Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Posts

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#26

Re: Seaton chisels *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bridger

On the making of dovetails, I read an interesting account on dovetails in the 18th century from Richard Maguire (theenglishwoodworker.com), link below.

Richard commented that he found it took the same time to make well-fitted as ill-fitted dovetails. The conclusion was that a likely reason for ill-fitted dovetails (by a decent woodworker) was not speed, but the poor quality of the saw. The only way he could replicate the "scruffy" dovetails was to cut them with a panel saw.

It would be helpful to know more about the quality of saw plates in the 18th century. Richard is knowledgable in this regard. I have seen good and bad saws in my time. I also acknowledge that, even when I rush (which is a relative statement since I do not have deadlines in the same way as a pro), my dovetails still tend to be a close fit off the saw. That is, I view each aspect of a build as being equally important. Have times changed that much?

Regards from Cape Town

Derek


Scruffy Dovetails

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#28

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Sgian Dubh

Hi Roger, I think you'd have all the chisels you need to do all dovetails from coarse carcase dovetails to skinny pinned drawer lap dovetails in either of those two chisel sets you're considering. If I were buying a set of chisels I'd steer away from the Japanese chisels towards the Veritas PM-V11 chisels, but that's because I'm simply not any kind of fan of Japanese chisels. There's nothing wrong with them, and I know they're the choice of many people, but they're not for me. I've got a mis-matched collection of rather well used bevel edged chisels ranging in width from 1.5 mm (1/16") to 25 mm (1") - I don't think there's more than two that are the same brand, but they work well enough, ha ha.

I think all the subsequent suggestions for things like skew and fishtail chisels are essentially superfluous. I've never owned an example of either, although I've tried using both types that other people have owned just to see if they provided an advantage to my dovetailing: neither offered anything useful to me.

If you find getting bits out of corners tricky in your lap dovetails, as does everyone to a greater or lesser extent, the solution is to use the narrowest bevel edged chisel in your kit, i.e., the 1/8" Veritas chisel if that's what you've got (or the Japanese equivalent) and just winkle that little corner out. In reality you will slightly overcut the depth because you use the chisel at an angle matching the rake, but that is hidden when the joint is assembled.

I also wouldn't worry too much about the depth or thickness of the lands you asked about. For the most part there's no need to get those lands tight up into the corner of either the tails or the pins because you just angle the chisel a bit as you use it, except into the bottom enclosed corner of a lapped dovetail, and that's when you'll find yourself switching over to your narrowest chisel to get right into that corner. Slainte.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#29

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

David Weaver

Excellent and practical advice.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#30

Re: Seaton chisels

Brian Holcombe

Let's not forget that those 'scruffy' joints were sawn 200 years ago, and likely 100 of those years were daily use.

It's easy to cut a clean joint off the saw and look like a hero by comparison but we haven't shown what 200 years looks like on our stuff. I like to look at my work after a few years of regular use and see where I can improve. Wear and seasonal movement are what really tell you that. Sometimes I go back and repair things that could have been better done.

So commonly we're simply held hostage by the temperament of the material, good material that doesn't move much really helps the 'craftsmanship'. Material that moves in surprising ways really makes one look like a hack. :D

I often wonder if the reason for much of these 'poor fitting joints' is that someone took an antique finished product made with material that was air dried then stuck in a retail shop for years that had the heaters on full blast. Not surprising that when you take material that was 12% and bring it down to 8% that is shows gaps.

In 200 years craftsmen may look at the quality of tools that we had available to us and wonder why often people still chose to make something such as kitchen cabinetry with wire brads and pocket screws. I wonder still if there would be any surviving examples. :D

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#31

Re: Seaton chisels

david weaver

I've had a couple of early 1800s saws, and I'm sure some of the 1700s saws were a bit rougher, but there was nothing about the saws that I had that would've led to ugly dovetails.

The explanation must be something else - not having a poor saw necessarily, but lacking the right one in general due to cost, maybe.

What I've seen of the older plates is an issue of consistency - inconsistent hardness within a plate, etc, but even that's not universally true. I've got a saw from 1820 or so with two split nuts, and it's a delight to use, and it's a click or so softer than a modern saw and sharpens beautifully and cleanly. The steel has a really "dry" feel to it (it files off crisply with very little burr). It's a tenon saw, but it would easily cut neat dovetails in skilled hands.

I tend to think sloppy is due to standards. They didn't have bloggers in the old days telling them that commodity furniture needed to have show dovetails. There is some truth to speed being similar for "good" dovetails vs. loose ones, but speed isn't the only thing that occurs with craftsmen. Fatigue, lack of interest, lack of need for perfection, inebriation...

I'm sure that making large carpenters saws was a bit of a challenge before industrialization, but saws large enough to make dovetails would've have been that difficult to make. Everything about the original saws (folded backs, handles, etc) are things that can probably still be done better by hand and with care if the maker is skilled, perhaps with the exception of the saw plate itself, but saw plate quality isn't critical in a backsaw.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#32

Re: Fishtail not skew

North of the Border

The cover of his book shows the skew chisel Ian made from a 1/4" chisel. Details in his book, p. 46.

https://www.highlandwoodworking.com/thecompletedovetail.aspx

But as I said, dovetails, any kinds, can be cut without using any skew or fishtail chisels. Corners can be cleaned with a small chisel, 1/8" if necessary.

Skew or fishtail chisels are nice to have...a point I always stress to beginners so they don't get loaded up with expensive tools before they can even cut any decent dovetails.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#33

Re: Seaton chisels

North of the Border

There are no bevelled firmer chisels in the chest, no fishtail chisels, and no skew chisels. I don't find these things necessary for making dovetails.

Agreed!

I may not cut dovetails as quick as Rob Cosman but mine -- taking twice as much time, perhaps or more to complete -- are as good as his when all is said and done. Gap free 99% of the time, probably 99.5%. And I have never used any chisels other than regular bench chisels to cut all my dovetails.

To say skew or fishtail chisels are helpful, I agree. To say they are necessary, I smell a sales pitch.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#34

Re: Seaton tool chest book

steve voigt

Hi Derek, regarding the quality of saw plates in the 18th c., you really ought to get a copy of the Seaton book. There is a lengthy discussion of how excellent the grinding of the saw plates is, all done by hand and eye. Fascinating stuff. I doubt very much that saw quality is a major factor. Probably the biggest reason for "scruffy dovetails" is that DT's were rarely exposed in 18th/19th c furniture. Brian's comments about age and wear are also relevant.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#35

Re: Fishtail not skew

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ian's chisel looks essentially like a one-sided fishtail chisel. He is using it like a fishtail, that is, it is cutting on the push. Most skew chisels I have seen are angled at about 20 degrees. This limits their ability to be pushed and cut on the forward stroke.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#36

Re: necessary vs. desirable

steve voigt

Lots of things are not necessary, but make work easier or faster or more enjoyable. I don't own a fishtail, but I don't cut a lot of DT's. If i did, I'd grind a fishtail.

There's a good argument for restricting oneself to necessary tools. As Warren often points out, it breeds familiarity with ones tools if the kit is of manageable size. It's also cheaper and takes up less space.

On the other hand, having a few "nice but not essential" tools can definitely help. When deciding whether to acquire such a tool, it's good to weigh the cost and space against the utility of the tool. For example, a dedicated iron shooting plane and vintage Stanley shooting board would cost a small fortune, weigh a ton, and take up a lot of space. It's hard for me to imagine it being worth it. On the other hand, to make a fishtail chisel, it would cost less than $20 for a vintage chisel that I could re-grind in an hour. What's not to like?

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#37

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Rob Lee

Hi Roger!

Sorry I'm so slow replying - am just back from family holiday outside of Quebec City...

Yes - the lands on our chisels are very narrow (.5mm comes to mind) - but they are not zero - or we would not be able to control the chisel width.

Yes - they can be sharp as well. However - they would still be sharp if the lands were larger! The sharpness of the edge comes from the precision of the grinding of the land, coupled with the lapping of the back - two very flat surfaces meeting to form an edge. Even if that edge is at 90 degrees - it will still cut!

So - we recommend (for all edge tools) that you dub any sharp edges in a hand contact area that result from lapping. We do not do this - as no matter how much (or how little) we did it - it would not please all customers. This way - you can adjust to your preferences.

Cheers -

Rob

(still a bit sore from skiing, hockey, volleyball, and basketball over the holidays!)

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#38

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Richard

How would you clean out the corner of these sockets without causing any damage using a straight (non-bevelled) chisel, such as a 1/8"?


You can pare from the side and the rear, but not from the front (owing to the socket angle). The sidewall is too fragile for "poking".

This is where a fishtail chisel is best utilised, in my opinion.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#39

Re: Fishtail not skew

North of the Border

Yes, angled on one side only. I think he recommends the skew angle to be 3 to 5 degrees more acute than the socket angle.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#40

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

roger lance

Rob....Thanks for your response.....I've always been very impressed with your monitoring ww sites and willingness to answer questions.

As you know, a portion of your customers are not able to see, hold, and use your products prior to purchase. They have to rely on photos, videos, reviews, and ww site conversations for their product impressions.

Such is the case here.....and a possible problem may not be a problem at all. The idea of relieving an edge to suite personal comfort works for me.....and as you've said, even a sharp 90* edge can be very uncomfortable to the hand.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#41

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Sgian Dubh

Hi Richard

How would you clean out the corner of these sockets without causing any damage using a straight chisel, such as a 1/8"?


I'd approach it the way I've always done it. In the description following, socket length runs with the grain, i.e., vertically in your picture, and socket depth runs across the grain, i.e., front to back (with the lap away from the viewer) in your picture.

Chop out the bulk of the waste using any preferred method after you've defined the rake of the pins with a saw. You can chisel it, bore it out with a drill; set up a router, small diameter cutter and side fence, whatever you prefer. That just leaves cutting the shoulder line across the grain accurately, trimming the side of the pin where the saw can't reach, and defining the depth of the socket.

After the bulk of the waste is removed I move on to defining the shoulder line accurately using the cutting gauge line as my guide. Usually I start with a narrow chisel, 6 or 10 mm all depending on the wood's hardness and resistance to cross grain paring, and make light cuts perpendicular to the wide face that take me up to the shoulder line. I drop that chisel and pick up the next wider chisel and extend the shoulder line using the existing flat created by the narrower chisel as my guide. I keep dropping chisels and picking up wider ones until I get to the corners where the pins are. I aim for perpendicular to the wide face, but quite commonly slightly undercut to ensure there's no gap at the shoulder when the joint's assembled.

At this point you have to start to angle the wide chisel to cut at the same, or slightly lower, rake angle as the pin's rake. This means a wide chisel can't cut right into the bottom corner because the tip furthest from the corner bottoms out on the inner face of the lap. So I drop that chisel and pick up a narrow chisel or chisels, perhaps a 6 mm chisel followed by on 3 mm wide, to get right into the corner, and slightly overcut into the lap.

Then it's a case of tidying up the pin where the saw couldn't reach when sawing to define the rake. A chisel of about the same width as the socket's length does this neatly through using the existing saw cut as a guide for the flat side of the chisel. Pare down across the grain or with it if that cuts neatly.

In all of this there's been nothing yet said about defining the depth of the socket, but here I pare with the grain using as wide a chisel as I can to get into the corner to meet where I chopped down across the grain to define the shoulder. Sometimes there's a bit of necessary cutting in two directions, i.e., with the grain and across the grain to get most of the corner neat, perhaps slightly undercut in both directions (which is preferable to leaving any high spots that would prevent the joint assembling tight to shoulder line and depth of socket)

That just leaves that awkward little corner to pick out, and where the narrow chisel severs off the little bit of grain left from paring with or across the grain on the pin and on the inside face of the lap.

Hopefully you can follow the description well enough. Unfortunately I don't record videos of this sort of thing, and I appreciate it would be much easier to follow the technique if I put up a wee five minute video, but I'm afraid I can't do that (or perhaps more accurately, it's not something I have any interest in doing at the moment - more work than I want to take on). It's much harder to describe than it is to do, which I seem to achieve without thinking about it much really. It's just a case of chop a bit, pare a bit, change chisel, do a bit more, clean out the corner, next, that sort of thing, try not to let your attention wander while you're at it because it's a pretty boring and repetitive procedure really if you've got something like a few drawers to make, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#42

Re: Seaton tool chest book

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here are some pictures of the Seaton chest drawers.

It is kind of strange that people would disparage work they had never seen. For myself I made skew chisels sometime in 1975-76 and soon abandoned them for dovetails. I think they take extras time, without adding quality.


img

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#43

Re: Seaton tool chest book

david weaver

Are those the original planes? They are really bright!

George told me that eventually my planes would turn brown if I used them enough, but obviously, a couple of years isn't enough to make that happen.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#44

Re: Seaton tool chest book

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Those are original planes. Here is another picture; maybe the light is different. I have held Wenzloff saws that were copies of the Kenyon saws in this chest; I will take the originals for superior workmanship.


img

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#45

Re: Seaton tool chest book

david weaver

I'm not surprised that the planes are bright - they've been little used and stored away from light. I'm glad to see that they're bright like that, as I always thought the six pairs that I've made look funny as bright as they are.

Agree on the saw handles. No slight to Mike Wenzloff, he used to say that he was trying to get nice saws made for a price that would get them in as may hands as possible, but the lines on the Seaton chest saws are the finest I've ever seen. Crisp and unquestionable taste. There are workers now who can duplicate them (some of George's saws have exceptionally crisp lines and delicate details if he chooses to make them that way), but very few saws available to the public that are made so well.

I hate to say it, but I can't make a handle as good as the handles on the seaton saw, and I don't know enough history to say for sure, but I doubt that the maker was "making saws for a special chest". They are something for an amateur sometimes-maker like me to aspire to.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#46

Re: Seaton tool chest book

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is another picture. I am satisfied with scruffy.


img

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#47

Re: necessary vs. desirable

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Not even $20. This one cost $5 at a MWTCA meet, an old Stanley #60 plus an hour of grinding. Works great.


Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#48

Re: Seaton tool chest book

david weaver

I am not in the category of people who fusses over things like dovetails, though, obviously, there is nothing wrong with that chest.

I posted pictures of "authentic" handsome dovetails on here a few years ago, pictures that I had taken from my parents' furniture when I was home visiting them. All of their items have come from Gettysburg/New Oxford, and while they were not furniture made for royals, they were quite nice (the proportion was lovely). When I posted them here, the response was that they were "sloppy". Modern looking perfect dovetails with fat sided drawers were held up as better.

I'd take the old ones as better - the lines and proportions were just that - better..more appealing. The seaton chest saws are not only perfectly executed - or near it - but they have the proportion and lines set up in a way that would be difficult to improve.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#49

Besides grinding...

david weaver

....any chisel that has a reasonably thick cross section can be heated, hammered and then quenched, and it'll be a fishtail.

George suggested that long ago when one of these threads came up (I think he may have recommended using square stock and just hammering the end, but it doesn't really matter - same effect).

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#50

Re: Besides grinding...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

If I had some eggs, we could have bacon and eggs, if I had some bacon. :D

All I would need is a forge, a big hammer and an anvil. The chisel I have.