Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

washita and XHP

Posts

Re: washita and XHP

#51

Speaking of which, Bill,

Wiley Horne

I tried to repeat your unexpected finding that the dull side of PMV11–the supersmooth side—showed the highest friction coefficient.

I got the same effect, though just qualitative. Planed a board edge to a gloss, then raised it to a ramp, and adjusted the ramp angle to where the shiny side of a PMV11 blade just started to slide. Then flipped the blade over to the dull side. In repeated tests, the dull side would cling at an angle where the shiny side would slide. And when I found the angle where the dull side just started to creep, the shiny side took off at full speed.

What it means...dunno, but we do know that the dull side has a considerably greater ‘real contact area’ than the shiny side. But the closeness to the wood is not enough to create adhesion, which requires nanometer closeness to happen. So it seems to be some sort of surface effect different from the gross ‘rougher=more friction‘, but not yet an atomic effect.

Now who’s off chasing extraneous information?? :) :)

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#52

you just measured static coefficient

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Static coefficient of friction is simply the tangent of the angle of an inclined plane where the object begins to move. All the multitude of variables cancel in this experiment to yield the simple result. It is a delightful observation to watch the variables go away from the derivation and be left with Tan (angle).

Contact area is not a variable unless there is deformation of one of the objects sliding. So we need another explanation for dull vs shiny. Maybe it has lapping grits embedded.

My bold previous statement that if anything we want to increase friction is likely flawed. I am struggling through a static analysis of forces on the cap iron and in turn the useful force on the shaving. Every time I think I have it right I find an error. But, I think I will eventually prove that substantially more friction force is wasted in the orthogonal to the wood surface (Y) direction than the pushing force from the cap iron along the axis of the wood (X). Hence, it will be more efficient to get the force on the shaving from the angle of the cap iron and not from increasing friction of the shaving on the cap iron. David wins after all ;)

My neighbor is a brilliant mechanical engineer. I need to get him engaged in this problem.

Re: washita and XHP

#53

no worries....

David Weaver

I'm making a crappy wall shelf for a basement TV (repurposed to watch movies with a "real" stereo, which the mrs. banned from polite living spaces). It makes for an opportunity to use wood that I thought I'd never figure out how to use. The shelf is just two right angles with corner supports, and will be screwed into painted block (basement only semi finished - which is a good thing here, so that it, too, doesn't become polite space and require removal of tools and other guy stuff down here).

At any rate, I thought - you know, this whole cap iron thing was kind of a dumb idea, as I like the idea of inarguable acid tests to spur ideas. With the cap iron, even before I used it, I could not come up with any argument against the following:

* it was difficult to make cap irons by hand, why would someone go to the expense?

* in an era when people were just struggling to die without being destitute, why would they have spent more on a plane like this almost to the exclusion of anything else?

Well, what makes the cap iron thought stupid with stainless? one simple thought - how could there be that much friction on the surface of a cap iron if we don't see significant wear, especially considering that the steel is far less wear resistant than the iron and I've got literally hundreds of very close pictures of iron edges that I took myself showing how fast the irons wear!!!

There are very smart people who have only mediocre and good ideas. I generally have dumb ones, but sometimes they work out. Who would know that you could heat XHP in the open atmosphere and dip it in oil and get an acceptable result? Nobody would tell you to even try it. knowing my limitations, I have to accept dumb ideas to allow for mediocre ideas to materialize, as well as the once in a while chance successful thought.

Crappy wood - somewhat happy to find a way to use it and a space that's not nice enough to demand better! (this would've been difficult to plane without a cap iron, but it's just planed through from end to end and looks OK right off of the plane, despite the knot being a little punky).


Re: washita and XHP

#54

Angle....

David Weaver

Agree on the angle being more important than the friction, but perhaps since we're looking for a certain amount of holding, it needs to be had either from friction or angle, and we cancel out one and then need to compensate with the other.

Practically, I've been doing what warren does - polishing the contact area and then just using the tool, and that's that. I guess the conclusion from that is that polishing allows for a consistent familiar area so that the other part of the equation (angle manipulation) can be done without interference.

I looked closely at the center of my stanley cap iron last night, but noticed that I'd left a couple of dull but deep scratches in spots on it so figured that I wouldn't take pictures!! That said, with the naked eye, I couldn't see much difference from one end of the cap iron to the other (no real wear), just very faint tiny marking that could very well have been due to a few examples of abrasive wood.

https://i.imgur.com/YXmQDNF.jpg

And then I finished the job and zipped off the insignificant irregularities that I'd left behind last time with the deburring wheel and the buffer (all further up on the curve than where the shaving would contact, but ruining the picture opportunity nonetheless).

Re: washita and XHP

#55

Re: Goal

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The friction forces on a cap iron are dwarfed by forces we can both notice and easily do something about. For example, poor placement of the cap iron can easily be felt, but many just set the cap iron extremely close and don't bother to look for an ideal.

Another example is dullness. David did experiments to see how long an iron can go before it stops cutting. However someone who is seriously planing wood figures out that after not much dullness the increased force encourages sharpening.

I have seen videos of well known craftsmen honing at 38 to 45 degrees. This is another example of a force that can easily be discerned and can be easily be lessened.

I have more examples, high angle planing, too thick a shaving, heavy plane, on and on. But the point is to focus on forces we actually notice.

Re: washita and XHP

#56

Re: Goal

David Weaver

The biggest turn off with the 5 micron diamonds in the durability test 66% of 1 micron diamond and about 80% of a Dan's black, wasn't the poor durability. It's actually how dull the plane felt. The surface was very dull, too.

The feel between small diamonds and Dan's black was small. The Dan's is the finest and slowest finish stone that I have. More interesting in that test, though unrelated to this, is that a very well settled in washita planed about the same distance as the Dan's black. Surface brightness is also similar. I didn't scope sharpened versions of both, but have in the past and edges look much alike. The washita on a harder chisel looks as good as an 8k waterstone.

Most people would probably call the settled in washita a finish stone if they didn't know what it was. Steel hardness plays a big part in the two stones above yielding a comparable edge.

Re: washita and XHP

#57

wax

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If i was smarter, I also would've realized that I could've just rubbed the cap iron surface on paraffin

I did suggest Carnuba earlier

Re: washita and XHP

#58

Re: D8EE

Philip F Duffy

In all this discussion I have been left with the thought and question; What affect, if any, does the "hinged cap iron" that Millers Falls patented so many years ago have on all this coefficient science? NO EXPERT =me, just a curious and admiring fan of those who are, and of MF planes that Grandpa made. P.

Re: washita and XHP

#59

Re: D8EE

Wiley Horne

Hi Philip and all,

That’s interesting that Granddaddy made Millers Falls planes! Did he share any stories?

There may be a few others like me, who are unfamiliar with the MF ‘hinged lever cap’. If so, here is a link that shows pictures of how that invention works:

https://smallworkshop.co.uk/2018/03/25/the-millers-falls-2-part-lever-cap/

In short, the MF hinged lever cap pins down the blade/capiron assembly in three places—top, middle, and toe. This compares with the Stanley design (by Leonard Bailey), which pins the blade/capiron sandwich at top and bottom, but not in the middle.

Now, if the Stanley blade/capiron had any tendency to bow upward in the middle, or vibrate in the middle, then the geometry and action at the blade edge would be affected in a way that the Millers Falls design corrects. However, I’ve never noticed the Stanley having any such tendency—every one I see lays flat and doesn’t have vibration (that I can make out).

Question: Does anyone notice whether the MF planes have a different feel than comparable Stanleys?

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#60

Re: D8EE

Philip F Duffy

Grandpa was a very big man who died young from "black lung disease" That was the term used to describe the disease the men who ground the blades and polished the bodies. I only met him 2x and he was already infirmed at the age of 45. P.

Re: washita and XHP

#61

Re: D8EE

Wiley Horne

Hi Philip,

That’s a sad story. Can leave a whole family wrecked, but I hope not.

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#62

Re: D8EE

Dick Coers

Was it silicosis? When folks complain about OSHA, I point to that kind of working conditions and early death of skilled men.

Re: washita and XHP

#63

Re: D8EE

David Weaver

Silicosis is a type of pneumoconiosis. The term pneomoconiosis around here is usually associated with coal dust

Re: washita and XHP

#64

Re: D8EE

Rafael in PA

I've several MF planes, they perform very well. I need to look more closely at the effectiveness of the lever cap.

I've only noticed the iron not resting flat on the frog on a Craftsman smoother, but I haven't used much to notice any problem with it.

Have you read the history of that company? It's very interesting, their management chose a paternalistic approach in dealing with their work force. On the other hand, It's unfortunate to realize that working conditions and safe practices were not as advanced as we have them today.