Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Posts

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#1

Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Winston

The pictures I've posted seem to have been well received, so I thought I'd post some more pictures of what I've seen experimenting with buffing. No edge sharpness or durability tests here, but this might be of interest anyway to sharpening nerds.

I got a new buffing wheel. The previous one was a soft cotton wheel. The new one is a sisal wheel, which is much stiffer and coarser. Here's a drill with the new wheel.


I used the Buck Brothers chisel. First, I honed the bevel side on a Shapton Pro 1000. This is what the bevel side looks like. I didn't work the back, so there's a big burr.


Next, I moved to a Suzuki Tool 4000. I again only did the bevel and didn't touch the back.


Here's the back. You can see that the burr looks pretty ragged.


Next, I used the buffing wheel. This time, I used a different compound which was advertised as being 1 micron aluminum oxide, but I think it's actually much coarser than that, for reasons we'll see.

Here's the bevel side after a few seconds buffing with the sisal wheel and this white compound. (There are two pictures because the angle of lighting makes a huge difference in what you can see.)




The edge is obviously much more uniform than before, but still, it's not perfect.

Compared to my previous tests with the softer wheel and white rouge that came in the Ryobi set, the rounded bevel region is smaller. In the previous tests, the area near the edge was completely smooth (as far as could be seen with my scope), but this time there are visible scratches near the edge.

At this point, I had not touched the back. When I felt it, it seemed like there was still a significant burr, but it turns out it was mostly buffing compound that had accumulated on the back, as you can see here.


If there was a burr left on it, it was small enough that it wasn't visible at this magnification.

I buffed the bevel side of the chisel again, hoping to work out the scratches near the edge. However, even after a few more seconds of buffing, there were still visible scratches. I should note that I don't know if the scratches affect edge durability or ease of cutting.


At this point, I decided to use another sisal wheel (I bought a 2-pack), but with the white rouge that I used before, instead of the new white aluminum oxide. It turns out this did a good job removing the scratches. The surface near the edge looked significantly smoother.


I buffed it for a few more seconds, and it ended up being almost completely smooth. It was actually hard to focus the camera, because there were almost no visible features to focus on. In the picture below, I think the white lines are oil from my fingers.


This the edge at a higher magnification -- I used the 10x instead of the 4x objective used for the other pictures.


Some things I learned from all this:

- The harder wheel results in a smaller rounded region. It's also probably easier to control the resulting angle near the edge by changing the angle that the chisel is presented to the wheel, but I don't specifically test that, and it's difficult to see the angle. (It's possible that a bench buffer with a softer 6" or 8" wheel might behave similarly to this stiff 4" wheel on a drill -- I think that the greater diameter and RPMs would make it behave like a stiffer wheel due to greater centrifugal force.)

- The new aluminum oxide buffing compound that I got was probably much coarser than the 1 micron it was advertised as.

- The finer buffing compound (white rouge), leaves a visibly smoother surface and doesn't take noticeably longer than the coarser stuff. I don't know if the smoother surface necessarily results in better durability, but since there's no drawback to using the finer compound (as far as I can see), it makes sense to just use it.

- The burr from sharpening on stones is almost entirely removed by buffing just the bevel side. If a burr still remained, it was smaller than I could see through the microscope.

I should mention that the chisel seemed extremely sharp after all of these stages of buffing, in terms of how it felt and how easily it shaved hairs. However, I didn't do any real testing of sharpness or edge durability.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#2

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I remain in awe of your picture quality

Next, I moved to a Suzuki Tool 4000.

To my eye whatever a Suzuki Tool 4000 is, didn't do any refining of the scratch depth and the next buffing step just rounded these "deep" scratches at the edge.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#3

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

David Weaver

excellent pictures!!

Whatever someone calls their compound (or in another case that I used a scope for - whatever someone calls their japanese natural stones when they're selling), it doesn't matter once the scope arrives - the truth is told.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#4

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

David Weaver

the edge looks more uniform, which is all the middle stone is really designed to do.

They often catch fire in peoples' reviews for not being fast enough or fine enough, and what we know of sharpening (the roll or the microbevel), they aren't absolutely necessary unless there's a flat bevel or relatively large facet involved.

I don't know what the s-t 4000 is, but I'd guess it's around 5 or so microns, the shapton pro is something like 15 or 20 (and this is probably starting to sound familiar with a diamond progression if you use a middle grit).

visuals are difficult before a polish is achieved other than to look at the line left at the edge and the depth of the divots (and make a mental correction for unevenness that's just wire edge).

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#5

Thinking about establishing the Unicorn profile

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These pictures brought into focus ( ;) ) the two facets of the Unicorn Profile, one of which I was overlooking. In David's and your hands it is a rapid and seemingly sure fire means of establishing a sharp, burr-free edge. This fact alone will make it attractive.

The second part is the profile it leaves at the tip which strengthens the edge against the forces a chisel sees in preparing mortises and dovetails.

Because I have endured dulling by edge deformation the profile part of this discovery caught my attention. But the ease and reliability of sharpening could be attractive to an even wider audience.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#6

Amen, Reverend

Jim Matthews

"But the ease and reliability of sharpening could be attractive to an even wider audience."

That's precisely why I'm jazzed about this.

A buffer and wheel cost under $100 and should last indefinitely.

Compare this method (both costs and results) to Diamond plates, proprietary shatpening gizmos like Tormek or Japanese unobtainable.

I still maintain it could be a regime changing appproach.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#7

Suzuki Tool 4000

Winston

I agree that the 4000-grit scratches don't look that much smaller than the 1000-grit ones, but I think it probably has something to do with the lighting. With the naked eye, the difference between them is easy to see.

The sharpening stone is the one described here: https://fabulalignarius.wordpress.com/2015/01/08/found-the-ultimate-waterstone/

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#8

eek...expensive..

David Weaver

...I bought a gaggle of synthetic stones, but left playing with them too early to see these (presumably private label vitrified stone made by someone like bester).

Interesting review - what I take from it based on experience is that it's more coarse than a shapton 5000. The chosera is an oddball - it's a fine gritted stepping stone for knife sharpening. IIRC, about 3 microns and soft.

Same for the shapton 5k - something like 3 micron.

There's not much free lunch in synthetic sharpening stones, but I saw many promoted by gurus (not commenting on the suzuki stone) promising one. If it's faster and finer, it'll be softer. If it's faster and same hardness, it'll be coarser.

At some point, one of the knife suppliers made a dizzying array of what I'd call $50 stones but for about double that because they offered three hardnesses at each numerical rating.

Probably a direct comparison to the suzuki 4000 would be the chosera 3k, which is still even a fine stone (4 micron).

I've cast off most of them, though, and use an oil bath (crystolon and india stone) for coarse work, even on japanese tools. Those two don't stay that flat, but do fast prep (can be blindingly fast with the crystolons if not careful). I find that the very hard japanese tools don't mind that regimen unless they're overhard (the edge may crumble, but that's a tool problem, not something to coddle as the tool will punish a user each time it chips - interestingly, the unicorn bevel that we're talking about here is protected for overhard tools).

Anyway, I've seen the same thing with the scope - what looks less coarse and more matte can look similar under the scope. When stones get close together in fineness, it can be very hard to see a difference except to look at the very edge of the tool.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#9

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

Winston

You know, I had assumed that the 1000-grit stone would leave scratches that were too deep to buff out without significantly rounding over the edge, and that's why I used the 4000 afterward. But maybe the second stone isn't necessary.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#10

Re: Amen, Reverend

Winston

> A buffer and wheel cost under $100 and should last indefinitely.

Or even less! I initially spent $10 on the buffing kit for my drill, which is not only cheap, but also doesn't require any additional bench space.

Now, if this can be made to work with plane blades, then it would greatly simply my sharpening setup. As I mentioned before, I got a very, very smooth surface with a buffed plane blade, but I didn't test it to see how much wood it could plane before having clearance issues. Even if that's the same or slightly worse than my normal sharpening, that's still very good, considering how simple and easy it is.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#11

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

David Weaver

I haven't been using anything other than ezelap 1200, but must admit that as worn in as it is, I have no clue how it compares to a typical shapton pro 1k or bester 1200 or some other such stone. It seems slower than those when they're fresh.

I think the buffer can follow those stones, though. They're really uniform and leave an edge with deep scratches, but not damage.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#12

for testing plane blade durability..

David Weaver

...i nominate someone else.

...anyone!

I buffed an already sharpened plane blade, which wasn't the same thing as we're doing with chisels by keeping the primary thin. It may be a good edge on a plane if the edge is low to mid 20s and then buffed.

But that still doesn't address back wear, which is significant. Not sure if the back wear can be partially ignored (something most people do as I rarely get a plane that hasn't accumulated scratches and damage on the back).

I may take a blade that's not in use and grind it back to 20 and do it the same way and see if the clearance issues are gone.

I've gotten older planes with very long thin primaries, and they've held up well, but the secondary was more pronounced - someone was probably maintaining the primary in off hours so that the secondary could be maintained more quickly...just my guess.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#13

Tormek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Winston, the Tormek is designed to prepare all edges - planes and chisels - in exactly this manner. Grind on the abrasive wheel to first 220, then 1000 grit, and finally power strop.

Years ago I argued this was polished serrations.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#14

Clarification, please

Jim Matthews

"Years ago I argued this was polished serrations."

By this do you mean "tooth" as Leonard Lee described in his instructional text on sharpening? I think this may be accurate when we're stopping at grit sizes larger than the steel particles being polished.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#15

Re: Clarification, please

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That's correct Jim. I still consider the process recommended by Tormek to produce a result that is simply polished serrations or, as you referred to, polished tooth.

Is it possible to create a flat/coplanar, smooth and polished edge this way? It is not that different from what Paul Sellers does, that is, he goes from 1000 grit (diamond stone) to 0.5 microns (green compound), with about 50 heavy strokes on the latter. Obviously, he would say one can do it. I wonder what his edges would look like under a microscope?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#16

if the tormek had a higher speed leather wheel...

David Weaver

..it probably would've done well. The trouble is that it doesn't have the speed to finish the job on the buffing side.

I always thought folks who touted the tormek as a finishing device (or as saying it's faster) were missing either nerve endings or some basic experience.

Interestingly, the pa-70, which smells, feels and finishes identically to autosol (and i'm pretty sure that's what it is - my microscope works as the expert witness on it) is quite nice on a strop if you want a pasted strop.

For whatever reason, the buffer is a softer background working at a higher speed and it doesn't settle into the tracks from prior abrasive.

Importantly, though, it's only a tiny bit of the edge, or there's no unicorn. Slow speed strops don't seem to excel at this. High speed aggressive strops, same. A medium stone and then the buffer used very specifically ends up being mama bear's stuff.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#17

Re: Clarification, please

David Weaver

they should look like the unicorn edge, except the LV green stuff will leave scratches that are easily seen under a microscope because the alumina has more backbone on hard leather and can scratch the edge.

He probably has less control of the geometry with his method, and he leaves a bunch of unnecessary metal behind it, but I get what he's doing - finding something suitable for beginners.

We're generally past that and trying to find something else. (100% success, same or better sharpness by finish and by wedging resistance, every edge pretty much identical and edge durability that's as good as a blunt edge).

Not just functional, but worthy of the Constructive Laziness Club.

And cheap. Cheap isn't essential, but it's worth chasing.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#18

judging scratches

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Visual observation is not useful for assessing depth of scratch if the scratch profile could be different. Sharp diamond makes a V (more or less) profile that becomes a light trap of incident light. Surfaces can look black. U profile scratches from less aggressive particle that is plowing and milling the surface will appear brighter. I would be more inclined to judge scratch depth from the microscope. I'm skeptical the second stone is doing anything useful.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#19

David &  Winston

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

David and Winston....it may become like the Watson and Crick of Woodworking .

Will you all compare and contrast exactly what you are using on the buffer. I am unfamiliar with buffing compounds. Are they the same, do they seem to be working the same if they are not the same and how do I know if I have bought the equivalent?

When you become guru status it is critical that the David and Watson groopies do exactly as you do. :)

I discovered I have a buffing wheel I bought decades ago. Still in the box. And it came with some sticks of stuff. How do I know if the buffing wheel will be equivalent, what to look for?

Do you have introductory kits available on Ebay :b

Note I am not in the shop. Annoyed. Cut first two slips to width. Fit. Cut the next 8 the same only to discover these later pre-made a while back sticks of slip stock is enough different that the result is not wide enough. Start over.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#20

Scratches from various compounds

Winston

With the talk about stropping and compounds, I decided to see what the scratches look like from different compounds.

This time I started off with an edge from a Sigma Power Ceramic 6000. I again didn't do anything to the back, so if you look closely, you can see a bit of burr hanging on (it's quite a bit darker).


I wanted to start with a smooth surface before trying out the other compounds, so I first buffed it with the white rouge.


I have a leather strop with (supposedly) 1 micron diamond paste on it, so I stropped it maybe five times at a higher angle. This is unbranded diamond paste I bought on eBay about 10 years ago. I remember that it was very inexpensive.


A little background before the next pictures. I recently bought a strop that came with two compounds: a coarser white aluminum oxide which is supposedly 1 micron, and a green aluminum oxide that's supposedly 0.5 micron. I haven't put either compound on the strop yet.


First, I buffed the blade with the white rouge to get a smooth surface. Then, I dragged the blade backward on the stick of green aluminum oxide compound a few times.


Finally, the white aluminum oxide. This is the same stuff I had used before with a buffing wheel, but for consistency, I just used the stick directly this time. I buffed the blade smooth again, and then dragged the blade backward on the white stick a few times.


I should say again that the blade seemed extremely sharp after all of these steps. It's possible that for the unicorn grind, the scratch size doesn't matter much for durability, but that it's the rounded edge profile that really matters.

So far, the white rouge has left by far the smoothest surface. Apparently, the abrasives aren't as hard as others. Here's one description I found: "White rouge: An extremely dry grade of compound made with ultra-fine, soft abrasive powders. Produces a clear, brilliant, mirror-like finish on chromium, stainless, carbon steel, brass and aluminum."

So maybe the reason it's leaving such a smooth surface is because it's softer, compared to abrasives like diamond and aluminum oxide. On something that's hand "powered" like a strop, you might want a very hard abrasive so that it works quickly, but on a powered buffing wheel, a softer, slower abrasive is still plenty fast for working on a tiny region like this, and will leave a smoother surface. (The drill I used for this can do 1600 rpm, and with a 4" wheel, that's a surface speed of 28 feet per second. A 6" bench buffer has a surface speed of 94 feet per second.)

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#21

Re: David &  Winston

Winston

Thanks to David for figuring it out and posting about it! I definitely don't deserve that much credit. :) I'm just a guy who figured out how to take good pictures with a cheap microscope. It's funny -- the only reason I started using the microscope to look at these blades is because a friend borrowed my 30x loupe a few weeks ago and hadn't brought it back. And he still hasn't brought it back. :b

The pictures are helpful for understanding what's going on, but they're not the whole story. They don't give a detailed image of the edge profile -- and of course the pictures by themselves don't tell us anything about edge durability. Someone is going to have to experiment with that...

As for others getting similar results, there are a lot of variables: different types of buffing wheel, compounds, amount of compound on the wheel, types of steel, angle that it's presented to the wheel, and so on. But have the feeling those variables don't matter all that much -- maybe you just have to buff it enough (using your eye as a guide) and to get a big improvement. It's possible there's a set of values for the variables that will maximize durability and sharpness, but I think there's probably a wide range of things you can do that will still result in a big improvement.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#22

Buffing wheel vs hard felt

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Any difference or advantage of one over the other? The reason I ask is that I have both, but the hard felt seems a little more controllable.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#23

Re: Buffing wheel vs hard felt

David Weaver

I found the felt too aggressive years ago when I tried it, but wouldn't be surprised if it was just a touch thing.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#24

these results will require some study

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

See of you can get an image of the edge of the chisel to show the profile of the Unicorn Profile, or whatever it will show.

Re: Sharpening and buffing progression pictures

#25

The white stuff is...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

aluminum oxide in a very fine size. Probably submicron. Literature says it barely cuts metal. Used on hard metals like chrome.