Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

washita and XHP

Posts

Re: washita and XHP

#26

answer, how cap iron works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When analyzing forces that are not orthogonal to a surface the first step is to resolve the forces into the fraction parallel to the surface (friction in this case) and normal (the resisting force of the cap iron on the shaving) Newtons law, for every force there is an equal and opposite force or something like that)

Doing the analysis for a 60 cap iron edge, 87% of the force on the shaving is the force normal to the cap iron face, purely a resistive force against the shaving. Friction force is relatively small. It is primarily this normal force the applies an opposite force to the shaving along it length., which in turn resolves into a force normal to the planed surface and one parallel to it, at the point the shaving is being lifted by the blade tip. The normal force holds the shaving down, thereby mitigating it lifting and fracturing ahead of the blade tip. That is how the cap iron works to mitigate tear-out.

This force can be huge when the cap iron is "working overtime". A too closely set cap ion will apply so much force along the length of the shaving that it will crush the wood fibers and result in an accordion- like shaving. Kato and Kawia have some nice pictures of the effect.

Re: washita and XHP

#27

never underestimate what......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....an experienced person can feel. I recall a neighbor that worked on the guidance systems for ICBM's in the 1960's. Three beryllium balls spun in the heart of the gyro. The balls were hand lapped to part per million spherical tolerance by an experienced hand lapper. I don't doubt David can feel an effect from some cause. I remain skeptical it is a difference in friction between steels. The vast majority of the force applied by the cap iron is not resistance at typical cap iron angles.

I have found a means of measuring friction differences which I will do soon PMV11 vs O1.

Re: washita and XHP

#28

how cap iron works and The SMT Loopy!

Raymond in Trenton NJ

I'm with you on that Bill.

Way back, a long time ago when Badger Pond wasn't drained and filled, there was this this guy named Stephen Thomas (and NOT the TOH host). Someone I ended up respecting, admiring and envying because of his technical knowledge, level of work/craftsmanship and problem solving skills. We became good friends. Anyway, in the late 90’s or very early 2000’s he made this custom coffin infill based on a Spiers or Norris model. Instead of DT’ing the metal sides to the sole, he used the ‘cove and pin’ joint (also known as a ‘Knapp Joint’) as a visual pun and the plane became affectionately known as the ‘Loopy’. It was one of the ‘readers tools’ published in the very first FWW Tools issue.

Anyway, he also made the iron. A wicked thick iron, just about the time that wicked thick modern irons started being popular. Can’t remember what steel it was; I’m sure Paul in NJ, John Aniano or Sir William would likely remember that. He wasn’t local to us, but we seemed to get together often enough that he lent me the plane (as well as to others) to try it out. It sharpened and polished OK on my water stones, a vauge memory is saying it took longer, but nothing epic. I put it back with his chip breaker setting (right at the edge) and tried it out on a piece of quilted maple (Western Big Leaf - [and before Sir William chides me] Acer macrpphyllum :o). It was a little harder to push and the surface was not what I expected. Not bad, but ‘normal’.

I set the chip breaker back, maybe a whole 1/32” and it was not only easier to push, but the surface was now flawless off the iron. Mirror like. A drop of water would not soak in, but bead up. That was the best finish I ever planed. The metal of the chip breaker may a affect this, but as you opined, there’s a lot going on down there and everything is influencing everything else.

Wish I had time to find my old photos of that.

Regards,

Raymond

Re: washita and XHP

#29

Well THAT is not what I expected, coefficient of f

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Coefficient of static friction (which will be proportional to sliding which is what we need . I can measure static with what I have, and can't sliding. So

A LN and a Hock O-1 0.26 (estimated range 0.23 to 0.30)

PMV11 shiny side 0.36

Dull side 0.58

Surface is burnished ash prepared with machine planing, a bit dull knives.

Will do more work tomorrow. These results have some error bars of course, but the differences are definitely significant and astonishing at least to me. What's with the LV dull side!

Re: washita and XHP

#30

Re: Well THAT is not what I expected, coefficient

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

Your results make sense.

The dull side is the lapped face of a PM V11 iron. The shiny side shows machine marks. But the dull face is machine-lapped to an extreme tolerance.

Here is Veritas on ‘lapped blades’, in the instructions that are packed with PM V11, and yes, I carefully counted the zeros:

From Lee Valley: The blade “.....face has been machine-lapped to an average roughness of 5 microinches (0.000005”) or better and to a flatness tolerance of 0.00005” or better over the working surface....The working surface is the portion of the face that extends from 1/8” below the bottom of the slot to the cutting edge.”

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#31

Re: Well THAT is not what I expected, coefficient

David Weaver

Dull side is probably lapped with sic, very toothy. Hopefully these irons were hit repeatedly with naphtha or lacquer thinner.

Iirc from a table that I saw, greased static friction for mild steel was extremely low. A little may go a long way.

Re: washita and XHP

#32

Re: Well THAT is not what I expected, coefficient

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Washed with solvent many times before testing.

Re: washita and XHP

#33

Something else accounts for the "feel" ?

Jim Matthews

There's a gliding sensation from a keen blade on compliant boards.

Do you suppose something at the point of action accounts for this?

I'm baffled by really small (or genuinely vast) numbers as the frame of reference is beyond my senses. Anyone who keeps an old car alive has seen this in practice; at start up things are rattling and loose - somewhere on the drive, the car comes alive to purr.

I expect no one measurement will explain what it is we're noticing.

Re: washita and XHP

#34

more from literature

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a trove of literature on the friction of metal on wood from the perspective of cutting it......all in Japanese and the same journal as the K&K work.... it figures >( .

My value for the coefficient of friction of the cabon steel blades was, within our experimental errors, identical to referenced values....about 0.25.

Ground vs polished tools have about 50% more friction because the rough edges are milling shavings of wood from the test specimen. Surface roughness of the wood has but a small effect (typical of sliding friction).

Re: washita and XHP

#35

equivalent polish?

David Weaver

I think getting equivalent polish will be difficult because the same abrasive on one will potentially yield a different result.

I don't think I could set up anything accurate enough to test this, at least not without spending more time than I want to.

Re: washita and XHP

#36

Surface roughness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To a first approximation surface roughness has no effect on coefficient of friction. Where this assumption breaks down is extreme roughness. In the case of a coarse ground tool the sharp edges were shown to be milling wood from the surface(SEM pictures showing wood stuck in grooves). Even here the coefficient of friction only increased about 50% over polished.

Going the other direction the coefficient of friction of tool on planed, sawed and band sawed wood was little different.

Re: washita and XHP

#37

Re: answer, how cap iron works

Bruce Mack

You guys have educated me about the placement of the cap iron for minimal tear-out. The current discussion is fun to read, but not as much fun as my L-N low angle jack plane newly equipped with the Henry Eckert powdered metallurgy blade. I just watched a video on Grinling Gibbons and one on Thomas Chippendale. I don't think either would have hired me to sweep their shavings. My obsession is enhanced by people like you who seek knowledge for its own sake and conduct a civil discussion while doing so. Keep it coming.

Re: washita and XHP

#38

Could be....

David Weaver

when I did testing, the M4 had the most resistance, 3V was just behind.

The resistance difference from M4 was enough to make my wrists hurt some (no kidding), but no way of knowing - the V11 (those two duked it out, which made comparison really easy in the higher footage). I thought that M4 wouldn't outlast V11, but it kept chugging.

It's possible that it's a difference in quality of feel and not quantity and I could be wrong about forces vs. something else in feel. Sharpened with diamonds, A2 is slightly smoother through the cut than carbon steel, too.

The virtue of carbon steel still seems to me to be uniformity. In wear, its uniformity is best. In heavier work, it retains its edge uniformity better, but the reason it does may be more to do with having to sharpen it more often and the fact that it abrades twice as fast on typical media (making it easier to keep it ahead of nicks and damage).

For finish planing, the surface brightness of everything was fine in the test, and the slightly less bright (but still very bright compared to sanding or even scraping) finish from the carbon steel probably makes getting a uniform planed surface a little easier. The v11 shine is probably similar to the shine from an 8/10 bu carbon steel japanese plane (that's something I could check, I guess).

My whole foray into the double iron was two-fold - one to be able to dimension productively without having to have perfect wood or do things like "make your bench with all of the boards going the same way!!". The second was to be able to use the cap iron on a japanese plane to get the shine that they get, without the sometimes strange surface failures (tiny ones) that mess up an otherwise large wet looking planed surface. I tossed the japanese plane(s) aside for several reasons, but one of them being time spent sharpening and time spent adjusting the cap iron.

That strayed way off topic....at any rate, I could be wrong about what I think I feel, confusing the quality of the feel for the quantity of something.

Re: washita and XHP

#39

Refined data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Surfaces cleaned with acetone and then "polished" by rubbing with gray Norton synthetic wool, equivalent to 3/0 steel wool on wood. This polish removed some spots of some groad on some surfaces. The "shiny sides" were apparently Blanchard ground judging from arcing scratches.

I have improved the measuring device enabling better measurements at high coefficient of friction values and reducing variability.

A LN and a Hock O-1- both surfaces

PMV11 shiny side

The coefficient of friction for these surfaces fell in the range of 2.1 to 2.5 for 5 trials. The PMV11 was a bit higher than the others, but in this range.

Dull side of PM V11 0.39-0.42

I have no explanation for the dull side result.

Conclusion, given the piddly contribution of cap iron friction force to the overall force at a 60 degree cap iron, and the small and going the wrong direction measured coefficients of friction between carbon and stainless steel, changing the composition of the cap iron steel is not going to be worth the expense of the stainless steel for most users. Reservation, if the cap iron is subject to corrosion this conclusion may not be valid.

Re: washita and XHP

#41

Re: Refined data

David Weaver

I probably didn't think through enough (initially) about how much of the force with the cap iron is spent bending the chip vs. rubbing it whereas the iron itself, some of both occurs, but much more on the rubbing side.

The one issue that stuck out when thinking about the rubbing is the fact that I've never seen appreciable wear on the cap iron of any of my tools. There's probably some wear occurring, but not often in an identical spot, and the "hard" forces near the cut (the chip is thin, but it's connected to the wood on the top side of the iron - since that dip we've all seen in back side wear is close to firm wood, and the bottom side is rubbing firmly on wood).

I do think a lower cost stainless (realizing that it's a pain to machine and stamp compared to mild steel or medium carbon steels) would be good for the average white collar woodworker. The first place to rust on an iron set is the cap iron (guessing unhardened steel corrodes faster than hardened), and then the contact line between the cap iron and iron).

Since the V11 irons are already stainless, it may eliminate the nonsense about "hone rite" and other things people trouble themselves with preventing corrosion on planes. Slightly greater than 8 ounces of hone right is $40 (!!!!). They boast that the concentrate will make 6 liters of solution, but an avid woodworker could go through that in a year or less spraying their stones.

Re: washita and XHP

#42

Ditto to Bill

David Weaver

I'm pleased that I posted a curiosity and Bill did the legwork - else I may have bought stainless stock and made a cap iron to find that it made no difference (and wouldn't have my preferred stanley bump).

Re: washita and XHP

#43

something easier that I could do..

David Weaver

...i noticed when looking at the various friction coefficients that teflon is far lower than any of the metals (on the list that I saw, wood on wood was compared, metal on metal was compared, but not metals on wood - and stainless wasn't there, just chromium).

AT any rate, teflon was something like .04 vs. 78 for mild steel and 0.41 for chromium on that list (contact surfaces different than bill is testing, thus different values).

That's static friction, too, but ...not going to go down that rabbit hole for now.

teflon is out there in all kinds of stuff, but I forgot that the only real hurdle to using it (usually) is heat. That's not really a concern on a cap iron - the ones that I have are definitely mild steel the way they file.

I'll see if I can find some cheap bakeable teflon coating and then report what I find. If it doesn't work, it can be abraded off easily based on what I've seen with teflon pans :b

If I can't feel any difference from teflon, then it's really a dead curiosity at that point.

Re: washita and XHP

#44

Re: something easier that I could do..

David Weaver

engineering supply advertises bakeable PTFE. I maybe dreaming that something like that would be available at a consumer level, but dupont does make a plain teflon spray that's more of a finish for $7.90 at walmart. That should be good enough, even if it may not wear well.

Re: washita and XHP

#45

an idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have done teflon sintering, and sent it out.. Not trivial to get an adherent film do it yourself. there are places that will do the coating. Cost not huge but likely too high to satisfy a curiosity.

Buy a steel frying pan that is "nonstick" coating of some sort. Cut it up and make a cap iron from the bottom. Or wax the capiron with tough wax...Carnuba, and see if there is a difference. The Carnuba lasts a while on my thickness planer bed.

There is an easier experiment to see if frictional forces are significant. Change the angle of the cap iron. The two extremes are 90 degrees- no friction component. 0 degrees only a friction component. The fraction friction is the cosine of the angle. If you lower the angle and it feels easier to push friction is insignificant contributor.

Re: washita and XHP

#46

Re: an idea

David Weaver

yes on both - beyond the level of trouble I'm willing to go for. The spray appears just to be more or less a finish with PTFE in it (no oil, though there are bunches of products with PTFE added to water displacers or thin oil).

The spray should last long enough to experiment, but I'm not hoping to have teflon on a cap iron in the long term - just test an idea, so if it's gone in 20 strokes, that's OK.

A strong application of carnauba is also a good idea.

Hard to tell the difference in bending or friction forces at different angles (because there's more bending).

I tried a flat 80 degree bevel like shown in the K&K machine video. It's not very pleasant. It's either not preventing tearout, or it's like pushing concrete blocks filled with lead.

Re: washita and XHP

#47

Goal

Wiley Horne

Hi David, Bill, and all,

Invite your comments......It strikes me that the goal for the capiron face is to make it consistent—repeatable—with respect to total backpressure = friction+effective angle.

Bill has established two points:

1. The capiron works by backpressure on the shaving taking effect at the cutting edge. Meaning, for a given wood, shaving depth, setback, etc, you need backpressure = X for the capiron to work. If the friction is reduced to zero, say, the angle would in principle have to be increased to bring us back to X.

2. As between friction and angle, angle is dominant by a lot.

And David has pointed out, he doesn't see any wear, for all his planing.

Can we conclude from the above, that the best we can do is follow Warren’s advice to keep the face of the capiron polished enough to make the friction component repeatable?

Wiley

Re: washita and XHP

#48

could be...

David Weaver

..that could be the conclusion. It's been so long since I didn't publish the contact part of a cap iron that I couldn't make much comment about the value of the polish.

But that habit started with building wooden planes where there's another factor - choking if the cap iron isn't set up right - the part that Larry always assumed made it harder for a plane to feed right is precisely what makes it feed *better* than without.

Everyone here knows about my buffer and deburring wheel - a good way to polish a cap iron that's been filed or stoned into geometry, and to remove the persistent wire edge that can be formed on mild steel :b

The fact that there's not a lot of wear on a cap (and warren has said similar things before - especially when the internet cowboys watched the KK video and started talking about honing methods for upkeep of cap irons - actually, that was an argument against it for folks who couldn't live with the idea that some of their loved planes may be outperformed) is a strike in a reasonable man's test about friction. The wear on the iron is stark. I've seen many pictures, and made many.

https://i.imgur.com/kJSaaei.jpg

My scope would not take pictures of a curved surface, but I have a cheaper handheld scope that would allow for examining the center of a cap iron vs. the edges (where more of the original polish may be present).

These are the kinds of things we think of, I guess (we...me) when we've solved all of the other practical problems.

I did order the teflon spray to play with it - I have use for it elsewhere (shovels, etc) where I'd like to try it. The literature on it states that it doesn't last that long on smooth surfaces.

If i was smarter, I also would've realized that I could've just rubbed the cap iron surface on paraffin while the plane was apart, and removed just a little polish from it after that with 220 sandpaper or something, to see what can be felt.

Re: washita and XHP

#49

excellent point Wiley

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Wiley the engineer steps back and reveals the folly of this discussion.

The whole point of the cap iron is to provide a parallel force down the length of the shaving, not to reduce operator fatigue. We don't want to decrease friction; rather, if anything, we want to increase it. That said, the friction component at a cap iron angle of 60 degrees is small compared to the normal force component against the dam created by the cap iron. So it probably doesn't matter what is done to the friction component to alter it. Angle will dominate the force required to push the shaving up the cap iron, not coefficient of friction. Better to reduce wasted work by reducing friction against the blade and sole.

The fact that one can feel the effect of changing the cap iron angle shows what a substantial force is delivered down, what would seem to be, a frail shaving. Wood has impressive compressive strength.

Re: washita and XHP

#50

Well, thanks yet we also

Wiley Horne

don’t want to discourage experiment, any experiment. Experiments almost always lead to unexpected findings.

Data is treasure. Data has a habit of slaying the original hypothesis and pointing the way to something even better. For example, David’s as-yet uncorralled PMV11/XHP/3V/O1 planing marathon, spinning off a dozen findings and greatly benefitting LV’s exacting work.

So, instead of being a smartypants, I should have encouraged David to follow his curiosity and bring us more treasure. Which I now do!

Wiley