Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tormek: getting old wheel off?

Posts

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#26

David, please link us to

Wiley Horne

The econo $99 CBN wheel. I don’t doubt you for a second, but am suggesting we get very specific in our proposals.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#27

Please listen, more issues that aren't......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What often follows even the lower grade wheels is diamond tools[tool] to true them [[$15, I prefer the Tee tool],

balancing kits, [I don't have any nor have I recommended]

all kinds of stuff. [I don't have any other stuff]

If someone is productive and using a lot of hand tools, they'll wear out soft wheels. [I likely make more stuff than anyone on this Forum and I have not come close to wearing out a wheel I paid $20 for 10 years ago.]

No shaping a wheel [I recrown once in a while, 15 seconds]

and no loose grit. [could be a deal beaker for some, maybe most.

I'll give you 2 out of 7 points. The data has been presented. Now add to my column $30 or less vs $99 or more and let the bystanders make their choices.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#28

Re: David, please link us to

David Weaver

https://woodturnerswonders.com/collections/spartan-affordable-cbn-wheel-1

It appears that they're $109 now.

Of course, the ultra cheap could get a chinese wheel, and the wheel surface itself is probably just as good, but they have arbor sizes that would necessitate a very accurate bushing.

For the extra $50, I'd get the wheel from vince - I found him as forthright as you. Actually, he had a wheel on ebay with damage at the back edge of the radius. It was something like $125, and the radius wheel he has now was the price it is now. I somehow missed the end of the auction due to inattention and he sent me a message through ebay to buy the wheel through his page and he'd refund me the difference. There was no reason he needed to offer that, but he did.

(eyeballing ebay again, there are econo 6" wheels now for $51, but still with a large center arbor that would only suit someone with a lathe and the desire to make a bushing. Actually, even that wouldn't be difficult for me to do with corian offcuts chucked in a wood lathe, but i'm not sorry I bought a wheel from vince).

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#30

Did it.  Here are 2 extensive sources:

Wiley Horne

https://www.travers.com/surface-grinding-wheels/c/297966/

https://www.mscdirect.com/browse/tn/Abrasives/Grinding-Cutoff/Grinding-Cutoff-Wheels/Surface-Grinding-Wheels?navid=12100094

Some may need a source for bushings.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#31

Re: Did it.  Here are 2 extensive sources:

E Phillip Smith

Both Travers and MSC sell reducer bushings.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#32

Re: Please listen, more issues that aren't......

David Weaver

I used about half an inch of pink wheel per year. Albeit I am covering far more feet per year than most combined workers, as well as refurbishing and making a lot of planes.

If you lock a grinder down, you don't need balanced wheels. $20 brown Norton wheels walked my grinder around. Not essential but improved the experience with the baldor.

Just to see what they're like, I ordered a CBN Chinese wheel today for $50 shipped from Hong Kong and will see if it works with a house made bushing. I wouldn't mind putting the guard back on my machine on the shop side as my kids still are a liability in the shop.

At any rate, I was able to find camel wheels for $12, but buying another one for $30 isn't something I'd do again after having cbn for a while. I keep a brown coarse wheel on the machine for working annealed steel. I doubt many do that, but pink and cbn both aren't set up for that. I'd still point a beginner to cbn.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#33

Wheel recommendation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I forgot an important point. Wheels sold for bench grinders are limited and hard. One has to look for "surface grinder wheels" to get much selection for sharpening.

The soft Norton 3X wheel you found, if crowned, will surely be effective and the price is not onerous. I'd try it if I was in a buying mood. If someone wants to send me one I'll evaluate it compared to what I use. It will be returned crowned, however.

I know a pink wheel in H or I bond will be effective. A true "ceramic" wheel even harder will likely do well. I am reluctant to recommend a particle size. I don't burn at 120, but this wheel was custom made by Radiac. I thought at the time the finer particle size would better prepare the bevel for the next step. I now think wheel particle size irrelevant when followed by diamond and probably any other sharpening regime.

Beginners are going to have to learn control- how to sweep back and forth with light pressure without mowing off the end of a chisel. The problem will not be how slow this grinding is, but how fast. Once I get a straight edge I never desire to loose it. That is to say I grind to near the original edge, but never to it or beyond. I despise straightening crooked edges on the following "stone" step.

So, what particle size to buy will be governed by what can be found for sale and how well one can control the grinding. I know I can grind at 80 or even 60 grit. With a thin Stanley blade, 60 grit is breathtaking fast. Recall 7 passes across a 120 grit wheel established a hollow all the way to the edge. With the massive hunk of steel in a LV shooting plane, not so fast.

I used to get 1/2 x 7" Radiac wheels on sale from Travers for $12 not long ago. I see prices have risen a lot with $30 or more common. Don't know if there are still sales as I don't get sale circulars any more.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#34

Re: Fear of heat

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think fear of over heating is well justified. The only way one can really know if the iron has been overheated by grinding is by evaluating the performance of the tool. Someone who cannot feel how sharp the iron is would have trouble judging this. There might be some correlation between people who have no fear of grinding and people who judge plain carbon steel as inadequate for woodworking.

I remember years ago Derek tested Stanley 750 chisels and had them fail in five inches cutting in Marri. I am not a big fan of these chisels, but I know professional cabinetmakers who have used them on much harder woods for decades. They would not put up with this kind of performance. And now Bill says his edges fail quickly on end grain. Without having the tool in my hand it is difficult to know what the problem is.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#35

It sure as hell ain't from heat

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My chisels are made from CPM 3V that was tempered at 1000 degrees F. Even I would notice an edge getting this hot during grinding. But then I don't grind to the edge; yet another reason your speculation misses the mark no matter the steel.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#36

Re: Wheel recommendation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, I am replying to your post as you raise a few pertinent issues.

Regarding the Norton 3X wheels ...

These are wheels sold by Joel (the guy you do not know) at his store, Tools For Working Wood. I do not recommend them. They are touted as friable and cool-grinding, but I say they are a health risk since they create clouds .. CLOUDS .. of dust. To a lesser extent, the same goes for all the white and grey wheels I have used in the past. I have not used pink wheels, so cannot comment here. CBN wheels do not create dust from the wheel, per se.

Regarding the despised wavy edge which needs straightening ...

I, too, avoid this like the plague. The advantage of my grinding set up is that it creates a straight grind every time, and the edge off the CBN wheel is very clean (as per the Tormek) ... so much so that it is possible to start honing at 6000 grit (waterstone) and forgo the 1000.

Grinding to the edge (safely) - and stopping as you feel a fine wire - uses up as much steel as one would if using a 1000 to remove the wear bevel (one has to do this sooner rather than later anyway, but I say this for illustration purposes). Wheels like these are easier to develop control on.

I am not suggesting that you change your method, or that everyone should switch to CBN wheels, but you asked for other advantages of CBN over pink wheels that were not due to wear, change of wheel shape, and coolness (which are present). The initial cost of a CBN wheel is a factor. They can be very daunting for many to consider laying out for. Woodworking does not need to be expensive. I ground on a cheap 6” bench grinder and 36 grit (too hard) white wheel for many years before affording a Tormek. What Dave and I have both written is that the CBN wheel offers advantages. So does my Hammer K3 slider over the contractor saw I had, but I do not expect everyone to purchase this machine.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#37

Re: Fear of heat

Wiley Horne

“I think fear of over heating is well justified.”

That is what originally drove me to Tormek (wet grinding). And it wasn’t actually fear of bluing or browning a tool, because I was more careful than that (after bluing the first one!). Rather it was fear of detempering, from 62 to 59 say.

One might say, well, but you would feel 450F. But I’m not talking about detempering the whole tool; the sharpened edge is only microns thick and who knows what heat transients are generated by a dry spinning wheel and felt by this very fine edge? I don’t want to find out.

Now CBN comes along, and makes a vast improvement to the stock Tormek set-up, with no discernible heat above body temp.

Wiley

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#38

some heat calculations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Neighbor that does heat calculations for heating and cooling chemical equipment took a stab at seeing what the situation is at the tip of a plane blade. We have data from K&K that enable the work to be calculated, the volume of bade tip experiencing friction, mass of shaving etc. Forest products lab provides heat capacity and thermal conductivity of wood, so some estimates could be made. What came out is that the shaving needs to soak up substantial heat or the tip will be heated significantly. The K&K video show that the frictional forces are distributed well beyond the blade tip, which is fortunate for the tip. It was an interesting exercise with no exact answer.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#39

Re: some heat calculations

David Weaver

like many things - no exact answer. If you have a cap iron installed, put your thumb on the web on a board and plane so that the shaving runs over your thumb. You'll get a sense of the volume of heat that's leaving with the shaving and the surrounding air. It's a lot.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#40

Fear of heat- any evidence?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A $500 solution has been proposed to solve a problem I am uncertain exists. That cost might drive someone to buy a thickness planer and have some change left, or an M2 blade. David could easily do the experiment. But like some of the later experiments details between users would render the conclusions uncertain among users whose conditions deviated from David's. My details might avoid loss of hardness and yours might not, it could be argued, and the experiment would settle nothing.

That said, has anyone suspected loss of hardness from grinding under careful conditions? I don't grind to the tip and anyone that does with a wheel is further removing the resulting tip with subsequent edge refinement. This situation would seem to dismiss this heat concern. I, and maybe others, don't try to get a uniform hollow. If heating is an issue the thicker places would heat less, be harder, and wear less, which should be apparent when examining dulling. In fact this experiment could be done by anyone concerned about their technique.

I only hollow grind when edge refinement finally removes the hollow. If I lost hardness from grinding the blade would become harder with each subsequent sharpening until I ground again. Had anyone seen this effect?

Have any differences between the high speed steels like M2 and CPM 3V and those tempered at lower temperature been revealed?

Loss of tip hardness will result in the tip folding in use. Might take a magnifying glass to see it. I saw it with an unusually soft Sargent blade, soft enough to scratch with a file( Rc?).

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#41

My set up is like yours...

John in NM

Only cheaper and less rigorous if anything. I think the wheel cost me $9 at the used tool store where I got the grinder (a 6" Rockwell) around 1995. The wheel I use most is a soft brown wheel, probably silicon carbide. Friable wheel and a light touch and you have no significant heat problems. I don't have a wheel dresser, but I think I may finally get around to replacing this wheel and I may pick one up.

The other wheel is some hard white thing. Mistake. Hardly ever use it. I may replace it with a hard scotchbrite wheel, those are fantastic for deburring parts and I really only need one wheel for tool grinding.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#42

Re: Fear of heat- any evidence?

David Weaver

The first grinder I had, I replaced the coarse gray wheel with a fine white wheel. It had heat problems, but I learned to use it. The gray wheel had terrible balance but because of the coarse grit, it ground cooler. It was a $6 wheel kind of thing - molded center.

Since then, I haven't had a burn issue with anything, but I've seen a lot of posts from people who say they do. For a long time, I've cooled an iron by dragging it across my palm. The only irons that really challenge that are HSS since they'll generate more heat when they grind (but it doesn't matter).

I get the sense that the edge issue with the stanley chisels in Derek's test is probably something solved by two or three more degrees of final bevel.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#43

Re: Fear of heat- not an issue

joel moskowitz

Norton 3X wheels in I grade are excellent and when I was working with Norton to develop the wheels we thought "I" grade was all we needed. However turners hated the softness of the "I" grade because turning profiles would wear away the wheel very fast. So Norton introduced a "K" grade - much harder for those folks. As most turners use HSS there wasn't a real need to be as cool as there is for carbon steel.

The coarser the grit the cooler it will run. And as you are generally honing edge tools after grinding a coarse scratch pattern means nothing. So for friable wheels 60 and lower seems the choice.

With CBN because it runs so cool finer grits can be used (although it grinds slower).

Crowning the wheel makes a huge the difference for control and everything. Crowning is down with a wheel dresser on friable wheels. I think we are the only seller of crowned CBN wheels.

As I prefer a deep hollow I love my 6" 3600 rpm grinder. 8" makes more sense if you don't want a hollow grind as when turning. In any case with a CBN wheel, a crown, or a dressed friable wheel grinding to a wire edge should not be that tricky.

The major reason for upgrading stock grinder wheels is really to make the job easier. But with a properly dressed wheel you can grind to a wire edge on almost anything.

I don't like 3600 8" grinders because the extra speed buys me nothings - (a savings of a few seconds) but the risk of burning goes up. and of course I like my deep hollow.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#44

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given that the preferred way to use a wheel to grind chisels and plane blades is to crown it, why are the Noton 3X wheels sold in 3/4 and 1" widths and not 1/2"?

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#45

Re: Fear of heat- not an issue

E Phillip Smith

I've read you blog on the use of crowned wheels. I've been using crowned wheels for years and fully agree grinding with a crowned wheel is the way to go. Your site is the only place I've found crowned CBN wheels, but what I don't understand is why the 8" wheel is 1" wide. With crowned wheel you only use the center and 1/2" is plenty of width, so why waste the CBN on the edge of the wheel that will essentially never get used?

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#46

Re: Fear of heat- not an issue

Joel Moskowitz

First of all we can all agree that you don't get point contact with a crowned wheel. What you get is an arc ground in the chisel depending on how far a hollow grind you are in. That is when you first start you get point contact but as you keep on grinding the bevel the hollow gets bigger top to bottom and also because of the crown side to side. How wide the lateral hollow will be depends on how shallow the crown is. Since all we want to do is protected out corners I try for the smallest crown I can. so I do use as much of the wheel as I can. If I had a narrow wheel as I got closer to a full hollow grind I could in theory at any rate have a lateral hollow the width or more of the stone which puts me pretty much back in the soup as a straight wheel would.

The second point is a little more practical. The entire point of the crown - aside from protecting the corrners is to enable you contacting the wheel and start grinding without being perfectly square to the wheel. I will touch the wheel somewhere first but since it is crowned it won't hit the corners first. But once I make contact and start grinding I am not just pushing my blade into the wheel I am going back and forth. And because this is all freehand, and because I am not and don't need to pay particular attention my blade might wobble back and forth a bit as I move left to right. So as I go from left to right I have a tendency to use the entire left side of the wheel and going right to left visa versa. I don't know if I am making sense but it is easier to demonstrate than explain.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#47

More exercises with no exact answers

William Duffield

Could the additional thermal mass of a closely set chip breaker make a significant difference in the rate of heat transfer from the edge, and therefore in the possible loss of hardness of some steels?

If so, could choosing a more thermally conductive steel for the chip breaker result in longer edge retention? Might it even make sense to use a copper or copper clad, or even a silver plated chip breaker?

If the above questions result in improved edge retention, would it also decrease the likelihood of an inexperienced sharpener losing hardness if the chip breaker were left attached to the blade while grinding?

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#48

Re: More exercises with no exact answers

John Schtroumpf

Keep in mind that the primary function of the chip breaker is to deflect the shaving. In order to accomplish that without the shaving going under or catching on the chip breaker. A point contact is intentionally made between the leading edge of the chip breaker and the blade. Point contacts do not make good heat sinks because there is little contact surface between the two pieces of metal, so heat transfer is restricted. A standard chip breaker should have no problem dissipating the small amount of heat transferred.

When grinding, if you used a different piece of metal that is optimized as a heat sink. I don't know, but it might make a difference.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#49

same, but details different, and a question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anyone that uses a crowned wheel will understand your description. Some details differ. I use 1/2 x 7" wheels because I use inexpensive surface grinder wheels.(Radiac at lest used to make whatever you wanted in 20 lot batches) I wind up grinding on about 3/8" of the width, which is determined entirely by the depth of the hollow in my case.

If sliding the flat tool back and forth on a tool rest, I can't use any more of the wheel width than what nestles in the hollow, so long as I keep the tool flat on the rest. So, the part I don't understand is how one can use the edges of a 1" wide wheel that is crowned. Are you not using a tool rest?

And agree it is easy to teach. I showed a machinist who ground metal working tools and he proceeded to grind his thin Stanley blade uneventfully, 1st try. I have showed lots of people in the club and all have been successful, even the lady that stuck her finger into the wheel to "see if it was spinning" (left a trail of blood to the first aid station). As one's soft touch becomes refined the need for the coolest slower cutting wheel becomes less. I support the suggestion that learning on a slow speed grinder will be easier, as well as it is fast enough, if the grinder is dedicated and not a multitasker.

My marketing talent has been shown to be near useless, but I'll still suggest that a less expensive 1/2" wheel might result in more sales.

Re: Tormek: getting old wheel off?

#50

Re: same, but details different, and a question

joel moskowitz

Bill,

I have a rest that I rest the iron on but nothing to keep it square. When I go back and forth I go use the left of center, then center, then right of center parts of the wheel because I am angling the blade as I work. The wider wheel gets even use, and I don't have to dress as frequently. But you method on a narrower wheel will work fine too.