Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Posts

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#101

Thanks, Jon!!

David Weaver

As bad as the videos are from any kind of production value viewpoint (which someone reminds me of about once or twice a month in video comments), when someone likes them, I know that means it's because they're really into the content.

And that's exactly what I'm aiming for.

My goal posting the videos was to maybe influence five people to make a good plane with information that wasn't laid out anywhere else. I don't know if five had (there are a lot of views), but it's probably likely.

Feel free to contact me with any making-related questions at my email above.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#102

Re: Factory ground 1816

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, you thought I was picking out pictures to suit my preferences? Really? There is no need to pick. All of the 19th century mortise chisel illustrations I have ever seen had single flat bevels. All of the 18 and 17th century examples also. It would be quite a shock to see something like you are suggesting.

I looked at your "Tooltique" references to Sorby mortise chisels. Right on the page it says he used a water cooled wheel to "refurbish" the tools. So the "factory grind" might just be the Tooltique factory.

I have been interested in mortise chisels since 1973. There were no bloggers at that time. I never saw the Blogger type grind (small secondary bevel long shallow bevel etc.) until after there were bloggers.

Here is a picture from 1667:


Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#103

Re: Factory ground 1816

David Weaver

Warren - it would seem to be short odds that my chisels (which didn't come from tooltique) have an identical grind on them, and tooltique's grinding wheel has so much influence that it would put the exact same profile on Bode's low use IH sorby chisels - from thousands of miles away.

I think you confuse "you haven't seen" in a marples catalog or a french book with "wasn't done" by some of the more highly regarded makers in England.

You're welcome to be confused, but you're incorrect in this case. The chisels show no sign of use, match low use or unused chisels in two other places, and you're grasping at marples catalog pages and digging in instead of saying "maybe that maker made them that way".

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#104

blogger grind

David Weaver

I have no idea what bloggers have to do with the fact that I have two chisels that have identical tool marks from end to end, side to side, and even on the small bevel ground on them at the factory.

You do realize that you're arguing that I have a chisel that is finished (two, in fact) identically all the way up to the bolster, on the roundover, on both sides of the bevel and on the sides. Everywhere. Neither shows any sign of having been on a stone or ever having a honed edge put on them (The edge has no final apex) and you're more or less arguing that someone went to the trouble to make identical tool marks on the roundover to hide that they were applying a roundover, that jim bode has a little used IH sorby chisel that's done the same way, and another dealer in england who more or less deburred a chisel has the same profile.

That somehow against all of these odds, it's not done at the factory based on what marples did or what you've read since 1973.

I don't know what blogger you have a row with, but if you ever use one of these chisels in a deep mortise (not a furniture mortise unless you're making beds), it will be instantly clear how valuable roundover is on a chisel with as tall of a cross section as these).

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#105

Re: blogger grind

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I had one of these long grind mortise chisels too. I bought one from Lee Richmond. It had not been used for mortising in years; the side edges were way too worn and rounded for it to be used effectively. However Lee had freshly ground a long bevel on it and honed a very small "secondary bevel" to conform to what he was seeing on the internet. Once I straightened out the sides it was usable, but was much better when I made a full flat bevel on it.

This reminds me of a 2011 double iron discussion:

I do not see a lot of evidence in older planes that they were universally used in a way that would improve surfaces, especially in old woodies


Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#106

you're still failing...

David Weaver

..to address the chisels at are out there from I&H sorby.

you've had one of these :|

This is a yes or no question:

* the chisel (two of them) has grind marks that go end to end and the marks on the small bevel match the rest of the chisel in terms of fineness, and there is no fine edge on the chisel and no sign of damage (it's not blunted off)

* there is no sign of honing on the bottom of the chisel, the mill marks at the bolster are identical from end to end (very finely finished, but obviously by a wheel as all of the marks progress parallel to the direction of the chisel

* the curvature on the tops of the chisels have the same mill marks on them, no evidence of being stoned or ground with something else

* tooltique has chisels that look identical (you've dismissed them because the guy does minimal restoration)

* bode's listings of IH sorby have this rounded top unless they're short (those still have a rounded top, but it's sloppily refreshed in some cases)

* all of the chisels shown pictured anywhere with this roundover have a similar look

This chisel was modified by later users, including some who never used the chisels or honed any other part, and all of them match (all of the different users made an identical looking roundover) - yes or no.

Now, let's do another survey of likelihood -if this was done to the IH sorby chisels, I should be able to find neatly redone marples chisels and a sample of all of them from a similar time frame should show that most of the marples chisels that are full length should be rounded over.

There's no unknown variable that would make them different.

IH sorby (you have to parse the I sorby and R sorby out, different maker):

https://www.google.com/search?q=IH+sorby+pigsticker&tbm=isch&ved=2ahUKEwjQvPDu5tTqAhUO0awKHcEUBmMQ2-cCegQIABAA&oq=IH+sorby+pigsticker&gs_lcp=CgNpbWcQAzIECCMQJ1DzDljNFGDJFWgAcAB4AIABZYgB4gaSAQM4LjKYAQCgAQGqAQtnd3Mtd2l6LWltZ8ABAQ&sclient=img&ei=y94RX5CrPI6iswXBqZiYBg&bih=969&biw=1920#imgrc=Jok-GiD0HEElJM

Marples:

https://www.google.com/search?q=marples+pigsticker&sxsrf=ALeKk00MkBQJmPTkhgRJY9nDRoNzkFrWrQ:1595006620298&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjDnpHY5tTqAhWFB80KHfGgD_oQ_AUoAnoECA0QBA&biw=1920&bih=969#imgrc=GNGhjsA0n5fn_M

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#107

after you do your survey, you'll find

David Weaver

Most of the marples chisels retain a flat bevel. A couple of sloppily done roundovers on the top edge.

All of the IH sorby chisels are rounded except those used enough to move the bevel far back (some of those continued to be rounded)

You'll have to describe the mechanism that would cause users who don't know each other to only do this to IH sorby chisels. It's remarkable.

You have an argument with a blogger so the extremely unlikely becomes likely.

All of these things point to a conspiracy against someone who looks at tool catalogues in 1973 (none were IH sorby), had one of these in hand (not IH sorby), and refuses to believe that anything could've been made more than one way.

As you find that you're less and less likely to be correct, you point to double irons and a chisel from a century before.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#108

Separate on the IH sorby chisels..

David Weaver

They're pretty well established to be factory ground exactly as I have them. The two that have been used haven't had the factory roundover removed or chased back yet -and those two have a primary bevel angle of exactly 25 degrees to a shinwa rule.

Not 25 1/4, 24. something, etc, they are absolutely dead on the line 25.

This is interesting as the speculation on the English site is that the oval bolstered mortice chisels were a production tool and not a cabinetmaker's tool. Production where mortises were deep (and if you have the opportunity to use one of these, they are superb to use on mortises deeper and longer than we would typically make in furniture).

The angle behind the round over is (by chance) almost identical to what I've come up with unicorning lighter chisels. They are undeniably faster to use in deep mortises than a single flat bevel they hold up well (unfortunately, it's rare that we would make much large enough to use them).

The chisels that I have are about 3 hundredths of an inch wider at the cutting end than they are at the tang, and the taper is even. The tops are about 3 hundredths narrower than the bottom of the cross section on the wider chisel and 2 on the narrower.

A bias in favor of the maker.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#109

If the UK guys are correct...

David Weaver

..and these tall mortise chisels with long primaries were used often in production work, the second edge retention test shown above (monstrously less effort to use a bevel of this profile vs. a flat bevel) may go far in explaining why such a tool would come from the maker with a fat unicorn bevel or a long bevel necessitating the user apply a fat bevel.

The roundover on them is nice both in rotation and also just because the height of the profile is so tall that it's nice not to have it catch on the edge of a mortise.

The debate about whether or not the pigstickers were used bevel down or straight into the mortise rages on (I use them bevel down - they'd have a lot more friction in the mortise cutting if the full bevel was ridden on them, especially on the early ones that had soft iron backing instead of hardened steel through and through).