Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Posts

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#76

Re: Wooden planes—Steve Voigt link *LINK*

Wiley Horne

http://www.voigtplanes.com/

Note also Instagram link from website.

Wiley


Voigt Planes

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#77

Re: Wooden planes

Jon Snider

Thanks David. Understand and appreciate the reply.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#78

hardness of iron oxide

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Both hematite and magnetite are about 6 on hardness scale, about like feldspar, a mild abrasive.

There is no mineral that is chromium oxide so I do not know its hardness.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#79

Re: hardness of iron oxide

David Weaver

Chromium oxide iii is very hard, but I understand it to be a little more round than most types of alumina. It makes a gentler edge on razors than comparable alumina or diamonds. That's probably the only way you could ever tell now that we've pretty well put to bed the idea that strong cutting small abrasives damage tool edges.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#80

Google monster says

David Weaver

Cro3 is 8 to 8.5 mohs which fits my recollection. There's a rumor that it cuts tougher steels than alumina but most people who think they're using it are using mostly alumina.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#81

Re: Some other things to try

Michael Todrin

So I did just that with a plane blade and had no problem getting .001 shavings in cherry and could have gotten thinner if I fiddled with it more. Surface finish was of subjectively equal quality to a blade prepared more traditionally.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#82

Re: Interesting..

Michael Todrin

I agree that it seems a major strength of the unicorn profile is the both its ability to strengthen a low bevel angle allowing for easy wood penetration and durability and the rapidity and repeatability of setup.

Additionally I concur that mortising is not the ideal place for the low bevel angle followed by buffing, however it did provide an intense wear environment.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#83

not sure I agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Additionally I concur that mortising is not the ideal place for the low bevel angle followed by buffing, however it did provide an intense wear environment.

I'm not going to dismiss this profile on a mortise chisel. I usually do a tiny secondary bevel and it would seem that this rounded one would be better, easier to do.

I just did some kitchen knives. Fantastic. If it has an edge I am going to try it.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#84

Re: Some other things to try

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The use of a buffer has several potential benefits. Whether the profile is beneficial or not the buffer is one quick way of getting a fantastically sharp edge anywhere it is needed.....tomato knife for example. 10 seconds and done. Can't wait to see the result on my skinning knife.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#85

Re: not sure I agree

Michael Todrin

Bill, it is the low bevel angle on a mortise chisel I think is not ideal. The buffing on a 25-30 degree chisel was great. The 20 degree came up short.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#86

Re: Some other things to try

Michael Todrin

I am about to go out and do some knives!

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#87

Re: not sure I agree

David Weaver

I agree with what you're saying, but some of it also has to do with my own technique (there was a huge blowout thread on the UK forum a couple of years ago about this - you'd be surprised how many people were bright red outraged when they found out that not everyone agreed with their mortise technique).

There is a school of straight in mortisers vs. bevel riders who really like fast penetration, and the profile I've seen on some 1900 or so pigstickers in good condition shows sort of a unicorn that's just a good horse (the primary bevel is much shallower than the secondary roundover, but the roundover is very long compared to what we're doing here).

So, it would be a fair comment for someone to say "you stole this from the way some old pigstickers are set up", even though I really stole it from the knife people. But they are both on the same page.

I do like using a tiny bit of this on the end of a bevel riding mortiser, though - it does little to increase cut resistance and you can pretty much mortise until you can't stand up. It doesn't seem to be enough just at the very tip to change the experience of bevel riding, either.

I think you'll find as you go to bevel edge chisels and parers, this really comes alive.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#88

Re: Wooden planes

Jon Snider

David. So maybe I’ll give a shot at making my own. Do you have contact info still for Mike Diggity? Thx again. You can email me at jonfsnider at gmail if you’d like.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#89

Re: Wooden planes

David Weaver

Hi, Jon - I believe Mike Digity is fully retired now, but Horizon Wood products has been selling 16/4 beech for planes (sometimes, or maybe permanently, it's well sawn european beech billets due to trouble drying american beech - am. beech at 16/4 is really slow drying and it creates economic problems for them tying up their kiln).

the european billets that I"ve gotten from them are exceptionally well sawn, though.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#90

Correction

Winston

For future reference: It turns out that the McMaster-Carr website has MSDS sheets for the buffing compounds, which are not the same as the ones I found on the Osborn site. The sheet for the 1-micron green compound says it's 60-70% aluminum oxide, 2-10% chromium oxide. The sheet for the 0.5 micron red compound says it's 70-90% iron oxide.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#91

Re: not sure I agree

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

You and Joel at TFWW seem to be on the same page, in re long narrow primary, and a secondary rounded into the edge. See paragraphs 4 & 5 here:

https://toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/MS-MORT.XX

Great minds thinking alike,

Wiley

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#92

I remember reading this...

David Weaver

..I took a picture of my IH sorby chisels - I don't know if this may be the factory primary bevel. Someone horsed it. All of them were like this but some with more use than the others.

With chisels this (a cross section as thick as they are) if they didn't have a shallow primary, they wouldn't be able to get out of their own way in a mortise.

The horse is the "roll" that we discussed a while ago.


A horse will still get you from a to b just fine! (just as bill found dovetailing ash).

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#93

Re: not sure I agree

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is wrong to find some chisel that was made in 1900 or earlier and assume that it was last used by some master craftsman. I just doesn't happen that way. Better to look at old drawings and old mortises.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#94

Re: not sure I agree

David Weaver

I'm not sure the one I pictured was ever used. The bevel on it open closer inspection looks like it was factory ground and the primary and rounded bevel has the same finish right up the top of the chisel up to the holster.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#95

Factory ground

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is what a factory grind looks like.


Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#96

Re: Factory ground

David Weaver

Actually, you saw the factory grind in my picture.

I have a full set of these chisels. The grind marks are the same top to bottom, end to end and the same on the small bevel as they are on the side of the chisel.

I have two in the set that I've used - those obviously don't look the same.

I never looked closely at them before - all may have been unused, and were perhaps worthy of leaving unused if I'd thought about it.

The maker is IH sorby, as good as any maker that's ever existed (better than marples).

(edit, further look - same owner mark, same handles - the whole set is IH sorby, but with two different marks. One is the typical letters only with serifs and no border, and the other is the stamp shown below).

I believe these are probably middle 1800s. This mark started around 1825. I am not a collector, I bought this set of chisels because they were relatively cheap (about $25 each). It looks like later oval bolstered chisels came with a flat grind on the bevel, but that may have been a cost cut by then.



To reiterate what's said above, the bevel is ground, it doesn't look like it was ever finish honed, as the grind marks on the small bevel are the same as the rest of the chisel. No evidence of having ever been honed on the back of the chisel, either - the factory grind goes all the way to the edge, except on the two that I've used, the factory marks are long gone (further up than I've honed them, also).

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#97

Marples catalog...

David Weaver

i tracked that picture down to an 1862 marples catalog. The mortise chisels that I have are likely from 1822 - 1850.

more from this maker:

https://www.tooltique.co.uk/shop/special-vintage-i-h-sorby-of-sheffield-%C2%BD-wide-mortice-chisel/

https://www.tooltique.co.uk/shop/vintage-i-h-sorby-3-16-cast-steel-mortice-chisel-sharpened-honed/

https://www.jimbodetools.com/products/9-16-inch-i-h-sorby-pig-sticker-mortise-chisel-87074

https://www.jimbodetools.com/products/rare-whopper-3-4-inch-i-h-sorby-pig-sticker-mortise-chisel-92375

I see none with a short flat bevel, and none without the characteristic curve at the top of the primary bevel unless they are very short.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#98

Re: Factory ground 1816

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here are some 19th century Sheffield mortise chisels 1816


Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#99

Re: Factory ground 1816

David Weaver

Warren - I have idea what you're angling for. It's clear that I&H Sorby mortise chisels were ground like this from the factory.

if you have a preference for other profiles and search for pictures to find them, that's fine.

I&H sorby chisels are generally in a class with ward chisels, so I'm not inclined to worry about whether or not they have shortcomings because they're not ground like your favorites.

If you think my chisels aren't factory ground, then you probably ought to address why the other used versions look identical or state what the point is.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#100

Re: Wooden planes

Jon Snider

Thank you David. Great YouTube videos too.