Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Whelan planemaking book?

Posts

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#76

Re: Where did the ball go?

Brian Holcombe

I do the same with Japanese planes, set them up straight and slowly camber most of them for ease of work and for the fact that I'm typically using them on panels. I have some set straight across for small beams and shoji where the work is smaller than the plane.

Your planes fed well, I don't usually skew it much at all, at least not intentionally so. The jack of course would not have issues with feeding, the try plane I have pretty lightly cambered and can usually take a full width shaving or very near to it without any issues.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#77

Re: Reference: paragraphs 3 and 4

John Schtroumpf

Title: The Mechanic's Companion

Author: Peter Nicholson

Date: 1845

Chapter: JOINERY

§5 The Jack Plane (Pl 12 Fig 1)

¶3 The bringing of the iron to a sharp cutting edge is called sharpening. The cutting edge of the iron must be formed with a convexity, and regulated by the stuff to be wrought, whether it is hard or soft, cross grained or curling, so that a man may be able to perform the most work, or to reduce the substance most, in a given time. To prevent the iron from tearing the wood to cross grained stuff, a cover is used with a reversed basil, (Pl 12 Fig 4) and fastened by means of a screw, the thin part of which slides in a longitudinal slit in the iron, and the head is taken out by a large hole near the upper end of it. The lower edge of the cover is so formed, as to be concentric or parallel to the cutting edge of the iron, and fixed at a small distance above it, and to coincide entirely with the steel face. The basil of the cover must be rounded, and not flat, as that of the iron is. The distance between the cutting edge of the iron, and the edge of the cover, depends altogether on the nature of the stuff. If the stuff is free, the edge of the cover may be set at a considerable distance, because the difficulty of pushing the plane forward becomes greater, as the edge of the cover is nearer the edge of the iron, and the contrary when more remote.

¶4 The convexity of the edge of the iron depends on the texture of the stuff, whether it is free, cross grained, hard or knotty. If the stuff is free, it is evident that a considerable projection may be allowed, as a thicker shaving may be taken: the extreme edges of the iron must never enter the wood, as this not only retards the progress of working, but chokes and prevents the regular discharge of the shavings at the orifice of the plane.

Plate 12:


Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#78

Re: Reference: paragraphs 3 and 4

david weaver

Excellent, thanks John!

Always desiring no other possible interpretation, at least I do, leaves me lacking a little in this case.

It looks like, if I was taking a most likely reading, that if the iron is straight across, then the edge would be parallel. If not, concentric implying that it traces the profile of the iron laterally.

However, the picture is not of any help and one doesn't ever see this with jack plane irons that are found. Caps are rarely in perfect condition, not even on little used English planes, but they are usually rounded in the "basil" as this says, just not across the width.(I do like a rounded bevel better than flat, too, but came to that conclusion in use, and not from reading. It just seems to work a little better and give a bit better of a range).

I just don't agree with concentric because it's only useful if the cap iron protrudes below the mouth, and it doesn't. It doesn't mean I think I know more about woodworking than Nicholson, I just think I'm further into the cap iron and experimentation with it than Nicholson might have been.

I don't expect other people to have the same opinion as me if they don't wish to, though.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#79

Re: Reference: paragraphs 3 and 4

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you said once before Nicholson did not know what he was talking about. How did that work out?

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#80

Re: Reference: paragraphs 3 and 4

david weaver

Well, in this case, I don't believe he knows more about the cap than I do, though he likely does about everything else that he talks about (well, perhaps not sharpening media).

Every time anyone says anything, they take a chance of being wrong, but this time, I understand the subject material a lot better.

If there was more detail somewhere that referred to feeding problems, i could buy that (it took me a little while to figure that out as a maker, and a sloppily made plane or one that had moved may have such problems).

But mechanically with the cap iron. I've never had any issues at all at the corners once the plane feeds properly. Certainly making the cap iron less effective by lessening its influence at the edges of the cut wouldn't solve any that I've had if I had them. But it might fix a feeding problem that should be fixed another way.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#81

Focussing on the key point

Patrick Chase

The basic point I was trying to make earlier is this: Allowing the cap iron to extend to or below the plane sole isn't absurd to the point where we can dismiss it out of hand as you seemed to (and my apologies if I misread your argument).

You replied by citing an example (7 mil shaving with 5 mil setback). While it's true that that isn't viable on multiple levels, it's also a strawman in the sense that it didn't address my point. The "critical configuration" that we need to consider here is the equivalent of a 5 mil shaving with 7 mil setback (assuming 45 deg bed angle), in other words the converse of the one you cited. If that configuration is workable, then it may be worthwhile to profile the cap iron.

I've tried putting the cap iron in the plane of or slightly below the sole when edge-planing (such that the corners are a nonissue), mostly out of curiosity than any real need [*]. Planing forces were noticeably increased, but it works perfectly well.

Again I'm not saying that this is something we need to do (at least not in any situation I've encountered), merely that it isn't blatantly unreasonable to the point where we should dismiss somebody else out of hand or dismiss them as lacking knowledge for doing it.

[*] Since I expect you'll ask, when I measure setback (which is very rare) I do it using the ~1.3 um/pixel camera setup that I outlined in another thread.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#82

Re: Focussing on the key point

david weaver

I think I've probably never measured the setback, I'm just speculating.

Not trying to be flippant on the cap iron below the sole thing, it's just a set that should never be used, even if you can physically struggle through it.

In the exceedingly rare case that you can't plane a piece of wood (which is usually the result of quartered wood that's been improperly dried or that just has a predisposition to being really weak/dry/crumbly in the earlywood), then you'd go to a scraper rather than projecting the cap below the sole of the plane (I think that would just crush that kind of wood, anyway, only to leave tearout as it broke away).

That is the important point that makes matching a cap iron to the iron profile on a flat-soled plane pointless - unless there are feeding problems, but that decision loop goes back to fixing the feeding problems. With modern planes, that's not really an issue, because the feeding problem doesn't occur on a stanley plane - it occurs in the wear on a wooden plane.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#83

Errors or suboptimal statements in books

david weaver

I can't recall if it's Hasluck's carving book or Holtzapffel's texts about abrasives, but one of those two refers to washita stones as substandard stones that should either be discarded or ignored.

While 99% of the time, the texts are a good guide point (far better than the people instructing woodwork today and trying to be experts on planes without having dimensioned by hand or built planes), there's something once in a while that's either stated as fact where it doesn't matter or that is not quite correct.

I'd say this is probably the former (adjusting the sides of a cap iron is a lateral move at best). While Nicholson pushed a plane for more feet than I have, I seriously doubt he made more planes or experimented with more different planes in the context of use. If he discusses that anywhere else in his text, I'd be interested, but I can't imagine too much of that would've made its way into a general text for cabinetmaking (vs. one that had a serious discussion on planemaking. )

When i saw a well respected text calling washita stones poor quality, I wasn't impressed.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#84

Everybody makes mistakes

Patrick Chase

If you dismiss every source that contains at least one factual error then you'll rapidly end up with exactly zero trusted information sources. If you apply that standard uniformly then you certainly can't trust yourself, as like all of us you have been fallible in the past.

Also, abrasive/stone preferences are about as subjective as they come. One person's "best stone ever" can easily be another's "mediocre", and yet they may both be perfectly accurate albeit judging on different criteria.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#85

Re: Everybody makes mistakes

david weaver

Actually, what I'm implying is that the source can have a mistake in it even if it is a good source. It doesn't make it "not" a good source.

In terms of washitas, they are actually superior to a soft arkansas rather than it just being a matter of opinion. They have a larger range, cut faster when you want them to and can work finer. In old catalogs, they commanded twice as much money despite probably being cheaper to process (or no more expensive) and coming out of the ground in giant chunks (up to 2500 pounds) of clear stone.

I think the writer may not have been familiar with them. They get dismissed in modern woodworking because people tend to focus on the finest cutting stones and forget others exist - at least in the US (a good suita in japan is still really expensive, even in country where stuff is not as expensive as it's made out to be over here).

I can't recall if it was Hasluck or Holtzapffel. Either is still an excellent source - just caused a jolt when I read it, as soft arkansas stones were widely sold in catalogs as a low cost alternative to washitas.

There is only one mine source for washitas, too, which might have something to do with why the market wasn't flooded with them. It's still full of stone that you don't have to work that hard to get, but Norton suggested it's not in their financial interest to open and close the mine to produce stone to be processed in the north east (I suppose they process their arkansas stones there).

I'm leaning toward Hasluck as I'm writing this, because I believe Holtzapffel refers to washitas as crushing the market in the UK for the UK-based natural stones in one of his edition updates.

(as I sit here today, I shaved off of a razor that I used nothing but a washita to reset and hone after it hadn't been shaved with for a few decades - at least. I have a gaggle of them - perhaps 8 or 9 right now, but I don't have trouble locating them or selling them with little effort, so that number tends to go up and down. There is something about their structure - a matrix of pores rather than an agglomeration of particles - that makes them hone a razor better than their coarseness would suggest, but that's not really a discussion for this board, so I'll stop there).

I don't have nicholson's texts, but I do have Haslucks and Holtzapffel's and don't plan on unloading either of them any time soon.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#86

Things that can be out of date, too

david weaver

There are nice discussions in Holtzapffel's texts about setting razors, too, but the razor discussion is archaic because better quality razors were made after the two editions that I've seen. Probably the golden era for european razors was the early 1900s to about 1950 or so (mostly solingen - french razors were made in droves, but they tend to be a bit sloppy in their finish, and the English also made razors, but they are less consistent and also not as skillfully finished and ground).

The best razors ever made (most consistent and absolutely the best, including the edge they take under a microscope) were made by a few japanese finishers in the 1960s and 1970s or so. Incremental improvement is the reason for that, and a supply of specialty steel in japan that is better than vintage steel (it is easily as good as the finest vintage steel ever made, but every single piece of it is superb without variation). Tanifuji Fukutaro is a finisher who comes to mind (though there are others, I just find his razors a little more easily). His razors are harder than solingen razors but still sharpen well on anything, and they create a smaller foil, lose less of it to the linen and strop and have a smoother edge line (which you can actually feel as a better shave). Tanifuji's lifelong quest, which he probably succeeded in pretty early, was to make a razor that took and held a better edge than any german razor. He had the benefit, though, of having the bar set elsewhere so that he knew what he had to beat.

So, not every topic in a vintage text is covered better than one in modern, but the discussion of design and life in a piece, and not sanding the liveliness out of it is well covered in Hasluck's carving text, and there's quite a lot of interesting stuff in holtzapffel. I don't suspect anything in the last 200 years has improved discussion about planes or their use, either.

I also hate to say this, but finishing an already well finished razor with inexpensive chromium oxide pigment will result in a better edge that can be gotten from the most expensive of natural stones. Getting a metallurgical microscope and seeing when to use it and how much so that it's more consistent has really illustrated that to me. Plenty of shavers fall short of an edge that's ready for it, though. Holtzapffel talks of various things to finish hone a razor, and various items that are used by cutlers as they're finishing them in production, but none of them are as good as "Chrome ox" in its pure form of 1/2 or 3 tenths of a micron.