Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

premium chisel vs narex

Posts

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#26

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

Hank Knight

Japan honors its artisans by designating them "National Treasures." I wish we did the same here in the U.S.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#27

Re: premium chisel vs narex

North of the Border

Q: is a premium chisel that cost more than all my narex chisel combined worth the value?

My A: Absolutely NO, if value is defined as getting the job done.

#1, the single premium chisel does not cover the full width of the set.

#2, the premium chisel's edge may last longer but sharpening will still be needed. I consider the sharpening session therapeutic.

#3, the premium chisel's edge may not necessarily be sharper as to a good extent, it depends on the sharpening skill

#4, if it was so premium, I might prefer not to use it for every job, making its rate of use lower.

But that doesn't mean to say premium chisels are not worth it. I have several Veritas PMV11 chisels and use them as often as the Narex. If money was tight, the narex would do any job you threw at them.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#28

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Joseph Piotrowski

for the heavy lifting my Narex will be a go to tool. but i'm thinking all my special chisels, which i don't need anyway, will tend to be higher end chisels, i'm eyeing a large paring chisel, at this point if i'm going to get a chisel , it has to be better than what i already have or i could live without it.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#29

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Patrick Chase

You seem to be ignoring the value of your own time in your analysis.

Narex chisels are inexpensive largely because they aren't post-machined after heat treatment. See my earlier post for more details. If like me you insist (perhaps irrationally) on a flat back etc then Narex will take longer to set up than most "premium" chisels.

Another related gotcha is that Narex chisels (or at least all of my examples) have some residual internal stresses such that the cutting edge curls up a bit and "self dubs" each time you grind the primary bevel. If you care about the resulting amount of dubbing then you have to spend yet more time re-flattening, though admittedly you only have to remove on the order of microns each time. Again this is time that I have to spend on the Narex chisels but not on my "premium" ones.

Don't get me wrong: I think that the Narex chisels are great tools, and I recommend them to people who are starting out and want to get a decent setup inexpensively. You get what you pay for, though.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#30

i agree

Joseph Piotrowski

i spent a lot of time flattening the backs of these chisels. if i have any point, its that they are perfectly fine chisels for cheap if you want to put the work in.

something a beginner may be interested in hearing. the side benefits is your learn a lot about sharpening :). also beneficial whether i want to admit it or not because i hate spending shop time tuning up what should have been flat to begin with.

it seam i still don't know what a premium chisel is like so i will try a few more :).

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#31

What we often forget...

John in NM

The bulk of us don't need perfect, we need usable.

The two Narex I have work just fine for my purposes with minimal back flattening. Since I've never worried a great deal about how flat chisels are, I kind of wonder where the notion of needing super flat backs came from... I could see problems with those highly polished Two Cherries and Hirsch, but I've never owned a bench chisel where I found it to be much of a problem - mostly older Sandvik & Narex. And some Freud ones at a shop I used to work for (basically Sorby bench chisels). They all were flat enough to sharpen easily and they all worked fine as they were.

I've often tried to rationalize buying premium pretty chisels, but in the end I never do it since I've never had any trouble with the cheapish ones. The Narex chisels are an incredible bargain - the price of yellow Stanleys and way better steel. Sure the amount of time spent flattening is large - but I would suggest trying out the chisel without doing that first, one will likely find that the step is completely unnecessary.

Now for applications where it does matter, I do buy the premium tools, like hand cut rasps. I've never gotten the hang of a machine cut rasp, but a hand cut one works like a dream, so I pay the money when I need one.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#32

Re: premium chisel vs narex

North of Border

Regarding time spent on the one-time back flattening...it was negligible over the lifespan of the chisels (30 or 40 years? provided I live that long). I understand the argument of putting a cost to time, but with hobbies, one can even argue people making a 5 or 6-figure salary or more a month should never have any hobby, not even golf.

Internal stresses? My least worry since I work with wood, not with other steel or metal. I know some people might worry if their straight edges are indeed straight to 0.001".

The only legitimate complaint about the Narex for any average woodworker or hobbyist is their handles. I don't like the NA version of bulky handles.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#33

handles

Joseph Piotrowski

I like the narex premium series handles but those other ones ugh!

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#34

True thing...

John in NM

I remember Stephen Shepherd reshaped his more to his liking. I've left them alone for now, but one day I may mess with them. The black plastic handles on my Sandviks aren't much better!

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#35

Re: handles

Patrick Chase

Clarifying one point: I like Narex chisels a lot, and think they're a great value for the money. I presently own or have previously owned Narex bevel-edge, firmer, cranked-neck, paring, and mortise chisels. I've also prepped and given a couple sets to friends and relatives.

I also think that "North of the Border" makes a good point about the competition at that price point - there really isn't much else in their league.

The paring chisels in particular were an absolute bear to prep. IMO those do need to have a reasonably flat (or at least slightly concave) back to register in long slots etc, and the cumulative belly over the length of a couple of those 9" blades was "impressive".

The argument about amortizing setup time over a 30 year life can equally be made in regard to purchase price of "premium chisels" (time is money after all). Both the value of the time you spend setting up a Narex and the value of the money you'd spend to avoid it end up being quite insignificant next to the time you'll spend actually working with the tool.

I agree with everybody about the handles. For that matter I think that the "premium series" ones are still too much on the massive side.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#36

Re: Unless....

david weaver

the premium chisel goes back to some elegant forged design from 200 years ago, I really don't get it, either.

I've tried a lot, and spent a lot, and unless something is absolutely too hard through and through or too soft through and through, you can do an awful lot with it.

Plus, if you don't like the profile of a narex chisel and you put the sides to a grinder, who will cry about it? Try to sell a Lie Nielsen chisel that's been adjusted.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#37

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Michael Brady

I had the opportunity to use the Narex "premium" chisels yesterday during a class. This student explained that he liked the regular Narex but wanted to try the premium version because this was a dovetailing class. The profile of the blade grind is great for dovetails and they came sharp enough to use right out of the package. I was dismayed when I turned them over to find that the backs are hollowed like a Japanese chisel and the 1/4" chisel only had about 3/16" of flat behind the cutting edge. I advised this person to perhaps use his new chisels only for paring and do the chopping with his regular Narex. He agreed. What was their thinking in hollowing the premium chisel backs? Other than that question, the chisels were nice to use and his first dovetails turned out very well.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#38

Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

Patrick Chase

What makes you assume that the back of that chisel was hollowed on purpose?

As I've said clearly several times in this thread, Narex does not fully post-machine after hardening like most makers. That's why they can price their chisels the way they do. Their hardening process produces lower distortion than most, and that enables them to sort of get away with it, but that's the cause of the profile you saw.

I've prepared about 4 dozen Narex chisels over the years between my own and ones I've set up for others including their "premium" line. I've seen just about form of distortion imaginable in the backs of those chisels, including twist and compound profiles (bellied in the tip, hollow behind is a particularly "fun" one that shows up in their long paring chisels).

Your student needs to either decide he doesn't care about flatness, or spend some quality time preparing his chisels. If it's any consolation you get better/faster at it with practice.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#39

"Premium" or "Dovetail" chisels?

Patrick Chase

Sorry about the double-reply, but are you talking about the Narex "Premium" chisels (catalog #8116) or the new "Dovetail" chisels (catalog #8135)?

Catalog here: http://www.narextools.cz/en/download

What I said in my other post is true for the "Premium" chisels but not for the "Dovetail" chisels, which do have an intentionally hollowed back.

As to why they did that, I assume they knocked off the external form of a Japanese chisel. Unfortunately they don't seem to have copied the laminated construction that makes hollowing the back a sensible thing to do in the first place. The obvious problem here is that one can't do Ura-Dashi on a through-hardened Cr-Mn blade.

Lame.

Then again I don't know why I would expect anything else. These are after all the woodworking savants who bought nice expensive CNC machines to stitch their rasps, and then programmed them to create regular tooth patterns. On the plus side they seem to have finally recognized their error and added hand-cut / randomized rasps to their line as of this year.

In case anybody can't tell, I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with Narex. They're extremely competent metallurgists with World-class processes for making consistently good and inexpensive metal implements, but it's hit or miss as to whether those things they make are actually sensible tools.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#40

Re: premium chisel vs narex

david weaver

Discard our previous discussion about retailers, I don't want it to make this seem like more than just an observation I've had from use of japanese chisels:

(and, I don't know if the narex chisels are hollowed consistently like that, if those just happened to be hollow).

Anyway, very little of a chisel needs to be flat for it to work well for dovetails. We're told often about the long reference source of a perfectly flat back, and david C often talks about bellying chisels. When I was a beginner, I was terrified of it. I've learned that I could use all of them well, and the diving that I thought would occur with hollow back single ura japanese chisels just hasn't happened. I think what's going on in terms of direction of cut is determined within a mm or two of the start of a cut, unless the cut is very light.

I'd encourage that student to use his chisels and pretend he never saw the hollow in the back for a while, and draw conclusions after use. He may not notice anything.

Another aside, and maybe it's just luck, but each time I've hardened something (irons, whatever) that's got a bevel on one side, it's hollowed in the opposite side of the bevel. They are blunt bevels when I do that (to prevent decarburization of the edge), but they are there nonetheless.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#41

Re: "Premium" or "Dovetail" chisels?

david weaver

We often just hone the backs of japanese chisels if the hollow gets too close to the edge, and I'd do the same thing with that (it would be easier on the narex chisels because the steel is much softer).

On wider things like plane blades, it's easier to tap out, and some do tap out really wide chisels, but it's usually easier to just hone the metal away unless you're using only natural stones.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#42

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Patrick Chase

Through-hardening leaves the center slightly in compression and the edges in tension, so I think that would tend to cause what you describe (curving "away" from a bevel).

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#43

Re: Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

Michael Brady

It is hollow because a groove is machined or forged down the center of the back of the blade. I thought that seemed pretty clear from my original post when I referred to them looking like Japanese chisels. Since you seem to require documentation, here is where you can look:

https://www.highlandwoodworking.com/narex-dovetail-chisels.aspx

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#44

Re: Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

Brian Holcombe

Interesting, I’ve thought to do that with some full steel western chisels before but the only trouble is that they can’t be maintained except for grinding the back.

Japanese really don’t grind the hollow so much as form the hollow through careful processing. The best ones are not touched after heat treating. I’ve had some that arrive truly forge black nearly all-over on the back and the landing forms rapidly with some careful tapping work.

Grinding a hollow without the features that help it to function over time is only getting one halfway there but I think it’s an improvement over a fully “flat” back.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#45

Re: Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

Patrick Chase

If you were referring to the dovetail chisels, then why did you say in the post I responded to that you were referring to the Narex "premium" chisels (which exist and are a completely different thing)?

You can't really criticize people for getting confused as I did here when your post is simply confusing. While I'm very familiar with the "premium" line I didn't even know that the "dovetail" chisels existed until now, so there was no way for me to detect your error. Please put yourself in others' shoes for a moment before you flame or criticize (I don't "require documentation", but it would be nice to have enough accuracy to be able to tell what you're talking about)

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#46

Re: Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

Michael Brady

I'll just avoid the places where you post. When do you find the time to work wood anyway?

Adios!

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#47

Re: after looking....

david weaver

Definitely different than the japanese ura, which is shallow and gradual, and if anything, I've often seen it worn through sooner than someone would want it to be.

I looked at the link you posted and tracked down a review, and see that Narex "cnc"ed a slot right into the back with what looks almost like a stop cut with a cove bit (no clue what the metal equivalent is).

There's a fair amount of back before the "ura" that I saw, and it should take most users a while to get to it - especially considering that it won't be convenient to grind those chisels in most devices (anyone with an upside down rest?).

I would imagine that Narex had a reason for that hollow, and it may have been that users found it difficult to flatten the chisels with the sharp peak on the back, and reducing surface allows for fast work. It does introduce the chance that someone will try to flatten the backs of their chisels with the chisel hanging off of the edge of the stone right in the hollow (that yields disastrous results).

At any rate, I wouldn't be ashamed to have them, and am sure that by the time someone gets to the ura, a few minutes on a coarse stone with each sharpening will eliminate the ura. For most users, if they're not easy to grind, it will take a very long time to get to the ura, and I wouldn't be surprised to see some people grind the peak off of their chisel backs.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#48

Re: Not intentionally (or consistently) hollowed

david weaver

This can only be settled with an arm wrestling match.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#49

Re: after looking....

Patrick Chase

Where's the picture you're referring to?

Narex steel is reasonably easy to grind, probably most similar in that respect to O1. They describe it as "low-alloy, high-carbon" and I see no reason to question the "low-alloy" part. As Rc59-ish tool steels go it's fairly tough, ductile stuff that holds up well to chopping. That's about what you'd expect from something that's been treated to convert to lower bainite (the objective of austempering).

As I said before, their metallurgy is first rate, particularly when you take value into consideration. IMO it's more impressive to see a maker get good performance out of a low-cost steel/process than it is to see somebody make marginal gains by splashing out big $$$ on unobtainium alloys.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#50

Re: after looking....

david weaver

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/handtools/narex-set-of-3-dovetail-chisels-tool-review.html

I had the parers. I thought they seemed more like garden variety chrome vandium type steel, but I didn't have them long. They made a stringy wire edge, but that may have changed over time.

Regardless of that, i wouldn't be afraid to have and use them. The only chisels that I ever had that were absolutely too soft were a couple of duds in stanley 5001 sets and same for some marples blue chips (which is a shame, because the older blue chip sets have really nice profiles.)