they want to have the Gathering next year because I was maxed out as it was and I know there will likely be more people here next year than we had this year. Our county fairgrounds is available but we'll have to see what developes. It takes an awful lot of work to make these events happen. Still, dollar for dollar I think it is the most bang for the buck. We had some good demonstrators and some vendors and it was all free other than a donation jar to help cover the costs of the food. I would personally like to see more events like the Gathering and welcome the one being put together in Indiana and hope I can make that one.
>Bill, I have asked our club if they want to host another Gathering for next year. I fear it will grow by next year and I was at max here as it was so it will have to be held at some larger facility. I'll let you know. I really think these local get togethers are important. I attended my first one at Phil Wall's in Murphey, NC and it was such a great way to learn that I don't want to see the ball dropped.
>Time and money limit my attendance - time more than anything. It is virtually impossible for me to get away from work and the cattle farm more than 3 days in a row. As such I concentrate on the close symposiums such as SSS that start on Friday and let me get home on Sunday afternoon. Louisville was out of the question with the show being in the middle of the week - no way to get off work that long! The crowd at SSS this year was a little lower in number but most of that was blamed on folks holding out for Louisville. As with all there were good and bad demos - one that I learned the most in the demonstrator drove me crazy moving out in front of the speakers and causing feedback. Some of the demonstrators just were not as polished as in years past. Like others, the vendors may not number many but I always get home with a load of wood and tools and no money!!
Terry would you expand on your comments about the small symposiums being a problem for the vendors. I know that sales won't run as high as say Louisville but neither should the cost of the booths. Is it a help situation getting set up that the groups could set up a labor committee to have some assistance, financial that sales just don't justify, or other? I know when we show cattle to promote the farm we actually like a small to mid sized show as it gives us time to visit with potential customers and not be just over run with crowd and time constraints as occurs at the big shows.
>Wilford I talked with the folks at Bestwoodtools and they told me that travel and lodging were huge expenses. Choice woods said it simply wasn't profitable to do the smaller shows when I asked him to do the TAW show. I think he did it for us once.
>My experience with the small shows has been mixed. When I have been allowed to fill my booth with turning items for sale I have come out ok. My lathes are a big ticket item and I do not sell one every year so I must count on selling a number of smaller items to cover my expenses. Prior to a show I must find some deals on things that I can resale to pay expenses. Unfortunately some of the small shows, especially the SSS, give protection to certain vendors but fail to give other vendors a list ahead of time of what one cannot sell in his booth. The last time I had a booth there I was given a list of the brands of lathes that I could not sell. After that I decided to not have a booth there anymore until the rules change. Life is too short for confrontations.