I may have contributed to the notion that the shaving can be a diagnostic tool by a remark I made on this forum, 4/27/12. However, the most important consideration is the surface that is left behind. As you suggest, poor placement results in tear out on the one hand or cloudy surface at the other extreme. The placement is also related to the thickness of shaving. The shavings are slightly different if the planing is done slowly rather than at speed. If the surface is fine, though, nobody cares what the shaving looked like.
These things are much easier for a hand tool woodworker. We start out planing with a jack plane, and already have a good feel for the timber when we set the iron for the trying plane, which should leave a very nice surface. We have some intimacy with the timber and we can make an adjustment again when we smooth at the end.
Thank you both! That is useful. I have in mind finish planing a cross-banded or inlaid surface, where you know you have grain in all directions, plus slight differences in elevation between ground and inlay, and where you want to know that the setting is right before—repeat, before—the first stroke on that surface.
The solution seems to be to just keep a particularly complex test board or test surface on hand, and that test board is your diagnostic. Of course, those experienced with relying on the cap iron would likely be able to skip the test step.
Is there any reason to believe planing is the "best" way to level such a surface?
I don't do a lot of inlay and haven't seen a lot done in shops so I don't know what is commonly done to level inlay. The one example I have hands-on experience with was doing inlay and stringing with Steve Latta. We scraped things level. I saw a cross banding demo with Phil Lowe and the result was scraped.
I don't have any experience with "toothing planes". Weren't they designed for veneer smoothing to deal with unpredictable grain?
Let's discuss "best". For me, with the goal of delivering a product(furniture) to someone, best has numerous factors whose importance depends on the details of the operation. If the operation is done on something where a lot of labor or materials have already been expended reliable becomes the most important factor in "best". Personally I would not risk planing a Federal leg with shell and bell flowers or a figured border of satinwood when scrapping is an equivalent alternative. I would be taking the chance that I could set up a plane to plane tear-out free and not lift a piece of inlay under every circumstance, with no benefit from the decision to plane instead of scrape.
To answer your question on shaving diagnostics. In the K&K tutorial for the students at their tech school, shaving length was the diagnostic. (they are probably being schooled in planing house beams not inlay). When the cap iron was set too close the shaving compressed in length. Left unsaid, however, if the goal is to be 100% sure the inlayed table top with 20 hours of labor in it planes tear-out free and not lift out a piece of inlay, what is the safest setting? Performing final steps on a labor intensive element of building something focuses your mind on avoiding risk.
Toothing planes, as I recall, were designed to scuff veneer. I don't have much experience with inlay but it's one of the things I'd have a fine mouthed plane for, at least initial leveling.
I've seen george scuffing veneer in his harpsichord video, and never did mention much to him about it. I know the round scraper that's shown in that video where marcus or larry is thicknessing a guitar top is something that george purpose made quickly (think infill scraper made in about an hour).
Why does everyone want to do everything the hard way? When there's a mention of Colonial Williamsburg, I get it that people see the single iron planes there and want to do it like the museum does it, but the museum put a constraint on the staff that the rest of the world doesn't have (not allowed to use double irons because the curators determined that they weren't common enough there in the 18th century).
About a month ago, I planed three ribboned guitar bodies. Stanley 4, washita. A minute or two each after jointing them. One was khaya (the crumbliest of the bunch) and the other two were honduran.
I don't read FWW (not much on tools or guitars), but that guy's got real creds. Such a simple thing to learn, and he's forgoing it for who knows what reason.
I have used a plane for this type of work for almost forty years.
In many woodworking operations the skill is to quickly get close to the final form and then more delicately finish up. In carving, for example, being able to rough out quickly is where you make your money. In ripping you want to saw very near the line so there is not much planing work, and in bringing a board to thickness you want to get very close to the line with the jack plane before using a trying plane.
In this case I would take a different approach. I would set the iron very fine and take my time about bringing things level. You want to sharpen often because the edge is subject to all kinds of discontinuities: edges of inlay, glue lines, grain changes etc. which are rough on the edge. The sharper the iron, the cleaner the cut.
For suggestions on this type of work I would go to OWWM.org and go to the woodworking site and look at the work of Bill Thomas who goes by the moniker of cabinets2inlay. His work is simply off scale both in quality and complexity. Look at his current project Roentgen Desk. It's currently at 113 pages, and 1690 post with hundreds of pictures of how the inlay is made along the veneer and desk assembly.
Here is an example of the inlay work.
If you go to the site you can see that the stringing is a series of half moons.
You will need to join OWWM to access to the wood working site.
Dave, Bill Pavlak is now the head of the Hay shop at Williamsburg. He's perfectly well aware of what double irons can do, but you're right that they have historically been considered out of bounds at the Hay shop. Whether that's accurate is an open question; we know that double irons were being sold in Philly in the 1760s, but did they make it to the southeastern tip of Virginia before the war started? We may never know.
In any case, I wouldn't be surprised to see Bill allow double irons into their shop at some point, but in the mean time everything they do and demonstrate is within the bounds of single iron technology.
Toothing planes were used with a dual purpose. For veneering, the glue side of both veneer and substrate would be toothed, often with two different blades (with different tpi, for example 25 tpi on one surface and 18 on the other).
Toothing planes were also used to combat difficult grain, either on the show side of veneer, or in solid wood. The toothed surface would then be scraped. This method predated the double iron but I believe it was used after as well.
Wiley, I don't have a ton to add, but I'm a fan of using a test board--I wrote about that in my M & T article. IIRC you have some 55° planes, right? I suggest finding a piece of scrap that the 55 can't deal with, then see if you can't do better with the cap iron. The results should be illuminating.
Yes - I haven't followed who is at CW now that George, Peter, Mack, etc. are all out. Looking at the other articles cleared that up.
Even so, using a toothing plane on figured grain reminds me of one of my first math proof classes.
Our first assignment was a relatively routine proof (i don't remember what it was at this point, just the rules). It was made more complicated in that we were only allowed to assume that +-/x had been proven and we could rely on nothing else.
It made it a real pain in the rear. I don't think I ever proved it, and while I was in office hours in a linear programming class, I posed it to one of the professors there, and drew a crowd of other younger professors who became enamored with trying to prove it without using what they knew.
I'm not sure anyone in the class did, actually. The group of professors could easily prove it, but not without other later proofs.
Buying an old toothing plane to potentially do a small test board like that is one thing. Buying an old toothing plane to put it in regular rotation for deep tearout on full pieces would lead to "plane on shelf disorder". It reminds me of that class because something others found really easy was made artificially far more difficult.
There was another video of CW on youtube where I saw one of the curators showing someone very deliberately planing a piece of mahogany - just rough lumber to be used. The curator said that they budgeted an hour per board foot to bring rough lumber to finished. I can't imagine that was right or even close to historically accurate, but the guy in the background was accommodating with his pace. I live in a vacuum, and when I see things like that either being milked or done with artificial constraints, it baffles me a little more easily. In 2006, I wouldn't have questioned either, because i hadn't been through the "Training by laziness" that working through a bunch of rough lumber provides.
Insert time for a troll reply here about how much better of a woodworker those guys are than me (I'm sure that's true times 10..which is what makes it even more baffling).
While I understand your interest in this topic, these discussions are more akin to a theological debate than anything scientific.
While a multi-variate model of whatever you are testing is probably unrealistic, I am very interested to learn whether you plan to publish your data and results in a more comprehensive fashion? Further, what conclusions do you plan to draw from your investigations?
I wanted to see exactly what a given setback looks like. Here’s what I did....I folded a piece of white note paper and mic’ed it—7.5 thousandths at double thickness. Then found a sorta fat Post-It that mic’ed at 5 thousandths.
Then got 2 planes ready, LN4 w/PMV11 and LN5.5 w/Elliott 3V. Sharpened irons to pass the newsprint test. Capirons at a rounded 50 degrees.
Set the capiron setbacks: Joined blade and cap iron with screw only finger tight. LN4 bladeset stood up on 7.5 thou folded paper; tapped the iron through the paper to the benchtop underneath, with capiron staying on top of paper, and tightened screw. So now there’s a 7.5thou setback on the LN4. It looked just like how I have been setting intuitively.
Then repeated this operation with the Post-It, to get a 5thou setback on the LN5.5. Visually, that looked like the tightest practical setback I would ever attempt in real life.
Just out of curiosity, I retrieved a partially inlaid Federal leg. When I made this table,
I started with 5 leg blanks, figuring I would make my learning mistakes on the first blank, then the other 4 blanks would be for-real.
So I tried three planes out on this unfinished ‘learning’ leg. The LN4 w/7.5thou setback and 2 thou shaving; the LN5.5 w/5thou setback and 1.5thou shaving; and a Konrad Sauer 50-degree A5 (capiron retracted, tight mouth) and 1-thou shaving.
Planed the upper leg section, first photo with the grain and second photo against the grain. The grain is laying at ~14 degrees. The result:
Pretty uninteresting. No tearout. The various gaps revealed are either unfinished inlay or sloppy gouge work. [The inlay was done by gouge only: the pattern was dug into the leg with gouges, and the same gouges were used to cut the inlay pieces from the veneer sheets—if you do it right, you have an exact fit.]
Oh, and one other thing...the shavings at 2thou, 1.5 thou, and 1 thou, with or against the grain, all stayed curled—shaving had no diagnostic value within this range.
Conclusion: To do this in real life again with fresh inlay, I would first wait a day until the hot hide glue has fully set and the surrounding wood has dried and shrunk back to normal. Then file any protruding edges more or less flat. Then lay on shellac to glue down any loose ends. Candlewax on the plane soles, to reduce friction so I can feel the blade engage and cut.
Then plane with either LN at 1thou with 5thou setback, or with the infill. Should be no difficulty. But it all starts with having a mental image of what the setback should look like.
Your numbers come up to what I measured with the microscope against a piece of wire known to be 7 thousandths in diameter.
Early discussions centered around trying to get sets based on shims, but it's not necessary. Setting the cap right on the edge and then "just until you see a glint of light)" will easily yield something like 4 thousandths and then "a little bit more space than that" will double it. The two are discernibly different and one with less experience (like me) will end up settling around there with a smoother because it's safe.
I mentioned the closed mouth (And warren the thin shaving), not because tearout might be an issue, but because breakout of fibers on the ends of pieces obviously could be. The one thing where a cap iron is not an asset is planing across grain and rolling fibers off. Ends of boards with bad grain also present this, where the resistance of pushing a chip, even a little bit, can plane the very edge off of such a board.
It's sort of a false dilemma in that case, because you wouldn't want to work dovetails into such a board, either. They'd have no strength and cutting / paring sockets in half blinds in wood like that is miserable.
..was just to see if we could prove or disprove lee valley's comments about blade life, and update some of the older information about blade life along with it, since we'd have context with well known blades.
That turned out to be pretty easy to prove. In good wood (not to say that in less than good wood, it's not true - we didn't test that), LV's steel does actually last about twice as long as what's typically available (good O1 and good A2) and in wide use.
Bill is fascinated more with the details of why that is, I just wanted to know what is, and some of the follow up-stuff (this heat discussion will never appear in any paper) is just forum fodder. The kind of stuff that someone else may publish in detail (as in a metallurgist, or someone enthusiastic about such thing), but I know far too little about it and won't even post suppositions about planing, which I know more about than the average individual. It went to unexpected places for me - again, unrelated to anything that will be published - in that I'm replacing all of my metal plane irons with XHP. I could speak to doing that for anyone interested, but I would bet that number is zero - I'm more than willing to walk through what i did to make a plane iron if anyone thinks they will, but I think it's easy for people to say "I'd try to make one if you show your process", and then most would say "I changed my mind". We did learn because of that that it's likely that someone who considers v11 to be too hard to sharpen with natural stones will find it quite good if they put it in an accurate oven at 400-415 degrees. LV may not like it if you do that, but you might.
Long story short, all of the details about duration and sharpenability are done, they will be posted in a paper with pictures online. Supposing things that can't be proved (like beyond number of feet and weight of shavings), that's not going to be published. The result is a surprise, but understanding the variables involved is minutiae that won't change them and it won't be published. Going beyond just those simple results and pictures is something that a typical reader just won't be able to do anything with (heat at tip, etc), but knowing that you're getting your money's worth with a V11 iron for an extra ten bucks - people will be able to grasp that.
Experimenting with XHP will be left out, too. It disappears quickly here and is no threat to someone chasing down supply and making substandard irons and trading on LV's work, but in a paper that google can search neatly due to lots of clicks, it becomes a threat.
Actually, google brought me the information that I wanted in the form of XRF from an old SMC post by patrick chase, but I doubt most people would run into that, either.
You may also find the chinese irons pretty interesting given their (price $7 to $11) and the fact that they really only come up short against V11 and M4.
It's an unfortunate rabbit hole search that everything devolves into. I'd spare everyone (or at least half of it) if there was a lot of other content on this forum, but the interesting thing is that when there isn't minutiae on this forum, it seems to crap out entirely. I think that's a shame. I enjoy looking at other peoples' work, but expect that mine (which is almost entirely making tools and guitars) won't interest many people.
If someone was making danish modern furniture and trying to do it with hand tools, I'll admit, I'd fall off of my chair backwards snoring. I respect the talent (derek had a nice series on trying to make a machine made chair by hand, and it was expertly done) and dedication that it takes to do those things, but when you're not thinking you'd want to do the same thing, then the same as what happens with our discussion of minutiae (it only appeals to a few people).
We all live in a world full of tags now, and if more than 5 people were interested in the discussion of plane iron steels beyond "how many feet planed", I'd be surprised. Most people who don't contribute anything will get upset when they see a bunch of posts and then get upset that they're not interesting to them, but in some cases, people having a bad day are just looking for something to have a problem with in the first place. I can't stop that.
Tags would be nice. I'd have slapped the "minutiae tag" on all of this that wasn't just "how many feet did each iron go". And even that elicited a negative response from a couple of people who don't like LV for no real legitimate reason.
Often, the rabbit holes are searched in the background, but this one's being searched almost in a streaming to text mode. It's overload unless you're one of the five interested.
On the bright side, the answer that I thought would be potentially inconsistent to figure out or with ambiguous results was crystal clear, and some interesting applicable side things came about (V11 planes for a long time. It's probably worth sharpening to a finer edge if it doesn't take too much extra time, and the big shocker to me was a drastic difference in planing resistance from one iron to the next. Some feel slick, others not at all). That'll be written up in a much clearer manner.
Some day, I'll get kicked off for following too many branches on the tree all the way to the end, but the disgruntled will just disappear then, because they're not here to contribute, anyway.
(none of that is in direct relation to your post - I get exactly where you're coming from - what's the alcohol at the end of the distillation process and where can I get the bottle without having to know how it was made or diverging into soldering methods?)
We'll probably discuss them at the next CJWA meeting, as well. John Aniano, Brian Holcombe and Wilbur Pan will probably be there. It won't be a formal presentation to the whole membership, because a lot of the others would be bored to tears, for sure. But I find that most people are bored to tears with most of the really important stuff, anyhow.
It will take one graph and 2 minutes explanation to summarize David's blade metal results. Either you are planning on more verbiage than necessary or your group has less attention span than the average teen ager.
And, why is it that knife enthusiasts are passionately interested in the metals their blade is made from and supposedly planing enthusiasts are not?
Do I understand your clever means of setting the cap iron? The paper prevents the cap iron from penetrating the thickness, while the blade slices through and stops at .....something? If so it seems like the cap iron edge is going to compress the paper somewhat and the blade is going to penetrate whatever stops it but good fortune would result in these errors being equivalent.
Did you see any visual difference in the surface from planing uphill vs down hill?
What does the surface of the stringing section look like that I suppose was planed orthogonal to the grain direction?
When we made Federal legs with Steve Latta we used white glue and the inlay and string were scraped shortly after installation. When scraping the cross banded string the scraper leveled it at and angle such that we were not scraping across the grain. The result was not favorable scraping across the grain.
Having proven it can be done in this situation what advantage did you find of plane over scraping?
These days, I spend most of my unproductive Internet/phone time on Instagram, both as a poster and a viewer. If people want to see furniture projects, or beautiful shots of anything (tools, instruments, bowls, etc), that is the place to go. Want to see the awesome stuff that Brian Holcombe is cranking out? Go to Instagram. It's also a good place for quick-hit tips, things that can be explained in a paragraph, and shown in a few pics or a 30 second video.
What it's not is a place for detailed discussion, or argument, or long form presentation of intricate stuff like Dave's planing studies. The widespread resurgence of the cap iron that started 7 years ago wouldn't have happened there.
Forums are pretty much dead though. The main ones in the U.S., which I won't name, have become almost a complete loss through mismanagement, lack of interest or both. But I'm glad this one is hanging on, because it's got a small core of very knowledgeable folks. I don't care if only a tiny number of people are reading; I'm happy to carry on an occasional conversation with people who know what they're talking about. It's fine with me if the content sometimes becomes overly arcane or tends toward minutae.
It’s sort of a combat method, and yes you got it right. The blade goes thru the paper with a tap, and bottoms out on a hard maple benchtop. The blade is 2 or more inches wide, so it doesn’t even make a visible dent. The cap iron is loose enough against the blade that it is not pulled down. Well, it’s a ballpark method, and I shouldn’t have used a decimal place , but as you say the errors tend to offset.
The main advantage of this method is that it is immediate, once you get the paper mic’ed. Anybody with a mic can do it fast, and get a visual memory of what a 7-8thou setback looks like. It’s bigger than you might think. If you don’t have a mic, ordinary garden variety Post-Its are close to 4 thou. The Truth: I was too lazy to go undo the Starrett thickness gauge leaves, and pull out the right ones to stand the cap iron on. That would have gotten an exact answer.
I didn’t notice a surface difference between uphill and downhill, but surely the downhill was brighter—the thing is, I was planing over the previous result, so had no side by side comparison. Blade was perfectly sharp, so the difference in push force was not noticeable either.
I couldn’t do final planing on the string section (the taper section). The table, shown here,
has legs with an ebony ankle band and a spade foot below. That foot is integral. So you don’t have a clean run with a plane. What I did.....wait a day for everything to dry out, including wood abutting the channels, then (1) skewed scraper to remove most of the liquid hide glue squeeze out, (2) skewed LN shave to level any remaining string and glue still above grade, (3) file to detail, esp. the bottom down around the ebony bead and spade foot.
In other hands, the whole tapered section could have been scraped to final; but I was afraid of scraping swales on my first attempt, so used the LN shave to maintain as much level as possible. Also eased the arrises with 220g as I went so as not to tear out a splinter there with scraper or shave.
The horizontal string was done with scraper and file, as you say at an angle so as to cut it rather than grab it. Sandpaper tends to blur the edges of stringing and inlay—has to be cut with a tool to get a sharp result.