Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Heat balance at plane blade tip

Posts

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#51

Re: This isn't Instagram

Oskar

agree fully Steve.

For pictures and inspiration Instagram is great. For detailed discussion the forum format is much better. This forum is great in that respect, and I really like that it collects people (some that dropped out of SMC and other forums) that really know and care about the minute details.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#52

Re: bored to tears ?

Warren in Lancaster, PA



It will take one graph and 2 minutes explanation to summarize David's blade metal results. Either you are planning on more verbiage than necessary or your group has less attention span than the average teen ager.

And, why is it that knife enthusiasts are passionately interested in the metals their blade is made from and supposedly planing enthusiasts are not?

The noun "metal" is usually reserved for elements. We use the term alloy or steel (which is an alloy) for plane iron material. For centuries.

You can summerize David's results if you want, but the subject is much more complicated, once you start asking questions. Like why did David use diamonds to sharpen the irons? Was it only to accommodate the more goofball materials he tested? Or if he used a sharpening method that took four times as long as his normal routine, where is the savings? Is it true that some of these alloys "take a crappy edge and hold it forever"?

I cannot imagine someone familiar with this stuff suggesting it could be summerized in two minutes.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#53

clever setting procedure; blurring?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am anxious to employ the cap iron setting procedure you described. I'll use my dovetail chopping finesse.

Sandpaper tends to blur the edges of stringing and inlay—has to be cut with a tool to get a sharp result.


The holly string was scraped level and then the whole affair sanded to 180 followed by garnet shellac sanded in between coats (don't recall how many, probably 3). I scrape(level) as I install and move along piece by piece at a rate, limited by patience. If by blurring you mean fuzziness at the edges, I don't see it.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#54

There is one thing remaining..

david weaver

..the other questions are easily answered, but not maybe for a group of newbies who have just set out on a method that won't work with certain irons.

I can do freehand with the cast diamond plate and the diamond hones about as fast as the cycle time with carbon steel, but I still like to use stones, so the eased temper has pretty much put me back to where I was with the finishing. The reminder about why I don't use guides was a nice refresher. It always seems like it should be as fast, but it's not. It takes too much control away from a user.

The remaining question is whether or not I will be able to work with the xhp and find the same lack of defects as carbon steel while planing. In my initial tests, I didn't see much, but the surface left by XHP is brighter by quite a bit, so it's hard to tell if tiny defects are just because the surface is too bright to hide much (this can be a problem planing with japanese planes - things that would be hidden with a stanley and a washita are glaring).

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#55

Re: clever setting procedure; blurring?

Wiley Horne

Bill,

After seeing yours, I quickly take back that remark. Dangers of generalizing from personal experience. Also, my light inlay was soft maple, not holly, which may have been the difference. Advice to others—use holly for the light inlay/stringing.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#56

Re: A small experiment

Steve Voigt

Wiley, that method for setting the cap iron seems fine to me. Another popular way is to use a piece of blue tape to tape a mechanic's feeler gauge to your bench top, or a piece of scrap. set the cutting iron right next to the feeler gauge and slide the cap iron down on top of it…I guess the only advantage is that it's easier to find the exact size you want. Either way, I agree that using a method like this is a terrific way to develop a visual feel for how much setbacks like .004 or .010 are. Do it a few times and you won't need to anymore.

I really enjoyed seeing that double iron plane by Konrad--I don't think he makes them any more, only single irons now.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#57

Re: A small experiment

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would concentrate on taking a thin shaving rather than a close cap iron setting. With your numbers (.005 cap iron, .0015 shaving) I think you are in danger of getting a little cloudy. I would recommend shavings in the .0005 to .001 range for less worries about disturbing the banding.

I use a rounded cap iron with the terminus closer to 80 than 50 degrees. I am having trouble imagining that anyone would need a cap iron as close as .005 inches.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#58

Re: A small experiment

Wiley Horne

Steve,

I was too lazy to get the deck of feeler gauges out, take them apart etc etc, although that would make the setback exact. The method I used has two virtues: it gets you in the right ballpark fast, and anyone can do it who has a ordinary Post-It note (4 thou), or a sheet of ruled notebook paper (3-3.5 thou), or a sheet of 20-lb bond business paper (4.5 thou).

I find one only needs two benchmarks, one around 4 or 5 and the other around 8 or 10, so that when a forum participant references a particular setback that they measured, you can immediately call to mind what that looks like on your plane.

Konrad makes custom infills—will make anything one is ready to pay for. Will size the tote to your hand, make to your bedding angle, set the mouth gap where you want it, with or without adjuster, double iron/single iron, etc. Files a really beautiful layback of the top side of mouth and other details. He has been making a long recovery from a serious shoulder injury, working on his sports therapy, and would surely like to hear from his old acquaintances.

I have a question about your own plane-making....what do you use to shape the totes? I was looking at Lee Valley’s Japanese files last night....

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#59

Re: A small experiment

Wiley Horne

Thank you Warren. That’s very helpful. And an insight that I hadn't heard before: that if you think you need a setback in the 4-5 thou range, it’s better to go to the finest of shavings, and also that a supertight cap iron can begin to interfere with the surface.

Very useful to us all!

Also, I have been misquoting you on the bevel angle of the cap iron. My apologies. Should be, rounded with 80 degrees where it meets the face of the iron.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#60

Holly inlay properties

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Holly is quite soft, similar to basswood. In addition to being white it is limp and hence easy to bend. Because of its flexibility it is easier to stick into troughs curving this way and that than maple. But I can't imagine it being less fuzzable than maple.

Wiley, come visit. I'll teach you sanding and you teach me planing.....October is a good time.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#61

My suspicion...

david weaver

...since I didn't state it, is that I will be able to get XHP to be just as good performing as far as surface quality (except that it is brighter and with less resistance through the cut at all stages of dullness) vs. all of the carbon steel irons that I have.

AT this point, I can't say that it's not superior in nearly every way to all of my best carbon steel irons. It will pin a dry india stone a little bit if you let it, but that may be true of other irons. It may also be less favorable to full bevel sharpening, but not by much. It is cut easily on a crystolon stone, and with hardness eased a little bit, it is extremely well behaved on the washita and other natural stones. The wire edge is removed without much effort just by alternating strokes front and back of the bevel, to a point that i couldn't notice any remaining without stropping.

Even if I were to sharpen it the same frequency as carbon steel (say every 400-600 feet), it would still be sharper at all stations.

I did not expect that. Actually, I didn't expect to notice the difference in cut resistance from each steel that I was able to find out. It is one of the few alloy steels that I have tried that all I can say is that it's actually really good. The high vanadium steels are good if you're willing to sharpen them the way they like to be sharpened - as a finish planing iron? i don't know, I like to be able to refresh a finish planing iron quickly on a natural stone.

The "self healing" characteristic that carbon steel also shows is present in the XHP, and that is very important. tiny defects are worn off quickly, resulting in a visually uniform surface, and the steel can be cut and heat treated by a dummy in a garage with a coffee can forge, and tempered in a kitchen oven.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#62

Re: totes etc.

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Good points on using ordinary paper. I also agree that only two settings are needed to acclimate ones eyes, after which one can do it freehand, as it were. I find I have four basic settings: out of the way (maybe 1/32), normal (probably .010-.015, depending on the timber), close (a little more than .004) and the nuclear option (less than .004).

Warren's made the point a couple times that really close (like my "nuclear option") can have an adverse impact on the surface. True enough, but it's not a symmetrical problem…the worst effect of an overly close setting is far preferable to tearout. A super close setting that produces shavings that are crinkled like bacon will look no worse than a scraped surface.

Funny that Konrad should come up--he and I were discussing the process of tote making recently. He does it all with a variety of rasps and files, which makes sense given that he's working pretty recalcitrant materials (blackwood, ironwood, etc). I prefer to take off most of the material with a gouge or chisel.

As for what follows the gouge/chisel, a lot of things will work. If there's a lot to take off, I'll start with a cheap, black plastic handled rasp from LV. Usually though, I take off enough with the chisel that I can go straight to a medium rasp from Auriou, my only high dollar rasp. After that, I like a mill tooth file such as Nicholson's super shear. Then finish up with 220 sandpaper.

The Japanese mill tooth files from LV are good files. They are very sharp and will feel grabby unless you use a very light touch. One thing I don't like is that the half rounds are hollow, so there is no flat side to use, just the convex side. Also, the radius on the half rounds is much bigger than it is on a typical half round file or rasp of the same size. So, I end up using the Nicholsons more, even if they don't cut quite as nicely.

By the way, Konrad seems to be very well, and recovered from his injury. He posts what he's working on almost every day. Here's today's post:

https://www.instagram.com/p/B1_Z16Kpa47/

And here's his main page:

https://www.instagram.com/sauer_and_steiner/

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#63

Divergence from the classic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The pattern on the door is common for this period. What is not common is to omit half the berry clusters and not pierce the diamond with the arcs. For better or worse I thought the result less busy looking, though not piercing the diamond is more demanding of technique.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#64

Re: The whole translation/review—for the obsesse

Mark Hooper

Snarky and sarcastic - what class. The unending obsessive postings do take up a huge amount of space. Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans knew millennia ago that sharp cutters in planes cut quite well. There, fixt!

Your propensity for denigrating new/beginner woodworkers, and condescending attitude while inferring that the ultimate measure of planing prowess is how close to the edge one places the shipbreaker. Craftsmen over the centuries created masterpieces without fixating on how many hair thicknesses the space should be.

Oh well, I have no further interest in your screeds, and will enjoy instead other websites.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#65

Re: not quite, but find what you like...

david weaver

Inaccurate assessment (We don't see how close we can set the cap iron, we see if we can set it away further and still have it work well), but have fun on other sites. SMC is good for light discussion - in all seriousness, if it gets too far into facts and people start debating anything, they'll shut it off. I watched them castigate George Wilson for suggesting that his opinion might bear more weight than someone who had just started woodworking (it does, of course, but not on that site).

(I doubt you're a beginner - I've never seen a beginner talk about romans and what they did with edges, but before you jump in and express a negative opinion really about anything, it's always good to show something positive instead. Something you're working on, something you've made, a technique. I haven't seen it, but I don't remember anyone - often not even the people who have fed me negative comments in the past and are offended when I address them in earnest in a later post. Life's too short, and my posts are *really* easy to avoid. They have my name on them).

I also doubt there are many people who have given more stuff and more compass calibrating to beginners than I have. It doesn't saddle me with the obligation to make sure everything is suitable for them. I'm solidly advanced beginner - if we couldn't at least get to that point, we'd all be sharpening for 8 minutes and building square things in jigs.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#66

I don't understand social media

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I go to the library and see a book I am uninterested in I don't feel entitled to tell the librarian that I don't like the book. The Dickens dude is too wordy. If a group meets for lunch and I have no interest in what they talk about I don't have the urge to inform them of my opinion of their discussions. I would not have such an inflated opinion of myself that I would imagine these people would care what I thought....which should be true. But on social media some expect that they are entitled to comment unconstructively about what others are cordially doing and believe we give a s***. We don't. I suppose these unlikable people have no friends to talk to, so they have no support to teach them good behavior.

On the other hand, for those that have paid their dues with beneficial discourse, and if anyone has it is David, I owe them the courtesy of letting them have their say and if I can't say anything constructive I should not say anything at all.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#67

Re: Handle shaping method and tools... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Wiley,

You asked about tools/methods for shaping plane totes. Below is a description of the method I've used to make QS beech saw handles.

First, cut to the exact line of the pattern. Don't aim wide and then say "I'll just take it down later". Cut to the line!!! The mantra "craftsmanship of risk", or something like that. I prefer my Jet Scroll saw, on slow speed with an agressive as possible blade installed. It will take a while. Just let the blade cut and don't force it. I've used the Flying Dutchman blades and they work well.

FWIW, if I can, I use chisels and knives to cut the shaping bevels as aggressively and as quickly as possible. Use whatever works. In the tightly curved concave sections, I've used coarse and fine rasps, using a side/skating motion. Not straight along the length of the rasp, but instead pushing it sideways while going forward. One of the Ariou modelmakers rasps is my favorite. On the convex portions, I prefer the flat side of a narrow rasp, again moving sideways as well as forward. I am right handed and these are right handed stitched rasps and files.

My comments about the bevels themselves - make them beautiful. Make them even, flowing, smooth. All else in the flow of the handle will arise from these bevels. Make them as good as possible.

After creating the bevels, usually five along the whole contour, break the corners off with a rasp. Then, with 80 grit cloth backed sandpaper strips, do the shoe-shine method to fully round the edges. If the sandpaper gets worn, get new strips! Use the cloth backed abrasive as a cutting tool. Move up to 120 grit cloth strips and maybe 240 grit. Then it is basically done. Just need to lightly plane and sand the sides to get that crisp line between the handle sides and the contour.

My method is based on Isaac Smith's excellent blog on saw making. Somewhat the same, but somewhat different.

Over and out,

John


Isaac Smith's website

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#68

Kent B

David - keep at it

Kent B

Man, David......that brought back memories. Bad ones.

I remember distinctly the beating George got. There was never one single topic he raised that did not make my jaw drop at his skills, capabilities, and knowledge. I got every bit annoyed at the ankle-biters as much as he did, and I was on the sidelines.

You did not get off scott-free with that gang of self-important fools either, IIRC.

There's a difference between experts and know-it-alls. And then there's the peanut gallery throwing popcorn and empty drink cups.

Glad to be able to once again follow your journey through things that are far beyond my expertise, but I love your curiosity and pursuit, and the analytical process is fascinating. And I have learned some very useful bits along the way.

You won't recall, but you helped me on a few things via PM back in the day.

As Sir Winston always said: KBO

regards,

Kent Bathurst

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#69

Re: David - keep at it

david weaver

Thanks, Kent. I recall that you were one of the few that raised your voice about the quality of content vs. catering to a feel good place (that more or less favors advertisers and continuing to draw in the beginner demographic at the expense of anything substantive).

George talks about design. Nothing sells. George shows his old work, nothing sells. Someone starts an argument about premium planes, and even if it's never settled, a bunch of premium planes sell. I get how that place operates.

George operates at a level that almost nobody ever does. I asked him once what he does with his prototypes since it's hard to build something well the first time, and he said "i generally have pretty good luck with them and don't make duds". :\

I asked him about the brass scraper that shows up in the Williamsburg harpsichord video (seemingly being used to thickness a guitar top, even though that wasn't the topic of the video). He said "It was coarsely made. We needed a scraper and i made it in about an hour" (??). I asked how you make an infill in an hour, and he said: *squash a tube of brass to make the outside oval shape, sweat it onto a sole and do most of the work with a mill (including the infill).

he often says "You need a mill and a lathe". I think the mediocrity of everything that I make would get exposed if I could make it at speed and in numbers.

Long story short, I can only satisfy curiosity and fiddle around with stuff like this topic, and I'm comfortable with that.

(George is fine, by the way. He's just not interested in getting on the internet too much lately. I've always been struck by how willing he is to share information - he likes to - even when you're a piker, as long as you're interested in getting advice from him and trying to get better using it, even if your ceiling is low like mine).

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#70

Kent B

Re: David - keep at it

Kent B

I'm sincerely delighted to hear that George is still around. I jumped on anything he posted. Could not wait for his next reveal. I enjoy being amazed, which carries on to your work.

Yeah - I was on the wrong side of "history" exactly as you recall. Had a PM - not public - hassle with a Mod who was a bully - he even ran off a member who was a preacher, for cryin' out loud. Therefore, I was deemed "unfriendly" by His Lordship, which in all honesty was true with respect to the Politburo Standing Committee. But that was cool - my time and patience were used up by then. Way in my rearview now.

Ima waitin' for your next big thing, David......

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#71

Re: My suspicion...

CJ in MPLS

David:

I don't have any of the data sheets for the steels that you are working with, but if you do, can you tell me whether the basic hardness/toughness data provided lines up with your research, i.e. can one rely upon the basic data and if not, why?

Cheers,

Chris

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#73

Another table from SB

Wiley Horne

http://sb-specialty-metals.com/staticproducts/knife-steels-online-store/

This table includes CTS-XHP. The only other steel I’ve heard of (butso what :( ) in this table is D2, and SB shows XHP tougher, better edge retention, and stainless, compared to D2.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#74

Yes - the confusion without XHP

david weaver

is that many of the charts show A2 and more alloyed, or that and less with a few PMs or D2.

This is one of the few that shows XHP with a whole bunch of things that we've heard of before.

If we see a chart of O1, A2 and a whole bunch of other things up to V9 or T15 or whatever the most highly alloyed stuff is (that doesn't reach the hardness we want in tools), they we don't have a reference for XHP.

I think bill said the other day that he wouldn't mind having chisels made of PD1, and I'd never heard of it. I see from the chart why he'd like to.

My preliminary response to the original question about relying on these charts is, yes, they probably have some valuable information, but first confirmation needs to be made that they have woodworking or edge tools in mind and not square edged dies.

Also, hardness is important information in these. CPM154 looks a lot like XHP in these charts, but it does so at lower hardness than we have in XHP. Once you put the demand for 62 hardness on these irons to limit issues with deflection, etc, then XHP separates itself from 154 by a mile.

Most of the super high toughness steels have constraints on hardness, and the charts show them at a different hardness than we use, and then some of the super wear resistant steels are extremely high in vanadium and may also have low hardness, or low toughness.

204P looks like an interesting thing to try from these charts, but it needs to get to 2100-2200 degrees F before being quenched, and I'm out. I can just barely get the heat needed for XHP.

Someone with a taste for commercial heat treating could use it no problem, but base stock plus time or cost to mill irons plus heat treatment plus grinding afterwards would probably yield some $75-$100 irons that may or may not match the chart.

I'm pretty thankful for the XHP at this point and am ready to just use it.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#75

Odd thing about CTS-XHP wear resistance

Wiley Horne

Until I ground and then honed XHP, I thought that a given steel would respond in a consistent way to all abrasion tests. Not so sure now.

We on this forum reference three different tests of wear resistance: (1)the ASTM data sheets, (2) the resistance to metal removal during sharpening on medium X (oil stone, water stone, etc), and (3) resistance to dulling in use (edge-holding).

XHP seems to excel in items 1 and 3, but is less resistant (in item 2) to honing on natural stones than one would expect. In fact, I found it honed more easily than I expected, because it was fairly resistant to grinding.

Now, during honing (in my case on natural Japanese stones) it did not give up a lot of metal, but it got quickly sharp—in other words, natural stones cut the carbides in XHP, and did not just worry away the matrix.

Question: Is the mechanism of metal removal from XHP the same whether it occurs during ASTM testing, or grinding on CBN, or honing on natural stones, or planing beech? Or does the metal removal mechanism vary according to the challenge?

Wiley