Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Light vs Heavy planes

Posts

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#26

Note on fitting

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

To add to your point,

“ and the abutments have to be precise enough since there's no wedge - precise enough to keep the iron tight but not prevent it from getting it to the end of the plane.”

Western and Japanese woodies share this problem of precise fitting of the iron within the abutments. The Japanese plane has evolved to solve this problem by having the iron slightly sprung in the abutments. That’s how some practitioners are able to use the plane with no chipbreaker. The iron comes from the smith with a slight curvature (1-3 thousandths), based on measurements I made of a half dozen kanna some years ago.

Sometimes you see the western woodie with the wedge slightly sprung—scraped just a tiny bit hollow, so as to ensure a tight fit top and bottom of the iron. To be sure, we have also seen western woodies where the wedge was not sprung, just perfectly fitted its whole length. But overall I find it an interesting comparison of two ways to solve the same problem.

Not suggesting the Japanese iron is smithed with this curvature to aid fitting—no, surely it is a natural product of the welding and heat-treating process. But over time, the dai makers (who were often the users) figured out how to use this blade curvature to advantage.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#27

new vs. old planes...

David Weaver

infills and all wooden planes can be sorted out to work like that, but the easiest way to learn to fit them well is to make them -then, suddenly, refitting older planes is very easy and often takes less than an hour end to end.

Which is probably not that realistic. The interesting thing about both types is that it's not hard to make them with the critical details right (including really nailing exactly what you're looking for in an iron, the fit, etc). But it takes a little bit of individual attention to each one and I guess nobody is going to do that in mid range tools.

And nobody is going to pay for it until you get up to the cost level of Larry's planes.

Once in a while, I'll find an English plane (greaves, griffiths, etc) made well with a full ward iron, refit it and I can't tell any difference between my planes and those refitted. Except I could pretty easily sell a plane for double the cost of materials and If I refit an old plane and list it on ebay, i'll never break even after fees.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#28

finding out who to listen to...

David Weaver

...warren, when I first started out, I had trouble figuring out who to listen to. Ultimately, I ended up listening to experience and started paying attention to what you said as my experience matched it and I was working enough wood rough to finish to actually notice differences (where as folks planing with caterpillar D9 style planes were probably using their planes between projects and not in them).

But what made it difficult to tell was that others offer up their thoughts, and take criticism. I'm sure you have posted a post that is the initiation of a thought line rather than a rebuttal against one, but I can't remember it.

I am oppositional and not immune from this, and I'm also still just an amateur hack with a few party tricks, and what I"m posting that may be seen as "contributions" is often more me posting something to see what reaction it gets. Not to manipulate people, but to learn from it - if I can get legitimate positive and negative criticism, I can learn something.

You're probably not looking to learn anything here and that's always going to result in most people seeing your responses as nitpicking others until or unless they get enough experience to understand which ones are really the right answer.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#29

Re: Same

Steve Voigt

I have to agree with Dave here. Warren, in the parallel thread over at SMC, there was a particularly excellent phrase in your post--"like playing ping pong with a cast iron pan"--with regards to using heavy planes. It was unfortunate though that the line was buried by the airing of very old personal grievances. I think most people missed the good part because they were distracted by the rest. Not trying to pile on here; just trying to be honest.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#30

Re:wedge fitting

Steve Voigt

Wiley, I recall you mentioning this before. My experience is that it's fine if the wedge/iron interface is "sprung" because one or both is concave. Double irons will always be that way, by default. But if the front of the wedge (or the mating abutment) is concave, it seems to contribute to the condition in which the iron jumps or shifts downward when the wedge is seated. That's annoying because then you have to go back and forth between seating the wedge and retracting the iron until you get it right. I try to dial in the fit so that the abutments are imprinting on the wedge along their full length. Doesn't have to be 100% but I try to get as close as possible.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#31

biases for the maker...

David Weaver

Hi, Wiley - I think all of these things are biases for the maker. If you're going to make an iron by hand, you can either make it perfectly (which is extremely unrealistic) or bias it so that even with error in manufacturing or movement in the wood being used, the bedding will still occur where you want it.

I like to hollow the back of my plane irons, as I did with the skew shooter. This probably isn't realistic for modern irons as I'm not sure how it could be mass produced without hammering.

AT any rate, looking at my japanese irons, they are concave along their length on the front and across the width on the back. I'm sure those things arose out of finding where you want the contact points to be (or the bias for sharpening) and making sure the biases guarantee them.

On wooden planes, I bias the fingers of the wedge at the bottom a tiny bit, but try for a more even fit in the abutments. Once things are pretty good, the plane is like a vault with the older irons (but the older irons are also sometimes a little irregular - even wards - and require work on the bed of a plane to get the contact points in the right place.

I guess where raney would call all of these details complicated (vs. someone drawing lines and living in a world of perfectly straight lines and flat planes) but to someone who is looking for a result, consistently, they just seem like common sense.

I asked Rob at one point how they managed not to have irons high centering on BU planes on the machined area since it's so much easier to bias something like that hollow, and his response was that the area looks like it's machined flat, but the beds of the planes are biased, too (The finished area is a bit hollow in the center).

one last thing for these biases - early on, I bought older stanleys because the machining on the frog was just "common sense - they're better, there's more contact area"....I've come to have a bit of a preference for later planes because the large adjuster wheel usually makes them less effort to adjust. The frogs have a small belt sanded contact area that I'm sure is not machinist flat. But the irons bend with the cap iron applied and they work like a treat---and are often new enough that nobody has worn them out or battered the soles (the cast is often soft, too, and they're easier to flatten and file).

All of these things are the little treats of making. There's a whole little area of what is (vs. what looks good and is popular) in guitar making, too. I can make a fender style guitar that will make someone's ear itch near the neck joint if the strings are strummed, but it requires the little biases and moving things around in our favor. Those are usually lost in production. Much of the human element in guitar feel has been lost in the consumer ranges, too - you get a very neatly made guitar cosmetically and 80% are kind of dead sounding and you get neck profiles that when you wrap your hand around them (they used to be finished on a specialty belt sander and felt by a "neck guy" or "neck girl" until they felt good), you feel stuff that just makes you think "I guess the CNC file can make them all identical, but the "neck guy" or "neck girl" would've never let a guitar that feels like that leave the factory.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#32

funny...

David Weaver

how we've come to the same conclusion - my thoughts almost matched yours. I will make sure the fingers are tight at the bottom, but then on a western plane, I want the top side of the wedge fingers to be marked most of the way and a little bit less drastically at the top of the abutments ( to prevent break out - admittedly, I've never managed to make a non-skew plane break out, but I've seen stress there when the wedge is biased).

The cheaper euro machine made planes often have that very top of the abutment clipped off with a backward cut toward the bed.

use of a plane should lead to compressing the abutment and wedge fingers together nicely over time, anyway -even though that compressed fit is probably a thousandth or two at most, it kind of seals things up.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#33

Re: funny...

Steve Voigt

Dave, I agree that the abutments should imprint a little less at the top. I don't think splitting is a concern, unless the fit is really terrible! But I think there's two other benefits.

First is that if the the fit changes through wood movement, the wedge tips might not be putting enough pressure on the iron, and we don't want that.

The other, which took me a long time to come to terms with, is that an absolutely perfect fit is not ideal, because the wedge tends to go thunk and seat without any significant travel. Having a slight bias at the bottom allows for enough travel between "barely engaged" and fully tight" to make the wedge easy to adjust. Of course that bias has to be really small to work right; it's all in the details…as I'm sure you've discovered.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#34

Re: finding out who to listen to...

Wiley Horne

My experience....Like David, I have learned from experience to heed Warren. But here’s the thing: Warren doesn’t write a cookbook for you. He gives you—usually in one sentence—the clue or the observation you need. He gives you a course correction, but you still have to do the work of thinking. One time, I was struggling with a satinwood project where I was using a lot of shop sawn veneer to stretch the limited supply of quartered wood I had. Somewhere in that sequence, Warren said ‘use solid wood’. At the time, I thought that wasn’t very helpful. But I had pure hell with that project, and in the end I was left with the unforgettable conviction that Warren was right. Another time, more recently, I was showing the result of some double-iron planing with different setbacks. Warren commented, just from the phone camera photos, that one of the planes had its cap iron too close and was dulling the surface. He did this in 4-5 words, and it was a great help to me and an insight about reading the surface (I was mainly looking for tearout) that I had missed. Immensely valuable, and I haven't forgotten. There are other examples, but those will do.

It reminds me a little of Krenov. If you’re trying to build a particular Krenov project from his book, you won’t find steps 1, 2, 3....But it’s all there—you just have to search for the clues, and do some thinking about it.

So. My experience is that Warren’s posts have given me deeply valuable info in a few words and no explication. I listen now.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#35

Re:wedge fitting

Wiley Horne

Steve,

To me, the perfect wedge is when it is 1-2 thou hollow, and can be set with my thumb. I may have given the impression of something more extreme. And I understand you’re going for full-length printing—I’ve seen the result and it’s terrific!

It occurs to me there are many other similar situations. Like on a double-screw vise, where you want the top to close just before the vise closes in depth. So the vise will hold thin or narrow stuff well and suppress vibration at the top.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#36

I agree...

David Weaver

I learned the same - that it's worth taking time to decode it - it took me a while to figure it out. I call George fairly often, his advice is generally pretty plain - but it will always be worth figuring out.

I also have no solution as it's not really the case that if you take the time to offer information on a forum on a regular basis that anyone will respond (more likely to get responses from detractors). no guarantee that helpful advice won't lead to the "every method is equally as good" brigade showing up and getting a thread torched.

I see why derek makes a template post and posts it in a whole bunch of places at once - it would hardly be worth the time to organize things as he does otherwise and even then, it takes someone who wants to do that regardless of the outcome.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#37

Re: finding out who to listen to...

Bruce Mack

Several years ago Warren was gracious in a reply to my question on fitting end caps to a coopered box whose inner surface was faceted. His advice was invaluable.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#38

I like tools from Brooklyn

Jim Matthews

Sellers have a canny sense of what really works, based on returns.

That's an insight few can dispute.

I think the legitimate complaint from Old Timers us that no one listened to them.

I think bloggers with sense take a gentle approach.

I'm a fan of one published in Brooklyn.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#39

Turnover, newbies and FAQ

Jim Matthews

Few stay with *any* hobby more than 18 months.

That implies fresh faces, asking the same questions - again.

Nobody reads the manual, or reviews the FAQ.

If you've been at this longer than a year or two, it must be frustrating to hear questions you've answered, repeated ad infinitum. If you're a regular contributor to a website which has survived so long you will inevitably be asked to repeat yourself.

The solution is to collect your thoughts in blog, website or printed form.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#40

Re: I like tools from Brooklyn


Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#41

comment on teaching

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you've been at this longer than a year or two, it must be frustrating to hear questions you've answered, repeated ad infinitum. Teachers enjoy teaching. I don't find this part of Forum life frustrating at all. Lots of people along the way have helped me and I feel some obligation to help others as I have been. Alf Sharp, one of the finest contemporary Period Furniture makers, voiced this same thought in response to a question someone asked him about. And it really is not that frequent a question is repeated.

WC provides for a place to record information that comes up with some frequency, the Articles. For example, questions about the production of hardwood lumber use to come up frequently. I gathered information on the production of hardwood lumber from forest to KD product and put it in the Articles. Now one can direct questions that can be answered there to this source.

The solution is to collect your thoughts in blog, website or printed form. The fact that you mention these possibilities means that these are possibilities from some. But I can't ever imagine myself doing any of them.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#42

Old history

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was not the one to bring up old history, Steve. Reread the opening post in this thread. The whole post was revisionist history. Perhaps it was designed to disguise the fact that Derek Cohen was on the wrong side of history. There were not a lot of people promoting heavy planes the way Derek was. It was not de rigueur.

There are about two thousand woodworking shops within 20 miles of my shop. And I'm not talking about retirees and hobbyists. I have never seen an infill plane in a professional shop, let alone one of the monsters like Derrick is talking about. One is more likely to see a #4 than a #4 1/2, more likely to see a standard Bailey than a Bedrock.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#43

Shops using mostly hand tools..

David Weaver

Warren, how many shops near you that build furniture generally do the majority of their work with hand tools?

I went to a Weaver furniture shop out your way (I'm not Mennonite, but my spouse - because of where she's from - has been asked more than once if she married a Mennonite) and the owner was probably 10 years older than me. He doesn't use any hand tools.

An amish cabinet maker up from the best man in my wedding and his brother - both making for a living, no hand tools. these guys are all doing making only and not repairing.

The shop owner with my same last name had a son who was beginning to experiment with hand tools, but he was using them to get a "rustic" look by planing against the grain to tear out wood.

I've not made a full case out of rosewood or macassar ebony (gabon planes easily), but jumping over to the australian forum where people are planing woods that are hickory and pecan and on up vs. what we're used to, there is definitely some case for these heavy planes there. The hitch is nobody is dimensioning those woods by hand on a regular basis. Neither would we.

If I wasn't dimensioning by hand, I wouldn't be woodworking, at least not beyond making guitars. I don't think anyone using jarrah or harder would be doing too much hand dimensioning, though, either. I don't mean planing a board here or there either (that often comes up on forums "i've planed ___ with ___ without issue, and mine cost $7), I mean dimensioning several hundred board feet per year with hand tools. Or more.

If those woods are less than perfect (knots, or even just poor mill sawing), they can knock the wedge loose on a typical 19th century double iron wooden plane.

When the dimensioning is done well by a machine, it's easy to see why people would like something like the heavy infill planes - they're not going to be using a plane long enough for the weight to be an issue.

The older infill panel planes were heavy. Why? I don't know. They can be made lightly - some of the earlier cast infill planes weigh about the same or less vs. a similar sized stanley (I've got a 2 1/2" wide cast panel plane that was very early with a wedge and brazilian rosewood that's 6 pounds to the norris A13s 8 1/2). Those were planes sold to professional users. The smoother infill planes were lighter than current infills - I could speculate on that, too. I'm guessing the panel planes were generally made for heavier work, and on the rare really hard wood, they are much easier to tolerate than a double iron wooden try plane.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#44

Misprint?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

two thousand woodworking shops within 20 miles of my shop.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#45

cultural thing...

David Weaver

..when you get over toward ephrata PA and north, south, east of it, there are one-man and "a few man" shops everywhere (many larger than that making chairs or kitchen cabinets).

At the consumer level (tables and chair sets for $1500, for example, or bar chairs for $300 each), there isn't much evidence of hand tool use.

If there are smaller shops catering to higher-end customers (repair, carving, restoration), I wouldn't be privy to those, but would be curious about how many of them are building furniture (for a living) using mostly hand tools.

FIL and I went through a few chair and table makers' shops, and there was definitely not a single hand cut dovetail in any of them, but in one of them, the proprietor (a mennonite fellow who sold only amish-made furniture - as in, he didn't make anything, just owned the shop) said something along the lines of one amish guy having an automated dovetailing setup and most of the drawers in his shop were made by that guy on one machine. He implied that the guy dovetailing the drawers made nothing but drawers - and the rest of the bits were made by another shop.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#46

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Misprint?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Not likely, Bill. Warren's in the middle of the largest Amish area in North America, and wood shops are everywhere. They make everything from baskets, to coffins, to outdoor furniture, to really fine, custom designed furniture.

Wife and I have cruised that area many times. Dozens/hundreds of quilt shops, too.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#47

Infills in the UK

david charlesworth

I find it interesting that serious cabinetmakers, in the UK, chose to equip themselves with heavy infill planes, for about a century. Norris, Spiers, Addis, Mathieson & sons, Melhuish, and many more.

It is also told that craftsmen in the 19th century would build their own infill planes, in their lunch times.

Now why would they do that?

Perhaps exotic hardwoods were used more over here?

Best wishes,

David

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#48

I'm glad you commented.

David Weaver

...I saw your comment on SMC but requested to have my login guested over there when they were repeatedly rotten to George Wilson.

you may notice what I wrote above. If you work with a lot of infills (I've had about 20 and built 6), you'll notice that the weight of the more common older infills (before norris went to adjusters, etc) was usually somewhere in the 3- 4 1/2 pound territory for a smoother. The smoothers were kept compact and relatively light compared to modern infill "cast iron ping pong paddles" as warren puts it.

It's hard to find solid data (this is the dovetailed type, not some of the less costly giant casted things like the plane 'o ayr).

I have an original 13 still and have sold off all of my other smoothers expect for a casted slater coffin style with a wedge. I'll weigh them later today, but recollection is that they're quite a bit heavier than the open handled norris, matheison and spiers planes that I've had (the lightest of which, the dovetailed spiers - was low mid 3 pounds). The 13 is a larger plane than the others, so the two that I have left may not be that representative of the finer dovetailed planes.

At the same time, almost all of the panel planes have been relatively heavy (and could've been made lighter if someone wished) like modern panel planes - except for one early casted 14 inch trying plane that's just over 6 pounds (it's not a cross to a stanley 4 despite the length - its' 2 1/2 inches of cutting width).

I suspect a great deal of why they were allowed to be so heavy (preferred?) is because they were used more as a trying/fitting plane after wood went through a machine and was sized elsewhere.

admittedly being not much of a reader, I've never read why those things are true - they're just what I've seen buying good planes (not strange contraptions) from norris, mathieson, slater and spiers, and excluding later planes that were made of beech (the later norris A1 that I had in 17 1/2 inch length was actually only a little over 7 pounds - 1 1/2 pounds lighter than a 15 inch or so #13 norris panel).

For a while, the tight mouth on older infills was used as an argument against using the cap iron. It turns out to be a false argument as unlike stanley, the older norris planes were very finely made inside the mouth with the wear of the sole sloping away to allow the cap iron to be set closely (and even with a mouth of a hundredth or so, they don't do a good job of eliminating tearout or staying in the cut without a cap iron unless everything is downgrain).

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#49

Note on a modern infill

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

Not all modern infills are extremely heavy. I weighed a Sauer & Steiner 2” steel/ebony A5 against a bronze LN4. Here are the planes:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/50062778392/in/dateposted-public/

The bronze LN4 with one of David’s irons aboard (thank you David!!) weighed in at 4lb. 12.9oz:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/50061967143/in/dateposted-public/

The Sauer & Steiner steel A5, with a 3/16” Elliott iron aboard (thank you Steve!!) weighed 4lb 15.3oz.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/50062524261/in/dateposted-public/

So this infill is 2.4 oz. heavier than the LN4. In practice, you don’t notice the weight difference, in part because the shape of the A5 (tapered nose) gives it a nice balance.

Wiley

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#50

konrad's planes...

David Weaver

..are made closer to the vintage patterns, of course (and they look wonderful). I'd guess his plane (with the thicker iron and slightly more substantial lever cap, etc) is probably 6 ounces heavier than a typical norris A5 (I had two of those, both were beech - there actually fairly light - if more than 4 pounds, I"d have been surprised, but they weren't good planes in later trim in beech, either, and required a lot of work just to be tolerable. Tolerable was all I could get out of them. The adjuster was coarse and tough to use, and adding tension to the lever cap increased cutting depth, so the lever cap would become a secondary adjuster of sorts and allow several thousandths of adjustment in shaving thickness.

I copied (buying the lever cap and iron from Ron) Ron Brese's pattern for a "sort of" norris #13 single iron. Same metal thickness that Ron uses and bois de rose (boy would I like to have that blank of wood back - didn't know what it was) infill for a 2" plane and it came out around 5 1/2 pounds. It's a very pleasant plane to use if you use it for what it's good at, but not very productive for more than finish smoothing.

It'd be great to see a huge spectrum of weights, but it's hard to find good information. The first time I was really alarmed about the weight of a plane, there was a small spiers dovetail smoother on ebay, and the seller said that it was 2 pounds 15 ounces. I passed on buying it as I feared it wouldn't be heavy enough to work well (open handled and dainty). On the other end of the spectrum was the loopy...can't remember the weight, but I think that plane was a ruse (at least at first).

CS lists darell hutchinson and holtey a13s at 5lbs 15 oz and 6 lbs 2 oz, respectively. Karl's 98 at a little over 4 pounds.

at 5 1/2 pounds, my #13ish copy does feel heavy at 2" of width and it would be awkward trimming small things.