I believe that the only way to prove this is a demonstration, by yourself, on YouTube, of the various tie knots. Wearing them, of course. Clothing is optional.
My father taught me how to tie what he referred to as a "double Windsor" knot. Did it for many years when working for Allied-Signal. Could tie it with my eyes closed or in the dar and I still can. Sometimes it came out better that way!
Is the "double Windsor" the same as a full Windsor? I'll have to look that one up!
I can tie a full Windsor in the dark and a half Windsor, as well. A point of trivia: only officers were allowed to wear a full Windsor when I was in the USMC. we lowly enlisted types were permitted only the half Windsor.
Don’t know of the distinction between full or double, if any.
I always assumed, maybe wrongly, that the double (full) Windsor knot, using more length of the tie within the knot, was better suited to persons who were "height challenged". Or at least "torso length challenged". The tie that results from using a single Windsor knot is longer and better for tall people.
The full Windsor knot looks more symmetrical, and to my eyes, more formal than the single Windsor.
I agree that the full Windsor is more attractive. I like symmetry.
It was kind of funny. When I was in the Marines, a fellow enlisted friend of mine got accepted into OCS. From the day he got his acceptance letter, he started using the full Windsor.
The Windsor knot has a history of use in uniforms, likely for the symmetry. It’s the only tie knot allowed for the Royal Air Force, according to Wikipedia.
So I think that you both are correct in that it’s the most formal knot, I believe military dress is considered equally formal to white tie.