Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

Posts

Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#1

Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Please watch the video in the link.

Supersurfacers are industrial size handplanes; And being industrial they have to work, so have had a lot of thought put into understanding the mechanics involved in cutting.

Like handplanes they have a knife and a chipbreaker (back-knife)

Marunaka have been making supersurfacers since the 70's and they understood chipbreaker settings and apparently a lot more. The K/K video only covered chipbreakers, and to understand planing you need to consider what wasn't on the video as well.

But to those that keep saying this was "lost" I will tell you it may have been lost to you, and you can make whatever excuse you want for that, but it was always knowledge that was known and available in this brilliant age of information.

I got my first supersurfacer probably 25 years ago and the instruction for knife setting are quite detailed and specific as you will see below.

So i will again post the supersufacer set-up diagrams for those that may be interested.

If anyone has any questions and would like more information i will be more than happy to help.













Below is the knife/ chipbreaker setting gauge for precision setting the chipbreaker setback.




And a video ;https://youtu.be/eaClhzlpc_0

And yes they do cut hardwoods;

Birdseye Maple and baked Birdseye Maple


And you can cut some pretty thin shavings if you want to have some fun;




supersurfacer video

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#2

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications

david weaver

I see some evidence of crushed grain on the pine (that's just an issue of setting), but the machine is really fantastic (and compared to the planer chatter that's literally on the trim in my house and was never removed, the crushed grain is far better).

In a world where I had more room and more money, I'd have one of these. The dust load is significantly less. A beautiful machine with a very intuitive operation and intuitive setup.

(I know warren will see what I mentioned if he watches the video - if I can spot it, he'll see it, too).

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#3

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications

Mark Hennebury

Warren the pursuit of perfection is a journey without end;

The closer you get, the more you focus and the imperfections are still seen, they just keep getting smaller and you keep magnifying, it is only when you step back you can see how far you have traveled.

Is a supersurfacer going to give you a perfect finish at all magnifications, no.

Keep in mind that technically the best surface is made by the first cut, as your blade edge degrades with each pass. If you were truly searching for perfection you would hone your blade for the final pass. But from a practical level a supersurfacer does an incredible job, at incredible rate, for a lot fo lineal feet between sharpenings.

Also i would caution you on making judgement of the surface from the video, as it is really hard to definitively say what the surface is like from the video. To be sure you would need to examine it in person, preferable under magnification. The surfaces have been studied and verified scientifically in Germany and Japan under scanning electron microscopes.

See images below.

What a supersufacer is, is an attempt at perfection; and at that it is the closest that i have seen.

They have put effort and research into understanding and improving the mechanics of cutting wood.

they have advanced and documented the specification of tool geometry.

They have researched and developed knife steel, grinding and sharpening.

A fine planed surface is a subtle but brilliantly beautiful thing to experience, but sadly something only a few appreciate or even notice.

They deserve a lot of respect for "going against the grain" When sanding is so much easier to sell.

Images from the Arco Baleno website

© Pictures SEM E.Bäucker kindly consented by the T.U. Dresden.

Pictures of super surfaced woods, taken by a scanning electron microscope (SEM)






Some woods that i dressed as sample, note the reflection on the walnut.


Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#4

Re: Strawmen

steve voigt

You wrote:

But to those that keep saying this was "lost" I will tell you it may have been lost to you, and you can make whatever excuse you want for that, but it was always knowledge that was known and available in this brilliant age of information.

I've said repeatedly, in the other thread, that the knowledge was never actually lost. David and others said it too. We've pointed out concrete examples of how it was not lost. Yet you and other continue to distort what we've said, I guess because arguing with strawmen is always easier.

For the last time, what we've actually said, and supported with evidence, is:

* credible discussion of chipbreakers was entirely absent from forums.

*credible discussion of chipbreakers was almost entirely absent from the woodworking

press.

* on the other hand, alternatives to the chipbreaker were very widely discussed in the press and on forums.

* proper use of chipbreakers does not seem to have been taught by well-known woodworking instructors.

* planemakers post 1980, large and small, were almost entirely unaware of how to use the chipbreaker.

* to this day, influential figures continue to dismiss the chipbreaker as a viable means of controlling tearout.

If you've got a serious response to all of this evidence, let's hear it. But please stop twisting my words so you can make your argument more easily.

Even if we take the "I knew it all along" chorus seriously, what does it prove? That you're smarter and better than all the schlubs on forums? Congratulations.

Feel free to reply, but I'm done with this topic.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#5

Re: Strawmen

Mark Hennebury

I am sorry if you are upset; I was just presenting what i know;

Chipbreakers have been on planes for a long time.

They perform a function.

I was taught that at school in the 60's.

I believed it to be common knowledge.

I learned to understand the mechanics in much more detail in later years with the supersurfacers setup diagrams and the k/k video.

I would never have thought that moving the chipbreaker closer or further away from the edge to find what works best would be enough to qualify me as smarter than everyone else.

I mean, i never invented the handplane or the chipbreaker, i just tried to make it work; not really a Nobel prize worthy accomplishment. When did it become something to brag about; being a woodworker that knows how to use basic woodworking tools. Give me a break.

I guess handplanes fell out of favor with the trades as mechanization took over, and ended up being hobbyist tools.

Woodworking teachers are also in a special place in that they are teaching to hobbyist and studio craftsmen, not industry.

Maybe you should look to placing some blame on the teachers. Maybe they have a duty to know the basics, even if they are no longer used in industry, they are important to the understanding working wood.

I make no excuse for learning my trade.

If i am bragging then it is you who made it possible.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#6

Who are the teachers?

david weaver

Who are the teachers teaching how to use hand tools these days? We know the internet instructors, and they all had no clue. That includes people who have been teaching since long before the internet (including folks like Paul Sellers).

I can't remember, but I'm assuming you may be from the UK. In the US, I'm not sure how long it's been since hand tool use was common on furniture, cabinets, etc.

My grandfather had a friend who was a clock maker and cabinetmaker in Gettysburg, PA (maybe specified as a smaller local town) and I looked at the clock and cabinets that this man had made. There wasn't any evidence of hand tools (late 1960s), though the guy's work was quite nice and very tight - and not bulky.

I'm going to assume that this is something that is different between the US and the UK (when legitimate hand plane use stopped).

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#7

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications

david weaver

That was just a cursory comment. You can see the crushing of the grain on the pine boards (which is common with a cap iron set too close). It's hardly a significant issue, though, as one could remedy it or just plane it off by hand.

I think the machines are great, and almost nobody else other than a few of us would notice the crushed surface. I'll see if I can find a time point in the video, otherwise, nobody will follow what I'm saying.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#8

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications

Mark Hennebury

David, although supersurfacers are great, they are still a little fussy to get close to perfect, its a bit of a challenge.

There are several variables that all must work together to get the best result. With each species of wood that varies; Not only perfectly sharpened blades and precision back-knife setting, you also have the best mouth opening, the nose-bar height, shear angle and feed down-force pressure, its a bit of a ballet to organize if you are searching for absolute.

All of the geometry is required to be very precise.

The knives on the "small" machines are 13" long, back-knife setback is a couple of thou, Your shavings are only a couple of thou thick so your margin of error is slim before you will adversely effect finish to some degree.

Take the nose-bar height above the table for example.

Nose-bar height 0.02mm or 0.0007874016"

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#9

Re: Who are the teachers?

Mark Hennebury

David,

I am from the UK originally but moved to Canada in 1970.

I don't know when hand tool use was last taught in schools.

I don't know why the teachers don't know or don't teach it.

I know that there are probably ten of thousands of supersurfacers sold in the world

Marunaka has sold several thousand units including more than 600 in Europe, but there are many other manufactures that make them also, Shinx, Takekawa, Heian, and the big names like Ryobi, Makita and Hitachi, So the understanding of chipbreakers has to be known. And a supersurfacer is doing the exact same operation as a handplane.

Supersurfacers didnt catch on in North America when they were introduced by Makita, Hitachi and Ryobi in the 80's and maybe it had to do a lack of understanding of the chipbreaker although they came with instructions, or maybe the instructions weren't taken seriously by people not used to such fine settings. Also the blades need to be sharp and require a special knife grinder to be purchased with the machine. Maybe it is some cultural thing, i know that they sell many supersurfacers in Germany, why?

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#10

Re: Strawmen

TomD

"Even if we take the "I knew it all along" chorus seriously, what does it prove? That you're smarter and better than all the schlubs on forums? Congratulations.

Feel free to reply, but I'm done with this topic."

I would agree with a lot of that, but unless I am having a senior moment at 58, I am pretty certain there were months of people saying this was new, which was odd given the source was industrial research for the purpose of standardization. I can remember attempting to refute the novelty claim by going through ever book I owned on woodworking, and all the main articles, the videos, in search of evidence this was common knowledge. And to my surprise it was less common than I thought it was.

Over the years there have been a variety of hotly discussed topics on planes, going back well before this discussion, there was a period of infill worship for instance. One of the common denominators around here were that people we were discussing this with did not have any background in Japanese planes. The curiosity on that score does not seem to have been peaked by the source of the breaker info being Japanese. But if one uses Japanese planes the issue is impossible to avoid. Which may have impacted some of us on the other side of things.

But anyway, an honest, or complete discussion would not leave out the certainty of unique breakthrough discovery that permeated this place and was not easily dropped, and proved very frustrating to some of us. If for no other reason than that the history is also important.

I think what it proves is that some of us had experience which is something you take from others, I make no claims to an original thought on this subject and it did show me some of my ideas on the history were also wrong.

I think an idea that still needs sorting out is how useful the knowledge on breakers is. In my work it has little impact, because I work with good wood. Or wood so bad sanding is inevitable. The breaker crowd is still in denial on this score.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#11

Re: Who are the teachers?

TomD

"Supersurfacers didnt catch on in North America when they were introduced by Makita, Hitachi and Ryobi in the 80's and maybe it had to do a lack of understanding of the chipbreaker although they came with instructions, or maybe the instructions weren't taken seriously by people not used to such fine settings. Also the blades need to be sharp and require a special knife grinder to be purchased with the machine. Maybe it is some cultural thing, i know that they sell many supersurfacers in Germany, why?"

Don't go to David for experience on having been around in the 80s. I never owned an SS, but some did, like the guy from Masterpiece tools, were hundreds took courses, including courses on making Japanese planes. We all knew where the breaker was supposed to go, you shut it down till the shaving comes out straight. The masterpiece courses were critical to getting a generation of Japanese hand tool guys out there, like John Bart. I was there for the hand plane course, and the one also in that neck of the woods in the 2000s.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#12

Re: All screwed up?

TomD

Does anyone know whether in the western world the breaker ever had a substantial presence in planes without being held in place by a screw? That is part of where the rot creeps in. You make your decision on how to set the breaker before you can tune it in use, and it becomes needed for other things, like as the means of attaching the blade setting mechanism, independent of it having a function of it's own. It would make sense that at one time they were independent and could be adjusted separately, since that works super well in Japanese planes. Which as it happens we are told were inspired on their breakers by outside tools. Then when the mechanics took over people retained the idea they were there to break the shaving, and reduce tearout, but forgot to pay attention to it. Now we have the information back on that aspect.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#13

Re: Strawmen

TomD

"Even if we take the "I knew it all along" chorus seriously, what does it prove? That you're smarter and better than all the schlubs on forums? Congratulations."

That lacks nuance:

1) I was dead certain everyone thought breakers were to control tear-out, but it turned out there was less specificity when I returned to my sources, than I expected to find (I have hundreds of books, mags and videos, and there was less than I expected to find in them);

2) due to Japanese experience certainly, I knew the breaker needed to be set close to the edge, very close;

3) But for a variety of reasons I didn't follow that practice with Western tools, in fact I am somewhat of a convert to the idea of no breaker whenever possible. I had no number in my head like it needs to be 5 thou back. I knew it was extremely close because at times I would drive it over the edge. But you can't really see it, or need to see it, so I didn't know. Being able to tell people how to set breakers on assemblies is very useful, and not something I knew all along.

It was a combination of being certain of some things that were right, some things that turned out I was wrong about; some things that are useful info that were not on my radar.

Then on top of that there is the issue of where from here. One thing the boards are useful for is getting the sense of what people find useful, and what one might usefully say to a beginner. I was not inclined to tell beginners to throw out their Kings for Shaptons, or diamonds. But in the contest for ideas one may get a useful sense of where things are headed. Does anyone know what the sales figures are for single blade planes, low angle planes, vs for people who plane with an intentional breaker position. Who is winning?

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#14

Re: Who are the teachers?

TomD

I had never heard of Paul Sellers until the internet, and I got a fair amount of UK media. In Europe the knowledge was still hanging around. The tools have been available all along, so someone must have been using them. Alan Peters was the big name I remember who had books and stuff.

In the US, you just need to look at the FWW index, Frid at Rhode Island; Krenov at College of the Redwoods. None of the big outfits would use hand tools in NA today, or in the past, but strong presence among amateurs. I just figured it out from books, it was pre video, but there were lots of books. Ellis was publishing magazines. Roy Underhill has done a mountain of work, but I didn't find inspiration in the type of tools he used until a lot later. Once you go back before the Ryobii planer, or the widespread availability of Taiwanese tools, you used hand planes, or you didn't work solid wood. Back then planers were in the car money range. Back then FWW had info on how to make wooden machine tools.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#15

Re: All screwed up?

david weaver

Very early double iron planes sometimes had loose cap irons, but they were long, too (the cap irons, not necessarily the planes).

I prefer them to be screwed together, but like everything else, you can learn to work with whatever you have.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#16

Re: Who are the teachers?

david weaver

I never heard of Paul until probably 5 years ago, 3? who knows? I see he's got a piece in the white house (apparently, he knows GWB or had met him at some point). I never really looked at it until yesterday, but it's not of the class of work that someone like George could do. It's actually quite nice, but bits of the design look a bit off.

I know who Alan Peters is. Charlie tells me I'm nuts for thinking George is in a class with Alan as a maker and designer. I think Alan's stuff is wonderful, but George could make any of it and the converse isn't true (if you flip names). Notwithstanding the fact that they are very different makers, and both excellent.

Why do I bring up George so much? Because you can literally pick the phone up and call him (but only because he's retired - he didn't exist on the internet before then, other than some people posting about his guitars and maybe some references to him). If there were 10 other guys like him, we'd be talking about the group of guys like George, but most of the others are not accessible. I appreciate George's design sense, too, because he's not much for anything post art-deco. Neither am I, but our tastes aren't fact even though we sometimes convince ourselves that they are.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#17

Print from 1993 *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

APPENDIX A:

THE CUTTING ACTION OF PLANE BLADES

by John Whelan

From The Wooden Plane: Its History, Form, and Function

By John Whelan,

Published by Astragal Press ©1993

and reprinted here by the kind permission of the author and publisher.

Another major improvement in performance was introduced early in the 18th century, with the discovery of the benefit of the cap or breaker iron. A shaving riding up the surface of a single iron gains some leverage helping it to initiate a split in front of the cutting edge. The cap iron serves to break or to fold the shaving before it has gained too much leverage (E). With this help, a sharp, well tuned and finely set plane can cope with difficult grain.




page link

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#18

Re: Print from 2010

Mark Hennebury

Woodworker's Guide to Handplanes

Scott Wynn



Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#19

Re: Print from 1905 *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

From A manual of carpentry and joinery 1905




PDF manual

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#20

Re: Print from 1950 *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

From the Stanley 1950 bed rock planes

The pdf has much clearer images




Stanley pdf

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#21

Re: Who are the teachers?

Charlie Stanford

I've always liked the work of Kristina Madsen, though she has a very low-key internet presence.

Here's a chair of her's in the Smithsonian's collection:

https://americanart.si.edu/artwork/dining-chair-36483

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#22

Integral Chipbreakers in handplanes

Mark Hennebury

Chip breakers are used in metal and wood in hand and power tools.

The 3 photos below are of my Japanese plane with disposable blade that has a integral chipbreaker ground into the blade.


Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#23

Re: Integral Chipbreakers in machines

Mark Hennebury

A Jointer / thickness planer knife with a biult in chipbreaker


Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#24

Re: Integral Chipbreakers in machines

Mark Hennebury

Controlled chip cutterhead for planers and jointers

US 4353400 A



ABSTRACT

Cutterheads operating in the gap between in-feed and out-feed tables of planers, jointers and the like wood cutting apparatus are provided with a body of increased diameter and a gib having a chipbreaker pocket shape that will expose only a minimum projection of the knife before the chip must curl into the pocket thereby reducing the potential bite of a kick back such as might occur by a tipping of the wood workpiece or by a pull out of the wood grain during the feeding of the workpiece to the cutting knives. The knives of the cutterhead protrude only as much above the cutterhead body as is required not to interfere with the advance of the workpiece per revolution of each knife, the gib is positioned with its chipbreaker pocket down from the tip of the knife no further than is necessary for chip thickness, and the chipbreaker pocket has a radius just sufficient to accommodate the curled chip at the maximum depth of the cut. Since the cutterhead body is larger and the blade exposure is less, the gap between the tables of the planer or jointer and the cutterhead is reduced. In addition, since the exposure of the knives above the body of the cutterhead is reduced, a lesser fan effect is achieved to decrease noise levels when the planer or jointer is idling. The cutterheads and gibs of this invention thus reduces the possibility of kick back, reduce the severity of kick back should it occur, reduce the severity of injury should contact with the blades occur, reduce chipping out and grain pull out to improve the quality of cut on wood burl or other swirl grain type wood workpieces and produce a tight curl chip that is easily handled by dust collectors.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#25

Re: Print from 1905

Patrick Chase

This one actually clearly illustrates a common problem with the prior references. It's correct on the general idea, but wrong on a crtitical detail in a way that renders it less than useful.

Specifically, 1/64" is NOT a close set as it states, and actually won't do much to prevent tearout on difficult woods (at least not for thin finishing cuts). Somebody who followed this manual literally would conclude that the cap iron doesn't help very much, and resort to other mitigations instead. This is what I referred to in a prior post when I pointed out that many people were aware of the "lore" about double irons, but were wrong on the details.

In the same vein you can find an effectively infinite number of sources from the dark ages (90s/00s) that recommend setting the cap iron at 1/32" or 1/16" to "prevent tearout". Again that shows awareness that it may have prevented tearout at some point in the dimly-remembered past, but no real understanding of how to achieve it.

Some of your other references in this thread are of much higher quality, though.