Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

premium chisel vs narex

Posts

premium chisel vs narex

#1

premium chisel vs narex

Joseph Piotrowski

Q: is a premium chisel that cost more than all my narex chisel combined worth the value?

A: Maybe.

i find myself in need of a 3/8 inch chisel. i don't have one. i have a 4 or 5 pc set from narex( the classic) and one of the premium bench chisels. as a side note, i like the premium handles better. all together maybe 70 or so dollars. vs 130 for one.

the narex took some effort to set up, they also seamed to need a break in period. as they now hold a edge better after a few months of usage/sharpening .

my dovetail techniques scream out for a 3/8" chisel. so i figure i try a premium one for comparison sake. i purchased a blue steel Japanese matsumura dovetail chisel. i think it's a premium brand, or at least as far as i'm willing to go.

flatting the back took less than 5 mins. another 5 sharpening. my narex took about 30 mins each.

so a little experiment on a test run on some practice dovetails this week. the winner is definitely the Japanese chisel. it cuts cleaner, thinner shavings longer than the narex. hones as easy butter while working.

it's not going to make me throw away my narex and if money is tight, the narex are perfectly fine. i'd still recommend these chisel for a budget minded person as they are a step above my old craftsman chisels. i'll use these for the rough stuff but when it comes time to clean out the waste to the line, its the Japanese chisel all the way!

at least that is my story and i'm sticking to it.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#2

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Patrick Chase

Narex uses a single step hardening/tempering process (austempering in a molten salt bath, with interrupted quench) that produces a relatively small amount of warp. They take advantage of that to reduce their costs, by doing 100% of their machining before heat treatment.

In contrast the premium makers all post-machine after HT. This has two benefits:

1. Better geometry and therefore less setup/tuning for the end user. Narex' HT process produces admirably low distortion, but it's not as good as can be achieved with careful post-machining. That's probably why your premium chisel took so much less effort to set up.

2. HT can leave some (relatively) soft/decarburized steel at the surface, and post-machining gets rid of that. That may explain why the Narex chisels require some break-in. I've seen the same BTW.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#3

very detailed info

Joseph Piotrowski

one thing i can say is they both will cut your finger just the same! lol and if you can't chop straight they both leave a gap in the dovetail :)

i'm not dismissing the narex. they are fine and considering 10 times cheaper are a value buy.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#4

Re: Lee Valley...

TomD

The third option is to make your own. I made a 3 piece set in an evening or two. Cost was so low I can't even place it, mostly scrap. They matched a fourth chisel that goes for 80 or 100 dollars, there is no difference. The advantage to the home made, other than cost and proficiensy is that I personally don't see the point in spending a lifetime of free time making "better" stuff while my personal life is populated with crap. If I was in the studio furniture selling business, and there are different ways of doing this, I would wonder why my clients would spend thousands for a chair with someone whose own circumstances were dismal. It is the artist craftsman designer environment, not the peasant carpenter environment. So what neither Narex, or Japanese have is customization to specific use or user. I have spent as much as 350-500 on a Japanese chisel, and always thought I got value, but I didn't get a chisel designed for a western way or form of work. You can sure enough use them, but you can use a fiberglass chair also.

Another thought is that a huge proportion of woodworkers seem to be more interested in tools, methods, and gaining skills. Most are not really that well informed about furniture, or involved in trends related to that. The closest this board may have ever gotten to that was a discussion about the reproduction of a 50 year old chair. But mention a new tool release, and the number of hits on a thread goes through the roof. So why not split the difference and make your own tools, you know you really want to.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#5

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would recommend oils stones for the Narex chisels and water stones for the Japanese chisel. What did you use for the comparison?

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#6

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Hank Knight

My wife gave me Matsumura blue steel cabinet chisels by ones and twos for Christmas and Birthdays over several years and I now have a very nice set of them. I agree with you completely, there are superb chisels. I was on a chisel binge for several years and collected Witherbys, Swans, Stanleys and some other premium traditional brands. I love them all, but my Matsumuras are the best. They are reserved for dovetails and the very finest detail work. I sharpen them with water stones and I give them a final polish with a natural Japanese Honyama stone. They get wicked sharp.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#7

Re: premium chisel vs narex

david weaver

The steel in the matsumura chisels is almost certainly a hitachi white or blue 2, which is superior to the steel in the narex chisels and driven to a higher hardness.

It's probably also done in a gas forge one at a time, whereas I'd assume that the narex chisels are done in open air on a line (which will do a good job, but you'll get some atmospheric no-nos that mean the first bit of use will be substandard, just as you describe).

I've had three narex chisels. I found them fine, and good for the price, but they lack the refinement of a better chisel and the alloy is fairly rubbery, which means quick sharpening techniques need to end with a very fine abrasive to avoid a big wire edge. You'll never get that with japanese steel, it's driven to too high of a hardness and is too plain to make that pain in the rear wire edge.

Whether or not the japanese chisels are worth the cost is up to the user. I just wish there was more available that didn't come through harima (or whoever the huge wholesaler is who brings stuff into the US and makes it expensive). There are other ways to get tools from japan (proxy auction, etc), but they're not practical for someone getting one chisel. If you ever decide you want to try a different make but don't want to spend a ton of money, the lowest "top tier" (fully hard, full durability) chisels you can find are koyama-ichi. They're very good chisels and about the same cost as intermediate stuff like matsumura because their finish is pretty much right off of the grinder. As you go up in price, the finish gets more refined, but practical use isn't affected much unless a chisel is defective. When you get to rare air (kiyotada, konobu, etc), you get a more neatly made chisel and really top level edge holding, but not too much practical gain.

Japanese steel makers take their plain edge steels a lot more seriously than we do here. When I've bought 50 year old mix and match chisels from japan, they are still superb. Like a harder version of the best vintage chisels you can find.

It's a lot like listening to music. You can listen to music on a $100 system from Target, or you can really tighten the screws and find something that costs a lot more and is a little better (but to someone who really likes the difference and finds it satisfying, they'll be glad to spend the difference).

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#8

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Hank Knight

David,

I agree with your analysis. I have five Imai bench chisels and four Imai slicks. They are superb chisels and cost a bunch more than my Matsumuras, but in actual use, I don't find them much better than the Matsumuras. They are hand made, better looking and feel good in the hand, but they don't outperform the Matsumurtas. That doesn't mean that I regret the purchase. On the contrary, I'm very fond of them and I'm glad I bought them. I love beautiful tools and my Imais fit the bill perfectly.

Hank

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#9

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Japanese chisel steel - even at the cheap end - offers a level of performance that Western chisels struggle to reach. I purchased a few Matsumura chisels about 20 years ago, and they surpassed the Witherbys and Bergs I was using at the time. A few years later I came across four 1980-vintage Koyamaichi bench chisels (dovetails style) on the UK eBay, and grabbed these, having read glowing reports about them in an article by David Charlesworth.

I recall a discussion with Stew (from Tools from Japan) around that time that, where Koyamaichi were not for sale outside Japan, Matsumura were not on sale in Japan, and were an unknown name there.

Comparing the two, the Matsumura were fairly brittle, and they remain the only Japanese chisel I have ever chipped. They were sold and replaced with a few more Koyamaichi, when these became available.

The Koyamaich are superb chisels, and retain their edge exceptionally well. I used one when comparing chisels chopping with different steels, and they were superior to PM-V11, which they beat into second place, and both just streets ahead of A2 and O1 far in the rear.


My paring chisels are slicks by Kiyohisa. These were a 3 year wait a decade ago, and now I believe this has stretched to double that. They do not look particularly special, but they are amazing. The steel does not seem hard, and they sharpen so easily. Yet they take an amazing edge and hold it forever - so it seems. Have I used "amazing" to describe them? :)


It is important, when discussing Japanese chisels, to mention that they are used differently to Western chisels - especially the bench chisels, which are designed to be worked with a gennou/hammer. But that is a topic for another day.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#10

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Hank Knight

Derek,

Not to be argumentative, but I feel I must comment on your post. I've heard remarks about the "brittleness" of Matsumura chisels, but I've been using mine for over 15 years and I've never chipped one. I did chip a no-name Japanese dovetail chisel I got early on, so I was particularly aware of chipping potential when I started using my Matsumuras. Granted, I don't use them for heavy duty chopping and excavation, but I have used them fairly heavily over the years and I've never chipped one. I've read your praise of Koyamaich chisels and thought I would start purchasing them to replaced my Matsumuras, but the need has never arisen. I have been, and continue to be, completely satisfied with my Matsumuras.

Hank

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#11

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Hank

I cannot imagine why one would replace a chisel - Matsumura in your case - if happy with them. I should explain that the chipping on mine was minimal compared to the damage other chisels would have endured, since I used them to chop into very dry Jarrah (salvaged roofing timbers), which was my main source of lumber in those days. This was not "everyday" pounding.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#12

Re: premium chisel vs narex

david weaver

Hank -

I had koyamaichi chisels, ouchi and iyoroi chisels. The iyoroi chisels are the worst of the bunch by every review, and technically, they probably are. They sharpen well on a washita stone (and are thus probably not that hard by japanese standards, but still are very hard relative to western chisels and very fine and even). White 2, nothing special.

the iyoroi chisels are the only ones I have left. I sold the KI chisels because they were the dovetail type and I found no great need for them. The ouchi chisels required more time overall because they were much harder (mine were an older set, I don't know if they may have toned them down a little), and between them and the iyoroi, I didn't really have a great preference either way, and knew the ouchi would be easier to sell.

So, I have my iyorois, as bad as they are regarded, and each time I cut a plane handle mortise and then sharpen them in 20 seconds, I feel good about keeping them.

I had two matsumura parers years ago (I just turn through some things quickly) one was 12mm and one 24. The 24 crumbled, and the 12 was a pearl. I'd imagine you got the pearls when you got yours, you just never know, but what works well at the bench works well at the bench.

KI chisels are a click or two harder than the matsumuras that I had, and that includes in parers. I thought the lines of both were quite nice (the finish on the KI may have been a bit more coarse and straight off the grinder, but it was lovely nontheless). I couldn't be sure if I have more than two parers at this point that are japanese - both are from Wiley, and i'll never sell them.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#13

Narex heat treatment process

Patrick Chase

As I said in an earlier post, Narex pre-machines and then heat treats in a molten salt bath (look up "austempering" for further info).

So no, it isn't "in air on a line". There are some surface issues, but nowhere near as severe as you'd see from the latter.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#14

Re: premium chisel vs narex

Patrick Chase

David already alluded to this, but brittleness is very much a function of process and can therefore vary, particularly in hand-forged tools. It's often the case that consistency is one of the most important differentiators between makers.

After all, everybody is buying their base stock from Hitachi, and the heat-treatment processes aren't exactly a secret in this day and age, so a lot of the differences come down to execution.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#15

Re: premium chisel vs narex

TomD

I think the whole thing about chipping on Japanese chisels is overwrought, and also not. I take the position that chisels should never be used to pry because 1) I don't believe they should be; 2) It is fun to learn how to avoid it 3) generally if one learns to avoid prying, the techniques involved are more efficient. Of course one can pry on chisels, and some are designed with that in mind. But if you don't pry, Japanese chisels which generally are not designed for that, are not going to chip.

However, I have referred to the case where some guy came in to change out our oil tank, and picked up one of my Ebony, blue steel, Oucii chisels, from a 15 chisel set, and used it as a cold chisel to cut away some bolts. That chipped the edge, though as tragic as it was to me at the time. It probably only chipped the edge about as badly as people imagine careful woodworking chips an edge. I lost a little blade length, not the chisel.

However, I got a good deal on Lee Valley sourced Japanese mortise chisels that they had on sale at one point. They were suffering a 100% return rate on them due to the fact that people pried on these sturdy looking spikes, causing a fracture at the point where the lamination terminated on the back of the chisels. So you can get some pretty big chips at times. The spikiness is there to allow you to pound on them as though you are placing the last spike on a continental railway, not so you can use them as a crowbar.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#16

A question of clarification......

roger lance

LV sells a set of Japanese chisels but spells the name of the blacksmith as Hiroshi Koyama (Koymaichi).

You spell the maker of your set differently.....Koyamaichi.

Is this the same maker.....or is the LV set being made by someone with a similar name??

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#17

Re: A question of clarification......

david weaver

Same maker.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#18

Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

roger lance

Do you sharpen using a secondary bevel on a Koymaichi chisel?.....or just hone a primary bevel?......do you hollow grind these chisels or not?

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#19

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

To answer your first question, "Koyamaichi" is the name used for these chisels everywhere but LV. They are made by Mr Koyama.

I do add a hollow grind to the Koyamaichi. This is only done on the Tormek, where there is no chance of heating the edge. I have been hollow grind them for at least a decade, and never had an issue with this. The advantage of the hollow is speed to hone, and self-jigging. ... no secondary bevel.

The Kiyohisa are honed in the traditional manner - honed on the full bevel. This is more out of respect for the maker, not because I believe hollowing degrades the edge .. plus I like to see the lamination, as it is so well done.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#20

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

david weaver

Notable for folks who buy the dovetailed chisels from LV, it'll be difficult to grind them because they don't have a reference on the top. You generally will want to do the entire process by hand.

I think those chisels (and I had a set at one point), the KI dovetail, are wonderful chisels but something to get later when your bases are covered, because their sharpness in geometry can make them somewhat uncomfortable to handle in some circumstances.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#21

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

Josko Catipovic

David - thanks for the timely comment - I was just thinking of treating myself to a set of LV Japanese dovetail chisels. Can you help me understand why a top reference is needed to use a grinder? My Tormek seems to work fine with just a bottom-edge reference, but I've never had a triangular chisel in it before. Also, what's meant by 'sharpness in geometry'? Thanks in advance.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#22

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

david weaver

Sharpness in geometry refers to the fact that the peak on the backs of this chisels is fairly sharp (that is uncomfortable, but not automatically problematic). The edges/sides are very gradual and an angle probably ..who knows, I don't have them anymore, but let's say 80 degrees. They are sharp, which is excellent for dovetails because they don't present any part that will bruise, but when you do the typical thing of knocking out the waste and then grabbing the chisels to do any minor cleanup work for corner stragglers, you'll soon find blood on your work.

When I had mine, rather than modify the chisels by breaking their edges a little, I put a piece of athletic tape over the first joint on my index finger.

They are lovely chisels.

I haven't had a tormek for a while now, but when I did, I had the old jig that people found problematic (SE-76 or something like that rings a bell). It counted on the top of a chisel being parallel to the back to generate an even bevel. There is no real top on these chisels, they come to a peak. I have no experience with the new "improved" straight edge jig and no longer have any tormek-ish type stuff.

If the new jig registers off of the bottom of the chisel rather than the top, you might be OK. I sharpened them by hand, which is both a blessing and a curse - the blessing is that the cross section is tiny. The curse is that if you're used to freehand sharpening by resting a tool on its bevel, it's like trying to lean back safely on a three-legged stool. It takes a bit of time to get used them, but not that much. once you get used to what they like, a tormek would just slow things down. They are superb edge holders as long as you just hammer them straight into things.

I saw yesterday on Stu Tierney's blog that Mr. K makes his chisels in a mechanical press (presumably in special dies for each chisel) rather than a hammer forge, so they are close to final dimension, and that probably has a lot to do with why the geometry is so precise without making them exorbitantly expensive.

I'll leave it to someone other than me to make a contention that you can't squish a chisel in a press instead of hammering and have it turn out well, because Mr. K has his bona fides in my view after using his chisels for a while.

(FWIW, I found the geometry to be almost the same on the old blue handled marples chisels - something they lost the concept of long ago, but in each set of marples or stanley 5001 chisels that I've gotten, there's always a dud, and the ones that aren't duds don't remotely resemble the quality of Mr. K's chisels. Translation, there's no great need to spend $400 on dovetail chisels, but if you have the money, you're getting what you pay for with them - your call. I've got no issue with paying skilled makers and their purveyors for good work, and am always a little confused by furniture makers who scold people for spending money on tools, but wish for someone to spend extra money on furniture that is no more functional than ikea RTA stuff).

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#23

Re: Questions on sharpening a Koymaichi.....

Josko Catipovic

"I've got no issue with paying skilled makers and their purveyors for good work, and am always a little confused by furniture makers who scold people for spending money on tools, but wish for someone to spend extra money on furniture that is no more functional than ikea RTA stuff."

I couldn't have said it better myself. I want Mr. K. to prosper and continue his craft, and want to support him. Getting an awesome set of chisels in the process is almost secondary.

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#24

Tormek blade holding

David Charlesworth

In the beginning the Tormek blade jig had the moving clamping plate on top. This caused difficulty if the blade was not of even thickness from side to side.

I discussed this with the designer at a show and about ten years later they came up with a jig which had the clamping plate underneath. Much better as the face side was registered.

Recently a similar jig with an extra! It can tilt the blade from side to side so that various cambers are possible. SE-77

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: premium chisel vs narex

#25

SE-77

Patrick Chase

That's a nifty jig. I do my skews freehand these days, but that would have been nice to have in the past.