Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Windsor mortice and tenon

Posts

Windsor mortice and tenon

#1

Windsor mortice and tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What the difference in seating the tenon is between a 6 degree reamer (ala Pete Galbert/Tim Malley) and a 12 degree reamer (ala Lee Valley)?

Pete Galbert/Tim Malley ...


Lee Valley ...


Allied to this, the shopmade reamer (ala PG) will scrape while the metal reamer (ala LV) will slice. No doubt the latter holds an edge longer. Are there other benefits for one over the other?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#2

Sorry, I can't resist...

David weaver

6 degrees

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

Jack Guzman from Maine

According to Curtis Buchanan the shallower taper has a better hold. I don't know about that but it makes sense. The main advantage to the 12 is availabilty of tools. I started with a 12 but I prefer the way the wooden reamer cuts. It is slower but I have more control.---Jack

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#4

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That makes sense to me as well, Jack.

The other advantage of the 6 degree reamer is that I can make my own ... the taper jig as well.

The 12 degree LV kit looks awfully flash (in a good way). Chris Schwarz certainly likes it. https://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/joinery/chair-joinery-tapered-tenons-tapered-mortises

Yet all the established chair makers use 6 degrees.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#5

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

Brian Holcombe

The scraper is fast enough, maybe too fast if you need to fix an error. I like the six degree taper.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#6

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

david weaver

The principle you describe holds true for planes. There is a wider range of hold for less taper. If the wedge has more taper, it tends to just pop out. Really hard wood and too much taper is a bad combination.

I've never measured plane wedge taper, I can just recall wedges that visually have more vs. those that have less. it's probably in the same ballpark as the chair taper values, though - probably between those.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#7

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Brian, as I recall, you have - or had - the Lee Valley reamer. How do they compare to use and to secure? In other words, why do you prefer the 6 degree reamer?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#9

I missed a big opportunity there...

david weaver

...I didn't even think of the Kevin Bacon reference :)

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#10

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

Brian Holcombe

Derek, I have one and also made the wooden one. The trouble with a 12 degree taper is that it gets to size too quickly if you want through tenons. I think it is better for joints between legs and so forth.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#11

I've built 17 pieces with the 12* tools

Chuck Nickerson

from Lee Valley and none of the joints have let go.

Yet I find myself trying to order Manney's 6* tool.

The 12* taper is not visually subtle once you've seen a piece with 6* tapers.

YMMV.


Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#12

clearly, one is a full Windsor

Joe shelton

And one a half Windsor

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#13

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

roger lance

If, eventually, you don't own both of these tools.....that will be some kind of first.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#14

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

John J.

I agree with Jack, the shallower angle locks in a bit tighter. Might theoretically keep the joint from loosening as much as the wider angle.

In theory, a shallower angle would also cut more quickly. In practice, I would guess the LV would be a more aggressive cutter than the scraping cut.

Probably doesn't make any difference though which you choose. Probably would be a fun project to make one from a sawblade J. Alexander style.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#15

They're both scrapers

Patrick Chase

If you look closely at the pictures of the LV (particularly the enlarged one on the cover of the instruction manual), the blade presents to the wood at 90 degrees.

It's every bit as much a scraper as the shopmade one.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#16

Re: They're both scrapers

david weaver

Anything other than a scraper would get stuck in the cut and break fibers, unless the blade had no clearance (like chairmaker's spoon bits) and then it would cut, but slowly.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#17

Re: They're both scrapers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yes they are scrapers.

I've been looking at Tim Manney's 6 degrees reamer, and decided that I will use it for inspiration and make my own. I can use it to make a tapered tenon cutter.

I am in the throes of completing one of Claire Minihan/Pete Galbert travishers. It feels right to make all the tools myself.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#18

Re: They're both scrapers

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My old reamer has a bevel of about 30 degrees, but the reamer is constructed so that there is about 10 degrees of clearance when used. So 40 or 45 degree cutting angle. Windsor chairs usually have seats of poplar, Liriodendron tulipifera or white pine, Pinus strobus. The idea is to have a light chair so it is easy to move around.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#19

Re: Making Your Own Reamer *LINKS*

William Duffield

If you need more reamer construction information, Peter Galbert provides it on his Chairnotes blog:

http://chairnotes.blogspot.com/2009/02/making-tapered-reamer-to-suit-your.html

Jenny Alexander provides another source of instructions:

http://www.greenwoodworking.com/SawSteelTaperedReamerPlans

Tim Manney provides instructions and jigs for sharpening the reamer blade:

http://timmanneychairmaker.blogspot.com/2013/05/reamer-blade-sharpening.html

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#20

Re: Making Your Own Reamer *LINKS*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks William. Those are good links. I have been aware of them - in my usual excessive fashion I have researched everything to death! - and would have posted them for all if you had not. :)

It would be great to get the tools done before Christmas, although we will be away for a few weeks and I shall not be in a position to start on the three Windsor bar stools I have planned until mid January.

Thanks once again.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#21

Re: clearly, one is a full Windsor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Joe,

A nice pun, tying the subject of reamers to the subject of neckwear very cleverly.

Show of hands: how many know the name of the knot they use on their ties? I had to look it up just now to discover that I used a half Windsor during the tie-wearing part of my life; and to learn that the Four-in-Hand and the Windsors (full and half) aren't the only knots for a tie.

Fortunately, I don't really need to know that anymore...since I graduated from work ten years back, I think I've worn a tie exactly once.

A nice pun.

Bill

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#22

Re: Making Windsors *More LINKS*

William Duffield

I figured you might have seen and studied the linked information. Since I have found it useful, I knew it would also be helpful to (and save some time for) others who are following this thread and considering building Windsor chairs.

While I'm recommending sources for information, Peter Galbert's "Chairmaker's Notebook" from Lost Art Press is worth a place on your shop's bookshelf (or on the screen of your shop laptop).

https://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/chairmakers-notebook

If one learns better from videos than from words and illustrations, Curtis Buchanan's YouTube series is also a good place to start.

https://www.youtube.com/user/curtisbuchanan52

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#23

Re: clearly, one is a full Windsor

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is many years since I (intentionally) wore a tie ... mainly back in my schooldays - we wore uniforms then - and in my years working in a hospital. Never in my subsequent years in private practice.

Back then we took pride in a full windsor knot. It looked symmetrical and smart ... unlike the sloppy and asymetrical half windsor. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#24

Re: clearly, one is a full Windsor

Brian Holcombe

The only knot is four in the hand, IMO. :D I feel more strongly about that that I do double irons.

Well, that and bowtie knots. Of which the only bowtie is a self tie bowtie.

Re: Windsor mortice and tenon

#25

Re: Making Windsors *More LINKS*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William and all ..

"Make a Windsor Chair with Mike Dunbar" is also available in book and ebook (for download) from Popular Woodworking. This was out of print for a long time.

Pop Wood mag shop also has "Build a Traditional Windsor Rocker" with Elia Bizzarri video, as well as one on Welsh Stick Chairs by Don Weber, and not forgetting the travisher/spokeshave building video by Claire Minihan.

Pete Galbert and Curtis Buchanan have been incredibly generous with their knowledge, and both have extensive videos on YouTube. Great guys and wonderful teachers, with skills most of us just dream of developing.

I find, when learning a new skill, that watching video and visualising myself doing the same, then practicing for real, is the way I learn best.

Regards from Perth

Derek