Re: Breadth of forum participation
Charlie
An optimistic view no doubt...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Breadth of forum participation
Charlie
An optimistic view no doubt...
Re: Breadth of forum participation
Charlie
Funny though....
Thanks William.
Beautiful workbench Roger!
Thanks Mark.....
roger lance
Its not perfect....but, I think I'll keep it.....
Perfection exists to be pursued not caught.
Re: Who are the teachers?
TomD
"I know who Alan Peters is. Charlie tells me I'm nuts for thinking George is in a class with Alan as a maker and designer. I think Alan's stuff is wonderful, but George could make any of it and the converse isn't true (if you flip names). Notwithstanding the fact that they are very different makers, and both excellent."
I don't know who George is, but have followed your comments about him. Your comment sounds to me like talking about someone who is a good local theater player being described as someone who could have done Brando's part in whatever as well as Brando did it. They point is that Brando created it. And arguably created an approach all his own, it has been said.
The repertoire of skills in a Peter's piece is not all that impressive. But it only has to be what he needs it to be. But he produced work over a lifetime that had a distinctive style to it. I have no idea whether Elton John is as good a musician/composer as Beethoven, but Elton John has risen to prominence within his generation in a somewhat similar way. You don't get the credit unless you climb the mountain.
Another example would be Rob Cosman, who studied with several notable craftsmen including Peters. Rob obviously has skills. Don't think he will be remembered internationally for his furniture at all. Could be wrong, and he has made the mark he has made living just outside Saint John NB, my mother's home town, for that he has my respect. Because I could do what he did living in Toronto. I can't say I tried, and there you go with that.
Re: Occasionally, someone thinks they have......
TomD
Roger, I have made that joint, and I turned a dowel on the end of the upright, and rammed it through the lapped base (I am an excellent turned and got a tight fit). Has wobbled ever since. Scowl. Yours is exquisite.
Re: Print from 1993
TomD
"And that's not you doing the latter, but I see it a lot. We would also help them if we gave broad generalizations. "Oh, so you want to dimension by hand? You probably will want to learn to use the double iron. It'll cut about 35% of the labor out of the process, make it much nicer to do and you'll have much less waste"."
Be the change you want to see. Don't start every response to such a question with two things you know will drive everyone else batty. You should know by now what they are. One of them is in the sentence above. You should also know you occasionally drive people batty based on the number of times you have given yourself a time out. A thing I share.
Re: Stanley...anyone care to comment?
TomD
The problem with this layout is that it doesn't describe or show the correct use of the chip breaker. Breakng of chips is what happens when the CB is too far back from the edge. Curling is the same issue. A proper placement allows shavings to emerge that are not broken, and at least with the geometry I prefer, they come out pretty much limp and straight. In the Japanese film, you can see the shaving pressing down into the cut. All the breaking does is snap the chip before it gets too long a lever arm, a little like the modern carbide machine tooling that segments chips.
The thing is that I know we know, and the reason for that is because the Japanese stuff works as in the Japanese film. It seems likely that given that CBs have been on western planes for centuries, they were there for a reason; that luck would have dictated someone would discover why; and as I said, I wonder if they were ever free to be set in the cut. As much as I thought everyone knew how they worked, it is hard to force that conclusion down the throat of anyone who resists it, because the evidence is not clear.
I don't really get where David is coming from because he claims to have learned this from the latecomers (sorry don't know who is getting the credit for others work here), yet he was heavy heavy into Japanese planes, I thought.
Since we are copying the Japanese here, could we put in a word for when they don't use breakers?
Re: Who are the teachers?
TomD
"Because I couldn't do..."
Re: Stanley...anyone care to comment?
TomD
I suppose that is one point the Stanley thing does make clearly, there is a place to use breakers and place not to use them.
Re: Who are the teachers?
TM Stock
Before every flight of an 8000 hour flying career that spanned 40 years, I finished the preflight, tossed the checklist and inspection gear in the aircraft, and did two complete circuits around the aircraft in an anti-clockwise direction before I got in the aircraft and committed to converting JP-4 to noise. Before I took those turns around the aircraft, I visualized open cowlings, control locks still in place, 'Remove Before Flight' streamers flying briskly in the breeze, and all the other stuff often missed in aircraft prep that go from inconvenient on the ramp to hazardous on the runway to a couple of letters from the unit commanders to spouses once airborne.
I did it because Ray Sovia - my chain-smoking, six tours in 'Nam primary flight instructor - did it, and insisted on an 18-year-old me doing it, and - more importantly - did it himself for every hour of his 25,000 hour-plus career.
I taught my primary students to do the same, and as an instructor of instructors, taught other instructors the technique. As a senior standards pilot for a large organization, I cajoled my boss into requiring it of all crews, and as commander of a combat aviation unit, required every pilot to do it on pain of getting booted from what was a plumb special ops billet.
I got grief for 'wasting time' by other pilots early in my career. I was advised that even if I did those circuits of the aircraft walking backwards in a funny hat and gesticulating wildly with a wand, it was still not bringing me any special favor with the sky gods that dictate whether a flight is trouble free or otherwise.
A funny thing happened on the way to that 8000 hours of incident-accident free flying time...no loose cowlings, no control locks still sitting between stab and elevators, and no pitot-static covers disabling my airspeed indicator on takeoff. No incidents or accidents related to preflight oversights in units where I ran the show or had the boss's ear on policy.
Sometime around 2005 when I retired from military flying, one of my original primary students (then teaching at Duke in engineering IMS) from circa 1979 sent me an article from one of the psychology/human performance mags that explained the why of what I had been doing since my first walk-around with Mr. Sovia in 1976. It was a bunch of interesting notions on pattern and anti-pattern recognition, and cited (amongst other things), visualizing a round in the chamber before picking up and clearing a weapon, versus looking for and expecting the weapon to be cleared.
It was nice to have some science to attach to what I had been doing and teaching, but the article did not generate a single second of those 8000 accident/incident free hours, or the hundreds of thousands of safe hours flown by my students, fellow pilots, or aircrews under my command. If I were still teaching flight instructors, I'd include the why of why I insisted on the practice, but most of those students would forget the why and simply comply with the what and the how.
Re: Who are the teachers?
david weaver
George isn't similar to what you're describing. Figure everything you've ever made, and then decide that there is someone who could make it 8 times better and twice as fast. That would be George. It doesn't matter if it's refurbishing a machine, making a knife, making a dueling pistol (including all of the parts), or making or contributing to a random item for half a dozen presidents, the queen or Margaret Thatcher.
George is a maker's maker, and i know you like to make a lot of musical instruments, but George's (violins and violas) are in professional symphonies, and one of his "pistols with a few kit parts" as he puts it (as in, not his best work from soup to nuts) was purchased by one of the duponts. As with the top makers in general, he's connected. If someone asked you to fix an 18th century telescope that was broken, what would you do?
He's not the guy at the theater, he's Brando.
I agree with what you said, that Peters - well, we don't really know what he was capable of in its entirety, because he was operating within a business that had to produce. It tends not to be your absolute best.
The difference between most folks and George is that George is still a sponge for information, still full of ideas, but physically limited about 4 hours of work a day. He's accessible to us, and sometimes his opinion isn't wanted by people, even though he offers it only in the interest of getting people to do better work. Little of his work is online, and showing something like this:
http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson1.html#wilson6
..makes it seem like he's a luthier (and he is), but luthiery is only a tiny slice of the things he's made.
The difference between him and most of the other makers is that he's retired, so he's accessible (whereas he wouldn't have been up to about 7 or 8 years ago).
The other thing that's helpful for us amateur dopes is that he has a superb sense of classical design and nothing that he makes comes out "sort of funky".
I bring him up all the time because I'm not aware of anyone similar to him - I certainly would never be able to make 95% of the stuff he does. That's life, and it doesn't bother me, but I sure do appreciate being able to get legitimate advice from him rather than bro-design from the forums.
Re: Stanley...anyone care to comment?
david weaver
There's relatively little about using the double iron with japanese planes. Odate talks about it, but I wasn't around for the first wave of japanese stuff in the 80s.
(That's an entirely different thing than whether or not the japanese use them, but what's written in English tends to focus more on the smoothing side of the operation and the final smoothing at that. I'm sure the use of the cap in dimensioning is pretty common over there, it reduces labor and it's hard to avoid something when it's easier).
It was only getting into dimensioning that stuffed me toward putting the cap iron back in those planes. I don't and didn't really buy much in terms of texts in 2012, I just figured warren was credible and limited myself to stanley planes for two weeks and figured out how to use the cap iron. It took a lot less than two weeks, but by the end of two weeks (maybe by the end of one) I had gotten used to what useful settings looked like and the whole thing of changing how the cap iron is set from time to time went away.
Re: Print from 1993
david weaver
That's my gimmick, my Piper's Pit if you will.
Re: Who are the teachers?
Patrick Chase
George established the musical instrument shop at Colonial Williamsburg and then ran their toolmaking shop. As David says he's fairly well known.
Skepticism
Mark Hennebury
I have to understand how everything works.
i cannot just follows rules without understanding why, so i wouldn't do good in the military.
My hats off to those who are, my father was, and i have a lot of respect for all that we have because of the military.
But i need to look and understand what a machine is doing and whats in it and how it functions, i could not just push a stick into thicknessplaner if i didn't look into it first and see how it works and check that it was setup correctly.
My best friend was a helicopter pilot for more than twenty years, and by all reports was similar to you was very conscientious about doing pre-flight checks. He died along with nine others in a flight off of the Maldives due to catastrophic mechanical failure, beyond his control. I have earned my mistrust over many years and many instances. I will trust no-one ( including myself) unless i can check and verify, i except the limitations of this and the repercussions.
I apply this attitude to learning woodworking, give me a tool and i will figure it out, i will take it and examine it and try it, i will modify it and try to improve it, i may cut and grind bits off it , i may destroy it, but i will understand it.
Many well respected books have a lot of flaws in them, and it is pretty obvious that they have not be pointed out, so that proves to me that although we look, we don't always see.
Joinery is the same, give me a problem and i will design a joint to suit it. I love Japanese joinery, but i believe that anyone given a specific problem, could design the functional joints with a basic understanding of wood structure and some basic engineering comprehension. they should be quite obvious.

Re: Skepticism
TM Stock
One of my flight school classmates told me recently that about half of the group is dead...about 1/2 of them due to excessive exposure to gravity and the rest to angry wives meeting shapely girlfriends, love of fast motorcycles coupled with distain for helmet laws, and the Big C. Helos are just harder to fly and more hazardous to life and limb than airplanes. As slow as most helos cruise (~180 mph is pretty fast for a helo), they will get you to the scene of the accident a lot sooner than most airplanes.
Re: Skepticism
Mark Hennebury
My friends flight instructor, (who took me up in the chopper once) died flying a fix-wing into the tarmac at an airshow.
Margin or error i guess is pretty slim in some of those things.
Re: Skepticism
david weaver
Reminds me of a Ron White joke:
Q: "Mr....Mr....how far do you think this airplane can fly on one engine?"
A: "All the way to the scene of the crash"
