Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Posts

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#51

Re: Angle near the edge

Winston

> You can get the effective cutting angle, before and/or after, by running the chisel bevel down across your benchtop, and check the angle where it first begins to dig in. Do this beside a vertical surface like a block of 2x4, mark the angle where the chisel begins to bite, and check that angle with your own protractor.

I gave it a try. On a very smooth planed piece of white pine, I got anywhere between about 35 and 42 degrees. It's hard to get a consistent reading. The angle where it first digs in is sensitive to amount of downward pressure. If the chisel gets rotated (along the long axis) a bit in either direction, the corners dig in, and then if I try to stabilize it by putting a little bit of pressure near the tip (as if sharpening freehand), that makes it want to dig in at a lower angle than it would otherwise. As I raise the angle, there's also a range of angles where it stutters but doesn't quite catch. So... in short, in order to get a consistent value, I think the variables would have to be controlled much better than I'm able to do.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#52

This is a difficult thing to do precisely

David Weaver

...especially when an edge has some roundness. everything needs a bit of clearance.

i'd bet someone somewhere making electric shavers, etc, has studied this (in the interest of making a sharp edge that doesn't have enough clearance to cut skin.

When bringing this method up early on, I was hoping to completely avoid the discussion of angles other than to discuss wanted results. Sometimes, lack of specification is better because it overcomplicates what's going on to try to measure these things (they're not needed for success), and sometimes it comes off more like an insurance agent selling absurd "investments" telling you "I promise you a lifetime of riches if you sign here, just don't read the contract details"

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#53

Re: various compounds - difficult to judge

Michael Todrin

This has been a fascinating topic so I couldn't resist getting the drill mount buffing wheels and giving it a try. Hopefully another data point will be helpful.

The chisel was prepared on a Washita, then black Arkansas and leather strop so was quite sharp beforehand. I used Mothers mag polish and probably 3-5 seconds against a chisel edge. It shaved hair easier than off the ark and strop treatment. Like discussed elsewhere there appears to be a tiny polished bevel if you tilt the chisel in the right way. Longevity testing to continue.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#54

Thank you for experimenting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The way science works is someone sees a result and draws a conclusion. But the question is how general is the conclusion. The answer comes when others repeat the experiment and try variations. Without others trying the technique it will not be known how widely useful it is.

I think I replicated the Unicorn Profile by rocking on a diamond plate. But I am encouraged by the speed reported from buffing. My buffing compound arrived today (Mac Master Carr Yellow buffing compound) . As soon as I get finish on the desk I will be trying it too.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#55

looking forward to...

David Weaver

...seeing what you come up with.

This is sort of like the double iron in a way. you'll quickly find a way to improve edge durability (just as setting the double iron close quickly eliminates any significant tearout).

Then, it's a matter of experimenting with application to see how easy you can make the chisel cut without it taking on any significant damage as it would with a single flat edge.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#56

Further Observations

Michael Todrin

Had some time today over lunch to prepare a few chisels and chop some mortises.

Mortises were all 1.25"x1.25x 1" deep in a black walnut scrap. The mortising was done neither with great delicacy nor with excessive force. Probably a 6.5/10 on the continuum between the two.

Back of chisel was observed before and after testing with cheap microscope to look for chipping and rolling after chopping.

Chisel 1: Contemporary Stanley sweetheart 1" about 30 degrees. The prep was 1200 ez-lap, spyederco medium, 1 micron diamond on corian. 5 seconds on 4" drill mounted buffer with Mothers Mag polish.

Chisel 2: Same as above but 1.25"about 30 degrees. Same as above but no

unicorning.

Chisel 2a: Same chisel and prep as #2 above but with 40 degree micro-bevel.

Chisel 3: 1.25 Stanley with resin handle about 20 degrees. EZ lap, then buffing wheel.

All chisels shaved hair effortlessly before chopping and pared end grain pine cleanly leaving the nice waxy looking finish.

After mortising tests:

End grain paring:

Chisel 1: No visible difference in shaving quality or perceived difficulty.

Chisel 2: Significant degrade in shaving, could not cut a clean shaving.

Chisel 2a: No change

Chisel 3: More resistance but still clean shaving.

Shaving hair:

1: Effortless and comprehensive shaving

2: Still shaved a little but more effort and some missed hair

2a: Effortless and comprehensive

3: Still shaved but more effort and missed hair

Microscope:

1, 2a and 3 had some visible wear while 2 had significantly more.

Conclusions:

It appears that the unicorn bevel confers protection to an edge without a degrade in sharpness or perceived ease of cutting. I am not certain it has advantages over a flat secondary bevel in terms of performance. This will need to be looked into further. It was interesting that with relatively minimal prep you could still have a chisel (3) at least at parity with a more thorough flat bevel preparation(2). It appears that a low primary bevel and minimal preparation give a nice performance with very little difficulty on a $12 Borg chisel.

Further Questions:

What is the effect of different bevel angles on performance of the unicorn profile? How low can you go? What is the difference in longevity between a rounded and flat micro-beveled portion?

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#57

great work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

and good follow up questions to work on later. Thanks for sharing results.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#58

Interesting..

David Weaver

..mortising is the one place that I don't really use the extent of buffing and lowering the bevel.

with mortise chisels, I just round the tip a little bit either by hand or with a buffer because the cutting of the mortise chisel isn't the bulk of the work - it's a narrow cut with a lot of holding wood on the side.

Plus, it's nice to ride the bevel (and lowering the bevel makes that a lot harder to do, and makes the levering out of the chips a lot harder).

I think there isn't enough additional edge support for mortising the way the unicorn profile is set up (and it would be hard to meet both conditions when prying or twisting is introduced, those being sharper feeling and longer lasting).

When I mention mortising planes (where I have posted below), it's a bit different as it's just mortising a large open cavity into a V. more like chopping than furniture mortises.

I do think there's probably a way to fish with a very small microbevel and get similar functionality, but the process (and the sharpness) is easier to control with a buffer.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#59

Some other things to try

Winston

I suggest trying to go straight from the EZ-lap 1200 to the buffing wheel and see if you get a similar result. That's one of the big advantages in my mind, that it can be very fast and you can skip a lot of the intermediate steps. Same for the 40-degree microbevel -- try going straight from 30 degrees on the the EZ-lap to 40 degrees on the 1 micron diamonds.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#61

Scratches from more compounds; buff vs stick

Winston

I decided to look at some more buffing compounds, and see what size scratches they leave. Previously, I used some mystery compounds that came with a strop I ordered from Amazon and rubbed the sticks directly on the blade, because I didn't want to commit a buffing wheel to some unknown compound.

This time, I ordered buffing compounds from McMaster-Carr. (Thanks, Bill, for recommending them -- I'm very impressed that they delivered it in one day with no extra charges!) I got a yellow bar, which is 5 micron calcined alumina, and a green one, which is 1 micron chrome oxide, and I trust that they actually are what they're claim to be. My understanding is that David uses the yellow stuff.

First, I buffed the blade with the white rouge that came in the Ryobi kit, using the soft cotton wheel that was also in the kit.


Next, I used the green 1-micron stuff on a new buffing wheel:


Then I buffed the blade with the white rouge again to get it really smooth, and then I used the yellow 5-micron compound:


Although these compounds leave results that look quite different, they all left an extremely sharp blade. With all of them, I was able to shave hairs without the blade contacting my skin.

Even if they all leave a blade that's equivalently sharp in actual practice, I still like the idea of using the finest one. I just wish I knew where I could get some more of the white rouge -- the stick that I have is tiny and definitely won't last forever.

*****

I also tried rubbing the bars directly on the blade -- I was curious to see if I could do that in the future to get a sense of what size scratches a compound would leave when used on a buffing wheel, without actually committing a buffing wheel to the compound.

Here's the white rouge:


Green 1-micron:


Yellow 5-micron:


So it looks like, for all of the compounds, using the stick directly on the blade leaves somewhat deeper scratches, compared to using them on a wheel. That makes sense.

*****

One other interesting thing... Before doing all of the photos above, I sharpened the blade on a 1000-grit diamond plate and then buffed it with the white rouge. I ended up with a slightly wavy edge, which was even visible to the naked eye. I think I probably had raised a large burr, one big enough that the buffing wheel had trouble removing cleanly. This is what it looked like.


The blade was still extremely sharp, but I didn't want the waviness to show up in the subsequent photos, so I went back and honed it with a Shapton Pro 1000 before doing the tests above.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#62

Re: Scratches from more compounds; buff vs stick

Wiley Horne

Extremely helpful, Winston! Without this info, everyone who wants to do this has to bet their new buffing wheel on an unknown abrasive. Your photos make me feel OK about the 1u green that arrived today.

Tx, Wiley

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#63

great experiments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Will you elaborate about putting compound on the blade? I am not getting a clear idea of what this description entails.

I'll have a "fine" white suggestion later. Need to work outside while still cool.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#64

Other Compounds

David Weaver

Winston - your thoughts on the small sticks is what got me away from woodworking supply once I got a buffer. There's no real reason for woodworking supply compounds at any rate, the softer sticks (like green microfine) still need a dot of oil to work.

I've gotten all of my large sticks from mcmaster carr precisely because I don't feel the need to be cheap with them.

All have been good and even, but I haven't gotten every type. McMaster has a 0.5 micron rouge colored bar and a green bar that's 1 micron. I have both coming today to see how fine they are. If the green bar is actually 1 micron, it will be finer than the microfine compound sold to woodworkers (used to be sold as 0.5 microns, but the manufacturer says particles up to 6 are present in it. It works well, but no great reason to pay $11-$14 for 6 ounces when a 2 1/2 or 3 pound bar from industrial or buffing suppliers is more or less the same price.

I'll report what I find with those.

Mcmaster adds a couple of bucks over the cheapest retailers, but their shipping is so cheap that it usually ends up being cheaper for me, plus they're located in several places. I ordered two bars yesterday afternoon and they're scheduled for delivery today with a shipping charge of $7.

https://www.mcmaster.com/buffing-bars

(the 0.5 compound that I purchased says that it's iron oxide, and the 1 says that it's chromium oxide, but at the price, I would bet they have a little of those and mostly smaller al-ox. We'll see).

Kocour and Jackson Lea (also labeled Osborn in some cases) are the brands that have come from McMaster - nothing has been low spec unbranded.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#65

wait till you try...

David Weaver

even the yellow and get a hang of it. you have the advantage of being able to talk turkey with my thoughts with the identical wheel (I ordered another one from that same supplier, too - not because there's anything special with it, but just because it's discontinued and I don't want to have to learn the fine buffing on another wheel).

The subjective sharpness from the yellow is beyond what I can do by hand. I think when we get to the really tiny sharpening sizes by hand, our influence on the edge is enough to do more bending and deformation than the abrasive itself. For some reason, the buffer seems sharper.


These shavings were gotten from just casually sharpening a plane (experimenting with a lower honed angle on the plane and then rounding over) with yellow bar. I don't have a way to measure them accurately, but I'd bet they're a fair shot below 1/2 of a thousandth.

Slowly getting to my point - you're safe with the bars for two reasons (as long as you get something 5 micron or smaller as a known particle size).

1) you're going to get an extremely sharp and uniform result

2) I don't think these waxed bars really hang around too much or too long in a buffing wheel. I'm sure some amount of them does, but charging every couple of uses is a good idea because of the amount that seems to be gone from the wheel.

That leads to a question that I had answered without asking, and that is, what do guitar makers and others do when buffing early wet sanded guitar top coats, because these small micron polishes would just create heat and burn surfaces.

The answer is that the bars come in a product called "greaseless" compound with coarse abrasive. Instead of the same type of wax as the coloring bars, the greaseless compounds are a glue mixture of some sort that sticks to the buffing wheel.

I'm going to buy a hard wheel with stitching all of the way to the edge at some point and one of the "greaseless" types to see if it works better than the deburring wheel (deburring wheels work really well, but if something with a sharp corner is introduced to them, they shed themselves pretty quickly). The deburr has no use in this process with chisels, but I do like to use it for interim sharpening with knives.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#66

Re: great experiments

Winston

I just dragged the chisel backward on the bar of compound, as if the bar itself was a strop.


Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#67

Re: Other Compounds

Winston

> All have been good and even, but I haven't gotten every type. McMaster has a 0.5 micron rouge colored bar and a green bar that's 1 micron. I have both coming today to see how fine they are. If the green bar is actually 1 micron, it will be finer than the microfine compound sold to woodworkers (used to be sold as 0.5 microns, but the manufacturer says particles up to 6 are present in it. It works well, but no great reason to pay $11-$14 for 6 ounces when a 2 1/2 or 3 pound bar from industrial or buffing suppliers is more or less the same price.

That must be the same green bar I got from from McMaster. I can't say how fine the particles actually are though. I wouldn't have expected 1 micron scratches to be as easily visible as the scratches I actually saw from the green compound (using the stick directly, without the buffing wheel), but it's hard to say for sure how deep those scratches were. And maybe there were clumps of abrasives, making for deeper scratches? At any rate, the scratches with the same compound on a buffing wheel were much smaller.

I did a little Googling and poking around on the Osborn/JacksonLea web site, and what do you know, the MSDS sheets say that the green (supposedly chrome oxide) and red (supposedly iron oxide) compounds have a lot of aluminum oxide, like 10x as much as the stuff they're advertised as.

Green: https://www.osborn.com/media/msds/pdf/47012.PDF

Red: https://www.osborn.com/media/msds/pdf/47013.PDF




Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#68

Well!  good work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would seem that the only purpose of the iron or chromium is to be a pigment to color the aluminum oxide abrasive stick. It sure as hell is not doing any significant abrading at those concentrations.

Alpha aluminum can be made in about any particle size one desires. With some looking about any micron size is out there to be found.

We used to do a teamwork exercise for new employees that thought they knew it all. The result was that several people working on a task was shown to generated more and better information than a one . Investigating the creation and attributes of the Unicorn Profile reaffirms this generally valid point.

(there were amusing exceptions. In one exercise the team had to survive in the desert until searchers found us and a rescue was made. One dominating team member whose military experience consisted of driving a submarine insisted he would walk the 30 miles to the nearest road in the cool of the night. Another, with cross country land experience, convinced the rest of the folly of this plan. )

OK on lookers. Get out there, do something, and make discoveries.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#69

partly my fault for voluminous posts..

David Weaver

.this is what I'd mentioned elsewhere. I think the colors remain on most polishes for identification, but the main component of most is aluminum oxide.

I first learned this when someone in a shaving forum compared the "LV compound" to 1/2 micron chrome oxide. The formax/LV/Microfine is 70% or so alumina and not that closely graded compared to things intended for razors.

The reality is, the things closely graded for razors only really make economic sense with razors, and most will find the LV/Formax/blah blah better suited to tools because the alumina makes it cut a lot faster.

I think everything that I've checked so far is alumina (green, blue, white, gold) with the exception of some large particle tan bars that are silica.

almost 100% guarantee that procuring small alumina is cheaper now and the compounds work faster than they did with crocus / water of ayr sticks, powder / silica.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#70

Red stuff

Winston

It's funny -- when I made my order from McMaster-Carr, I thought about getting the red stuff because it was 0.5 micron, but then I didn't because I figured that iron oxide might not be effective for hardened steel tools. Turns out that the red bar is made of something that's actually more useful than what they say it's made of.

> ... several people working on a task was shown to generated more and better information than a one . Investigating the creation and attributes of the Unicorn Profile reaffirms this generally valid point.

>

> OK on lookers. Get out there, do something, and make discoveries.

Agreed!

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#71

Wooden planes

Jon Snider

David. I’m using this post to contact you as I haven’t been able to locate any other contact info source. My apologies to the others posting here.

I’m invested in wooden try and jack planes are was wondering if you were still making them or had any available?

Thx much

Jon Snider

Jonfsnider at Gmail

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#72

File in useless knowledge

David Weaver

I have a lap of pure .09 micron iron oxide pigment from kremer. It is extremely fine and will bring a razor past where I'd have any interest in using it - linen and strop normalize that off.

the interesting thing is that the iron oxide pigment will blacken when a hardened razor is stropped on it - it does some cutting and not just burnishing. I never checked the mohs hardness of it, but some component of it must be at least in the ballpark of iron carbides, as the edge is supremely uniform.

Chris Griggs, who used to post on SMC was vegan and thus had to find something to use as a substitute for a leather strop (neoprene and other artificial materials by themselves just don't do nearly as well as good leather). He really liked the iron ox and tolerated the sharpness better than my face does.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#73

Re: Wooden planes

David Weaver

Hi, Jon - I don't generally make planes for pay. Only for charity here and there, or to trade folks I'd call friends (they may not consider me that!!).

Steve Voigt is the man for professional making of planes.

If by chance you have something like a really nice shape english plane that just needs refitting, I'd be glad to do that for you. My email address is here in my posts.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#74

Re: Other Compounds - reinventing the wheel...

John Aniano in central NJ

David, Winston, et. al.,

When all is said and done, if you could share with the group what compounds and buffing wheels worked well/best for you both. Tidbits like vendor, part numbers, etc. would be very helpful. Reinventing the wheel can be such a PITA...

Thanks,

John

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#75

will do...

David Weaver

i can share the part number of my favorite wheel, but I have probably over the years only tried 6 or so. No guarantee that a different type doesn't work better (more stitches to the edge, different material, etc).

Ryobi: A04BG06

there's differences in the number of plies, the number of stitches, where the stitches are, etc. No great reason to become an expert to save $10 (but I don't follow my own advice on that, i'll admit).

Those buff wheels show up unused from time to time, but I'm guessing based on the color of the packaging and the widespread availability of a different set of ryobi buffs that these are just old stock trickling out from oddball sellers (people who buy return lots, etc).

I see the sentiment is going toward finer here, but I'm inclined to stick with the yellow stuff because I'm used to it. The yellow stuff is 5 micron yellow jackson lea bar from mcmaster carr (calcined alumina). I think anything of reasonable quality will work well. I have no idea how many factors could affect my results (e.g., winston's bevels look a bit shorter and steeper - is that affected by the compound cutting power and the buff speed, both, etc?).

Sharpness is absurd even with yellow, and a complete result is almost guaranteed because the buffer doesn't just finish the edge that's there, it removes some of it and replaces the front side.

https://www.mcmaster.com/buffing-bars (listed as yellow in the top section under "cutting/coloring" category)

Will report back if experience with other bars is better, though. I think with a high speed buff and a wheel with a little bit of back bone, much of the compounds should be interchangeable.