Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Light vs Heavy planes

Posts

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#51

Re: I'm glad you commented.

joel moskowitz

I have actually done back to back tests of infill Norris's to compare performance. They work, sometimes great, sometimes not so great. However NONE of the famous furniture from England before 1800 or the US or France was made with metal planes. Sure there might have been an odd outlier here and there but except for marquetry, metal planes don't show up in the literature. Roubo thought metal planes were great and wondered why more weren't in use.

That all being said the indicator of performance is fit. Wooden planes have one serious flaw - in use they wear out. Infill planes have two serious flaws - weight on the long ones, and cost. I have tried using the longer Norris's for jointing and after 10 minutes I'm just tired. Also the higher center of gravity of wooden planes makes it easier to keep them square.

But it all works! It really does. My limitation is the limit of my skill not the tools. It's true that these days you can buy a plane shaped object that will never work properly. Or a Wooden Norris that is a collectible for a reason (they suck). Remember of course any Norris you have is at least 70 years old and might be worn out.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#52

what I've found...

David Weaver

I bought three beech norris planes early on. The panel plane was fine, but it was cheaply made. It wasn't better than a stanley plane, but it was expensive compared to one, and more interesting to look at, and someone had resurfaced the one I bought and passed it off as being pristine (casted) and never used. I got it from england and took my lumps on it. That kind of stuff is common among old tool dealers, but I don't like it. Some of the lacquer was worn heavily on the opposite side of the plane, but the seller didn't mention it. Their price was $300 higher than the going rate for a typical used plane and would've been fair if it was actually nearly unused.

At any rate, the two A5s were terrible. either the castings were never flat or they'd moved. I cleaned them up and flattened them and was glad to sell them (in good working condition) to people who wanted them.

the older planes, generally something needs to be done somewhere on them. It's just not likely that a plane made 100 years ago will go through 100 seasonal cycles and not have some kind of fit issue. I've been able to get all of those to be good performing planes, but only a couple would be deemed good out of the box. They often have adjustment personalities slightly different from each other so you have to build familiarity with them (little things all the way down to what part of the bed grips the wood better or the shape of the screw on the bottom of the lever cap will affect things). Some have replacement irons that are too snug laterally (probably due to the original irons being tapered in width), and many have lever caps (i had a norris 2 like this that now another person on here has) that just need to be used as they're a bit tight and slow.

I think that when all of those planes were made, they probably worked well and they were probably flat. I can say with my small sample of a dozen and a half or so that the planes with dovetailed bottoms and rosewood seem to be closer to flat (even when long out of use) than casted planes with beech.

As far as them being a good plane for a beginner to just buy off of ebay and expect to use and get a LN-esque feeling, the chance is probably about 1 in 15.

I have gotten good at fitting planes. What made me good at fitting and cleaning up older planes is making planes. That's not very practical, either. The same is true for old woodies. I can make nearly all of them (that are undamaged with original iron) perform about as well as any new premium wooden plane. But I couldn't do that before I made a bunch of wooden planes with the intent to make planes that work extremely well.

Same thing - not very practical, especially not as advice ("fitting your old plane to work well will be easy, just make 25 planes, and then come back to it")

One last bit that I've noticed with infills, especially panel planes. Those made of mild steel have more friction in use than those made with fairly coarse castings. I'm sure there are textbook coefficients of friction, and some may disagree, but practical use of these planes once they're flat will result in warm plane bottoms and a warm user. Same with the LN bronze. If you plane with it for a fairly long session, you'll be able to pull a paraffin block along the sole and the paraffin will melt slightly and clear up as it's going on the plane.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#53

Re: what I've found...

joel moskowitz

While I have several Beech infill norris's in my collection I have never seen a post war (beech) A5 that could plane a candle next to a pre-war Norris. I do have a 17 1/2" post war panel with a custom iron that is wonderful but I would guess that I like it because it is lighter than the rosewood version (which I never use) and a better performer than a similar length bedrock.

But again - this is my point - Everything works - And if you are planing stuff in 1800 you got a nice wooden smoother and when it wore out you replaced it.

It is possible to take just about any plane and make it perform better. That's why premium makers get to charge a premium. The amazing thing is that a bog standard Stanley from 1930 will perform very very well indeed. Sure 90 years later they might be wear and tear but unless the plane has been abused, or cleaned up too much it will work excellently. Is it possible to get better performance than a new 1930 stock stanley - sure - a stock bedrock from the period will work marginally better, and you will get much better performance especially with a dulling blade on with a #5,6, or 17 Norris or early 19th century wooden plane. But for most people it's just not that important. But the main difference in performance was fit and finish - which accounted for the price difference. And the second most important indicator in performance is becoming one with the plane. It takes time to learn how to you any tool to best advantage. The performance of my tools has actually gotten better over the years, not because they have magically increased or decreased in weight but because of practice.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#54

Re: Shops using mostly hand tools..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Weaver is a common name around here. If you start talking about David Weaver, you have to say which one.

There are lots of kinds of shops; restoration, reproduction, turning, carving, crates, trellises, chairs, cabinets, on and on. Also there is lots of cooperation between shops. Those that use hand planes don't seem to use infills. That is more something for collectors.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#55

Don felder's guitar...

David Weaver

...I wouldn't use an infill, either. Even in an even-up situation.

(separate and aside, your comment about cooperation between shops lends credence to the mennonite store owner suggesting that one guy was using a dovetail machine and making drawers or drawer boxes for some of his makers - maybe I shouldn't have been surprised by that).

At any rate, it reminds me of don felder (eagles guitarist), who had a favorite guitar that he refused to take on tour for a long time because he felt too much exposure and sooner or later it would get stolen. He was never satisfied with gibson's (judging by the way he manages to talk about how much more he likes his older guitar than their attempts at outfitting him with copies of the guitar made in their modern factory - in a promotional video for a music store to sell that modern copy, no less) attempts to make an equivalent guitar for him and now that he's older, he finally takes it out and leaves the copies in their cases.

I wouldn't be able to use my favorite infill plane (a norris 13) daily because it would get dropped sooner or later. I like it as much as a stanley and it's about as productive, but I'm sure I paid somewhere around $300 for it and once an infill plane's original wood is broken, that can never be changed. that doesn't make a lot of sense, but my relatives exhibit that behavior (and we have some amish bloodline from lancaster co - Habecker) - when you have something really nice, don't use it. Set it aside, stare at it, get something else to use.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#56

interesting that...

David Weaver

...your experience with the beech infill smoothers (no good) is similar to mine and at the same time, the panel plane (tolerable) is similar to mine - the lighter weight of mine made it OK to use. The thing that was subpar was the norris iron in it (which I think was stamped sorby on the back, as they must've been making those for norris). It was soft. Not close to the equal of the ward irons, but in heavier use, it doesn't matter quite as much.

I couldn't make the case that it's better than using a stanley 7, and so it was gone. I have other infill panel planes that are better, and nothing left with an adjuster.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#57

Weight Comparison

Steve Elliott

I just weighed two planes, a Stanley 604 from about 1920 and a Spiers round-sided smoother from about 1900.

The Stanley weighs 3 lbs 10 ounces and the Spiers weighs 3 lbs 14-1/2 ounces.

The blade on the Spiers is 2-1/8" wide so the slightly heavier plane also has a slightly wider blade. Both planes are well-balanced and good to use.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#58

more infill weights

David Weaver

* spiers panel - 2 1/2 wide, 13.75" long - 6 lbs, 14 oz

* Ironmonger casted panel - looks professionally made, but I think the casting was purchased from a hardware store - 2 3/8" wide (odd size), 14.25" long - 7 lbs, 3 oz

* Norris #13 panel - 15.5" long - 8 lbs, 8 oz, 2 1/2" wide

smoothers:

norris 13 - 2.25" wide - 4 lbs, 11 oz

slater coffin smoother - 2.25" wide - 4 lbs, 3 oz

all planes are rosewood infill

As a comparison, I also have a marples 4 1/2 sized plane. It seems heavier than the bailey types (subjective) and similar to bedrock (bedrocks being odd where some seemingly have no extra weight over bailey and others do - maybe it's an era thing)

marples 4 1/2 - 2 3/8" wide - 4 lbs, 14 oz

For anyone who has never shopped for planes in england, 4 1/2s are everywhere. Not uncommon to find a 4 1/2 on ebay there a couple of years ago for $30 equivalent (costs another $40 to ship one over here, though).

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#59

If you get my drift...

Jim Matthews

My last comment was directed at those who appear frustrated.

I'm with you, it wasn't long ago that I was so overwhelmed by competing voices that I couldn't figure where to start. This forum was invaluable when others degenerated into camps vying for recruits.

Sure would like it to stay that way - welcoming and useful.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#60

Re: more infill weights

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My two smoothers are 2 lb 14 oz and 3 lb.

A derelict 19th century beech smoother is 1 lb 9 oz

My memory was that the Marcou i tried in 2009 was 9 lbs, but looking at the current specifications on his website, it may have been 8 lbs, 6 oz.

I think for a hand tool worker it is more important to have lightweight jack and try planes; mine are 2 lb 12 oz and 5 lb 8 oz.

Here is one factor that greatly favors expensive planes: If a guy is having trouble using a Stanley Handyman that he bought for $11 he is likely to blame the tool. If he is having trouble with a $2000 tool, he is much more likely to realize that he has done a poor job sharpening or adjusting or whatever. The knowledge of where the problem lies is quite valuable.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#61

now there is a pearl of wisdom

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"If he is having trouble with a $2000 tool, he is much more likely to realize that he has done a poor job sharpening or adjusting or whatever. The knowledge of where the problem lies is quite valuable."

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#62

Re: more infill weights

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My memory was that the Marcou i tried in 2009 was 9 lbs, but looking at the current specifications on his website, it may have been 8 lbs, 6 oz.

I think for a hand tool worker it is more important to have lightweight jack and try planes; mine are 2 lb 12 oz and 5 lb 8 oz.

Here is one factor that greatly favors expensive planes: If a guy is having trouble using a Stanley Handyman that he bought for $11 he is likely to blame the tool. If he is having trouble with a $2000 tool, he is much more likely to realize that he has done a poor job sharpening or adjusting or whatever.

Warren, you are missing the point of my original post here. Either that, or I am misunderstanding yours (I doubt that).

I am not advocating a heavy plane. Indeed, I made the point that I prefer lighter smoothers.

It was interesting returning to the heavy planes on hard Australian wood (your mileage may vary here) after some years away. What was evident was that they performed extremely well, and effortlessly. The reason why they may be preferred by the less experienced is that they stay in the cut so well. One can get there with a well-sharpened blade and attention to feedback, but there is something to be learned here (that is, what is required to stay in the cut?).

It is not the us-versus-them situation I perceive you turning this thread into. You do recognise the issue with tuning, but can you discuss it without cynicism.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#63

Re: Calling BS

Steve Voigt

if you are planing stuff in 1800 you got a nice wooden smoother and when it wore out you replaced it.

Joel, I was going to let it go earlier when you said "wooden planes have one serious flaw--they wear out," but twice is too much.

Anyone buying a nice a nice wooden smoother in 1800 was buying a double iron plane. And that plane would not wear out in a lifetime, if properly taken care of. Yes, the mouth will open, but that doesn't matter if there's a cap iron.

Yes, we've all seen planes with half an inch taken off the sole--or more likely, 3/8 at one end and 5/8 at the other. Those planes were obviously not taken care of by serious craftsmen.

Who here has worn out a wooden plane without abusing it? Tell me and I'll stand corrected.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#64

initial fitting...

David Weaver

.going through the scenario I mentioned earlier - someone who has several million in their 401k and just wants to start with planing stuff may not care about a couple of hundred dollars for a wooden plane.

i like a try plane around 7 1/2 or 8 pounds and a jack plane around ....(have to measure it...the last 17" jack plane that I made is the one that I use - 4 lbs 14 oz.) I am fatter than you, though ( a little over 200 pounds).

When thought about building planes, I bought about 20 wooden planes, maybe more than that.

The variance in weight was surprising. I found quickly that I didn't like most wooden jointer planes (too heavy - one early lamb plane from new england was well over 10 pounds) and if they weren't heavy, they were often rough to use. I didn't get along with try planes if they were under about 7 pounds (too much communication) and like the jacks that are slightly longer (like a pattern that matheison made a lot of)

Here's the weights of the planes that I actually use (the infills, I use on occasion, but they're not lowest effort and I don't have any of the smaller lighter ones left because of the stanley below).

* later stanley 4 - normal thickness iron - 3 lbs 10 oz

* greaves try plane, 22 inches - 2.5 wide - 7 lbs 14 oz

* my jack as mentioned above - 4 lbs 14, it's 2 1/8th width, 17" long - my favorite pattern of all that I've tried

I have two try planes left of my own make (you've mentioned they're long enough to be referred to as long planes - both just under 8 pounds, 24" long. I would use either or the greaves - just have 3)

I haven't yet found a coffin plane that I care for, so I don't use them. Too light for quick work and I think most professional users would replace them with a stanley plane if they work more than agreeable softwoods. it's misleading to say "yet". I don't like them, it's not going to change.

There's on exception to that, I have a house-made cocobolo smoothing coffin plane that's 2 1/4" for the iron and it's 4 pounds 4 oz. It is excellent for pre-final work or early work on sticking. I made it, didn't like it at first (the iron isn't really good enough for smoothing work, but it's fine for heavier work), and found a use for it later. It's dandy to set where most people would set a try plane (e.g., 5-6 thousandths on cherry) to run the ripples off of machine planed wood, too.

There is no need for all of these planes, but I have them, so I use them. I've made and refinished several beech coffin smoothers from around 1 3/4 to 2 1/4, they just don't quite have enough density to make up for their small size. I made another in purpleheart just under 2" and inentionally mortised the mouth so that it could get an insert (to have a negative wear), and it's better than a traditional design with a single wear and heavy enough to feel and work like a stanley 4, but there's no incentive for me to use it over a stanley 4 as it's only as good. I don't like the aesthetic of exotic smoothers, either - that's a personal bias, but making those planes confirmed what it is I don't like about beech smoothers.

I can refit just about any old plane in less than an hour, iron and all - but there's no incentive to do it. I have offered once in a while when someone says they want a turn key wooden plane, but people see old wooden planes for $50 and I guess they'd rather buy a fully made wooden plane for $450 than potentially spend $100 getting a wooden plane and sending it to me and paying to have it mailed back. I suppose there's some suspicion that an old plane could be as good as a new one if the fitting is done properly ...whatever, it's not really my concern when people don't think my advice is credible. it becomes a waste of time feeling out who is actually looking to woodwork and who is just looking to buy a plane that they fancy based on pictures online.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#65

I haven't seen it....

David Weaver

...in my use, but I've seen abused planes just as Joel has (and you have) that may give someone the notion that a completely worn out plane is normal.

I'd imagine that anything worn out either planed dirty wood (or wood with foreign objects in it) and was intentionally abused, or was used for a single task and due to the low cost, abused when it was trued (as in belt sanded or run across a power jointer).

I've got one try plane that has probably trued about 750 board feet of cherry, beech, walnut, rosewood and mahogany. I've trued the sole once (how much, I don't know - the thickness of a sheet of paper or two) as the only thing that I can find that actually puts fast wear on a wooden plane is dedicating one to jointing a whole bunch of rough lumber with no other use (they'll wear hollow in the center).

More common to find a used plane with a spent iron or a replacement.

The treatment and constant tuning of japanese planes makes the relationship go the other way (n bodies per iron and n irons per body in western are probably not that different of an n)

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#66

one more follow-up comment.

David Weaver

I don't need any more planes and have sold off a bunch in the last two years.

I've fancied rosewood jack planes, but the boat builders planes are often pretty ugly to start and beaten heavily.

Rosewood billets are cheap right now and the cost to make planes out of it is actually the same or less than horizon's quartered beech. The density of plantation rosewood is not that high, only slightly heavier than beech. It can be more musical, but so can cocobolo, and the cocobolo plane in the prior post is a treat to use if it's set heavy. Less abusive than a beech plane of the same thing.

I've had these two billets for a while, they're not straight enough for any parts on a guitar (visually), but the back one is pretty good. The front one is terrible, but I"ll keep that one for me and throw it away if it moves around.


(for what it's worth, the English planes that I've gotten have all been somewhere around my preferred weight range, with the jacks maybe slightly lighter. once in a while, I get a plane that someone must've intentionally filled over and over with linseed oil - they must've had a want, but I don't know what it was. One of the mid-length planes that I got early on had a hancock iron - I think it was an american plane - and was 9 1/2 pounds at 20 inches long. Horrible)

My distaste for coffin smoothers isn't shared (more than one person has told me how much they love them), it's just a personal opinion. I much prefer the infill coffin planes to the wooden ones.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#67

Re: Calling BS

joelmoskowitz

It's in the literature. If you actually use a plane to dress wood you will ear it out and what was done is the newest planes were used for final jointing and smoothing, as they wore they were demoted to lesser tasks. I will look it might be in Joiner and Cabinetmaker but I might be wrong.

BTW if you are wondering why it is pretty easy to find late 18th century molding and special planes but late 18th century wooden smooth planes are very rare - it's because the most used planes wore out.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#68

Re: I haven't seen it....

joelmoskowitz

In "London Labor and the London Poor" Henry Mayhew interviews cabinetmakers and one important number was wear and tear on tools. - mostly saws but everything. 750 board feet of wood is nothing for someone who does this for a living in 1800 and even you decided to true up the sole once. Multiply that wear ten fold over 5 or 10 years.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#69

Re: I haven't seen it....

Winston

> The treatment and constant tuning of japanese planes makes the relationship go the other way (n bodies per iron and n irons per body in western are probably not that different of an n)

Why is it that Japanese planes need to be tuned so much more than a western wooden plane?

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#70

Rafael from PA

Re: one more follow-up comment.

Rafael from PA

David, where do you source your rosewood billets?

R

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#71

Re: I haven't seen it....

David Weaver

I agree on the wood quantity - my point is two-fold:

1) I have no idea at what point I'd see wear on a plane body, but an unstable plane that needed a lot of seasonal adjustment would wear faster due to the adjusting, and harsh adjusting would probably wear the plane faster.

I'm sure that both of those happened in history.

2) in context of a current buyer. If there are many people who have dimensioned 750 board feet of lumber from start to finish by hand, and they're buying premium planes, I'd be surprised.

It took less than 100 board feet for me to figure out why single iron planes are worthless in anything other than ideal lumber (for work prior to smoothing). If I were to extrapolate a guess - who knows...50k board feet?

The wear on planes is likely due to something other than planing the face of clean wood. For anyone working now, dropping or seasonal truing by power jointer are the only likely wear concerns.

I have no idea if the planes (as you mentioned) were handed down from one person to the next.

I don't have trouble believing that a steady worker would wear several irons out, though. I think I've seen warren mention that he's several irons in to each of his planes.

Double iron planes will generally need far less adjustment than single iron planes because the cut and quality of it are regulated by the iron more than the plane body.

Interestingly, my no 13 has good wood in it (no real issues, no dropping, breaking off of horns, etc), but the iron in it is a replacement and was worn in a skew direction, leading me to believe that someone was using it for a lot of edge jointing work, and maybe not in clean wood. It's cast iron, obviously. Of all of the infills I've had, it's the the only one that had more than just a little bit of sole wear.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#72

Truing Kanna

Jim Matthews

Japanese planes aren't just flat.

They have two (or three) contact points that must be in a plane with the exposed blade.

This requires removing the equivalent thickness of fine rice paper between the contact points.

Japan is almost entirely coastal and subject to Seasonal humidity changes. While air conditioning might help reduce the moisture content in the wood body, heating season will cause the opposite problem.

These Seasonal differences are exaggerated by the adjustment of the sole. It's *a lot* of fuss, but worthwhile in some applications.

I suppose the greater cross section of Western style planes resists twist and cupping, to some degree, but that's above my pay grade.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/08/11/kanna-dai-prep/

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#73

Re: Facts, not assertions

Steve Voigt

It's in the literature.

Where?

If you actually use a plane to dress wood you will [w]ear it out…

I do use plane to "dress" (i.e. dimension) wood, every single day. I don't retail tools for a living; I make them for a living.

…and what was done is the newest planes were used for final jointing and smoothing, as they wore they were demoted to lesser tasks.

I would love to see a period reference for this claim; I have never seen it except for 20th century writers, mostly bloggers and forum keyboard warriors. On its face, it doesn't make much sense: plane tasks are specific to size. I can't imagine roughing out parts with a worn out smoother--I would use a jack plane.

On the other hand, I have seen multiple period references that suggest using a single iron jack to scrub off the rough surface, dirt, and grit before dimensioning with double iron planes. I can provide quotes and citations if anyone is interested.

BTW if you are wondering why it is pretty easy to find late 18th century molding and special planes but late 18th century wooden smooth planes are very rare - it's because the most used planes wore out.

You are talking 250 years ago. Yes, smoothing planes will eventually wear out over several lifetimes. I might even wear mine out in one. A try plane will wear out faster, and a jack will wear out faster still.I was specifically rebutting your claim that smoothing plane would require frequent replacement, which is simply not true.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#74

Re: Calling BS

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think four people have criticized me for being negative, just in this thread. I noticed this stuff just as you did, Steve, but as you can see it is awfully tough to keep quiet.

If you actually use a plane to dress wood you will [w]ear it out

You have to be careful about making statements like this when there are people around with experience. I have used the same jack plane since 1978 and try plane since 1979 and used them hard since I have no machinery. I have worn out plane irons, but not planes. I may replace the jack plane. When I made it 42 years ago I was just going from pictures and memory of what the escapement looked like, so some things are a bit clumsy. But not worn out.

Re: Light vs Heavy planes

#75

Re: I haven't seen it....

joelmoskowitz

I would certainly agree that the wear and tear on a wooden plane is minimal for an amateur and minimal for anyone using a power jointer and planer. I quite like single iron wooden planes and while fussier than my metal body planes they have a great feel. And of course in my life time the only was I would wear one out is by excessive, ignorant, and possible unnecessary constant re-tuning of the sole.

What I like about my Norris A5 is that it is extremely forgiving on tricky wood.

But this is my basic point - from a function difference for different planing technologies there is no important difference. Everything works. The more experience you have the more consistently great results you will have. There is no practical difference in performance due to weight. That being said we all have personal preferences, light vs heavy, old vs new, wood vs metal, Japanese versus English, etc.

Let me rephrase this another way. I doubt anyone would argue that a sharp iron works better than a dull iron. This is accepted as fact. I also would argue that there are so many exceptions to the case for a heavy plane vs a light plane that making a general rule that would be accepted as fact is impossible.