Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Heat balance at plane blade tip

Posts

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#76

All metal wear not equal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have had the opportunity to discuss wear with a metallurgist that seems to know his way around knife steel. Particle steels have two attributes of interest to us. They are tougher than their coarser particle cousins and they are relatively more resistant to "soft abrasive wear" than material removal by grinding against hard sharp particles. It is information like this fact that makes wear data generated on wood with silica possibly different from data generated on typical furniture wood. Where as CPM 3V fell behind XHP in David's testing it's load of highly abrasion resistant vanadium could have made a larger difference in planing something with silica. (BTW, one can see quartz crystals in the SEM pictures of wood containing silica.)

The tabulated "wear" values from the manufacturer are useless to us unless the test generating the data is revealed. There are many "wear" tests available. Some tabulations are testing adhesive wear if the purpose was to generate data relevant to die metal. In other cases it could be grindability, important to fabrication. Etc. We should not expect correlation among these tabulations.

The data most relevant to us is to be found on knife forums. For example, a tabulation of resistance to dulling by cutting cellulose (rope) seems to be relevant and indeed these data correlate with David's data perfectly.