Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Old hand saws

Posts

Old hand saws

#1

Old hand saws

Joe shelton

I'm launching a new excursion, with old Disstons mainly, and one Atkins.

I'm relying heavily on Bob Smalser's article about straitening, but he caution that he "won't make me a saw Doctor", so I'll pose a question about tensioning.

I don't know the difference between a saw which is well tensioned, and one which is not.

Does the tension make the blade stiffer?

Re: Old hand saws

#3

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

Tension or hardness will make the blade stiffer. (thicker cross section, too, but you don't want to go that way).

I don't want to get into semantics with anyone about what's going on (e.g., if someone wants to start an argument that hammer tensioning a saw is due to point hardness where the hammering is done, i have zero interest in that kind of discussion).

Here's what I can say. I've tensioned two saws, and failed with a third so far that had what I'd refer to as a flop. It's tensioned until it gets to a point and then springs over. But to be fair, I've spent about 20 minutes with it, and I think it just needs more time.

The two saws that I tensioned lost their stiffness due to removing a pretty significant amount of the surface of the saw (to clean off rust) with a deburring wheel. the stiffness of a saw is in the surface of the plate, if you take too much of it off, then you end up with a floppy saw.

You need a good smooth faced convex hammer and my preference is a good smooth surface metal anvil under the saw. Strike a line of blows at moderate force down one side of the saw, then do it again. Observe what's going on. That will establish what your setup does to a saw (e.g., if someone is using a different type of anvil - softer or whatever, they may hammer on the opposite side of a saw to get it to move.). To me, tensioning an old saw back to an acceptable level is the same as hammering for straightness, except you do it progressively to each side, keeping the saw as straight as possible top to bottom and end to end.

I'm sure that everyone doesn't tension a saw the same way, and everyone won't hammer in the same places, etc. It's more important for you to get an acceptable setup and see what works than it is to try to duplicate something that someone else does lock stock and barrel. I will say that I do believe (not expect other people to, just what I've found) that at least half of the work should be about an inch above the toothline, and the rest spread over the plate progressively. that gives you stiffness where the cut is, and some stiffness (and more importantly, straightness) up the plate from the tooth line.

Re: Old hand saws

#4

Re: Old hand saws

Michael Brady

I would venture that Ron Herman could probably tension a saw blade, but I think that almost no saw makers / sharpeners today are doing it. Like the process of tapering of saw plates, it is a largely lost art.

Forrest still tensions their circular blades and I somewhere saw a video of a female doing that process at their factory.

Re: Old hand saws

#5

Direct, concise, informative

Joe shelton

Thanks, David.

Re: Old hand saws

#6

Chris Scholz

Re: Old hand saws

Chris Scholz

Snakeoil!

There is not such thing as tension with out an external force (like for example in a frame saw). Balance of forces is a fundamental principle of classical mechanics.

On the other hand, if it pleases you, tension your saw blades as much as you like. We all do many 'fun things' that make absolutely no sense.

Re: Old hand saws

#7

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

I'm guessing you haven't had a chance to use a saw that was out of tension. Plenty of arguments about what the right term is, maybe for some, the term needs to be stiffness. Take the outer layer off of a saw that was manufactured through rollers (like a disston) and it'll be difficult to use. Hammer it evenly, and it'll be stiff again.

Semantics arguments on forums aren't helpful, because beginners will come across posts and then assume that "there's no such thing as tension without a frame" will mean that there is no effect from hammering saws.

Not suggesting that everyone should hammer saws, but it's a useful skill to have if you're going to buy used saws or make saws.

Re: Old hand saws

#8

Re: Old hand saws

Wiley Horne

Agree. If you look at a Yataiki saw, you will see thousands or tens of thousands of tiny depressions from hammerstrikes—tensioning. The saw blade fairly shimmers from the strikes. The saw, though thin, has beam strength compared to a non-tensioned (and non-backed) saw, which flaps like a fly swatter in comparison.

It’s work hardening, which is well-known to us. Steel has crystal structure. A sheet of steel is like a lattice. What happens when thin steel bends?—the layers of the lattice are sliding over and across each other to permit the bent shape. Hammer strikes on that sheet cause breaks or discontinuities in the lattice, which impede the sliding action, and the sheet becomes stiffer, bends less easily.

A real metallurgist could explain this more precisely. But work hardening—and consequent stiffening—happens.

Wiley

Re: Old hand saws

#9

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

The good thing about it from an individual level is that even if you don't understand what's going on 100% (I don't), if you can get a good clean setup so that the anvil and hammer don't mark the plate too badly, you can become useful very quickly.

Not necessarily chasing maybes (as in, if you have a good saw, you may not be able to make it better), but practical issues. A saw completely out of tension can be made reasonably stiff again. As good as the best disston saws? I don't know, but better than some atkins saws that I've gotten that are undamaged.

More importantly, one of the most common issues that I've found in used saws, the undisclosed gradual wave, or the gradual wave caused due to tying saws together in shipping - that is easily taken care of.

I understand Chris's sentiment - it may not be a proper engineering term, but the part of it that is a hand skill (despite a potential naming issue) is something we shouldn't avoid. I suppose it's sort of a dark art. In order to become as good as someone like yaitiki, you have to be willing to do it day in and day out and develop the neurons in your hands and brain to see and do. I'll never get there, but the simple pleasure of making something happen consistently without necessarily needing to know the proper terminology.....

...I think warren calls that craftsman's sense.

I know Chris has proclivity for frame saws, i like them, too - I'd hate to give up either type of saw. The "craftsman's sense" thing is what we should be developing and encouraging.

(this is a saw with tension that's not tensioned - the blank is a guitar blank - sitka, too wide for any bandsaw that I've owned - i don't own one now - but good enough quality to save the top of the slab for an acoustic guitar.)

https://imgur.com/a/m80IcSK

I cut the curves with another frame type saw, I guess (a turning saw).

https://imgur.com/a/T7xaTR7

I did use a router and a drum sander (my first new used power tool purchase in quite some time) to finish the rough work on this blank, though - I didn't hammer those.

Re: Old hand saws

#10

Re: Old hand saws

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Internal stress in steel can be either tension or compression. In hardened steel it is these stresses, areas of tension and compression, that make the steel hard. If we anneal the steel we relieve the stresses and thus soften the steel.

Likewise a piece of wood can have internal stresses that we call reaction wood (or specifically tension wood and compression wood). Both steel and wood can warp when a piece with internal stress is sawed apart.

Perhaps "tensioning a saw" is not the greatest term. However, Chris Scholz has not given us a better one, nor any indication that he is familiar with the phenomenon.

Re: Old hand saws

#11

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

Are saws offered by current boutique makers hand tensioned? If not, and they are not demonstrably inferior (they generally seem pretty nice), then therein might lie the answer to the whole thing.

If they are hand tensioned, then let's hear from the people who perform this operation for the various makers.

Seems simple enough.

Re: Old hand saws

#12

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

George is probably the only person who ever talked about this on modern saws. he said that they didn't tension the long saws they made for the museum and felt the hardness of the steel was enough. I don't think they were tapered, but I'd have to ask him to be sure.

The long saws of the modern makers aren't as good as the better vintage saws due to the lack of stiffness. I'm not sure how thick the cross section would have to be to make up for it, but I've used .042" 1095 plate and it's not there on its own compared to a turn of the century disston saw. Same hardness level - 48-52 spec, which is about where disston saws were.

Some of the vintage saws are lacking, though, too. Of all of the saws I've bought, atkins seem to come up limp more often than others, even when they're unused or very little used.

It might be a challenge to find someone who will spend $400 on a rip saw from a modern maker and then actually use it to rip more than ten linear feet.

Re: Old hand saws

#13

Not Many

david weaver

....modern makers offering long saws right now.

Bad Axe claims to use hammer tensioned 1095 plate. I've never seen it anywhere, but his efforts would go far beyond mine, and there's a video of him sawing with his saws - no flop.

Far different economic proposition than a good vintage disston saw, though.

Re: Old hand saws

#14

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

Personal anecdotes abound.

I'm interested in the demonstrable inferiority (slow, rattles, vibrates, won't track, etc., etc.) of new, boutique saws because of the lack of hand tensioning, assuming they are not hand tensioned, which I don't know for sure. If they are hand tensioned, then let's hear from the guys and gals doing the work.

Otherwise, whatever it is that hand tensioning is supposed to enhance, fix, or correct, then somebody demonstrate that an otherwise quality saw, positioned at a boutique price point (or even a bit lower!), won't do or is guilty of.

Re: Old hand saws

#15

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

So, it's not tensioning now if it's done by machine or rollers, it has to be hand tensioning by hammering?

The real charlie shows up. The one who wants to speak from inexperience and waste other peoples' time while contributing nothing in terms of proving what he says.

Tip your glass of wine and confirm to yourself that everyone who has ever hammered saws (including Henry Disston before he had an industrial process) was just wasting his time or marketing hot air.

Re: Old hand saws

#16

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

I see that the Bad Axe guys say their D8 saws are hammer tensioned.

Re: Old hand saws

#17

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

Bad Axe apparently hammer tensions their bigger saws. Maybe Ellis could arrange a chat so that we could hear from people doing it in that setting, rather than a setting much less mission-critical.

Re: Old hand saws

#18

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

We should apparently rejoice that the expertise of tensioning saw plate has not been lost. Somebody at Bad Axe knows how to do it, and presumably well.

Re: Old hand saws

#19

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

I don't see anything on Lie-Nielsen's website about hammer tensioning though I don't think they sell a saw longer than 20", if that makes a difference and I think it would. I guess it would.

Re: Old hand saws

#20

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

Sort of a doofus statement, I guess. You have a floppy saw, you hammer it so that it isn't floppy and then it is useful.

I have no idea what mission critical is, but I'll wait for you to change lanes.

Re: Old hand saws

#22

Re: Old hand saws

david weaver

Anyone with a hammer and anvil can do it. It requires only one thing - hammering both sides of a plate equally (which isn't difficult - if you can see, you can hammer a plate straight). I'd imagine it's been lost for zero of history in the last 200 years since circular mills have done it the entire time, and so have Japanese makers.

I do recall someone discouraging woodworkers from hammering bowed saws straight - years ago. You. You asserted something obscure like "you'll hammer the life out of a saw leaving a floppy mess".

Straightening a saw takes 5-10 minutes. Tensioning a floppy saw takes, I'd guess, half an hour. The economic pickup in five to 10 minutes is about $50 in saw value. I have no clue why someone who doesn't do it would assert that someone else shouldn't - either of those.

I don't expect you'll try it, because that's not what you're here for.

Re: Old hand saws

#23

Re: Bob Smalser

david weaver

Did you read his initial post?

You're several steps behind. The relevant response to Smalser's article is that if you use metal on metal, the saw may move in the opposite direction that Smalser suggests. The original poster should hammer and observe - there's little more to it than that, other than deburring anvil and hammer. Point being that if you hammer a saw and it moves in the opposite direction of Smalser's description, that's all there is to it - nothing bad is happening and there's no reason to change setups to duplicate smalser's results. Metal hammer and metal anvil actually works better and is more predictable.

I've done both.

Re: Old hand saws

#24

Re: Old hand saws

Charles

I'm not asserting any of that David. You're welcome to hammer on saws all you want. Maybe you're right, it doesn't take that much expertise to do it or know when it needs to be done. That seems to run contrary to things I've read elsewhere, but if you have it mastered that's great.

Relax.

Re: Old hand saws

#25

Re: Bob Smalser

Charles

Well David, if you're that sure then I'm happy to defer to your expertise and I assume others will as well.

I have to admit that a lot of the stuff one reads about Disston and the high-end Japanese makers, with regard to hand tensioning, does sound like a lot of voodoo, marketing, and sales puffery.