Scratches from more compounds; buff vs stick
Winston
I decided to look at some more buffing compounds, and see what size scratches they leave. Previously, I used some mystery compounds that came with a strop I ordered from Amazon and rubbed the sticks directly on the blade, because I didn't want to commit a buffing wheel to some unknown compound.
This time, I ordered buffing compounds from McMaster-Carr. (Thanks, Bill, for recommending them -- I'm very impressed that they delivered it in one day with no extra charges!) I got a yellow bar, which is 5 micron calcined alumina, and a green one, which is 1 micron chrome oxide, and I trust that they actually are what they're claim to be. My understanding is that David uses the yellow stuff.
First, I buffed the blade with the white rouge that came in the Ryobi kit, using the soft cotton wheel that was also in the kit.

Next, I used the green 1-micron stuff on a new buffing wheel:

Then I buffed the blade with the white rouge again to get it really smooth, and then I used the yellow 5-micron compound:

Although these compounds leave results that look quite different, they all left an extremely sharp blade. With all of them, I was able to shave hairs without the blade contacting my skin.
Even if they all leave a blade that's equivalently sharp in actual practice, I still like the idea of using the finest one. I just wish I knew where I could get some more of the white rouge -- the stick that I have is tiny and definitely won't last forever.
*****
I also tried rubbing the bars directly on the blade -- I was curious to see if I could do that in the future to get a sense of what size scratches a compound would leave when used on a buffing wheel, without actually committing a buffing wheel to the compound.
Here's the white rouge:

Green 1-micron:

Yellow 5-micron:

So it looks like, for all of the compounds, using the stick directly on the blade leaves somewhat deeper scratches, compared to using them on a wheel. That makes sense.
*****
One other interesting thing... Before doing all of the photos above, I sharpened the blade on a 1000-grit diamond plate and then buffed it with the white rouge. I ended up with a slightly wavy edge, which was even visible to the naked eye. I think I probably had raised a large burr, one big enough that the buffing wheel had trouble removing cleanly. This is what it looked like.

The blade was still extremely sharp, but I didn't want the waviness to show up in the subsequent photos, so I went back and honed it with a Shapton Pro 1000 before doing the tests above.