Re: Old hand saws
Steve Voigt
Chris, props to you for changing your mind--it's not something people do a lot of on forums and the like.
A couple general comments:
I don't have nearly as much experience with saws as Dave does, but I have--once--had the misfortune to sand through a saw plate to the point where the surface tension disappears (as Dave described earlier). The effect is dramatic and almost has to be experienced to be believed. One minute, the plate is like a piece of spaghetti that's been cooked for 30 seconds--it is just barely flexible--and a few strokes of abrasive later, it's like an overdone noodle with no integrity at all. It doesn't happen gradually, it happens in one shot when you go too far. Anyone who tries it (and I don't recommend it, by the way) will instantly be convinced of the effectiveness of hammer tensioning.
I also had modest success retensioning that same plate. I would put the "modest" part down to my lack of experience, and not any lack of effectiveness of the procedure. I've definitely had some success straightening saw plates
As others have mentioned, Mark at BadAxe tensions saws. He's posted some clips on Instagram. I suppose anyone who really wanted to learn the art could go take a workshop with him.