Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Whelan planemaking book?

Posts

Whelan planemaking book?

#1

Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

This is probably mostly targeted at Steve and David...

I'm considering getting the Whelan book on wooden plane making ("Making Traditional Wooden Planes") and am wondering how it's stood the test of time and if that's still a good starting point?

WC's search function seems to be broken (the error dump points to an endian-ness bug of all things) but by searcing for 'john+whelan+site:woodcentral.com' I found Steve's 2013 thread about his first non-laminated plane, that seems to reference Whelan as authoritative. I've also found the thread where Steve pointed out a copyright violation :-).

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#2

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

I briefly had a copy of the digital version when it was out of print. I may have actually bought it then, too, but I have to admit I've never really read it. I've also got a WPINCA book or something that's got planemaking related stuff in it, but also, I didn't learn much planemaking from it.

Steve will probably have a different opinion than me, I think I probably have some kind of attention issue (not kidding about that) and I don't learn from much other than experience, at least nothing thorough. I never "own" the knowledge unless I really get in the middle of it so the thing that really sent me through the planemaking was just finding good planes and copying them and finding out why they worked and why they didn't. I know enough now to know that the mid 1800s English planes were the best planes ever made (Larry wouldn't agree, but a contest between his try planes and one of mine wouldn't last long if there was any volume of work to do), and that the early all steel ward cap irons were the best design ever made for cap irons (they leave a lot of room for clearance).

Same with the infills. I saw some basic bits and pieces about dovetailing, but it's far easier for me to just do the stuff and accept that the first one won't be so great.

I do the moulding planes exactly as larry's video describes, or at least close. No reason to deviate on those, he's set the modern standard.

Just my opinion, I think having a good working plane on hand (or ten, I bought about 15, maybe, to see which one I wanted to settle on to start) will get you farther (further?) and faster.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#3

Can't answer about the Whelan book

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but, yes, the search tool is broken.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#4

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have made planes since 1975. A lot of the skills in maintaining wooden planes overlap with the manufacturing skills, so a guy who is going to make planes needs skill in use, and any really skilled user can make a good plane. The reason plane making developed as a trade and individual craftsmen stopped making their own has to do with how quickly and cheaply a specialist can turn out a plane.

A friend gave me the Whelan book about a dozen years ago, but I have misplaced it. I would not call it authoritative. It is a survey book of various types of planes, smoother. plough, rabbet, etc., helpful for someone who knows their way around planes, a bit weak on the fine points. More authority on this forum.

Paul Dzioba (Paul from NJ) made a strike block plane from the Whelan book some years ago. Whelan's design is supposed to be a copy of the 1793 Dominy plane. Unfortunately Whelan decided to change it from a double iron plane to a single iron, and he did such a poor job drawing the handle that Paul's handle looks odd also. Paul would have done a much better job if he had seen the picture that Whelan looked at.

I would say the Charlie Hummel's With hammer in Hand (1968) is more carefully done and has good pictures of planes. The book is expensive, but Charlie is working on a revised edition. There is a free online access through Chipstone and University of Wisconsin.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#5

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

A perfect illustration of why having a good example in-hand is more useful.

If any of the proportions are off, the plane will look funny (or worse), and you can take pictures of parts (like handles) if needed to make patterns.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#6

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

steve voigt

Patrick, I will write a little more later today--running right now. But the nickel version is the book is flawed but probably worth the price.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#7

Thanks (NM)


Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#8

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Paul in NJ

Whelan has two books about planes. "The Wooden Plane , Its history, form, and function" and "Making traditional wooden planes". The plane making book is useful but some of the designs are more modern than traditional. I found his book useful when building a plow. I took features from several of the plow designs in the book and also had a nice British Sash Fillister to look at some of the finer points. It is a good value, starting at $15 on Amazon.

I have the first book, "The Wooden Plane", and found it a valuable resource. It has a wide scope, covers many plane types, and planes from different cultures. I would buy it again at the current price.

regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#9

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TM Stock

Years ago, I had a copy of Cecil Pierce's book, '50 Years a Planemaker and User' - seems to me that there were some instructions in that slim volume on making planes, and IIRC, the illustrations were by one the greats, Sam Manning. Anyone have a copy and can comment?

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#10

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

"I'm considering getting the Whelan book on wooden plane making ("Making Traditional Wooden Planes") and am wondering how it's stood the test of time and if that's still a good starting point?"

Starting point for what? What kind of plane exactly, for what purpose etc...

I have his digest book, and I used to read the glossary before doing seminars so I could be sure to know all the obscure terms. In books there is the before and after the "awakening" books. In the before category, mostly the authors didn't know how to do stuff, or if they did they weren't telling. Krenov who has a reputation for the effete, actually wrote clear blow by blow instructions during the period. Then after the awakening there were no secrets, and in that period, something like David's series of videos would be a better starting point for making planes of a truly traditional type, though traditional virtually describes everything in plane form with the exception of a few LV or Hotley types. :)

If you are an absolute beginner, or someone who uses planes in a shop, but isn't trying to recreate colonial Williamsberg, and if you have a power saw, the glue up planes are just as good, and are very easy to build. You can make any plane through a glue up process, or you can make ones like the Krenov style. or varients of the German planes that way. There are some advantages to mortised planes, and if you have the right gear, if your shop is better equipped with hand tools, they may be the right approach to take.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#11

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

The thing with YOutube and the internet it that you can design your own approach. If you owned a mortising machine, that would make certain approaches easier. A bandsaw tilts to another approach. A milling machine another. Not to mention that there is a specialized hand tool for every cut. The problem with books is that you are working in someone else's shop, but not actually.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#12

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

I'm most immediately contemplating side-escapement H&Rs (and have received the message to buy Larry's video loud and clear, thanks). I also would like to better understand the process of making mortised bench planes, to evaluate whether I want to do that. I would be using hand tools for all but initial stock sizing, and am willing to invest in learning new ones (for example, side and edge floats)

I've done a couple laminate planes, and as an engineer I clearly understand that any geometry that's feasible in a mortise plane can also be created in a laminate plane. With that said the process of making a laminate plane doesn't "speak to me" for lack of a better term. I wouldn't be doing this to sell but for the enjoyment of the pursuit itself, so that's an important consideration.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#13

Re: Whelan planemaking book? *LINK*

steve voigt

OK, so a little more now that I have time…

The good thing about Whelan's book is that it covers a very wide range--bench, side escapement, simple & complex molding profiles, various fenced planes, etc. It's a good basic introduction and has some valuable info.

The main flaws are that he take a recipe approach to layout, rather than proceeding from first principles, and he doesn't get much into the nitty gritty of operations--you're on your own for that. Probably because he didn't know the nitty gritty. My impression is that he was primarily a collector, rather than a maker, and he made enough planes to be conversant in the craft, but didn't really have expertise.

I won't really fault him for these things. He was writing in the depths of what Warren has called the "hand tool dark ages." Nobody else was writing about this stuff, and it was courageous of him to do so. 20/20 hindsight and all that.

If you want to build bench planes, David's videos are the best source. For side escapement planes, I'll cast another vote for Larry William's video, which is helpful for all types of planes, not just side escapements.

One other good source is Armour's "practical planemaking" article. This is probably not helpful for beginners, but is useful for people with some planes under their belts. Armour was a professional maker, and the article was first published in 1898. The handplanecentral.com link to this article is broken, but I'll put a live link below.

Shameless plug: I have an article on making a double iron smoother coming out in Pop Woodworking next week. Hopefully some will find that of interest.


Practical Planemaking

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#14

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

steve voigt

Oh, and I forgot to mention this in my other post, but I strongly second Paul's recommendation of the other Whelan book, "The Wooden Plane." I consult this book regularly in my own work. Whelan is on much surer footing as a historian than as a planemaker.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#15

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

William Duffield

I have a copy, but I don't feel competent to comment, as I'm not a plane maker.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#16

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

"I also would like to better understand the process of making mortised bench planes, to evaluate whether I want to do that. I would be using hand tools for all but initial stock sizing, and am willing to invest in learning new ones (for example, side and edge floats)"

In that case, you might want to look at David's video's he has gone into a lot of detail, and had a good teacher. I couldn't sit through them as I have been down this trail since the 70s or 80s, but I feel it would be good for me because certain aspects of the English are still a little vague as regards the the points of the wedge. Though looking at antiques, any one approach doesn't seem universal. Maybe David could insert a link.

If you break the tasks down, in either Japanese or Western planes, the basic structure is similar. There are two intersecting ramps that need to be formed from the block. This is power mortising, but of an easy kind, since forming ramps is a part of mortise joints, while the trickier part of squaring the hole's bottom is absent. It pays to have a hammer of at least 20 ounces, or whatever you can best handle, and a chisel built like a railway spike, no narrow shoulders. You want to start at the same angles as you finish with, but maybe a little flatter. You can sight this from your layout lines. A firm surface to whack on, like a good bench, beam, or floor will add to the efficiency of the process. Getting a 2x4 and practicing would speed up the learning.

Most people worry about getting the ramp the correct angle, and flat/curved. This is actually the easy part, you work it from the bottom/mouth as well as from the top, so once that plane is made flat, it will be correct to the layout lines. One difficulty is what to do when you get close, how to perfect the last of the end grain, and how to make it pretty. You can make some great planes that aren't that pretty. But the reintroduction of the special tools from the plane maker's toolbox, like floats, have zeroed out the skill required. A practice exercise is to get a good maple 2x2 and pare the end grain flat, then draw a new line around it and eighth lower, and pare that flat. One soon gets the idea.

Working the abutments is pretty easy also. I have used a variety of workshop tools like the LV flush trim Ryobi, or hack saws. Eventually I bought a purpose built saw, it becomes trivial. You are working a slash dado that is the size of a pencil, it does pay to get the initial saw cut correct, but a variety of expensive, though available floats can make anyone an expert.

As with most things in the return to classic woodworking, it was only difficult when we didn't have a road map, and when there weren't any available tools. Early articles came with instructions on how to built floats... With at least some of the right tools, and you don't need all of them, it is a pretty easy project. There is a lot less wood to remove than in one drawer corner dovetail, so long as one goes about it efficiently. I don't own any floats myself, other than a few I half made. So it isn't necessary unless you want to have the full experience, it would certainly make getting some of the crisp details easier.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#17

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

I can't imagine many people could sit through them. i sure couldn't, but I don't know how else to document the procedure in a way that everything is covered - putting anything on forums is extremely temporary and it would've been a killer to provide all of the detail in type and pictures.

Patrick's probably seen them (not to say that I think everyone has seen my videos, but he said he saw my washita sharpening process and I think that's the only place where it is). I don't like to self promote (though I do have ads turned off on all of my videos), and don't want to put a direct link up, but "making a double iron jack plane" should bring them up on youtube.

Definitely not appropriate for someone who wants edutainment type videos. they're literally camera on and make a plane with nobody else around. You could make a good video if you could even have one person holding a camera phone or moving it around while you work, but that's beyond my resources.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#18

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

I've watched some of your videos, but not the planemaking ones yet. They were already on my TODO list.

I actually like your videos, because all of those asides that would land on the editing room floor in a more scripted approach add a significant amount of context. Also, I like it when people "keep it real" in their videos (cue jokes about Roy and band-aids, etc).

I like having a textual reference, though, hence this thread.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#19

Whelan planemaking book?

Tom Colligan

David, can you point out which video covers your Washita sharpening process?

I did watch some of your videos earlier but apparently not this one.

Thx.,

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#20

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

Sorry I don't have a good quick video about it. Start at 8:00 in this video.

I think I must've been arguing with someone about whether or not you can finish plane without marks.

I've been arguing about these stones and smooth planing for quite a while, I guess arguing is the only thing that gets me motivated to make a video. Serious personality flaw, and I have little ability to be brief, too!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uc02mxDhX6A

(I do think this is far and away the easiest way to sharpen and maintain tools, though. )

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#21

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

"I can't imagine many people could sit through them. i sure couldn't, but I don't know how else to document the procedure in a way that everything is covered - putting anything on forums is extremely temporary and it would've been a killer to provide all of the detail in type and pictures."

I didn't mean to be snide about that. I just find, after 40 years, hundreds of books, etc... I can't take it any more. :) Which is a good thing, just do it.

I used to get annoyed in the early days of video when people would review some massive win in the expansion of information (which may be where yours are, given that I don't think Larry followed through with his promised bench plane videos?) and just pick away at the details on production. If someone would tell me how to do something I was desperate to know about, I would sit through anything. That is the main thing you learn from taking a serious education, patience. But I gave up as every second youtube video became more professional than a Taunton Press video, and when those were coming out they were dang good!

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#22

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

No problem, Tom. I was saying that in earnest - I couldn't sit through them. Sometimes I do something to document what I do, sometimes I do something because someone requests and it's not out there yet. Nothing I do is particularly special, but the world of information was lacking when it comes to double iron plane making.

I have ADD - three minutes into someone else's content, it's either time to start experimenting or move on for me.

I'd apologize for my lack of brevity and inability to not get bogged down in to details, but if I did, that's all I'd do.

(You're right Larry never did make a bench plane video, but I'm glad he didn't. I probably would've followed it verbatim before learning the double iron and then I'd just have a plane witting around that I don't use...or another one that I don't use). His moulding plane video is superb - the best LN video of any of them by far.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#23

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

It would still be better if he had, as there are single bit planes that work just fine, and there would have been people who could have learned something, and in the end the double bit would still be there, as it always was (couldn't resist).

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#24

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

In reality, people who are working with mostly power tools (to do all jointing and planing) are probably not going to notice much productivity difference.

Strange thing about planing with a double iron is that once you use it for some heavy work, when you get back to just smoothing in some cases, you're a lot faster at it.

Larry's planes are probably easier for a beginner, too, but I don't know that to make one well is any easier than making a double iron plane well. There are technical issues in the double that are more difficult, but the execution doesn't have to be quite as tight for the plane to still operate like a locked vault.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#25

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

The problem with Larry isn't so much that he chose to make single-iron planes. In addition to all of the reasons others have provided, he didn't have much choice as that's what his main customer demands.

It's that he went quite a bit farther than that and chose to use all of the recognition and influence he had accumulated to stridently advocate against double irons. I'm not talking about mere articles and random forum debates here. Much more problematic was that he had many "followers" in positions of influence who felt that his should be the last word on the topic.

I'm now watching his video on side-escapement plane building, and I think that his really *is* the last word on that topic, but he overreached when it comes to bench planes. With great influence comes great responsibility, and Larry didn't do so well by that measure.