Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Light vs Heavy planes

Posts

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#76

I think we're agreeing...

David Weaver

...but there's too much in my talk for it to be clear.

I think a 40 year worker could use my try plane without wearing it out. Could two in a row? I don't know. They would go through several irons. as to how much planing that is for someone? I don't know - there are not individuals who can do the act of planing and sawing (vs. moving up and getting younger bodies) for 40 years.

I don't read historical texts, so I have no idea how they address this - I recall seeing a video segment in africa where they are still building house trim/doors/etc by hand because there is no other option. They are talking to some of the carpenters who mention that by the time they are in their late 30s, they are spent and are looking for other career options. They were working in smaller groups and it appeared that in that case, it was more like freelance (So someone in their 30s didn't move past doing the physical work).

All that said, I would expect the double iron planes to last longer than single iron planes. They can plane a larger volume of wood for the same amount of iron consumed (that's a fact based on my use of a high quality early single iron jointer and the need for it to be sharpened more often and inability to do work as heavily as a double iron plane), and the smoothers are more dependent on the fitting and condition of the mouth vs. a double iron smoother.

I'm sure they wore out planes, but the context is important now - for Steve, the idea that he could make a beech smoother and someone may wear it out without abusing it is a chance pretty close to zero.

The other interesting point larry used to try to make is that single iron planes (it's in writing in the archives here) were more common than we think but they were "better" and therefore got "used up". That's borderline comedy material, but I'm not sure that larry ever hand dimensioned anything bigger than a plane.

The long and short of that is, I'm sure people wore out planes. I don't know what proportion of that was accelerated by misuse, and at this point in history, a new beginner may read that and think it's a concern (that the wood plane they're buying is a consumable), and it definitely is not.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#77

expanding on what jim said

David Weaver

japanese planes because of the hollow, will rely on the condition of the wood just in front of the mouth to work properly.

A double iron wooden plane will show wear in that area fairly quickly, but it will be a long time before it matters because the wood ahead of it and behind it hasn't been removed.

The bearing points on a japanese plane are chosen like that as I believe there wouldn't have been an easy way to true the sole of a plane "superfine" without biasing the process by removing most of the wood. Everything but the toe and the area in front of the mouth is removed so that just those strips can be tuned.

While I may condition a double iron plane once a year or every two years, the literature for japanese planes says that in heavy use, conditioning more than one time in a day was not uncommon.

single iron wooden planes will work OK if the mouth is eroded a little bit as a shaving will be able to lift a little bit, but not unrestricted. The use of the cap iron negates the issue because it works several times better than mouth tightness, and then large parts of the sole need to wear unevenly before truing is necessary.

Just as a follow up comment, I make quite a few planes and so have a long and very flat abrasive lap. It's how I true planes, and it's not historically accurate anywhere. I have trued japanese planes and used them without doing anything else, and they work wonderfully, but my lap is flatter than 99% of table saw tables (there is no area under pressure on it where a 1.2 thousandth feeler will fit under a 24" starrett edge).

I no longer use japanese planes much, but would probably do this in secret for my own use rather than following the traditional method described above. I've modified the wear on a couple to use a double iron more easily and they work great (leading back to the comment above where slight erosion at the mouth becomes a non-issue).

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#78

Re: Calling BS

joelmoskowitz

I was taught to buy wood in the rough, let it acclimate to the shop and then mill it. I have spent days milling lumber by hand. (not for a bunch of years though - my home shop is now a bedroom) But I have never worn out a plane and never will.

But if you were correct then how do you explain the ready availability of early 19th century wooden planes of all types - EXCEPT bench planes. The most common planes for milling wood are by far the least available survivors. This is even more remarkable because bench planes sold in orders of magnitude greater quantities than any of the specialized molding, rabbet or other styles.

I happen to own I think one late 18th century bench plane - a very long jointer by Gabriel. It not only is unusable because of so much wear and tear the mouth was repaired at least once.

By the way I don't even understand why this is controversial. It's not even that unusual to find old metal planes in great shape except for some rounding (through wear) on the leading edge of the mouth. No big deal but things wear.

I won't argue that in the normal coarse of events a modern woodworker will have less wear and tear on their tools than someone from a century ago, if nothing else the workday to day is shorter. And of course irons wear faster than bodies - you sharpen all the time I would guess - how much material do you lose each time? .002"-.005" (I have no idea) but it adds up. just for fun: sharpening once a day (conservative if you are dressing wood) 200 working days in a year (working only 5 days a week + vacations we are living high) 200 x .002 = .4" every year. With a usable iron length of about 2" every 5 years you would need a new blade. (Obviously your numbers might vary the calculation was just for fun)

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#79

Re: I think we're agreeing...

joelmoskowitz

"The long and short of that is, I'm sure people wore out planes. I don't know what proportion of that was accelerated by misuse, and at this point in history, a new beginner may read that and think it's a concern (that the wood plane they're buying is a consumable), and it definitely is not. "

This I agree with - my point was historical not modern. The modern woodworker has loads of choices at all price points with many different styles and features.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#80

rosewood

David Weaver

Hi, rafael - I search ebay about once a week for mahogany and rosewood for guitar building.

It's not every week that there's something on there to buy, and if you're making planes, you eventually get used to the idea that you'd rather have some stock (Guitars, too) in your shop for a while to observe, so I am a little bit tolerant of what I get. E.g,. indian rosewood is often sold as dry, as is honduran (plantation) mahogany, but removal of the wax finds otherwise. I have enough on hand that I have time to wait and then buy on grain orientation and price.

I typically search for table leg blanks 3x3 (they are usually rift or closer to straight sawn than just 3x3 blanks), or smoothers can be searched as other names (pool cue rosewood blank, peppermill rosewood blank)

3x3 of reasonable straightness sized is good enough for jack and smoother planes with a 2" iron, with a little luck, maybe 2 1/8th.

bigger than that isn't as easy to find.

Blanks often appear in 24/30/36 lengths when they do show up as those are sizes that are useful for guitar fingerboards or necks.

This is a good thing to set up as a casual thing to look for as one week, a 3x3x24 blank may be $55 and the next there may be none or only some for $200 and they're not straight.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#81

Re: Facts, not assertions

joelmoskowitz

Steve,

I like wooden planes I really do. You make fine planes. My comments are historical not modern. I was referring to bench planes in general not smoothing planes in particular.

IIRC The literature refers specifically to longer planes not smoothers - I need to dig it out. But my point about the dearth of old and usable wooden smooth planes still stands. Of the bench planes they were the most common model used, but not many survive from the per-industrial period in usable shape.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#82

Re: Calling BS

joelmoskowitz

"wear" not "tear"

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#83

by the early 19th century

David Weaver

..there were a few makes like my 1820s or so JT brown jointer. Someone managed not to use mine and I think it may have been entirely unused. I thought I'd found something really great once I was able to free the iron.

When you mill lumber that is less than perfect by hand (which probably started pretty early), and even wood that is perfect, you can at least double your productivity with double iron planes.

I can mill lumber flat and to size ready for final use never taking a shaving thinner than about 4 thousandths of an inch (with a smoother) and regardless of grain direction, plane almost without tearout (that's important, as that's the most productive try plane setting - not with, not without - allowing only as much as will be smoothed out) with a trying plane at something like 8 thousandths to a hundredth and a little more than 2/3rds that in ash.

Sharpening occurs about 1/8th as much per volume of wood with the same iron from the same maker as it was with the single iron jointer (which in my case is about the same weight as my 24" trying plane).

In jack planes, you can probably get away with not having a cap iron (Though it's useful for plane fitting and solidity, and sometimes wood is bad enough that you can make use of it - I usually go to the trying plane at that point instead).

If effort and economy has anything to say (and this would have converted to making a living, it would've been undeniable), I would bet that the double iron try plane almost immediately obsoleted the single iron try plane, the smoother shortly thereafter or at the same time, and economy-minded buyers would've hung on a little bit longer with a jack plane.

I had a single iron jack plane when first started - one of the inexpensive makes. It's terrible compared to a double iron jack, but you could get by with it. If you used mostly perfect wood, then it may have been no issue at all.

Once you get to a double iron plane, the chatter ceased, seasonal fitting is almost eliminated, work is faster with less demand on wood quality and sharpening per volume of wood is significantly reduced. In a group of tradespeople who were never rich to begin with, the economic value would've been apparent within a week.

This started in the late 1700s as far as I know, and news of it (due to shrewd marketing) couldn't have taken that long to spread.

It goes back to my prior statement - I doubt larry ever did much dimensioning by hand. I doubt he even does much now by hand on his planes, but in his moulding plane video, he triangulates his plane around to avoid tearout on quartered wood. With a double iron plane, you don't have to do it. I recall larry at one point saying early on that all of us had no idea how smoothing was actually done, that double iron plane fingers clog, that anything larger than a small smoother is pointless and he was all wet on all of those.

Even if it was some kind of other ideological preference existed, the economics of what was going on would've eliminated single iron planes for anything other than very rough work.

it exists in moulding planes because there's no easy way to economically make those with a double iron. it can be done, but the cost would've been astronomical for a plane where the economic benefit afterwards (you can always scrape mouldings, and save stock for them) wouldn't have made up for it.

Further into history (the early-mid 1800s when the first casted infill planes came along), infill planes were made in droves and none of those would've been used up, as you say. I've never seen any reputable (intended for professional use) infill plane with a single iron and the early norris planes are painstakingly made so that the cap iron can be set all the way to the tip of the iron without causing feeding problems. If there had been some usefulness of single iron bench planes, there would be examples of wedged infills with them as they could've been made far more easily than a slotted iron and cap iron.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#84

Re: Me too

Steve Voigt

The long and short of that is, I'm sure people wore out planes. I don't know what proportion of that was accelerated by misuse, and at this point in history, a new beginner may read that and think it's a concern (that the wood plane they're buying is a consumable), and it definitely is not.

Yes, this is a good way to put it. Glad we agree.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#85

Re: Can't argue

Steve Voigt

Ha! I was wondering if you'd call me out on this, Warren. :D

Point well taken. I admit I got a little hot under the collar. It's a good idea to reread what we wrote and make sure it's something we'd be willing to say in person.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#86

Re: by the early 19th century

Wiley Horne

I seriously object to the personal references in this post. And in many others like it.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#87

It's not offered as ball court...

David Weaver

...neener, it's offered in the sense of understanding how the advice could've been so poor for someone working from rough to finished only with hand tools. Larry's planes (or the type that he advocates) work great in any other context. The moulding planes and his and don's DVDs, as well as the floats offered are excellent. This is limited only to using bench planes for dimensioning and advising people of the shortcomings of the double iron design (which larry asserted . I just can't remember anyone else to attribute it to).

I could ask larry if he still posted, but he doesn't. I remember this so clearly because I spent money and time taking his advice on planes until it was intolerable (about 100 board feet into dimensioning).

If he stated that he does most of his work other than fitting of plane parts and shaping of handles (perhaps) by machine, it would solve the mystery. Otherwise, those of us who spent time digging in the woods looking for truffles are left guessing.

Essential human laziness will lead pretty much everyone to the same road when dimensioning, but without the dimensioning and the understanding of economy of effort, many ways work well....the context really matters.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#88

I miss Todd Hughes' contributions too


Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#89

Re: It's not offered as ball court...

Wiley Horne

David,

You say that someone can’t do something, as an ad hominem argument. That shows a mean spirit, rather than a proof of your point. I let things like this go without comment ordinarily, but Larry is a genuinely good person and I can’t always let it go.

The double-iron is superior technology, on the subset of planes where it can be used (bench planes and supersurfacer). It is a productivity enhancer. It enables easier use of less than straight-grained wood. But some, if not the majority, of the most beautiful furniture was made prior to 1800. Somehow the makers of the day managed to try their boards and join their edges and smooth their surfaces, and did not consider their single-iron planes ‘useless’ for these tasks. Isn’t that a balanced view of the subject?

Todd Hughes made very telling arguments, always from fact, and none of them ad hominem.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#90

I'm guessing on parts here...

David Weaver

..larry stated definitively (at least based on his statement) that the full width of an iron isn't usable and that the fingers of a double iron plane are a clog point and that a single iron plane well fitted will either not clog or generally clear its clog on the next shaving.

That part about the single iron planes is true. Sometimes they won't clear a clog in poor wood, but there's not much to put back together.

The statement about the fingers is actually not true. It is true on a plane that's poorly fitted with another plane's wedge, etc, or the off chance that a wedge is flatsawn and has shrunk (most are quartered or rift). I didn't set out to prove larry wrong on that rather experimented with a few planes to see where they would clog or not clog. When you first start planemaking, until you figure out the relationship of everything, you get some pretty planes but they clog and it's really annoying. I took my lumps figuring it all out (First finding the point where my first plane fed nicely, and then I made my second one - I'm still using it as my try plane. For some reason, the same wear angle and setup didn't work. I turned out to be due to the geometry of the cap iron (it's rounder - it didn't need more room for the cap iron, it needed a different wear angle. I was cautious about this as I didn't want a vertical wear - it's unsightly - not functionally problematic, but i'm trying to build a good plane.....

why am I trying to build a good plane? I couldn't tell you. Those are larry's arguments, not larry the guy down the street (I've never met larry, but I did get a few drive by shots from larry when I was advocating an inexpensive white steel japanese plane to someone. I didn't know larry, but he posted a picture of someone on the floor and demanded I go back to the stone age and work on the floor. That was probably 2007 or 2006. I was surprised, but he's enthusiastic and someone else may have set him off. It was on woodnet - apologies sometimes for having a good memory. I wish it was always the case).

At any rate, I wanted to learn how to make planes from larry, so I didn't care that much. When I asked him questions about floats or DVDs or when he was making a bench plane video, he mentioned that he shouldn't have been telling his life's work or providing the iron width details with the DVD - as I do, larry sometimes answered your question and 5 others. The idea of not sharing what you know is foreign to me, but that's a decision that everyone needs to make for themselves.

The relationship with the top of the cap iron, the side of the plane and the shape and end of the fingers is important, but it's not that much of a secret. I'd guessed if I could eliminate the ends of the fingers being away from the side of the plane (larry would need to do that), the overhang over the cap iron curve (larry probably wouldn't have that luxury on a single iron plane as there's no cap iron to extend the influence of the fingers) and trimmed the fingers so that shavings would get caught on them, I couldn't see where anything would get caught. I mentioned this to larry, but I don't recall him responding. I have to guess why larry couldn't figure this out:

1) he didn't want to

2) his customer was CW early on (I learned this later, not at the time I was challenging him on what he wrote), they wouldn't have allowed him to make double iron planes for them, and building your own cap irons is a challenge on something that's already fairly difficult to make profitably

Given what he went through with moulding planes and single iron bench planes, it's unlikely that he looked at this really hard and was never able to figure it out. After I chanced into those things (mentioned above) likely removing any pinch points in a plane, I kept buying good English planes and they were all made that way. In fact, it was shocking how nearly identically all were made. This would've been easily accessible to anyone willing to buy a dozen planes from England.

What strikes me is how firm larry was in denying these things - but never curious once they were brought up (at least outwardly). I would've been curious. I've gone back once in a while to use my single iron planes - not often. I think when I haven't used them for a while that maybe I will have learned something (neural) about planing and maybe it was me, but learn this quickly.

Guessing on the part about can't - I mentioned that I think it's unlikely (all of this is different than can't) that Larry had done a lot of dimensioning by hand or continued to. I don't know larry, so I have no idea if he can or can't. he makes moulding planes by hand on his video. I say it's unlikely not as a shot at larry - it's unlikely based on the arguments that he's made. I'm not sure if you've ever dimensioned a couple of hundred feet of wood in a year (this is always taken the wrong way - it's not a challenge, it's understanding context), but the point where the economy (And thus the comment about unlikely) becomes stark is in the middle of dimensioning a lot. I can't imagine more than 1 out of 10 people missing this.

When joel said earlier that he'd found (Sorry joel if this is butchering what you meant) that everything sort of gets to the same point and he'd used planes heavily, until he stated that the heavy dimensioning was for a couple of days, I was suspicious of the pattern of things.

I don't know Larry, you do. I believe that he's a pleasant guy if you're not talking about something he's drawn conclusions on and put his flag in the ground about. I'm focused on the bad advice, and you're focused on the fact that i'm attributing it to larry (it's not generalized, it's larry's advice). There's not a lot I can do about that - the group of people who have really gotten into the small bits on planes is too small to talk about many generalities.

There's another person who built a lot of these planes and had never really used a double iron correctly. George. I brought the same things up to George "how didn't anyone notice this?" and george pretty flatly said "if you say that's better, I have to believe you. We used single iron planes because we didn't have a choice, so I don't know anything about it". George is a nice guy, too, but I separate George is a nice guy and how good I've found his advice. One of the reasons we get along so well (I think) is because he knows I want his advice, I don't want him to worry about whether or not I'll see him as being friendly or not if he tells me I'm off the mark.

This isn't an online issue, either. I am not good in real life at "letting it slide" when someone (who I am friends with) says something incorrect and then asks for my consensus. I can't control how someone perceives that, but I can tell you that I wouldn't bring up larry if there were 10 sources. How can we tell that there's pretty much one?

https://msbickford.com/individual-hollow-round-pairs/

https://calebjamesmaker.com/toolgallery

it's hard to attribute the whole style to anyone else. Those are undeniably copies or near copies of larry's planes, not of English planes in general:

https://www.google.com/search?q=english+moulding+planes&rlz=1C1CHBD_enUS822US822&sxsrf=ALeKk00PdTd1STQqQQKl7UJVIZKnTDNEcg:1593640923772&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi7rqSJh63qAhWXgnIEHduDAxoQ_AUoA3oECAwQBQ&biw=1920&bih=969#imgrc=9OOyUjntyl20AM

I think he should be proud of that and the folks making planes per his instructions without looking around and taking style cues from some other historically significant planes should be pretty happy that larry doesn't request that they come up with something of their own.

I guess a question at the end of this is how to you ponder what's likely or not likely or speculate on context to solve a question if the source is a single person?I know it can be done sacrificing precision, but as long as someone can be identified as providing the argument, another will make the connection and we get to the same point.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#91

Wood isn't indefinitely stable, either

Jim Matthews

The nearby IYRS in Newport, RI has active boat builders engaged in restoration, repairs and fresh construction.

They're right on the water and deal with corrosion on steel, tools dropped from a height and damp on wood.

There are no surviving antique wooden planes in evidence.

I discussed the "standard kit" in use and why there weren't any wooden planes in obvious use.

His take on it was that no amount of attention will keep the Sea from reclaiming wood, given enough time.

***"""

Modern wooden planes are *more* durable than their cast iron counterparts for users like me - they're easier to hold, even when my hands tire.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#92

Re: expanding on what jim said

Winston

In my experience with Japanese planes (which isn't a lot), I found that the hollow makes it much quicker to true the sole.

When I got my first kanna, I flattened the bottom with sandpaper on granite, and it took a long time. When I had to re-flatten it due to seasonal movement, it took a long time to flatten it again. That's when I realized that if I hollowed the appropriate section, it would be much quicker to true the sole, because only a tiny amount of material (at the toe and in front of the mouth) would have to be removed each time.

Now that I've thought about what David and Jim have said about it, I think that another possible reason that kanna have to be tuned frequently is because the small contact points result in faster wear of the sole, because the downward pressure is concentrated into those small areas.

An aside: I stopped using the sandpaper method because it was still kind of slow and inconvenient with my shop setup. I don't have a Japanese scraper plane, which is the traditional tool to true the sole. What I do now is, when the sole needs significant truing, is to use a metal jointer plane on the kanna's bottom, until the toe and area in front of the mouth are co-planar. Then I use another plane across the grain to make the hollow. Much faster than the sandpaper method, but of course it requires another plane, one that is well-tuned.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#93

Re: expanding on what jim said

David Weaver

You're dead on with the wear - I had considered that got no bearing surface near it, but you're correct that it's also increased in focus at that spot. When you use a kanna that's got a lot of wear at the "back stripe" in front of the iron, it can be pretty yucky.

The sanding scenario that I mentioned is only really practical if one already has the setup and has confirmed that it's flat. If doing it instead, for example, on sheet sandpaper on granite, it would quickly become a nuisance.

Wooden (western) planes were generally trued by planing the soles where they were out of true - I think I got my long lap with 80 grit paper to restore metal planes, but it's turned out to be useful for miter tuning and working wooden planes. Without it, I'd have kept hollowing the soles.

Wiley at one point suggested an LN 212 to me and it was the last scraper plane that I let go of because it was so good for scraping the center of dais. I've still got a gaggle of japanese planes and would imagine a phase will come around again sooner or later (I have a bunch because of a rash of buying matched or unmatched unused or little used kanna on buyee - when I see bubbly wrought iron in a ledged dai and a matching cap iron for $60 or $75, it is hard to resist. There is just very little that looks like that that ever comes across the ocean and ends up being junk).

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#94

Coupla thoughts

Wiley Horne

David, Winston and all,

THOUGHT 1:

Added advantage of the hollow....It’s not unusual to discover that a Japanese plane has a bump in the center of the dai, behind the mouth. Not sure of all the reasons how this happens, but one reason can be that the blade is fit too tight, (which is something I’m prone to).

How does the bump happen? Well, the plane is likely to be bedded at 40 degrees or so, and the dai is not tall like a western woodie’s body. So there's not much wood under the blade, and the mouth has cut the strength away from it. When the blade is tapped into place—or hammered!—the wood under the blade may bulge, producing a bump in the middle of the sole, right behind the mouth.

If the sole is checked with the blade removed, you don’t see this bump (if it’s there). The sole has to be checked with the blade installed and at cutting depth. Matsui Measure makes a straight edge with a notch in it for this purpose:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Japanese-Single-Bevel-Straight-Edge-40cm-woodblock-plane-Matsui-Measure-Kanna/193523629312?hash=item2d0ee83d00:g:QqYAAOSwqDVe6uEc

This straight edge can be used to check the sole with the blade at depth—you just place the notch over the blade. Incidentally, they’re hard to find—Hida Tool is stock out. I got mine from SoYamashita at Japan-tool.

My point: check for this bump, with the blade at cutting depth. If it’s there, redo the hollow with the blade installed, so as to cut the bump away. And then consider whether the blade is too tight.

THOUGHT 2

On lapping stuff. I love to lap things. But sometimes scraping or filing is essential. Recently, I bought my first Bailey #3 off ebay, prompted by something Sir Wm. said. A Pre-WW1 model. It too had a bump in the sole, this one in front of the mouth. Which creates erratic performance that’s hard to figure out. Eventually, I found the problem, using that Matsui Measure straight edge. You can’t lap out a convexity, or I can’t anyway. It just stays there pretty much. So I filed this one away, not having a metal scraper.

In general, a double-iron plane is more resistant to sole imperfections than a single iron plane, which has to be about perfect to work right, with the front of the mouth sitting down hard on the work. But this double-iron No. 3 also wouldn't work right until the bump in the sole was removed.

That’s all! Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#95

Rafael from PA

Re: rosewood

Rafael from PA

Thanks David, I found some offerings. As I progress in my plane building project I'll start to stock on the woods I want to use.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#96

different methods of lapping and the bump

David Weaver

this bump is something I've found on wooden planes.

The ugly cocobolo smoother that I showed a picture of developed the bump a couple of times. It's all the same wood, so i have to believe that it's influenced wedge and iron pressure (just iron pressure for the most part on japanese planes).

There's less tuning with a plane like that because it's for heavy work and double iron, but I think the appearance of the bump has ceased or been reduced greatly. Initially, it made the plane unusable within a short period of time before lapped off. The nature of this bump wasn't that it went away with the iron out, it was if it had been "bent" out settling that way. I eventually also started loosening the iron and wedge (and loosening the iron in japanese planes) if they were coming into the basement out of the garage (where I keep things that aren't in current use).

As far as lapping goes, the internet and communicating things is cumbersome. If one person says "get a flat surface and sand the sole of your plane with the paper affixed to the flat surface", you just can't control what someone does.

Over the years, I've come to find that if you have a long lap like mine and the lapping of the plane is done as if you're planing (Vs. swishing the plane back and forth or unintentionally rocking side to side), it works well. On a 24 inch wooden plane, the flatness issues will probably be a couple of thousandths. The more you have to do with a metal plane and the less easily the plane laps, at least in my experience, the more the bias will be toward making a greater error.

That said, not proposing that people should lap the soles of their japanese planes the way that I'm doing it (with the iron partially set) or even scraping the back and lapping the rest. If it's been done a certain way for a long time, that's probably the best way to do it.

I'll be curious enough to check lapping a japanese plane I haven't used in a while (there's another plane that needs to be lapped soon, anyway) with the iron in partial tension and then check with the iron in tension - there's enough less wood in a japanese plane and enough difference in how the iron is held, it's not hard to believe that the iron itself could reintroduce the bulge even after flattening the body.