Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

Posts

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#26

Re: Integral Chipbreakers in handplanes

Patrick Chase

Nice picture. I wasn't aware of those, but am not surprised as the Iwasaki carving floats have similar tooth profiles.

As I said in another thread, my understanding is that practical cap iron use (including all of the relevant details such as setback) was never lost to the Japanese woodworking tradition.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#27

Re: Print from 1905

Mark Hennebury

Hi Patrick,

I am not a historian, i don't own any of these books or references, I looked them up today because i get abuse when i answer the false statements that "no one knew".

The fact is the function of the chipbreaker was widely known.

It was written in many publications.

And explained in enough detail to know that it functions to reduce tearout by the amount it is setback from the edge.

You can try to make the argument that some publications stated 1/16" setback, and that won't make any difference to prevent tearout, but on straight grain work you don't need a chipbreaker anyway.

But lets face it the setback is not an absolute, and you wont get beaten with a stick for moving it closer.

Most publication suggest moving it closer for more difficult grain and further for rough work or straight grain.

If you take the Stanley double iron setup, (hardly an obscure company)

It states; The plane iron cap should extend back 1/16" for general work, On cross grained or curly wood it should be as near to the cutting surface as possible.

That is pretty clear.

The point is there were many references to the function of the chipbreaker, and people being rude to me for stating that fact wont change it.

It is not that the knowledge wasn't available, the question is why did so many miss it?

How could people who are passionate about hand plane, users, makers and teachers, not know about the chipbreaker effect?

Why would people who own planes not have experimented with the chipbreaker position? There are not too many variables on a plane,( once you complete a basic tune up) Chipbreaker setback and throat opening are the main two, you could grind a backbevel, but that is pretty much it.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#28

Re: Print from 1993

Warren in Lancaster, PA

These references remind me of a post that appeared on this forum in 2005:

The verdict is pretty much "in" on chip breakers.

Chip breakers are simply a way of keep the blade (and consequently edge) held firmly, and they also help the shaving "clear" the plane.

Despite loads of books and "the old guys" telling you different, in some cases with diagrams :-)

You reference Whelan' 1993 book and diagram, but here is what RG Whelan himself wrote on this forum 12 years later:

I think the cap iron added stiffness and, of lower importance, helped break the chip in softer material. ...

With a bedding angle of 45 degrees or less (bevel down) the cap seems to be of some (slight) help in breaking the chip in softer material. I happen to like a bedding angle of 47-48 degrees for the material I use most often (cherry) and I have found no objective advantage in using a cap iron in this configuration.

This does not sound to me like someone who has learned to use the double iron, even years after writing the book.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#29

Re: Print from 1993

Mark Hennebury

Hi Warren,

Like i said, i am no chipbreaker historian, i pulled a few references of of the internet today to see if there was information in print, after having been told there wasn't any. I don't know Whelan, never heard of him or seen his book before i came across the info this morning.

But that still leaves me with Stanley and tens of thousands of supersurfacers around the world. The diagram in Scot Wynn book looks like he understands but i haven't read that either, maybe you have.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#30

Re: Print from 1917

Mark Hennebury

Title Modern Shop Practice V1

Author Howard Monroe Raymond

Publisher American Technical Society

Year 1916

Copyright 1916, American Technical Society


The cap-iron f, which is not sharp, is not, as is often supposed, used for the purpose of strengthening or stiffening the cutting iron, but as a chip-break to prevent the cutting edge of the plane-iron from chipping, tearing, and breaking the grain of the wood below the surface when the grain turns and twists, or when it is knotty and crooked. In such cases the tendency of the plane-iron is to split and tear out the fibres of the wood in front of the cutting edge. To avoid this, the cap-iron is screwed on with its dull edge quite close to the cutting edge, so as to bend and break off the fibres or the shavings before the split gets fairly started below the surface.

The cutting edge of the plane-iron is said to have lead in proportion to the distance it is placed in advance of the dull edge of the cap-iron. The depth of the splits, or the roughness of the cross-grained surface, will be just equal to the lead of the cutting edge. For soft, straight-grained wood, the lead may be 1/32 inch or even more, but this must be reduced in proportion as the wood is curly, cross-grained, or knotty.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#31

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

Mark, that's not accurate (that there aren't references in print). The issue was that there was a dearth of responses on any forum when someone asked a straw question like "I have a stanley plane, but I need to plane curly maple, what should I get?".

Of course, the answer is "nothing, use what you have", but we didn't see answers like that.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#32

Re: Print from 1993

Mark Hennebury

Sorry David but i don't understand you point.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#33

Re: Print from 1993

Charlie

Why would what was being said or not said on a forum matter?

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#34

Stanley...anyone care to comment?

Mark Hennebury


Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#35

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

If you're asking a question, and you get answers. It kind of matters. Does any of it really matter in the big picture? No. Anyone making money woodworking could probably make more money elsewhere and have more left over if we bought our furniture instead.

But when the internet is used like the guy on the corner pointing you in the right direction when you're in a new-to-you town, it sort of matters.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#36

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

Mark, the point in this case is the group that I complained most about is the "woodworking instructors" and others on the forums who seemed to have no clue.

I would assume other than being taught about the cap iron (nobody taught me, but at the same time, nobody on the forums sent me even to a text to describe the cap iron's use), a great deal of what you've come to know is based on how useful you've found it to be.

Once you figure it out, even if you're not taught (I figured Warren knew what he was talking about, because he was the only person I knew who worked without any power tools at all - but I still never really "figured it out" until I put my other planes aside and forced myself to use a stanley 4 to smooth for a two week period - I was making some basic case work for my daughter's room, but doing it entirely by hand by choice).

That's really the point, I suppose, is that except for the few who were professionally trained and then ran with it, the information was very sparse for someone seeking it. The fact that you ended up in the super surfacers (which will be very particular about their setup with the cap iron) multiplies the usefulness of the cap and your understanding of it. Few others will have as much exposure.

The other part of this point is that you have people like Charlie, who for reasons other than objectivity, just follow a few people around and say "oh, there's no real difference" .." you can do it a million ways". Charlie purports to do a lot of work by hand but suggests that there's little difference between cap iron use and use of a whole bunch of other things. I can only conclude that his perception is lacking in some areas where yours is not.

Pointing to old texts is fine, but most people wouldn't even know they exist at the start. Starting a beginner on the path to a limited number of bench planes and use of the cap iron is far better than "anything will work, and now we have all of these new tools that are better than the old ones". You're relatively new, and you were brought here by Bill's discussion, but there was literally a decade or two of discussion where little was said of the cap iron, regardless of what was in old text. Reality is the opposite - people were encouraged to find other means, but you know well enough that those other means are more intensive in cash involvement and less effective in terms of efficiency.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#37

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

By the way, Mark. Not arguing with you, per se on these things. I enjoy your posts and your point of view, and the various different places you show use of the cap iron, etc (like the super surfacer).

If I make a comment about seeing crushing on pine, it's just an observation. I've seen how Warren can spot and comment on things that other people don't notice, and i pay attention when someone like George Wilson talks about design (His favorite is classical design, so it doesn't necessarily jibe with those who love the whole studio furniture thing).

I enjoy your posts and the dicussion of stuff that most people don't talk about and recognize that setting up a supersurfacer is a lot like setting up a plane (almost exactly), and seeing something like crushing on the surface of pine isn't a criticism. If I had one of the machines, I'd do the same - that being, you can set it up to get every stick of wood practically perfect, but sometimes you just need to get material through a machine, and I'm sure that with a general setting, it would do awfully good on a whole bunch of stuff without the need for fiddling that perfection requires.

re: your other post about these machines not selling that well in north america vs. Germany, i couldn't comment beyond speculation. I understand the use in japan - lots of planed surfaces in architectural use, plus they'd make an ideal "try plane" to follow with a smoother, but finding anything made of solid wood in the US that doesn't come through the amish is fairly rare around here. Exposed timber in any buildings where I'm from is not done to the standard that it's done in japan (it's usually in barns, or intentionally exposed hand hewn stuff in old houses or factory buildings). I'm sure you know those things, though. Given I am descended from one group of the Germans, I am somewhat curious about where they're going with all of their planed beams, though. Architectural? Maybe they're higher class Germans than the group I can trace back to.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#38

Re: Print from 1993

Charlie

Answers from whom?

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#39

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

People with ASPD, apparently.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#40

Re: Print from 1993

Mark Hennebury

David,

I said this a long time ago, and i still believe that its true;

Understanding Woodworking is pretty simple, and with a little of the correct guidance a person could learn all they need in a month. Everything to get started on the road to a life of discovery.

1.Understanding basic wood structure; mechanical properties, relationship to moisture.

2. Cutting tools and their interaction with wood structure.

3. Referencing and marking out.

A good working understanding of wood is not complicated.

Basic cell structure, moisture and movement, and the mechanical structeral properties of working with a tubular material.

The fundamentals of cutting tools and their relationship is very simple; how many different ways can you put a chisel into wood? All cutting tools are in essence arrangements of one or more chisels.

The understanding of controlled cutting with chip limiters and chipbreakers.

An understanding of referencing principles, developing procedures project management, to mitigate error.

These are the foundations that all of woodwork stands on, learn these and you can go and build anything.

And they are simple and easy to learn.

Keep and open mind.

Don't pledge allegiance to any particular school of thought, or idolize any teacher.

Learn from everyone and everywhere.

Take what works and discard the rest.

Critical thinking.

Take responsibility to question and verify everything.

If you ask, someone will answer; that's not how you acquire knowledge.

If you look, you will see. Analyse, test, investigate, experiment, look and learn.

Don't trust others, most of all don't trust yourself. Test and verify.

The human brain doesn't care about right or wrong, it makes crap up and tells your mind that its real. That's why you can't argue with someone that believes something. Belief is the acceptance without verification or evidence.

Ask someone as a last resort, not a first, after you have pondered and tried to understand and solve the problem yourself. Then take with a grain of salt and test and verify before you accept it.

Everyone has to accept responsibility for what they know or don't know. Woodworking is not that complicated.

Help and guidance to point you on the path of discovery and understanding is what you need not need not quick answers.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#41

Occasionally, someone thinks they have......

roger lance

invented the wheel.....

I may be missing the point, but that Stanley shop poster just about covers what has been discussed here.

Years ago, after building my bench, I decided to make a bench slave (a stock support). Mentally, I knew what I wanted.....but, I couldn't see how to make the joint on the base. After much thought, I came up with a sollution that worked well.....




I felt good about thinking up that joint.....except, a few months go, I ran across a video/article that showed the same joint which was Korean and centuries old.

That's my wheel.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#42

I wish I had a wheel..

david weaver

..maybe I don't. The most beneficial wheel I've found is one that Warren beat us over the head with for years.

That and documenting how to make double iron planes, but that's just backing into making a wheel that someone else made.

Last year, my mother had a dog at our house and my wife is an extreme germophobe (who never had a pet) - when my parents visit, they're coming a pretty long distance and stay a few days. The dog is 16, and you know what happens with dogs that old. So, my mother brought along some diapers and cut a hole in them for the dog's tail. We made suspenders out of tape and felt pretty good about ourselves (it averted a lot of issues with my wife, which was a major positive). I told her that she should look into getting them made (my mother is a maker and painter of sorts) and selling them on etsy or amazon for $15 a pair.

And then I said to her "i'll bet it's already been done if it was that easy to come up with".

https://www.google.com/search?q=dog+diaper+suspenders&source=lnms&tbm=shop&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiN2sLm37nXAhVF5CYKHbrbBCYQ_AUICigB&biw=1920&bih=974

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#43

Re: Print from 1993

david weaver

Mark, like I said, I agree with much of what you say. You can see things that work materially well in the shop with your own two hands. Over time, I've realized that sometimes it takes a couple of weeks.

I've doubted things (like I doubted that I'd see any benefit from looking at my razor edges under a metallurgical microscope - something I do make a little income on), and been wrong at first.

I don't learn that well from other people, at least not in large step by step processes transferred from them to me. I like to think. I think you do, too. I can tell, and I can tell Warren works the same way.

I don't follow Tage Frid, I don't make the same things as George Wilson (well, i couldn't in some cases, but that's OK), but I'll take bits and pieces from whoever I can related to what I want to do.

BUT, a lot of people won't. I think they won't get really far unless they find something they like to make and make it over and over. they never really "own" their knowledge, if you know what I mean. They borrow it for a while and if they don't use it, they forget it. I don't like that.

What I find interesting is that I backed into the double iron for a very simple reason. It was a pain to dimension wood without it. It's easy with it - easy as in there's very little risk and it just feels great to do it (even though it's not always economically feasible). As you describe how you think, there's little chance you wouldn't have figured it out yourself, even if you hadn't been taught about it. As it is now, it sounds like were taught one and you now have 100 because you were willing to invest your time and interest and get the other 99.

I think it would be nice on these forums if someone new came along, even if those who are going to take something on their own and go to their bench and do more than copy Tage Frid are fairly rare, but it would be nice if we could point them in the right direction to start rather than bludgeoning them with antisocial comments. And that's not you doing the latter, but I see it a lot. We would also help them if we gave broad generalizations. "Oh, so you want to dimension by hand? You probably will want to learn to use the double iron. It'll cut about 35% of the labor out of the process, make it much nicer to do and you'll have much less waste".

Most starting with questions like that don't have the inclination to figure it all out from scratch.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#44

Re: Print from 1993

William Duffield

The R. J. Whelan who used to post on this forum is not the John M. Whelan who wrote "The Wooden Plane: Its History, Form and Function " and "Making Traditional Wooden Planes".

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#45

Re: Occasionally, someone thinks they have......

Mark Hennebury

Hi Roger, and congrats on your joint.

That to me is what this is all about;

having a problem and applying your skills, knowledge, curiosity and reason to figure it out. It doesn't matter how many people figured it out before you, you figured it out, and you have an intimate understanding and knowledge of that joint; Far better than anyone that downloaded the instructions and copied it.

Even if no-one had ever seen the Stanley instructions or any other, given a hand plane and a curious mind you would figure it out, and you would have afar great understanding than copying a set of rules that told you what distance to set the cap iron.

To rely on others to give you all the answers obviously doesn't work. Because all of those that profess to know are just people. like you, and maybe not as curious or knowledgeable. And it doesn't matter if they work for the big plane makers of our time, it doesn't mean that the person designing planes has a passion and intimate knowledge of the function, it might mean that they just have a job.

To understand woodworking you have to approach with an open mind; When you look to others (especially those that are highly respected) to supply you with answers, you have a tendency to not question what they have told you, and that taints how and what you will see. Once you have closed that part of your mind to question, you are going to have a blank spot and miss part of the picture, even when it is right in front of your eyes.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#46

Re: Occasionally, someone thinks they have......

david weaver

>>Even if no-one had ever seen the Stanley instructions or any other, given a hand plane and a curious mind you would figure it out, and you would have afar great understanding than copying a set of rules that told you what distance to set the cap iron.<<

Mark, if you were a lady, I'd ask you to be my adoptive mother!

My mother paints tole and shrugs at my planes. (It's fair, I shrug at her tole, though she has found a market for it for 35 years, I'll give her credit).

She wouldn't ever address this kind of discussion at all, but it's how she operates.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#47

Re: Print from 1993

Charlie

Seems that the depth and breadth on almost all forums is substantially less than it was ten years ago. I don't know why, but it appears so to me.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#48

Re: Occasionally, someone thinks they have......

roger lance

Mark.....we are in agreement when it comes to regarding woodworking and making things as an opportunity to challenge our minds and our problem solving abilities.

I'm 70 and I realize that the agility/flexibility of my mind is an important asset to preserve as much as possible. That's a major factor for my involvement with woodworking.....certainly not the only reason.....but one of which I'm very aware.

Re: Planes; knife geometry specifications *LINK*

#50

Re: Print from 1993

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks, William. My apologies.