Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Heat balance at plane blade tip

Posts

Heat balance at plane blade tip

#1

Heat balance at plane blade tip

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Neighbor the engineer came by tonight with a model and calculations. (things must be slow at work) The data from the K&K papers provides all the input heat information needed as well as contact area on the blade. Heat generated from the work to push the blade through the wood gets deposited in the wood being planed. Work is required to split the wood apart and the heat from this work for the most part will stay in the wood. Frictional heating from the work to push the blade through the wood is transferred to the blade tip and shaving. We do not know how this heat is proportioned between these heat sinks.

Definition "tip"-the very end of the plane blade

The heat profile on the end of the blade was modeled. It is simply a linear gradient from the tip to the place where the shaving and planed surface ceases contact with the blade, assuming equal heat flux into the blade over this distance. Beyond where the blade no longer touches wood the temperature falls off in a parabolic decay over the length of the bevel. This result means that the maximum temperature of the blade will be found at the very tip, in spite of the fact heat is being deposited along a considerable length of the blade.

If the shaving doesn't carry away a substantial portion of the total heat the blade tip gets very hot. If the shaving carried away no heat the tip would melt.

In thinking about dulling heat is likely a factor.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#2

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

William Duffield

Well, it's been over 50 years since I studied any thermodynamics or calculus, but your engineer's results agree with my intuition. I think they indicate that adjusting the chip breaker cap iron closer to the blade edge or refining its bottom surface for a larger contact area with the back of the blade or increasing its bevel angle to increase its thermal mass near the blade edge would all be ineffective at reducing the final temperature of the blade edge.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#3

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

Wiley Horne

The cap iron works by creating a back-pressure on the shaving; it functions by creating friction. Hence, the closer it is set, you move a friction (and heat) generator closer to the edge. Heat behind the edge, as well as in front.

No idea if this becomes a practical problem. But we have some testimony on these pages from seasoned practitioners who say they have observed the tips of irons lose temper to heat.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#4

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

david weaver

I would imagine based on the pictures that we saw, there is cap iron friction created away from the very edge itself, and that the overall heat created is greater with the cap iron than without. I can't confirm that, but someone willing to do so could easily plane for five minutes with two fresh irons, remove the same volume of wood from the same board and just take a measurement of the cap and the iron 1/4" from the edge with a non-contact thermometer and see what's going on.

The last contact with the wood on the iron is pretty well defined - if you set the cap at a hundredth, it's about 4 thousandths, maybe 3 (we saw that in all of my pictures).

My curiosity with the various irons (and it goes no further than mild curiosity) is whether or not at a supremely thin layer, something is going on that's related to temperature sensitivity with regular planing. Too many variables in real work - maple that warren describes has very good tensile strength in the shavings and the shavings are very smooth. i could see it generating more heat than beech.

The reason my curiosity doesn't go too far is that I wasn't overly deliberate in testing the irons, and the numbers tell us the most important thing (how long just planing wood like you might do in reality).

It's only a single point of extra interest that before this, I'd kind of categorized steels based on their temper temperature, less because of heat planing, but more in being mindful on the grinder. Rob had mentioned V11 as being considered in the same territory due to temper temperature and need for care on the grinder. I got surprised then when I accidentally hardened one of the irons and then thought I could just heat them some (but not up to quench) and anneal them. then, seeing the temper chart for XHP and seeing that it's still C58 at 800 degrees F, it's sort of a situation where you can make it softer by accident, but running all of the temper out by making it just a little hot? Probably not.

Is all of that more important than just testing the planes for durability and not considering all of the factors? Not to me. It is good for someone to know that if they brown the tip of one of those irons a little bit, they should just use it. It's probably still easily usable hardness.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#5

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

William Duffield

So, don't move it any closer to the edge than you need to prevent tearout.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#6

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

Wiley Horne

Good advice!

I was speaking to this as a physics curiosity, not a planing problem.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#7

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

david weaver

I think closer to the edge than that and you'll have feeding problems. I've never noticed edge durability to be a problem with the cap set close, even on old irons.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#8

K&K SEM pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These pictures of wear show where the heat is deposited. Friction causes wear and friction causes heat.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#9

Re: K&K SEM pictures—here they are *LINK*

Wiley Horne

The 6 photos Bill referenced. Wear pattern is shown for chipbreaker angles of 40, 50, 60 degrees; and for chipbreaker setbacks of ~0.004” (100microns) and ~0.008” (200microns). Note wear is deeper and focused more toward the edge, when the breaker is closer (4 thousandths) and steeper (50 and 60 degrees):

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48644915018/in/dateposted-public/

Again, my curiosity here is about the physics of planing. K&K were exploring whether this wear pattern amounted to self-sharpening.

Wiley


K&K SEM photos;  from Steve Elliott’s website

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#10

Re: K&K SEM pictures

david weaver

did K&K quantify the # of feet planed by each of these settings? As in, I recall that the close setting may have failed earlier, but how much earlier?

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#11

Re: K&K SEM pictures *LINK*

Wiley Horne

David,

Yes. The K&K data are below, again referenced from Steve Elliott’s website. The data show horizontal—pushing—force at each setting, and vertical force—whether the blade is pulling itself into the work or trying to push out.

The 4-thou chipbreaker setting, at 50 and 60 degree bevel, stopped pulling into the work at 75meters, compared to 100-150 meters for the other settings. In regard to pushing force required, the 4 thou setting required generally about 40% more push force (quick judgment by eye) than the 8 thou setting, for a given bevel steepness.

The legend is,

—black symbols are 8-thou; hollow symbols are 4 thou

—40, 50, 60 degree bevels are circle, triangle, square respectively

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48647947341/in/dateposted-public/

Wiley


K&K—Horiz and vert forces for chipbreaker settings

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#12

Re: K&K SEM pictures—here they are

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All their papers have SEM pictures of wear and include all the planing parameters.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#13

Re: K&K SEM pictures

david weaver

as I recall, they were taking a shaving of 4 thousandths. That's a bear if you ever match shaving thickness to cap iron set, so I'm not surprised.

8 thousandth is probably in line with a typical smoother set that protects against disaster but doesn't impede pushing that much. 4 thousandths is about as much as a user wants with 50-60 degrees and 8 thousandths.

I used about a hundredth setting (on average) for the tests, and the shavings were worked somewhat at 2 1/2 or 3 thousandths.

Nobody would normally measure that kind of thing, but I had the scope to do it and need to include it in the write-up.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#14

The whole translation/review—for the obsessed *LINK*

Wiley Horne

For the curious......from Steve Elliott’s website:

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html

Wiley


K&K data, with commentary

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#15

The data shown above

Wiley Horne

were obtained with shaving thickness of 2 thousandths (50 microns), in Monarch birch. What I gather from the figures is that experience in using the cap iron will gradually teach one where the sweet spot is going to be for a given shaving thickness and given wood. Also, the sensitivity to bevel angle seemed to back up Warren’s method of rounding the steepness a bit.

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#16

Re: The data shown above

david weaver

Ahh..that's not outside of a realistic planing scenario, though most will find the resistance from a 4 thou cap iron to be something they don't like. It's not hard to set one in that range, though. Just half of "that looks right for general use" and you're there.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#17

Re: The whole translation/review—for the obsesse

Charlie

I see they're showing re-runs at the Bijou...

:-)

Ellis is going to have to rename the forum to include the word "cap iron."

Just kidding, mostly, carry on!

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#18

Re: The whole translation/review—for the obsesse

Mark Hooperl

We can only hope that the tedious mind-numbing recent postings are ending.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#19

Re: The data shown above

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Ahh..that's not outside of a realistic planing scenario, though most will find the resistance from a 4 thou cap iron to be something they don't like. It's not hard to set one in that range, though. Just half of "that looks right for general use" and you're there.


The first time I saw this data I was thinking Kato had no real experience using a plane. I would say this data does not represent a "realistic planing scenario." Almost completely out of practical ranges.

I can say for sure that I have never planed at .002 shaving thickness with the cap iron at .008. The thought makes my arms hurt. And the thought of doing this for 200 meters (656 feet) is worse. Usually we use a more relaxed cap iron setting for heavier shavings like .002.

For this experiment, Kato uses an unusually close cap iron setting, almost outside the practical range. He uses a low angle on the cap iron (40 to 60 degrees). And he uses an overly long time between sharpenings. Altogether not very useful data.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#20

Re: The data shown above

David Weaver

I'm curious about that warren. I didn't really measure any of this until someone brought it up, but in beech, .02 at 8 thousandths is pretty favorable. Increase both of those by 25% and that's about what I ran in the last test. It was very easy favorable planing, and relatively low risk.

I don't know how far away the try plane is set, but it's further off.

I was reading something yesterday, I can't remember how I got there - it was something google returned to me and it sent me to the bottom of one of Paul Sellers' posts, and reading backwards, I realized that it must've been a post where he said the chipbreaker is poorly named because it doesn't have a function other than being paired with the iron. Must be too many classes chiseling off chunks of white pine and sanding it. Or maybe it's just not taught to joiners, which is what I understand his background to be, not cabinetmaking.

At any rate, I can't find too much fault with the settings for an average worker, especially compared to some of the parity settings in the testing (4 thousandth shaving, 4 thousandth set).

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#21

Re: The whole translation/review—for the obsesse

David Weaver

I must've drowned out your contributions to the board, because I've never seen your name on here before.

It's a real inconvenience to the folks who don't contribute when we talk about things related to hand tools on a forum that's called "hand tools".

The same folks who never really reply when someone posts a furniture building thread.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#22

Re: Agree on three points

Steve Voigt

Dave,

I also didn't find those settings to be outside my experience. In nasty QS beech with reversing grain, .001 shavings with the cap set as close as I can get it is not out of the question. On the other hand, if the grain is easy, my default setting is more like .010 and the shavings could be anywhere from 1 to 10 thousandths. So the range is pretty wide.

Agree on PS as well…I've seen that post as well. It also seems like there's no understanding of effective cutting angle in his discussion of BU planes.

On another note, It must be pretty galling to put a ton of work into researching and posting the results here, and then have someone come in and complain about it--someone who doesn't make any contributions of their own, I might add. Does this crap come from YouTube? I can't imagine feeling so entitled that I would complain about the quality of free content, provided by someone who isn't getting paid. Whatever.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#23

Question about setting blade exposure

Wiley Horne

I know you guys aren’t mic’ing the cap iron—you’re relying on experience and gut feel. And probably the shaving itself, which is what I want to ask about.

I’ve been working on proficiency with an LN4 and LN5.5, with the mouth wide open. It seems to me that the shaving itself should tell us what is happening. Now, does the shaving have to be truly straight—no curl—to show that the setting is right for that thickness? Or does a very loose curl (as opposed to a tight curl) also show effectiveness?

Generally,

1. Does the shaving tell all?

2. For a given shaving thickness, is there a predictable pattern of ‘curl behavior’, from tight windings, to loose curls. to a straight shaving?

Wiley

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#24

I used to get fired up...

David Weaver

..I've always had a bad penchant for carrying on a fight, and even more so if I think I might learn something.

But I've noticed that aside from some steady trollers like Charlie, most of the people are transients and there's usually nothing to learn from them. I tried searching the site to see if there was a "Mark Hooperl" in one of the other sections with interesting work, but couldn't find anything. My original assumption that most of those drive by posts were from people who had been there and done that and were too good to worry much about tools, I think that's a pretty small percentage of the time.

Funny you mention beech - the stick that Brian's try plane is made from is one of the more crumbly earlywood sticks I've planed. Nothing weak about it, and it was good density, but the grouchy behavior when you plane it quartered.

Re: Heat balance at plane blade tip

#25

Re: Question about setting blade exposure

David Weaver

I think if the shaving is being worked, you're getting most of the effect. If it's coming out of a plane, not shortened so much (that's a pretty stout set), but just straightening some.

When you plane something like maple (too much recent experience), it'll be 95% super bright and then with a couple of spots of small tearout. You can plane it safely with a set that straightens the chip a little bit and then back the setting off and take your finish passes without changing anything on the plane and be in good shape.

Usually, if you have to resort to putting the cap in office paper distance, you're going to end up with a surface that's a little fuzzy to the touch because some of the fibers are facing right back into the blade. If they lean enough either way otherwise and are packed closely together, the surface is pretty good.

Any work to the shaving (other than allowing the shaving to curl up into a tight curl - no effect), kind of lets you know that nothing catastrophic that would cause you to blow past a mark will happen.