Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tormek: getting old wheel off?

Posts

Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#1

Tormek:  getting old wheel off?

Wiley Horne

Welp, my new CBN wheel for Tormek came today. Job 1 is getting the old wheel off. The arbor looked shiny and bright, and the nut came right off, no problem.

The old wheel would not budge. First resort was to get Tormek on its side with arbor pointed to the sky, and get PB blaster into the little well around the arbor. Try to loosen things up...

After an hour or two, I got impatient and tried several dubious clamping, reverse clamping, wedging tricks, involving clamps, pry bars, big screw drivers, hammer...nothing, nada. I thought, what would David do? It came to me that David would get a bigger hammer, get his game face on, and bash the old wheel to smithereens, and then ship the machine to a friend :) . Rejected that for the moment.

So I tilted it up again. Added more PB blaster, and came here to try to get smarter, then get a fresh start tomorrow morning. Sitting here defeated, it occurs that if I were to get the arbor disconnected from the motor drive and bearings or bushings, whatever its got, and pull it out of the machine with the old wheel still on it, it would be simple to separate old wheel from arbor.

Question: Anybody here ever pulled the arbor out of a Tormek?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#2

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

Which Tormek (year) do you have? Older ones (such as my 2000) often did not have a SS shaft, and would rust onto the wheel. It does not sound like that with yours, but some mild corrosion seems present. What can you use to free the corrosion? I would have through PB Blaster would do it. Otherwise, can you focus heat on the shaft, and let the expansion break the seal?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#3

Similar to pulling rusted car wheels

Jim Matthews

If you can get a large "punch" or clevis pin from your hardware store, judicious tapping with a beefy hammer should move things along.

Don't fix the motor to anything immobile or clamp it down.

I would turn the works sideways, suspended by the stuck wheel.

A sheet of 5/8" plywood, cut in half with a notch to fit around the shaft should do.

Put something soft under the works for when it drops free.

*****

If you're more inclined to gentle persuasion, consider O'Reilly's autoparts yo rent a "can puller".

https://images.app.goo.gl/8yQxBtyH6AsFFEgu5

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#4

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off?

david weaver

Unfortunately, I don't have a suggestion. i twice got a wheel off of the tormek, cleaned it up *should've put much oil on it between each, but didn't*, and then put another wheel on.

The last time I tried to get the black wheel off, it was stuck too hard, and I didn't break it on purpose. It just broke due to repeated tapping, levering, etc. I wish I'd have known that it was going to break, as i'd have just broken it from the outset and saved myself a lot of pinched fingers and hand soreness.

The big issue at the time was after having trouble getting wheels off twice, I'd purchased the stainless arbor kit (which I thought was kind of ridiculous to have to pay for) and Tormek's suggestions around the rusted wheel weren't helpful. I thought somewhat evasive at the time "we've fixed the problem for you by offering this kit now that you can buy" .

(OK, I've bought a machine and three different wheels, and a bunch of attachments. I guess I don't rise to the level of being more than someone that you can just sell things at).

The other wheels when they'd rusted ,seemed like they wouldn't come off, then they slowly broke loose and then slowly got more loose until I could turn them reasonably and get them off.

The rust inside the shaft combined with an abrasive wheel that can really grip it even after it's been broken loose a little bit is a huge problem.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#5

Re: Similar to pulling rusted car wheels

Wiley Horne

Hi Jim,

I’ll try the low-tech plan first, using a couple of plywood slabs or more likely thin steel bars to suspend the whole apparatus by the stuck wheel`, then try to break the seal by punching on the arbor end.

If that doesn’t work, will look into the can puller, although this is a 10-inch wheel so .......

Thanks very much for a good plan.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#6

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off?

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

Gonna try Jim Matthews’ plan, using 2 lengths of flat steel welding stock to suspend the machine. If that fails, will drive in pry bars from opposing sides, and either break the wheel loose, or break the wheel. I have the notion I won’t be needing that wheel anymore, so it’s kind of a sunk cost now anyway.

Thanks for sharing your experiences—it’s all learning.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#7

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel of littl

Joe Shelton

This may be too little too late, but I think Kroil is way better than PB Blaster for penetrating and loosening.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#8

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel of littl

Wiley Horne

Joe,

Gotta go to Lowes anyway to get the other stuff—will get Kroil while I’m there. Or drop by HD or Ace if Lowes doesn’t have.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#9

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off?

E Phillip Smith

Went to Tormek site. Looks like you can easily pull shaft. Should be able to pull shaft with wheel on, then you can press wheel off shaft in arbor press with plenty of support so you don't break wheel. See link for video for pulling shaft.

https://www.tormek.com/usa/en/spare-parts/shafts/msk-250-stainless-steel-shaft/

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#10

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

Wiley Horne

Hi Phil,

Excellent advice! And straightforward search work I should have done myself.

As it is, I just got through hanging the whole apparatus by the wheel, and hammering the arbor. It worked, though took some force, however the Si carbide wheel ended up with surface fracturing about 3/16” deep on the exit side. Might be usable but I’m not going to fool with it—it’s in the trash right now.

For anyone else: follow Phil’s link to Tormek and pull the arbor with the wheel on it.

The good part: the CBN wheel on Tormek is pretty close to a no-brainer. I just ground a 2-1/2” wide M2 iron with half the hollow gone. No water—the water reservoir has been retired. Ground at about 25 degrees by eye. I took it easy on the pressure, and it took something less than a minute to grind to a strong burr. There was no heat (above body temp) that I could feel. It would have taken me 5 minutes with the Si carbide wheel, because there would have been 1 or 2 stops to run the diamond truer across the wheel to restore cutting (Si carbide cuts fast initially, but is insanely friable).

The 200 grit wheel seems right as a grind stone—I would not want a finer and slower wheel, since all honing is done after grinding to a burr. I used a 1200grit Atoma, then a 8000 grit DMT for the M2. Then hit it a lick with chromium green.

This experience convinces me that if I want another set-up, it will be Derek’s rig—half speed grinder + CBN + Tormek or One-Way tool rest/holder. And if I were starting from scratch, it would be that rig, not Tormek.

Phil, again, thank you for your effort. It is not in vain because I’m sure there will be more Tormeks with stuck wheels.

And thanks to Derek, Jim, David, and Joe as well.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#11

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

david weaver

glad to hear that the outcome was good, Wiley.

The wheels are still usable despite looking like an exit hole in ballistic gelatin. I doubt you'll have any incentive to use them going forward now that you have CBN.

Your CBN will lose a little bit of its snort (maybe) in the near future, but will then settle in. Mine lost its brashness in a month or two of intermittent use, but I can't say (on a high speed grinder) that I've noticed any real degradation since.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#12

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

Jonathan Elliott

Thanks for sharing Wiley, interesting to hear about your success and another positive very experience with CBN plus the minimum steps needed after.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#13

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

John Aniano in Central NJ

Wiley,

Can you again tell us which CBN wheel you bought (diameter, width) and where you got it and the $$$ ? Your post stated it is a 200 grit wheel, right?

Are there other realistic alternatives? David was suggesting getting them on eBay from China...

I might consider doing this myself. My 10" Tormek wheel after 20 years is just under 9" now. And still slow cutting...

John

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#14

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

Wiley Horne

Hi John and all,

Here is my new wheel:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48554811216/in/dateposted-public/

Note there is no water. In fact, you cannot use water, because bad things happen. Otherwise the wheel is guaranteed for the duration. There is no maintenance. There is no heat. Yayy.

I ordered my wheel from Wood Turners Wonders, proprietor Ken Rizza:

https://woodturnerswonders.com/collections/tormek-style-wheels

Mine is the wheel on the left, the cheaper one. There is a more expensive one, at $300, which gives you a side surface when you want to grind flat. The wheel I got is a perfect fit to the arbor, no play or slop. The wheel in action has no wobble, it runs true.

You’ll notice the grits are 200, 400,...,1000, 1200, for both wheels. You specify when ordering. Derek or David are better respondents on the different grits; for me, Tormek is a grinder, and 200 is perfect because it’s fast, even on Tormek.

I was impressed with Ken Rizza; he shipped the day I ordered or the next morning, and it got here in 2 days from Georgia. He also states if you want anything special done, to call him, and I get the definite impression he’ll get right to it.

I don’t know if there are other vendors offering CBN for Tormek.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#15

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, you did well. And your set up looks good. I might go for that same wheel if I decide to renovate my Tormek (which needs a new case, as this is rusted away).

The solid alloy wheel has a large flat area on the side, and its advantage over the one you have (which is laminated) is the ability to flatten blade backs.

As I mentioned elsewhere, the standard Tormek wheel grinds at 220 grit, therefore a 200 grit wheel should be a little faster. The machine rotates at 90 rpm, and heat is not an issue. Water is unnecessary.

For turners, many combine 180 grit and 600 grit wheels on a bench grinder. Heat is created on the faster machines, but the blades tend to be HSS and impervious to this.

There is now also a diamond wheel for the Tormek, which has been produced by Tormek - it appears that they are recognising the threat to their machine, which has relied on burnless grinding, but at the expense of speed. At this slow speed, diamond grinding is safe, that is, the diamond should last as long as CBN. I wonder if we see a new generation of Tormek grinders built specifically for CBN or diamond?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#16

Re: Tormek:  getting old wheel off

Wiley Horne

Hi Derek,

Excellent analysis. It certainly does seem that Tormek is hearing footsteps.

I would like to add one point on their new diamond wheels, which sell for $300-330 on Amazon, and which have a big side surface for flat grinding. In regard to the use of water, versus dry grinding, Tormek says the following:

“Included with every diamond wheel is 150 ml ACC-150 Anti-Corrosion Concentrate. Always use the concentrate in the water when sharpening with water to prevent rust on the grinding wheel. Add 10 ml of concentrate to 250 ml water (~ 4%). We recommend to always use water when sharpening with the diamond wheel, as it prolongs the life of the wheel and provides a finer surface. It is also possible to sharpen without water. ”

So they include enough anti-corrrosive for 15 sharpening episodes, and you can replace that bottle for $50. (five-oh). Or grind dry and take your chances on wearing out the wheel.

One other point: I find the CBN way faster than the original Tormek AlOx wheel, though the grit ratings are similar at 180 vs 200, and that is before you get to alloy steel.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#17

Fear of heat- not an issue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It seems that the main reason some are willing to spend hundreds of dollars to be able to hollow grind a tool, and not very hollow on a 10" wheel, is to avoid heating the tool excessively. For those that don't have a several hundred dollar grinder budget there is an alternative.

Yesterday I was getting a #2 plane ready for sale. The blade was out of square and not hollow ground. The fastest way to correct that problem and establish a hollow was on the grinder. 3600 rpm, 120 grit wheel of the proper specification. 7- 1 second passes passes across the crowned wheel and DONE. Less than a minute elapsed time. ( a more resistant blade like V11 would have taken 2-3 times as many 1 second passes.)

I have modest hand too skills. Yet, I can grind anything with this set up. I have taught numerous people in the club to grind on this set up and they were all successfully grinding Stanley blades in short order. Ditto for Smith posting above.

Anyone not successful has not followed directions- crowned soft bond wheel(ideally pink), sweeping light passes. The "white" wheel that came on your grinder is not soft enough. Norton 3X wheels are not soft enough. The LV white wheel is barely soft enough. You will need to order the proper wheel from a tool supply place- Travers, MSC, etc. But for 1/20 the price you will be successful.

The problem I used to have and I think many others have is the plane or chisel is thrust straight into a flat wheel, thereby heating the 3/4" of bevel all at once. The proper technique is to use sweeping passes on a crowed wheel. 1/2" wheel is wide enough.

My friend's Tormek, that otherwise now sits unused, was exceptional for sharpening sheep shears.

These things come with a silicon carbide wheel?! Why? It is well known that silicon carbide crushes easily to a finer particle size. It is therefore not a good abrasive for hard tool steels like we are grinding.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#18

Re: Fear of heat- not an issue *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The problem I used to have and I think many others have is the plane or chisel is thrust straight into a flat wheel, thereby heating the 3/4" of bevel all at once. The proper technique is to use sweeping passes on a crowed wheel. 1/2" wheel is wide enough.

Joel wrote a wonderful article for FWW magazine in 2008 on the use of a crowned wheel (which he learned from Barry Iles of Ashley Iles Edge Tools). As you note Bill, the advantage of a crowned wheel is that it restricts a blade heating up excessively. Indeed, Joel cautioned against a high speed 8" bench grinder, preferring the lower surface speed of a 6" to further lower heat.

But that was 10 years ago, and technology has changed. The alloy CBN wheels offer a cool grind. In fact, a camber is not needed on these wheels, as it was on the vitreous types.

My thought about the old wheels is that they wore unevenly, and running a blade across a supposedly "flat" face would cause a part of the blade to dig in/catch. This is what caused burning. The CBN wheel, on the other hand, does not go out of flat, and it is quite difficult to have the blade catch in this manner (I'm sure that one could if you try hard enough !).

Regards from Perth

Derek


In just seconds, get a tool ready for honing

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#19

All these problems aren't

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why are you offering Joel, who ever he is, as a source of wisdom? Joel, the "expert" in grinding cautions against a high speed grinder and advocates a 6" wheel. If Joel didn't talk about wheel composition and bond hardness in his teaching of how to grind tool steel (not to be confused with "high speed tool steel") he lacked the knowledge to teach the topic. I agree that slower speed is easier to learn on.

But the fact that many in our area that have been shown it works can grind successfully on my set up, or Phil Smith's, suggests that Joel lacked some knowledge or experience in the topic he taught. Maybe it would be best to listen to someone that isn't experiencing heat for advice on how to avoid it, inexpensively.

It is wonderful that the $100+ wheel on a $300+ Tormek doesn't heat or need camber. Neither does my $30 wheel on a grinder most have anyway for lawnmower blades and other uses. It is simply a matter of what one is willing to spend to put a hollow on a tool bevel. Both work fine.

I am not ignorant of the CBN wheel. I used one in a class. It offered no advantage over what I do, for what I do, so I saw no reason to spend a pile of money to own one.

CBN has two potential advantages for those that could benefit- doesn't shed grits, and shape stays the same with use without maintenance. Are there others? Don't cite cool for it offers no advantage for cool for those that know how to use conventional wheels.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#20

Re: Fear of heat- not an issue

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

There can be no doubt that the solution you put forward is the low-cost solution. This is a very significant benefit for many. I would encourage anyone considering investing in a grinder to read your comprehensive ‘how to, and why’ in Articles at this site. A competent 3600rpm grinder and wheel can be had for a fraction of the cost of the options we have been discussing in this and related threads. It does require touch and know how to avoid blade-burning, which is why reading your article is a must.

Question: Finding the right wheel will be a head-scratcher for many. Can you be specific, or provide an actual link, to where one can find a 6”, 7”, or 8” wheel, or crowned wheel, of the proper softness? I did a quick check of MSC, and the softest wheel I could find was K—it may be I didn’t look hard enough.

I also went to Travers Tool, and could only find wire wheels. Again, the fault lies with me I’m sure. However, I suspect others would have the same problems searching for an H or I wheel. Or crowned wheel of a stated softness.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#21

I did find this I wheel

Wiley Horne

6” or 8” I wheel by Norton:

https://www.sharpeningsupplies.com/Norton-3X-Blue-Grinding-Wheel-I-Grade-P37.aspx?gclid=Cj0KCQjwy97qBRDoARIsAITONTIHfQNmcH4nk0-ipwyUjbWuNfCtg0GscPcvsWYCq-95XNzhC59AANEaAmgEEALw_wcB

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#22

You have identified the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If it ain't in a woodworking catalog people are at a lost as to where to find it. I'll see what I can do...Irrigating now.......Need rain locally

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#23

already equipped vs. not

David Weaver

If you're already equipped, this is a lot like getting plane irons with new steel in them, because they really don't offer anything functional (for example for me) than a stock stanley iron (equipped assumes that you can sharpen in a minute and a half or are willing to work toward it).

If you're not equipped, or you're not willing to work toward the sharpening goal, then maybe V11 is worth it.

For me, I'd not suggest any older wheels over a budget CBN wheel ($99). What often follows even the lower grade wheels is diamond tools to true them, balancing kits, all kinds of stuff. If someone is productive and using a lot of hand tools, they'll wear out soft wheels. I won't wear out CBN, probably. If I do, it will pay for itself in wheels in the interim, but have the advantages you mention. No shaping a wheel and no loose grit.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#24

Problem 2

David Weaver

If you can manage to get woodworking suppliers to carry a wheel setup like you recommend, it'll be 50% more expensive than anything else.

Woodworkers are a captive audience. Thus, we get things like replacement of ezelap hones (USA) with overpriced trend hones (my opinion - $150 for a "kit" including a chinese made diamond hone) and goofy things like water treatment liquid.

You'd have to have a one off reference for woodworkers to buy somewhere else, and that never really makes much of a dent. A few people will use it, but someone new to wheels would be making a mistake to use your setup over an econo CBN wheel. Not a critical mistake, but a mistake nonetheless.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#25

What this wheel is, technical data, flawed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Norton developed seeded gel (ceramic) abrasives for tool room grinding of tool steel. They fracture to provide sharp particle edges while maintaining the grit size. Hence, harder wheels can be used with less heat generation. These wheels are expensive.

Somebody at Norton got the idea to offer a wheel with 30% of this stuff mixed with "normal" grit and sell it as a less expensive consumer product in a K hardness wheel. I was involved in the evaluation. They sucked for chisels and plane blades. Too hard. I could not prevent burning at 3600 rpm. I suggested they might be good for lathe tools and I suppose they eventually got marketed to this group.

Unknown to me they now offer an H grade wheel. But it is still flawed for it only solves part of the heat issue. This wheel is wastefully wide at 1". Used effectively one will be using 3/8 of its width.

I don't know if one where to jam a 3/4" chisel into the full width of this wheel whether it would burn our not. But if it did don't report that what I do doesn't work. Crowned, soft wheel, back and forth passes. One has to listen to everything required.