Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Posts

A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#1

A lands question for Rob Lee.....

roger lance

I'm considering buying an upscale set of chisels for dovetailing and am looking at two sets which are both sold by Lee Valley. I'm only able to read about these products.....watch a video on YouTube.....but, not see or use these chisels in person.....and; evidently, there are problems with the "lands" (side edge) of both chisels.

The Japanese chisel set by Koymaichi (60S05.50) have a significant land along the entire length of its chisels.....not unlike the land found on my current set which is largely my reason for buying another set. The land prevents the chisel from getting into the tight corners in dovetails without "bruising" the wood. The solution for this appears to be to grind the lands away or get a set made to spec in Japan which would then be forged without the lands.

The Lee Valley Veritas PM-V11 set (05S21.50) have no land at all for the entire length of the chisel but, people report that this edge is sharp enough to cut you in use. People are addressing this issue by wearing some protection on their hand or lightly grinding back a portion of the chisel's edge up to about an inch from the end of the chisel.

Rob Lee.....are you considering "improving" the profile of your chisels (Koymaichi or Veritas)??.....I have a history of buying things just before they are improved.....just as soon avoid that if I can.

Anyone having experience with these issues.....please share your insights.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#2

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

David weaver

The koyamaichi chisels are gradual enough that the small lands will not bruise dovetails. They're also still sharp enough to cut fingers.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#3

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

William Duffield

There is another approach to solving your problem: a pair of skew chisels. After I bought mine, I realized for quite a bit less money, I could have bought two 3/16" chisels and reground the edges.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#4

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Unfortunately William, if you are making skinny tails - such as 1/8" or 3/16" bases - then sharp lands are necessary to avoid bruising the faces. It is a different story with wide dovetails, where the chisel may be skewed into the socket wall. Pins are square-sided, and one can use any chisel.

Roger, it is a 30 second task to dull the lands after the first inch. I would rather it was this way that the alternative - having to reduce the lands by grinding. I think that the reference to the custom Koyamaichi was in regard to my own, which Mr Koyama ground for me. Apparently (according to Stu, who liaised on my behalf), Mr K was unaware of the need for this - the Japanese dovetails (such as on full blind mitred corners) are typically quite wide.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#5

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Unfortunately William, if you are making skinny tails - such as 1/8" or 3/16" bases - then sharp lands are necessary to avoid bruising the faces. These are too narrow to skew a chisel. It is a different story with wide dovetails, where the chisel may be skewed into the socket wall. Pins are square-sided, and one can use any chisel.

Roger, it is a 30 second task to dull the lands after the first inch. I would rather it was this way that the alternative - having to reduce the lands by grinding. I think that the reference to the custom Koyamaichi was in regard to my own, which Mr Koyama ground for me. Apparently (according to Stu, who liaised on my behalf), Mr K was unaware of the need for this - the Japanese dovetails (such as on full blind mitred corners) are typically quite wide.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#6

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Patrick Chase

A few comments:

You're probably in the wrong place if you want feedback directly from Rob. If you do a search for "rob lee woodworking forum" then the first couple results should give a strong hint.

Side bevel detuning/dull-back is very much a matter of subjective preference, and it's a lot easier to detune a sharp edge than to go the other direction. I think that LV is doing the right thing by shipping their chisels sharp the entire length and allowing people to adjust to taste. FWIW it takes me a few seconds using a patch of emery cloth and my thumb as backing (a habit from when i adjusted ski tip/tail engagement after tuning). It's thick enough to hold up to the edge, but flexible enough that you can feel what you're doing to the edge through the cloth.

For that matter the overall side bevel geometries on western chisels are highly adjustable. I have Narex and Stanley chisels with sidewalls every bit as fine as my Veritas ones, the difference being that I shaped them myself. I use a belt grinder to "sneak up" on the profile, and then special hard-metal-specific files to fine-tune (Valtitan/Corinox steel files and/or solid Tungsten-Carbide milled files for harder chisels). If you don't happen to have those you can obviously fine-tune on sandpaper or a stone, but it's slower going.

I also (as of fairly recently) have the Koyamaichis, and those are much more difficult to customize. You can still soften or "break" the edge as described above, but going beyond that and reshaping it is a fraught process for several reasons: First, the bottom ("bit") part of the iron is extremely brittle and prone to chipping in general. The forging process improves "lengthwise" toughness, which is why they don't chip as much as you might expect in use, but does very little for the crosswise axis that matters when shaping side bevels. As Derek discovered the hard way a while back, belt grinders are a bit of a gamble in that situation.

Second, the softer steel spine of the chisel isn't oriented very well to provide support to the side edges as it dies to the cutting edge. Third, at Rc65-66 the hardened bit is out of the usable range of even high-end steel files. You pretty much need to use a solid carbide file or a diamond file to work it, and if you're determined to do so that's probably the safest approach.

Finally note that you don't need a very steep side bevel angle for DT clearance. Instead of extending the existing side bevels of my skew chisels all the way to the edge, I created a 1:6 "lower-bevel" between the edge and the bottom of the existing bevel i in the first inch of the chisel (which is then tapered back into the existing bevel for another inch or two for aesthetics). It's less work than reshaping the existing bevel, and it gets the job done just as well.

A skew chisel with knife-thin side edges is a wonderful thing for blind DTs, by the way.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#7

Separate comment...

david weaver

that you're probably not interested in, but...

I had those KI chisels at one point. They are excellent. I used them to make a bunch of drawers, and each time I hadn't used them, they sat for a while. At that time, they were $300.

I don't remember why I sold them, probably just general turnover (something I need to do again), or it might've been that the apex on them makes them relatively uncomfortable if you're getting your fingers on the chisels cleaning out the last little bit of waste in corners (see comment below about grinding, too)..

Since then, I bought four cheap chisels and ground 1" of the lands off - as in 1" of distance from the edge to the point where I stopped grinding on the sides. None of those chisels were more than $10 (two old butcher chisels and two narrower cheap "buck brothers" firmer chisels).

None is as good of a chisel as the KI chisels, but I like them better in use. I could probably sit here and elaborate on why I like them better, but it would be just a bunch of pointless text if I could figure out how to express it. I just like them better- they're not precious and I don't have to take particularly "good care" of them. I dropped the KI chisels on the floor twice - once because I had the roll upside down, and another time one or two rolled off my bench. Each time, I had a lot of hand grinding to do, and the profile is not impossible, but it's less of a thrill to handle because of all of the sharp lines on it.

The other practical option is old english tang bevel edge chisels. Not newer chisels that have fatter sides (some of the later boxwood marples and greaves, etc, are not so delicate), but older ones. They are generally delicate enough to do that kind of work, but not one trick ponies. the AI chisels (which seem to be in and out of stock) are also superb. I just finished a plane wedge a bit ago with one and didn't bother to get a paring chisel out - they are perhaps the best overall chisel that I've used. Not the "highest quality" (but they are definitely high quality), but the right shape and weight, great balance of sharpenability and edge holding, and they'd do the dovetail work you're talking about.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#8

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

David weaver

Coarse belt and a belt grinder would be fine, but I wouldn't remove more from those chisels or the corners will chip. There's not a lot of extra stock on those chisels, anyway- and they're plenty delicate and sharp.

Roger- I can grind you a couple of old japanese chisels if you want to try them, gratis...just tell me what sizes.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#9

bridger

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Bridger

I don't do a lot of dovetails but I do have use for skew chisels. I have a pair of reground 1/2" vintage Stanley socket chisels for bigger stuff. I reduced the lands considerably on those. For small stuff I made a pair from a set of replacement cutters for a handheld power plane. Mine are like this, but carbon steel:

www.harborfreight.com/planer-replacement-blades-pack-of-2-94990.html

Though I suppose hss would be fine for what is essentially a very light paring chisel.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#10

Re: Plus 1 for Skew Chisels

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have found a pair of skew chisels to be the answer for me. I don't do skinny tails, so the land on the skew chisels is not an issue for me.

My 2 cents worth.

Ron

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#11

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

North of the Border

#1 Rob Lee has answered questions in this forum before. How often he comes to this forum, I don't know, but he is seen in other forums often.

#2, for regular and most dovetail joints, skew chisels are totally unnecessary. They are just nice-to-have tools. I have done numerous dovetails that were never touched by a skew chisel.

You can easily grind and shape a cheapo bench chisel into a skew chisel and save yourself a lot of toy money (for other toys). But in most cases, as I said, you wouldn't need a skew chisel.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#12

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Brian Holcombe

The chisel does not need sharp sides to get into the corner. Just skew a smaller chisel.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#13

Fishtail not skew

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Skew chisels are for clearing the corners of half-blind sockets. I find them far less useful than a fishtail chisels. The latter is simply pushed into the corner, while the skew needs to be used with a slice.



I've ground fishtail chisels, but my favourite is a 1/4" Blue Spruce (you only need one) ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#14

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

roger lance

David.....that is a very generous offer.....I won't forget this kindness.....but, for now, I'm going to decline what has to be the nicest gesture I've gotten in all these years on ww sites.....thanks again David.....have a great 2018!

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#15

Re: Fishtail not skew

William Duffield

I'm questioning your diagram of the skew chisel: Aren't you using it upside down, or backwards (on the wrong side of the socket)?

The eventual problem with a fishtail chisel is with repeated sharpening it will be narrowed down to total ineffectiveness. Of course, before that happens, they are more convenient than skew chisels, because one tool works for both sides of the socket, and you don't need to keep swapping them out. They are also usually expensive. Of course, that's never stopped me in the past. :)

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#16

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

Patrick Chase

Skews are useful for tail sockets in blind DTs, as are fishtails. Opinions vary as to the relative usefulness of the two tools, but both work fine.

Skews can also be useful for difficult paring cuts, though fishtails generally are not.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#17

Re: Fishtail not skew

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm questioning your diagram of the skew chisel: Aren't you using it upside down, or backwards (on the wrong side of the socket)?

The eventual problem with a fishtail chisel is with repeated sharpening it will be narrowed down to total ineffectiveness.

Hi William

The drawing of the skew is correct, not upside down. The point is, the skew is used in a slicing action to be effective. This is clumsy compared with the fishtail, which only needs to be pushed. I find the latter has much more control and requires less muscle.

Do fishtail chisels wear out? I guess so, however I have a few and find that they last and last between sharpenings. They are specialist tools and are only used briefly.

I think that I received the first Koyamaichi fishtail (for dovetails) made. :)


The chisel blade is smaller than the Blue Spruce.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#18

bridger

Re: Fishtail not skew

Bridger

If the grind angle of the skew matches (or close enough) the angle of the dovetail the problem goes away.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#19

Re: Fishtail not skew

Patrick Chase

Yep, skews matched to socket angles are a wondrous thing. I learned that one from Ian Kirby's old Dovetailing book, and have a set of 1/4 skews ground at ~1:8.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#20

Sounds better than it is!! (the offer).

david weaver

https://s13.postimg.org/b99lepf1z/20171231_171610_1.jpg

I can get japanese chisels from japan for about $10 each (from a proxy auction - I can't pick matched sets for that price, but sometimes a matched set isn't really what you need).

The above is one that cost me 8 or 10 bucks as a part of a group. I rounded it over tonight (which is a more comfortable version of the koyamaichi chisels) and then cleaned up the work with a deburring wheel.

So, something like 10 bucks plus 10 minutes.

I don't have any thoughts about whether or not it's japanese or western, just mangle anything you have into something like this. I don't have any western chisels I want to mangle at this point. but I already have two that I've hollow ground the sides on that are narrow like this (the two buck chisels I mentioned - of course, this chisel is better, and I did a nicer job on it than I did my other ones, because I knew I'd be taking a picture).

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#21

Re: Fishtail not skew

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'd like to see a photo of one. I cannot visualise this.

I have cut many, many half-blind dovetails over the years, and a fishtail is by very far my preferred choice.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#22

Seaton chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The chisels in the Seaton chest were purchased in 1796 and the chest was built in early 1797. I think it reasonable to assume that the chisels were used to make the dovetails on the chest and the bank of drawers inside.

There are 48 chisels in the chest:

8 mortise chisels

7 heavy socket chisels

33 firmer chisels

There are no bevelled firmer chisels in the chest, no fishtail chisels, and no skew chisels. I don't find these things necessary for making dovetails.

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#23

Re: Seaton chisels

T.M Stock

Modern conveniences...totally overrated. What next? Indoor plumbing? That new-fangled roll toilet paper versus the ever- reliable Sears catalog? Bah. ;-)

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#24

You had me go check...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I have the 1/4" Veritas bench chisel and the 1/2" butt chisel, neither has a sharp enough side to cut me, and as far as I can recall I didn't do anything to them.

In any case, if your chisels end up cutting you, just draw the edges on the side of a fine stone, problem solved...

DC

Re: A lands question for Rob Lee.....

#25

bridger

Re: Seaton chisels

Bridger

Warren, I don't know the Seaton chest well enough to answer this- are the pinboard sockets overcut? That is, assuming half blinds, is the saw work run to depth regardless of length to clear the inside corners? My assumption would be that on a piece as important to the maker as that that it would not have been done that way, but ideas of what counts as first class work do change over time and I've been to understand that dovetails were once considered a utility joint. I guess the point here is that If speed is valued more than a tidy appearance of secondary surfaces just overcutting would eliminate the need for having a skew or fishtail chisel.