Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

Posts

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#51

Re: reply

Wiley Horne

Bill,

That would be a wonderful experiment, especially because of the whimsy. Maybe we could get David to do it. Some guys at forest products lab back in 1941 decided to compress some 26% wet hickory sapwood—maybe this had to do with engineered wood. Anyway, they compressed at various temperatures, at up to 4,000psi, and got the hickory to compress to 60% of original at max. pressure, and it was going asymptotic with pressure at 40% compression.

I just did something way less rigorous, which was to go mark out one socket, saw and kerf it, and chisel out the waste. Took a minUte maybe to do the whole thing. This was a 12-13 thousandths saw kerf, a blued M2 kerfing tool a little skinnier than the saw kerf made from a short length of planer blade, and assumed a 3/8” drawer side for the depth of kerfing. My only caution as a result is that I would have marked the kerfing tool at 3/8” when doing it for real. Because it’s so easy that one could overdo it. You’re driving the tool down into the whole length of the drawer front, so there's no real splitting danger. But still....it’s best to stop at the drawer thickness depth.

The other thought is that you want to take it easy, because let’s say my tool cross section is 12 thousandths, multiplied by an insertion advance rate of 1/8”. That’s a cross section of 15 ten-thousandths (0.0015 sq.in.). So if you hit the tool with an effective force equal to a static weight laying on it of 15lb, which is a pretty light blow, then you’ve exerted 10,000psi of compaction force onto the wood under the saw kerf. It don’t take but one of those, maybe two, to get to depth.

Derek’s kerfing tool looks pretty precision to me, somI would hazard a guess that he is getting on the order of 90-95% compaction, and 5-10% side compression. In my case, it’s probably more like 60% compaction and 40% side compression. But at 3/8” travel how much should we be worried? I like the look of Derek’s pins when he’s done, and mine looked OK too.

So we’re not going to get “area man achieves cold fusion in workshop and vaporizes Pittsburgh.”

Wiley

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#52

The release cut

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, the point that I tried to make earlier (as has Wylie mentioned), and seems to be glossed over by Bill and yourself, is that cleaning out joints efficiently and cleanly involves a release cut. David Charlesworth has written about this extensively. The kerfing chisel is not simply about extending the kerf, but about preparing the corner for a clean and easier formation using a chisel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#53

I see what the hangup is...

David Weaver

I learned my basic firsts from charlesworth's videos, i know exactly what you're saying.

The part that you're missing is that you don't use the method that bill and I are talking about to clean directly to the corner (I'd call it the paring and leafing method, knocking parts of the wood off that will break cleanly and then paring the facets of long grain or side grain).

You (I) work almost to the corners instead, and then what's left when you're done can be neatly pared out right at the corner.

The two methods go in opposite order. what you're advocating is to remove the outline of the cut and then remove the waste. I'm advocating removing most of the waste (but not critical parts of the outline that may break past a mark) and then pare out the critical parts as a last step.

I learned this planemaking because the corners in a plane mortise are acute, but you're restricted in getting to them and seeing them. You have to leaf the material away and then remove the corner, but there's too much bulk to do a "release cut" without overcutting something. Since the mortise isn't hidden in a plane, you don't have the same overcutting luxury that you might have in a hidden joint.

I'd venture to guess historically, joints cut in volume and neatly were done the way I'm doing them more than the way you're doing them (and I did them at first). Historical work would've been done more often with mahogany, as well, which lends itself even more to manipulation without doing untoward things (like breaking out where you didn't expect it to).

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#54

The bottom line

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I accept that for reasons of satisfaction and efficiency you find the technique you use desirable. This result may also hinge on what preceded the need to remove this last bit of waste and any other variables unique to your situation, which has several unique features.

However, you need to accept that the use of this technique is rare. I know of no one in my sphere of woodworking using it and many who have tried it. It is not rare because it is unknown. In my own situation it offers no improvement to what I am doing either in efficiency or satisfaction. For an operation that takes seconds and involves a tool already in the hand there simply is no opportunity for improvement.

Given all the variables that lead to how one prepares this joint anyone learning or willing to explore has the information to experiment to see what works best for them. The fact that the leading proponent of efficient woodworking (Frid)advocated bashing out the kerf with a card scraper should encourage all to try it. I suspect that like Wiley, the details of how the total waste is excavated, and the experience in excavating this waste, may make this technique useful, or not.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#55

excellent summary of the situation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was fortunate for me that I don't do videos and never was influenced by Charlesworth. As I learned of what he advocated I saw that it did not agree with what I saw practiced in American shops making American Period furniture. Given a choice, I am going to first try what I see going on in a shop making a living selling the furniture they made. Acknowledging my prejudice, I believe that people making videos emphasize novelty over the "less apt to attract eyeballs" commonly used techniques.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#56

The measure of success...

David Weaver

..for someone in a shop making furniture with only hand tools would've been the results and the timing. If it took a skilled worker to do the techniques, that wasn't really a problem because the shop would've been filled with skilled workers and not with middle aged people like us flowing in with our brain plasticity not so plastic and a lifetime ego of being successful at something else.

The new school situation makes for lots of people learning to cut joints who will need a method that works whether they're good or not - they're paying to learn and often won't be that interested in the idea that the learning isn't about the results right away, it's building competence to get them later. I suspect frid, and most definitely charlesworth, need methods that aren't based on time and efficiency, but based on initial and continued success for show joints. Even if that means slow (if you need to do something hidden and fast, you can use screws or dowels or a domino, right?).

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#57

not the case with Frid...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have read some about him. He taught at some school that I don't recall the name of. The philosophy of the school was to turn out workers that could work fast enough to earn a living at it.

I don't know the details of the total process by which Frid made half blinds. Hints are in the pictures in his books but not sufficient detail that I can reliably reproduce what he did. But I would put my money on the fact that his use of the card scraper cut labor out of his process.

It seems the devil is in the details. The card scraper was assuredly not used in some Period- and who knows maybe none- shops as revealed by the remnants of how the joint was made as revealed in these joints. Were Alan Batty still alive I could ask if his experience, meeting a quota of 6 drawers a day, involved a card scraper. He never mentioned it. But then I didn't specifically ask.

What we can be assured of is that anyone making a lot of drawers is likely to become bored (or go broke if a professional shop) making them and look for any means of making them quicker. They will arrive at what works best for them. The choices are out there to try.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#58

Re: not the case with Frid...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have known some people who studied with Frid. One of my friends studied furniture making for four years at Rhode Island School of Design. He often asks me questions: "how do you do this? , how is this set up? and such. One time I said "Didn't Frid teach you this stuff? "

"Oh no, he was only interested in industrial woodworking."

I think he may have made dovetails on a table saw or router. Just not a chisel and plane man.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#59

Suspicious....

David Weaver

Anyone who was alive to teach or be teaching much when some of the members of this board were learning the hobby of woodworking makes me suspicious.

I'm less suspicious of the hay cabinet shop types, but from talking to George, they're missing a big part of productivity for the hobbyist (double iron planing). I don't suspect anyone who learned to work at CW and who is making furniture on the side is doing the dimensioning with planes, anyway, but at least their joinery and design isn't rooted in studio furniture, greene and greene, arts and crafts or any of that stuff.

Charlie and others on Knots used to like to hold up tage frid and others who came up in the same era, and I'm sure they were brilliant if you like the stuff they're noted for, but I'm not a fan of any of it. Most of it could've been drawn and left on paper and that would've been all I needed to see of it.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#60

Re: Suspicious....

roger lance

Humility is evidently not your strong suit.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#61

More information is probably needed

David Weaver

You'd be surprised - I don't build anything special and am willing to admit it. It's not about what I've made, it's about what I'm looking for and looking to learn.

There's a big difference.

If you were interested in learning classical piano theory and someone offered liberace (who could play classical piano quite well, but maybe a classical student might prefer to observe kissin - even if they couldn't play with either of them), you'd get my drift.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#62

Re: More information is probably needed

roger lance

You are not that difficult to see.

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#63

Re: My curiosity is perked

William Duffield

Magic? Naw, it's quantum tunneling. :D

Re: Entry hall table for a niece: Part 12

#65

Re: More information is probably needed

David Weaver

Conclude as you wish roger, it goes no deeper than wanting an information source dedicated to hand work, rather than someone who had a focus of wanting to train students in everything so they could work in any shop.

There's always someone around to tell you if you're selective that you're being arrogant. It's bunk. It's ok to have narrow interests and question ideas, just as it's perfectly fine for someone to question my tastes.

What's less fine is your showing up here only to hurl insults but offer nothing on the topic that anyone could learn from.