Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

premium chisel vs narex

Posts

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#51

Re: after looking....

Patrick Chase

Interesting picture. As you say they obviously machined the hollow out before heat treatment. Now that I think about it it makes some sense as a way to reduce post-machining costs (these are clearly post-machined, which is unique for them. They're apparently trying to go move up the food chain without breaking the bank and landing themselves in LN/LV territory).

Narex steel does indeed form a pretty tenacious wire edge on just about any abrasive but diamond, and like most steels it's at its worst in that respect on "blunt" abrasives like SiO2. That's not inherently a bad thing, though, as it's a positive indicator for ductility and toughness. You just have to be careful to clean it up, particularly if you use natural stones.

It's not very similar to Chrome-Vanadium IMO, in particular it lacks the super-hard carbides and relatively coarse grain structure. It also does better at low edge angles. Also I believe that the Cr-V steels are limited to conventional martensitic heat treatment.

I have the parers. Of all of the chisels I've ever handled those took the longest by far to dial in. A 9" blade is just too much without post-HT machining IMO.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#52

Re: after looking....

David Weaver

I've got some crv labeled steel that takes a pretty good edge, but I don't know the composition and have never examined it under the scope.

Do you have a set of vintage English papers?

That reminds me, the marples parers that I use in the planemaking videos say chrome vanadium on the underside, and they're pretty old.

If you don't have a set of vintage English parers, it's worth treating yourself. They make the narex parers feel like heavy tent stakes.They need to be bought directly from England to get a decent deal, though.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#53

Speaking of the shoes of others

John in NM

Its often a good idea to make light of people's mistakes and go with the "oh, now it makes sense to me" kind of approach. People then do the same for you when you make an error (and you will make errors, we all do). This makes the forum a pleasant and active place, rather than just a few people discussing how to sharpen tools :D

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#54

Re: after looking....

david weaver

By the way, I'd be happy to post a list of the UK retailers I use (aside from UK ebay).

A delicate paring chisel that comes from England and is resold here for $100 is probably about a $50 item bought from England, and the shipping is low because the weight is very little.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#55

Narex parers

Patrick Chase

Yeah, there's no doubt that the Narex parers are brutish things, which I think is attributable to two things:

1. They have to keep the blades fairly thick/rigid to minimize warping during heat treatment. This goes back (once again) to the lack of post-machining.

2. Narex tends towards heavy chisel designs in general. If you look at the handles on their bench and firmer chisels they're pretty massive, even the premium ones. That sort of thing is why I'm more skeptical about their ability to design usable woodworking tools than I am about their metallurgy and manufacturing processes.

I'll PM you about the English parer sources. I'm interested.

I think the Blue Spruce ones are pretty nice in terms of form, but I simply can't get over the choice of A2 for a *paring* chisel. Even if one favors high-alloy steels for some applications (as I do) one has to acknowledge that paring isn't one of them.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#56

Re: Speaking of the shoes of others

Patrick Chase

Agreed, it was my mistake not to let it go more easily.

Thanks,

Patrick

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#57

Re: Speaking of the shoes of others

david weaver

Punishment of a thousand soundtracks from the movie Frozen for you.

Let it go, let it go... :)

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#58

Re: Narex parers

david weaver

You could make the Blue Spruce chisels (they are just flat stock stabbed in a handle - albeit a superbly turned handle), and I hope I don't make any enemies saying this, but at $40-$50 each for vintage paring chisels, nobody should consider them at what they cost at least until the supply of vintage chisels has dried up. From a use perspective, it makes no sense.

The entire balance of usability with paring chisels (once proper slimness is achieved) is dependent on a fine edge and the balance of sharpening vs. use time.

(the attractive octagonal bolster on the older chisels is just a bonus - a nice thing to have around to copy in case you ever get the urge to grind or saw/file a chisel out of flat stock).

I'm going to assume that Narex makes the parers thick because they are more stable for machining. Even sheffield makers backed off a little and made chisels a bit thicker (not nearly as heavy as Narex, though) with fairly fat lands, and eventually, the bolster became round. I can't remember the bolster shape on mine, but the words "chrome vanadium" on the back of the chisels still sticks out to me because you don't often see such a thing on a chisel with a boxwood handle and a bolster. I'm not sure I'd suspect much regarding the steel if I hadn't seen that - it's really pretty mellow.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#59

Re: Speaking of the shoes of others

Brian Holcombe

Hahahaha!

My only reprieve in kid’s tv is Buddy Thunderstruck! I could watch those episodes by myself and still enjoy.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#60

Narex heat-treatment process

Patrick Chase

Hopefully everybody is aware of Verhoeven's "Metallurgy of Steel for Bladesmiths and Others who Heat Treat and Forge Steel". It's the best short-ish (200 pages) treatment of the topic that I can recall seeing. http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf

I was looking at something else in there recently, and noticed that it contains a reasonably detailed treatment of austempering (what Narex does) starting on page 115.

The short version is that they convert austenite to lower bainite rather than martensite as in a conventional quenching strategy.

For the relevant range of hardnesses (Rc59 in Narex's case) lower bainite is tougher than tempered martensite. That's why the Narex steel seems a little bit "chewy" and prone to forming wire edge.

Higher toughness at the same hardness is an unambiguously good thing (provided your sharpening process is up to it), and I would personally choose Narex's austempered low-alloy steel over O-1 or HCS conventionally quenched and tempered to Rc59 for that reason. IMO it's impressive when somebody can take basically the same raw materials (no high-alloy PM uber-steels here) and obtain superior performance via in improved process.

BTW the "bend a knife in a tube until it snaps" stress-test that David (I think) outlined previously absolutely *loves* austempered steels. See the pictures on p.116 of Verhoeven.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#61

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

David weaver

Is this the same process Paul bos popularized with buck knives? I have a new buck folder that is made of their popular and cheap 420hc to compare to my 154cm hunter that proved to not favor normal sharpening routines.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#62

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

One thing Bos was known for at Buck was using cryo on 420hc, to get an extra point or two of hardness. At least, that’s what the knife forum people say.

Wiley

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#63

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

Patrick Chase

I don't think that 420HC would be a very good candidate for austempering - it usually works best with higher-C and higher peak hardness. Also I don't see any references to salt baths or interrupted quenches in their literature.

It looks to me as though whatever Buck did was more about wringing additional wear resistance out of a fundamentally soft steel than about boosting toughness of an amply hard one like Narex. One possibility is that they did something to promote carbide formation, in which case your sharpening issues may result from Chromium carbides, which are a lot harder than SiO2.

I wouldn't expect you to have much "real" trouble sharpening an austempered low-alloy steel such as Narex uses, as you just need to be careful about the wire edge.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#64

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

david weaver

I had the narex tent stakes for a little while until I could find English paring chisels. I didn't notice them to hold an edge any better than the chrome vanadium marples parers that replaced them. I certainly didn't run a eighth off of them, though, so you never know what the centers would be like.

Even the one dollar chisels from HF can be used once you get past the edge (not recommended, though).

At any rate, I noticed the rubbery wire edge, but I've seen worse for that level of hardness - as rubbery as it was, it had nothing on high speed steel of the same hardness.

In terms of the knives, I haven't sharpened one with 420HC, but I don't anticipate any issues, even with natural stones. The 154CM poor edge came off of horse butt and dursol (I'm sure I tried a nakayama kan with slurry, which is a stone mostly of si02, or I should say majority, but the japanese naturals are just under 20% natural alumina (Al2O3) from volcanic ash. ). I don't use arkansas stones on stainless knives. It's pointless, not because the arks can't cut them, but because they usually get cut too deeply, and an ark loves a strop follower, and stainless knives love to give up their edge carbides to the strop).

the only thing that tuned the edge up was topping off the routine with excessive strokes on balsa with fresh chrome ox.

I could only speculate how it would hold up hunting, but even as it was giving up carbides to the strop very easily, the edge that's left behind would dress a deer no problem. It's just obnoxious when a simple 1095 blade on a tidioute knife will easily outperform it in everything except rust resistance.

(dursol is alumina, like autosol - same maker, which probably know, slightly finer abrasive than autosol and much smellier paste that it's delivered in).

I got the buck 110 folder that I'm going to sharpen for about minus five dollars., otherwise I wouldn't have gotten it, but since I've seen so much positive about the 420HC, which would've been what my buck hunter would've been as a standard model, i figured I'd like to see if it is practically better than the 154CM. I would suspect that for actual use in the field, the ease of sharpening would make it more practical.

I don't expect any of them to hold a candle to GEC's 1095, but other 1095 knives (like ontario or ka-bar, vintage or new) don't, either.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#65

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

David Weaver

Curious to hear what your experience with the narex is like compared to something else like a Stanley 750 or an o1 chisel like Ashley iles.

I wonder if the process you're describing offers better stability with less deformation through the heat treatment process.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#66

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

Patrick Chase

I think that the Narex chisels are broadly comparable to Stanley 750s. They're likely quite a bit tougher, but I generally try to avoid "discovering" those sorts of differences. I don't have enough experience with AI to have formed a clear opinion.

Austempering does indeed yield better stability through the heat treat process. The quench is interrupted above the Martensite start temperature (Ms), and the vast majority of deformation and cracking happens just below that as the Austenite converts to Martensite. Martensite has a different density than Austenite, so unless the piece is perfectly isothermal there will be considerable internal stresses as the part passes through the conversion range. Narex's process converts to Lower Bainite instead, which has less such issues.

As I've said several times in this thread, they take advantage of that increased HT stability to avoid post-machining most of their chisels (with the apparent exception of the "Dovetail" ones that we discussed in another tangent). That's part of the reason they can offer them so cheaply for the quality.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#67

Re: Narex heat-treatment process

david weaver

Though I complained about the wire edge, it's not like it was that far out of place (i may have said that already). Almost all newer chisels have that unless they're either very hard or something very plain. There's not much very plain left.

Iles chisels are terribly lovely to me, but I've noticed others don't like them for reasons like that you can tell that they're hand finished, which means you can see that they're not all identical.

At their price (despite the bubbles I found in a couple earlier - those were bubbles at 200x), they are difficult to beat. Their profiles are nice, and their weight and balance is a lot like really old chisels.

I think I am past the point of buying anything other than carving tools as far as handled edge tools go, but I don't want to jinx myself. I haven't bought anything else of narex because I know I will have the urge to grind the sides on them and then replace the handles (which is only fun a couple of times).