Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....
david weaver
Sharpness in geometry refers to the fact that the peak on the backs of this chisels is fairly sharp (that is uncomfortable, but not automatically problematic). The edges/sides are very gradual and an angle probably ..who knows, I don't have them anymore, but let's say 80 degrees. They are sharp, which is excellent for dovetails because they don't present any part that will bruise, but when you do the typical thing of knocking out the waste and then grabbing the chisels to do any minor cleanup work for corner stragglers, you'll soon find blood on your work.
When I had mine, rather than modify the chisels by breaking their edges a little, I put a piece of athletic tape over the first joint on my index finger.
They are lovely chisels.
I haven't had a tormek for a while now, but when I did, I had the old jig that people found problematic (SE-76 or something like that rings a bell). It counted on the top of a chisel being parallel to the back to generate an even bevel. There is no real top on these chisels, they come to a peak. I have no experience with the new "improved" straight edge jig and no longer have any tormek-ish type stuff.
If the new jig registers off of the bottom of the chisel rather than the top, you might be OK. I sharpened them by hand, which is both a blessing and a curse - the blessing is that the cross section is tiny. The curse is that if you're used to freehand sharpening by resting a tool on its bevel, it's like trying to lean back safely on a three-legged stool. It takes a bit of time to get used them, but not that much. once you get used to what they like, a tormek would just slow things down. They are superb edge holders as long as you just hammer them straight into things.
I saw yesterday on Stu Tierney's blog that Mr. K makes his chisels in a mechanical press (presumably in special dies for each chisel) rather than a hammer forge, so they are close to final dimension, and that probably has a lot to do with why the geometry is so precise without making them exorbitantly expensive.
I'll leave it to someone other than me to make a contention that you can't squish a chisel in a press instead of hammering and have it turn out well, because Mr. K has his bona fides in my view after using his chisels for a while.
(FWIW, I found the geometry to be almost the same on the old blue handled marples chisels - something they lost the concept of long ago, but in each set of marples or stanley 5001 chisels that I've gotten, there's always a dud, and the ones that aren't duds don't remotely resemble the quality of Mr. K's chisels. Translation, there's no great need to spend $400 on dovetail chisels, but if you have the money, you're getting what you pay for with them - your call. I've got no issue with paying skilled makers and their purveyors for good work, and am always a little confused by furniture makers who scold people for spending money on tools, but wish for someone to spend extra money on furniture that is no more functional than ikea RTA stuff).