Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

washita and XHP

Posts

washita and XHP

#1

washita and XHP

David Weaver

XHP, V11 - whatever you want to call it.

I am still using my XHP mule (the test iron that I made) as I don't have any other good ones made yet for my smoother. It's probably the worst decent one that I made (it being the one that planed 4050 feet to my 2200 foot total for my best O1 iron).

I got 5 washitas in the last 3 weeks. I guess that won't stop until I stop looking. The person I bought them from is wired a little bit like me and he knocked the tops off of the face of the stone and then lapped them flat, so they're fresh and a little aggressive.

XHP and a washita as a finish stone are almost a match made in heaven. Everything that A2 does wrong with a washita, XHP doesn't. Since XHP is abraded half as fast, it's abraded less deeply and the iron takes a finer edge and then moves through a cut better than my O1 iron.

All that's needed is some minimal stropping to remove a wire edge, and I"m not really sure that's even necessary. The picture below is a view down the length of a plane body for a jack plane - beech, and this is the sized blank. It's not finish planed, but rather sized only.

despite the phone's best effort to eliminate glare, you can still see about 1/4th of the reflectiveness that I see in person. All on a stone that has not settled in and is cutting aggressively (it raises a wire edge on XHP easily).


I've begun to strop my irons on the corners of the cotton buff wheel, too (those being the clean soft cotton that has no real spine or abrasive in it). I'm going to take pictures of the stropped edge vs. bare bovine leather, but I believe the quality of the strop (cleanliness of the edge with less being torn off with the wire edge) is better. These are not material things, but the buffing wheel never gets contaminated and I need to do nothing to care for it. It's just there.

Re: washita and XHP

#2

Lemme get this straight...

Jim Matthews

You got this level of finish on a tool?

Epic

Re: washita and XHP

#3

Just sizing the blank...

David Weaver

..Over time, I've learned that it's easier to near finish the blank on a plane and then do all of the work to it than it is to leave it oversized (to leave wood that can take a dent, etc, and then be planed off) and then plane everything to width at the end.

That's just the finish that comes out of getting the plane squared accurately. The utility edge" off of a new-to-me washita that's not yet settled in. It's just a good match to xhp.

Re: washita and XHP

#4

Re: washita and XHP

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

Very nice surface, to say the least!

I am enjoying your XHP iron (thank you), which lives in an LN4, and cannot detect a difference from PM V11. Which is a compliment. I still like the DMT 8000g diamond plate for XHP and all alloy blades. Then strop with 0.5u green.

Question: Is there a source for XHP in the range of 0.12-0.15“ thickness? Like, for infills?

For the Carpenter steel obsessed.....Veritas carries a 2-3/8” wide PM V11 iron for one of its own planes—this iron is 0.125” thick and can be made to work on an LN5.5 (and I suppose, 4.5, 6, 7) provided you grind about 3 thousandths off the slot to widen it in the vicinity where the lateral-adjust circular fitting engages the slot. I did the grinding, which wasn’t easy, using a carbide tile blade in a Fein multitool. Didn’t try to dull a file on the hardened steel.

The Veritas PM V11 irons for Stanley/Record (0.10” thick) work fine. They have that smooth feeling in the wood that you described in your studies. They will sharpen readily on anything after being ground to a new burr, but for repeated sharpening as the flats grow I shift to the DMT 8000 plate.

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#5

Re: washita and XHP

David Weaver

They do make the steel in various thicknesses, but the only things available on their web store are .1 thickness and .094 decarb.

As far as honing it, I have to remind myself that it will get notched more in rough lumber just because it lasts longer, and then be mindful that it hones for burr raising slower. After that, its behavior in light honing is great.

I've never seen anything else take as bright of a polish off of various middle stones.

I'd like to see lv make a cap iron with it at saw temper.

Re: washita and XHP

#6

Re: washita and XHP

Wiley Horne

David,

Why the PM cap iron? Not arguing, just don’t get it. Do you know: What is the spec, if any, on cap irons?

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#7

Re: washita and XHP

William Duffield

There are other plane surfaces other than the cutting edge of the iron that are subject to wear due to constant kinetic contact with the wood, where that wear can easily result in degradation of the resulting wood surface. Specifically, for bevel up planes, thatinterface is the lower front edge of the mouth. For bevel down planes, it is the leading surface of the chip breaker.The more they wear, the farther the plane's performance deviates from how the user tuned the plane to perform.

Re: washita and XHP

#8

OK.  Thanks.


Re: washita and XHP

#9

Re: washita and XHP

Joe shelton

Dammit! DMT has an 8K grit?

Before I go back and find that grit chart, is that what they call XX Fine?

Re: washita and XHP

#10

D8EE

Wiley Horne

Hi Joe,

As you say, DMT makes a zillion products. This one is,

DMT D8EE 8" Dia-Sharp Extra-Extra-Fine Diamond Bench Stone

The key indicator is D8EE. I see the price is up to the low $90’s. It’s 8” x 3”.

I use with water, because I have a spray bottle nearby for Japanese stones, but any cutting fluid would do. After cutting the diamonds off a few DMT plates, maybe due to heavy hand, I have learned to use some sort of lubricant.

It’s quite aggressive initially, then settles into not-so-brash cutting. I’ve used mine steadily since Jan. 2018, and it’s doing well.

I seem to recall Bill T. saying that the carving instructor Mary May uses it for her gouges and that prompted me to get one—maybe I’m misremembering what Bill wrote...But for me it’s been money good. Primarily for alloy such as A2, PMV11, 3V, M2—how did I acquire all that menagerie??? It’s a little embarrassing...

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#11

slickness of the chromium

David Weaver

..you're right to question that as I don't have much wear on any cap iron and the only planes I've seen with the cap worn through also had a pronounced groove in the sole (as if someone was using them to joint very dirty wood, over and over).

But the steel is very slick, and I suppose it could be seen as a trap for LV (but it's not!) in that they'd admit the practical use of the cap iron. I'm fairly sure that the shaving contact with the cap would have less friction, though.

Could also be done with a simpler stainless steel like regular process 440c.

Re: washita and XHP

#12

Re: D8EE

Joe shelton

Thanks, Wiley.

As to embarrassment, all I can say is I want to be like you if I ever grow up.

Re: washita and XHP

#13

Veritas and the chipbreaker

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

But the steel is very slick, and I suppose it could be seen as a trap for LV (but it's not!) in that they'd admit the practical use of the cap iron. ....

David, that is a rather - I hate to say - biased viewpoint.

I am not a representative for Veritas but, as many are aware, I have been privy to the development of many of their hand planes and field tested them for a long time.

I visited the Lee Valley factory in Ottawa in January 2013. This was a time when the chipbreaker discussions were hotting up on the forums. The Custom planes were in development from 2011, and evolved slowly. The plane was originally intended as a single iron, bevel down smoother with a choice of frogs to alter the cutting angle. I played with one. Jump to the production version in September 2014. It was now a double iron plane. There was still a choice of frog angles, but you must ask yourself, "why, if the chipbreaker was not meaningful would they have gone to the trouble of designing it in?". It certainly would have been a whole bunch cheaper to have left it out.

To be fair to you, I have seen precious few - if any (other than my own) - articles or videos reporting this area, that is, how well the Custom plane performs with the chipbreaker closed up. In my memory, all demonstrations of Veritas planes, such as those by Vic Tesolin who is their woodworking technical advisor, appear only to use the bevel up planes. Vic just likes BU planes and gravitates to them. Likely, this creates a skewed picture of the Veritas position. I am certain that Rob is reading along and will comment.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: washita and XHP

#14

Re: Veritas and the chipbreaker

David Weaver

Derek, who convinced LV to put the chipbreaker on that plane?

I was able to test one of the early ones and it worked fine, but not as early as yours. There was a cap iron on it, and it was a well-made piece of gear. The only thing I wished is that the mouth was forward further.

I floated this idea out there because if anyone would ever actually manage to bring a stainless cap iron to market, it would be Rob's group. I wouldn't aim this at LN - they couldn't get it done until after the 6th mass extinction event.

I tried to dimension a maple countertop with a friend years ago with a couple of BU planes. It was agonizing, but I hadn't dimensioned wood before and we followed the tricks suggested to make cuts easier at that time (lower angle, wax, etc). Each of us had to take turns while the other recovered. I think may planed less than a kilogram.

I hold Rob in the highest regard. He's a leader, and in my opinion, a good one. Sometimes when you're a leader, you have to let people under you do their job and take the advice that they give you and run with it. I think he's getting bad advice, and I don't think it's intentional (as some may), nor do I think they're protecting a product line.

What I posted was my honest thought, not snark. First, that I'd like to see them make a cap iron (they come to mind because they actually do things in a reasonable amount of time and they do real development), and second, it popped into my head that due to advice that they'd receive internally, it may be difficult to get a cap iron like that made and then explain why it's important as it may offend some people internally to suggest that it may have some practical gain for stopping tearout (not the cap iron itself, but a stainless cap iron).

If LV doesn't test steels and select what is probably XHP, we're not even having this discussion and I'm not making irons out of XHP (which has been great fun).

Sometimes I push peoples' buttons so that they'll actually give their honest opinion, but this time, the thought of how to get conveying the usefulness of a slick cap iron past an advisory group that obviously doesn't like the idea of learning how to use one and then teaching people to do it is just a practical question.

Re: washita and XHP

#15

smooth action...

David Weaver

The usefulness of chromium brings another thing to mind.

When I started shaving with a straight razor, DE blades were (and probably still are) a popular thing. I never caught on with them. As I've overbought stones, once in a while, someone will throw in a vintage DE sharpening gadget (glass, ceramic, whatever they may be. They're just little round shapes intended to align the edge, but the common thought on razor forums was that they don't work well.

I also admired the condition of the edge of some of the (new, not honed with the contraption above) DE blades as they made for pretty photographs. I don't know what they did to hone them, but later learned that they're coated some kind of chromium stuff. Knowing what I know now, I'd suspect that the "stuff" has as much to do with lowering resistance as it does rust resistance. Maybe it allows for a less refined honing process - not sure.

But that was confirmed when Dorco had "how it's made" do a spot in their factory, and they mentioned the use of chromium to decrease resistance on a shaver's face. Chromium carbides are something like 65-70rc, i believe. Plenty hard for wood and face, maybe not so great in metalworking tools. Decreasing resistance allows for a blade to feel sharper than it is, and it allows for a dulling blade to feel sharper than it is, and I'm sure that some is skin rubbing and some is actually cutting through hairs.

When I did the endgrain test, I came out with the LV iron getting about 10% more footage than O1, but O1 had more cut resistance and I may have pushed it a little further waiting for it to "fall off the cliff" - which it turns out, doesn't happen with end grain like it does with edge grain. The difference is probably a little more like 25%. But even in that test, where the V11 didn't fare as well as the consistent 2 to 1 ratio that it had in long grain, it was easier to push.

I'm sure that I've seen a chrome plated cap iron, but when I have, it's been relatively crudely finished under the chromium.

maybe I will purchase some 440c and make a lightly sprung type, heat treat it to saw temper (which would probably be hard with XHP, as it's still something like 58rc at 800 degrees F temper).

Re: washita and XHP

#16

Re: Veritas and the chipbreaker

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, who convinced LV to put the chipbreaker on that plane?

I was able to test one of the early ones and it worked fine, but not as early as yours. There was a cap iron on it, and it was a well-made piece of gear. The only thing I wished is that the mouth was forward further.

David, I suspect that it was Rob who decided that the Custom plane needed a chipbreaker. While there are advisers and a design team, he is very capable of understanding these factors. I have sat in on design meeting and Rob is very astute. Don't underestimate his knowledge. And don't forget, it was a hot topic all over the forums, and Rob both reads and contributes on all of them.

With regards the chipbreaker design, I have reviewed and discussed the Veritas design for the Stanley plane and the Custom plane. I preferred it to the Stanley chipbreakers I have had, which I find too springy to easily hold a setting when tightened. At the same time, I would like a little more spring in their chipbreakers, and add this in myself. Nevertheless, they work very well out of the box (along with a higher leading edge angle, as with every make outside of Stanley - I really do not understand why all makers have not increased this by now?). Interesting that you liked the Veritas chipbreaker. I came in for flack for saying it was good.

I agree with you that a wear resistant chipbreaker would be an upgrade. It is easy enough to polish a leading edge, but some of the woods I use are quite high in resins, and they likely gum up more quickly with less slippery surfaces.

The increased toe area has long been a feature of Veritas planes. Personally, I like the extra registration. It makes for greater stability when entering a board.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: washita and XHP

#17

Let's test your theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would not risk this statement with most here on WC, but you have a research data driven mind not easily offended by a hypothesis challenge. I don't believe stainless steel has a lower coefficient of friction on wood than carbon steel. I have no data to support my position.

I will have to look up how a coefficient of friction is measured but I think it can be, easily. (was just reading this chapter on doing friction calculations in a physics book, but no mention of how the coefficient was measured. )

In principle, force to move an object at constant velocity can be used to calculate the sliding coefficient of friction. Area of the object is not a variable so any piece of steel, two plane blades for example, could be test samples. Or, proportional to the sliding value, force to initiate movement can be measured to calculate static coefficient of friction.

Keys, of cap iron fame, is just the person to do the experiment. He has load cells. I'll contact him, presuming he has not tumbled to his death mountain climbing. K&K had a load cell on the machine and measured total cutting force, but cap iron composition was never a variable. They have an extensive paper on cap iron wear profiles as a function of cap iron variables.

Re: washita and XHP

#18

Wear resistance vs. cut resistance

David Weaver

I've never put appreciable wear on any cap iron. As mentioned earlier, I've only seen on abused planes - notably, the first stanley 8 that I got on ebay had the cap iron worn through, but there was a prominent diagonal groove in the plane and gigantic mouth erosion that I've never seen since. It was being used in some unusual way.

The slickness of the chromium (rather than its wear resistance) is what I'm after. I speculated on hardness because I don't know if that same slickness is there with annealed stock.

Yes, I gather that Rob is capable - you're misunderstanding what I meant by leadership. When you're a leader, it isn't always just making the decisions you feel are best based on what you see around you (your lens may be different than those advising). You have more than one stakeholder to consider - the customers, the ownership (no clue about the structure there of that and it doesn't matter), and the internal advisors.

A good leader will consider the latter, especially if there is reciprocal loyalty. Sometimes, you have to step back a little bit and allow people to perform their roles. If you can't do that, the cost may be advisors who decide that they'll make less effort because their work will be overruled, anyway.

I don't know what the real deciding factor is there (or was in this case), just making note that decisions as leadership are a little more complicated than ignoring every other factor and just picking your favorite answer each time.

I worked for an incompetent leader at a prior job. He was a competent doer, but his version of leadership involved convincing everyone else why his conclusions were better than others'. Micromanagement of decisions that should've been left to others led to turnover (10 times in a row, you're charged with spending significant time coming up with a strategy and it gets tossed - sometimes not for the better) as well as a change in morale where folks a level or two under just waited for him to say what he wanted everyone to do because they felt like their work would be stuffed aside, anyway.

I get the sense from Rob's demeanor that he's a much better leader than that.

Re: washita and XHP

#19

Re: Let's test your theory

David Weaver

For K&K, I don't think something that may amount to a 10-15% change in force would've been a big deal. Making the cap iron out of plain steel would've been fine - just turn up the power on the machine.

Historically, it wouldn't have been an option.

Kees may be able to start with a specific cut weighing shavings as I did, using the same cap iron but a V11 iron vs. carbon steel, and see which iron has a greater amount of total force. I'm less clear about just how much of the force on a cap iron is due to friction (vs. the bevel and underside of a cut) - if it was an incredible amount due to friction, then maybe there'd be more wear on cap irons.

It's something I'm curious about, but don't know if it would amount to anything. I mentioned saw temper because there's no way to know if the chromium in the steel would make the same difference in unhardened steel (but I will say that when you hand file XHP - "man mill" is the only way to size steel here with any accuracy - you can feel the slickness of the chromium in it).

On the irons (not the cap irons), the difference in the testing rotation is so stark that I'd conclude something was off about the testing if a machine didn't find V11 to have less cut resistance than other steels. When I tested irons, two stood out with extra cut resistance - 3V and M4 -M4 had the most. I don't know that it's something that would be noticed in isolation, but it's easily noticed in comparison when you're making the irons do an identical task (weighing the wood and such so that you don't just adjust the plane to a slightly thinner shaving to equalize the feel). M4 wore the longest but the resistance was really something.

The second iteration of the test was partially due to that - the extra resistance from the 3V made me wonder if I hadn't sharpened it properly. The addition of the m4 and a subsequent test just made it clear that it's a difference between steels (the same concern existed in the opposite direction for v11 - did I somehow do a better job sharpening it?). I think the answer is no. I think the chromium being dispersed in tiny bits evenly just makes it slicker in the cut. The other concern with 3V was whether or not the different plane was creating the feel issue (every other iron had the identical plane and cap iron to eliminate any variation), so phil offering up the m4 iron was invaluable. Not to mention, it settled the question of whether or not there is something that would outlast V11/XHP. There may be cases in rougher work where it separates itself more, but it's hard to test those things, and I don't think most people use planes for serious trying/jointing work on rough wood (in subsequent use, I suspect that the gap between XHP and O1 is narrowed some in rough work due to the beating that an edge takes in whatever settles on rough lumber and intermittent cuts).

A metallurgist familiar with friction from soft cut media may know the answer to this, just as you found (after much trouble) a metallurgist who was not surprised that small chromium carbides would be well matched to wood whereas big vanadium carbides may be a better it for wear in metal on metal surfaces (correct that if I butchered it).

Re: washita and XHP

#20

early data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your hypothesis is, in summary, the coefficient of friction of stainless steel on wood is less than carbon steel on wood. Hence, a stainless steel cap iron might be beneficial for lowering planing resistance.

The experiment does not need to be complicated by cut resistance. We only need to measure static or sliding coefficient of friction. A quick literature search turned up several papers on measuring the coefficient of friction of wood on steel, but the variables were all wood variables and no steel variables. I'll keep looking.

However, it was found that the source of the friction was primarily hydrogen bonding, leading to adhesion, between wood and the oxide surface of steel. Anything that mucked up this bonding, lowered and in cases substantially lowered, the friction. (wax on a plane sole comes to mind) In these studies it was fatty acid components of wood . )

The oxide surface of stainless steel will be different from carbon steel. Enough different to be detected by overall cutting force to push the plane? Keep in mind that the total cutting force is the plane sole plus the blade plus the cap iron. It will take a substantial difference in coefficient of friction at the cap iron surface to be felt.

If this was Myth Busters I would say at this point, "plausible", but needs an experiment to confirm or deny.

BTW, moisture content and grain orientation were large variables in coefficient of friction of wood on steel. Deformation was not much a factor on dry wood.

Re: washita and XHP

#21

Re: Let's test your theory

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I remember reading a blog where the fellow said that a cap iron needed to be sharpened about every three years. The odd thing was that he had not yet been using a cap iron for three years. I also went to a lecture at WIA 2011 where another guy said the cap iron needed to be sharpened every time you sharpened the iron.

I believe one of my cap irons was untouched since 1977. Since I am a woodworker who planes wood by hand and have only five planes, this cap iron has seen a lot of volume. It appeared polished, but under a strong loupe there was minor pitting and scratches. I polished it this morning.

I sent Bill Tindall an email in 2007 suggesting that polishing a cap iron was quite helpful. Polishing ought to be more important than the type of steel used.

Re: washita and XHP

#22

Re: early data

David Weaver

plausible but needs testing - that's exactly where I am with it. I use a smoother with XHP now for all finish planing. I use a cocobolo plane with an older iron for penultimate work (illustrating your point - the IH sorby iron probably only lasts 1/3rd of the time wear-wise vs. XHP/V11, but the plane so much better at taking a shaving that it doesn't matter - it's less work overall to use for penultimate work. I set it aside because initial use for fine smoothing found the iron not to have a particularly good edge life, later finding that it excels if the shaving is just a bit thicker.

https://i.imgur.com/FDWoPOG.jpg

Still use a try plane for all but the worst wood for something finer than tuning door rail thickness or width, too - the superiority of the plane design threw me early on because I can size more beech blank in one sharpening with a relatively hard (for the brand) butcher iron in a wooden try plane than I can with any metal plane no matter what the iron is.

At any rate, back to the subject - the thing I'm curious about for kees is that I can feel the difference in planing resistance with the iron, so i would be curious given all of the other variables if kees could establish the measurable difference that I can feel. I am annoyed by small differences in feel (pencil leads that don't write nicely, shirt tags, chairs with design problems) - easily distracted. But I'm certain that in a plane properly used, there's less effort planing with V11. If kees can measure that, then maybe there would be less effort with the iron and the cap being the same material.

I can test that, too. But, I'll have to make the cap. I wouldn't want to trouble kees with trying to find differences in materials that I haven't found that I can feel.

Re: washita and XHP

#23

polishing

David Weaver

It's been a long time since I polished a cap iron vs. not polishing one, just because the front edges of them can be easily polished without geometric change with a deburring wheel and a grinder.

I think there are several potential benefits to it, but having no problems with plane function since starting that, I haven't looked any further.

I think (leaning toward know) geometry of the cap iron will have a bigger effect than stainless, and probably polish as much as stainless vs. not. All of my cap irons are set up identically, so all of those variables are already out.

I am about to make my second video regarding the test results from long grain planing of clean wood - the V11 planes double the footage in a test like that of O1 (and the O1 iron planed about 30% more than my favorite ward iron). It's true that the V11 planes longer, but it's also true that the gain in use is far smaller (time, ease, effort) than mastering sharpening quickly and setting up a plane properly (And using the same type in the first place).

This is way on the fringes of my curiosity because the other things are pretty much settled.

As for wear, I don't see anything suggesting wear on any of my planes - and the smoother, at least, is the same smoother all the time. The planes that I received with damage to the cap iron in the center we being abused somehow. Maybe even stuck in a fixture in a shop or used to plane something other than wood.

When the K&K videos came out, a whole bunch of posters had all kinds of ideas about things they'd need to do, the cap needs to be hardened etc (not for wear in my guesses here, but to preserve the slickness - it's just a variable), we need to come up with honing regimens for it. It's possible that K&K managed to wear a chipbreaker on their planing robot, but Bill has mentioned before that they are dealing with far more than we'd put on a plane, and the planed blades for kilometers that we'd have found dull at a small fraction of that - the machine allowed pushing far past what can be done by hand.

I had thought about sending you an XHP blade earlier on, one that would fit a stanley 3, but decided against it because it really only makes sense with media that can grind it appropriately fast (power grinding being the most sensible). I think you would like its final edge-taking characteristics (and especially, the bright finish it leaves on wood), but the rest of the stuff before that may not be so desirable. I also think in anything less than clean wood (knots, anomalies, dirt, interrupted cuts) it doesn't enjoy the same edge life superiority (and have stuck with wooden planes for penultimate work) - it probably lasts longer, but it takes more time to get it back to damage free than carbon steel.

Re: washita and XHP

#24

Interesting ....

Raymond in Trenton NJ

I don't have a dog in this discussion. But being a former T&E guy, I like the hypothesis and attention to details to attempt to prove it, or at least put it to a legitimate test.

So to clear it up in my head:

You are hypothesizing that the frictional forces are different for (a given wood’s) shaving across cap irons of different metals.

Based on the discussion in the other posts of this thread, are you also hypothesizing that this frictional force is transferred through the shaving to the cutting edge as a reacting force to planning? Am I just inferring this, or were the discussions more about ‘wearing out a cap iron’ and not so much to ‘having to push’ (or pull :o) harder when in the cut?

Interesting ideas, interesting conversation, interesting experiments. I’m staying tuned ….

Regards,

Raymond

Re: washita and XHP

#25

Re: Interesting ....

David Weaver

There's two parts - I hope I"m not speaking out of turn and missed something in bill's response.

There's certainly an area of wear and friction that occurs when the cap iron holds the shaving against the iron. https://i.imgur.com/J2OMH4M.jpg

This is the back of an iron (the flat bit) and you can see a dark line, which is about where the cap iron was set. as the shaving meets the cap, it's pushed a bit trying to get up and past it (the essential function of the cap iron, to hold the shaving down a bit until the iron is past it and able to cut it).

So, the friction of the V11 steel is noticeably less in the same plane doing this than the other irons. I am supposing it's based on the chromium in the steel - no other iron in this test was high chromium. Others have some of it, but none without lots of vanadium, etc (I don't know if vanadium makes lots of wood friction, but M4 and 3v make for extra perceptible friction). The difference to a user feels like one is sharpened better than the other.

So, i'm planing on a fairly regular basis and I guessed the other day "if I can feel the difference in the wood contacting the two sides of the bevel and edge, I wonder if there's some slickness to be gained on the face of the cap iron". I'm guessing less. Maybe it's none. I'd like to try.

Wax on the sole of the plane is a greater effect than the difference in irons, setting of the cap iron is greater than the effect of the different irons. Once they're all set identically and you can plane over and over, then the difference becomes noticeable , even if you're just planing footage and trying to turn your brain off (i can't do that well without ceasing to pay attention at all).

Warren mentioned polish on the cap iron. I can't imagine that striations across the width of the cap iron would be helpful and polish eliminates them. I wonder of polish and stainless steel with little chromium would be even better. the slickness of a light stanley plane through wood with the V11 is pretty lovely - just as the surface finish on a given abrasive is better than one would expect.

The fact that the iron doesn't rust and having a cap iron that doesn't rust could also be doable may be useful, too. The detriment in this is that an XHP or V11 iron if polished definitely has less grip to the cap iron vs. carbon steel.

How much less friction in all of this? I don't know. If it's 10% and you're planing tens of thousands of feet in a test and the plane is waxed, then it's very noticeable. If you're planing with one iron, and several weeks later, you plane with another one - it probably won't be noticed.

it could just be a weird idea, too. I like the idea of Kees's planing machine (if it can isolate force differences well enough) seeing if my perception of forces is true, and if so, am I noticing 3% or 20%.