Re: Old hand saws
david weaver
The good thing about it from an individual level is that even if you don't understand what's going on 100% (I don't), if you can get a good clean setup so that the anvil and hammer don't mark the plate too badly, you can become useful very quickly.
Not necessarily chasing maybes (as in, if you have a good saw, you may not be able to make it better), but practical issues. A saw completely out of tension can be made reasonably stiff again. As good as the best disston saws? I don't know, but better than some atkins saws that I've gotten that are undamaged.
More importantly, one of the most common issues that I've found in used saws, the undisclosed gradual wave, or the gradual wave caused due to tying saws together in shipping - that is easily taken care of.
I understand Chris's sentiment - it may not be a proper engineering term, but the part of it that is a hand skill (despite a potential naming issue) is something we shouldn't avoid. I suppose it's sort of a dark art. In order to become as good as someone like yaitiki, you have to be willing to do it day in and day out and develop the neurons in your hands and brain to see and do. I'll never get there, but the simple pleasure of making something happen consistently without necessarily needing to know the proper terminology.....
...I think warren calls that craftsman's sense.
I know Chris has proclivity for frame saws, i like them, too - I'd hate to give up either type of saw. The "craftsman's sense" thing is what we should be developing and encouraging.
(this is a saw with tension that's not tensioned - the blank is a guitar blank - sitka, too wide for any bandsaw that I've owned - i don't own one now - but good enough quality to save the top of the slab for an acoustic guitar.)
https://imgur.com/a/m80IcSK
I cut the curves with another frame type saw, I guess (a turning saw).
https://imgur.com/a/T7xaTR7
I did use a router and a drum sander (my first new used power tool purchase in quite some time) to finish the rough work on this blank, though - I didn't hammer those.