Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Whelan planemaking book?

Posts

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#27

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

William Duffield

There is a new authoritative reference for building double iron planes. Megan Fitzpatrick just published an in-depth article in this month's Popular Woodworking by Steve Voigt on building a coffin smoother. If you can't build one from Steve's descriptions, someone should permanently duct tape your routah to your paw. ;)

https://www.popularwoodworking.com/nov17/smooth-operator

https://3dwarehouse.sketchup.com/model/76389b23-71c8-4dd4-b4ab-86400a07b096/Smoothing-Plane

http://www.voigtplanes.com

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#28

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

steve voigt

Thanks very much William, that's the first feedback I've had since the article came out. It was a challenge to pack everything I wanted to say into one article, and there's a lot that was left on the cutting room floor, but hopefully it's enough to encourage some people to get their hands dirty.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#29

Nice Article!

Patrick Chase

Steve, that was a very nicely done piece of writing. You successfully crammed a lot of critical information and techniques into a relatively small amount of text.

It reads very clearly and cleanly to me, though admittedly I'd already seen much of what you covered either in David's "Open Handled Jack" video series or in WC threads.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#30

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

TomD

I get what you are saying in your first two paragraphs:

"I'm now watching his video on side-escapement plane building, and I think that his really *is* the last word on that topic, but he overreached when it comes to bench planes. With great influence comes great responsibility, and Larry didn't do so well by that measure."

My view on the side escapement planes is that while we generally would choose better wood for that kind of work today, in essence, they are roughing through finishing planes in one tool, and if it works there, what is the problem with single bit planes. (and I suppose that the one client of note he had, is not exactly irrelevant as far as knowing what goes into woodwork).

On the influence and responsibility thing, Just from random things I picked up from his web pages and other musings, I thought he seriously believed he was copying the right historical tools. There might have been confirmation bias, just as the toofers have various blind spots. But I thought he claimed he was searching out, and copying tools of exquisite quality. The commitment to onesidedness isn't entirely unreasonable if one considers the commitment to the same philosophy by the likes of LV, LN, and others; or looking at how long excellent craftsmen in Japan did without the double bit for most of their time. Even those who stuck to the toofer had 10K fancy versions that were deemed necessary to get a good cut. The idea of being overrun by an army wielding rusty Bailey's hadn't occurred to many.

I think if there was a mistake, it was engaging with the internet, possibly angrily, which wouldn't help. He had his whatever status, and he should have just sat still on the mater. He had/has a good reputation helping other planemakers get started, and teaching weekenders in extensive detail how to make his signature product. If he had done the same on bench planes, he would have had half the mindspace.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#31

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

Side escapement planes aren't really roughing planes except for moving fillisters and rabbet planes.

I think there was little made in double iron planes for two reasons:

1) the functionality of the planes - matching soles, etc. Are you going to reprofile the cap iron when the sole gets out of whack and you reprofile it? You'd get stuck profiling the sole to the cap, and that's something I wouldn't have trouble with, but there's also an issue in making that functionality - affixing a double iron in a small plane either requires a tiny slotted iron (like the wonderful double iron ulmia rabbet plane) or coordinating loose iron and cap irons (which most users are probably not capable of).

2) More importantly, little other than the finishing parts of the cut is done with a hollow plane in most cases (you step out a profile with plow, rabbet, etc), and you try to do it with perfect wood because it's cheaper to do that than it is to try to make a half set of hollow and round planes with a double iron

That said, I've gotten (from enthusiasts) a couple of massive moulding plane blade combos from japan where both the iron and cap iron are laminated. The cap is not like what you see in a kanna, but rather very thick, like a mirror of the iron. Both tapered and loose. I've never troubled to build a plane with one. I'm sure they'd work well, but 1 and 2 above preside.

In terms of the single iron planes at williamsburg, the answer to that is simple. The curators didn't feel that double iron planes were common enough in williamsburg in the late 18th century, so they don't allow them. That's a decision made at the curator level, and not at the functional cabinetmaker level. (You know where I got that information, of course - George - because George is so knowledgeable about just about everything he does, and I was curious how he missed the double iron thing. The answer was simple, he flat out wasn't allowed to use them at work, so he didn't spend much time on it).

Functionally, though. It's no contest. I would like to have an event where any and all very fit comers can dimension 5 board feet of wood against me to a mark or thickness spec with the condition it be suitable for finish or suitable enough that a light scraping would finish it once done with the planes. They use any single iron plane they want (larry's would be fine), and my fat desk-worker out of shape rear will take them on with planes I've made. It would be an easy contest - I'd win. It's like being a fat desk worker and riding a road bike on the local loop here vs. the very fit mountain bike riders that I see. I can see their cadence speeding up when they hear me coming, but despite their superior physical condition, they have no chance - I pass them easily - too much static friction and the wrong riding position for road speed. My tool in that case is more suited to the job.

At any rate, that kind of difference becomes an economic differentiator, and when you're working without much profit, an economic differentiator puts a non-adopter out of business. Thus, the single iron planes in all but econo trim disappeared (not sure who the target customer was for the low price single iron planes that stayed in catalogs, but I am by no means any kind of historian at all, so it's no surprise that I don't know that).

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#32

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Williamsburg people decided not to use double iron planes based on "archeological evidence". They found about five plane irons in the soil around the shop, all uncut irons. These irons were probably used as single irons (or as double irons with loose cap irons).

Given that the shop was open for several decades under several masters and ending around 1776, it is likely that single irons were used for a good portion of the history of the shop, and that double irons might have been used only at the end.

About a dozen years ago, after reading the archeological evidence, I suggested that after they got their new double irons they just threw the old irons out the window. Having used my own shop for 32 years now, I know that tools that are no longer used have a way of getting lost in the shavings.

At Annapolis, capital of Maryland and just up the Chesapeake Bay from Williamsburg, famous cabinetmaker John Shaw was importing and selling double iron planes in 1774. I think the target date for the Williamsburg shop is 1775.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#33

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

david weaver

Warren, I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, and perhaps it's been a few decades since you've used single iron planes for any significant work, but the difference in economy of work when starting from rough is so start that even without any other advantages (being able to get a good finish with an iron that's not freshly sharpened, using common pitch, etc), I can't imagine that single iron planes even had a chance once the bulk of shops had double iron planes.

The efficiency would've been priced into work, and it would become like trying to sell hand raked hay these days and make a living. The difference being less stark, maybe, but the same example.

I forgot, too, in my example above that I could nail the thickness mark in stride, something that's often not doable at a respectable clip with single irons in anything other than perfect wood (in something quartered, forget about it - a double iron is multiple times faster).

I started to see your way when I began giving up power tools and tried dimensioning with various single iron planes. It didn't make sense to me that one would struggle effort wise with every little grain variation.

Larry demonstrates this in his video on a plane blank when he has to skew a smoother to plane quartered beech. There are some pieces with ribboning that can be tricky (brian holcombe's plane was one), but regular quartered stock is dealt with easily with a double iron unless it's been dried improperly (and in that case, the wood is junk, anyway).

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#34

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

David and Warren have already answered most of your points, so I'll just cherry-pick:

Hollows and rounds in particular are very much finishing planes. Their mouths are generally too tight to take any sort of roughing cut. If you look at Matt Bickford's book or older sources that describe the use of such planes, the heavier roughing work is consistently done with rabbets, and the moulding planes are used to refine the shape (by applying radii).

Even with complex moulders it's more productive in my experience to "rough in" the profile first.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#35

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Patrick Chase

Your explanation of the single irons being found on the ground around the shop is appealing for obvious reasons (not least because it's funny and jibes with my own biases on the topic), but the little voice in the back of my head questions whether craftsmen would have wasted relatively precious tool steel that way in the late 18th Century.

Don't you think they would have been more likely to hang onto those for later conversion to other applications (wide/complex moulding planes, etc). For that matter didn't people convert single irons to double back then?

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#36

Re: Nice Article!

steve voigt

Thanks Patrick, it's always tough to know how these things come across. so I'm glad it seems reasonably coherent.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#37

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

Brian Holcombe

I agree with the consensus here. I would not want to dimension with single iron planes unless I was able to work entirely with riven stock. Even with really prime sawn stock it would be tough to do and a time sink by comparison.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#38

Dimensioning:  Question about roughing planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Brian, Dave, Patrick, and all,

With the double iron plane, suppose you have a jack with 1/8" or 3/32" of camber on the blade, or you have a foreplane with 1/32" say. In such cases, approximately how many thousandths of an inch do you maintain between the blade and the chip breaker/subblade?

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#39

Re: Dimensioning:  Question about roughing planes

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Wiley,

This depends on the camber depth of the blade. Unless the chip breaker iron is also strongly cambered (which I have done, but is a pita) you can't get it super close to the primary blade cambered edge because the chip breaker would overhang the outer edges of the primary blade. Both would have to similarly cambered.

In this case, I would get the chip breaker very close to the primary blade at it's outer edges (where, because of the camber, the blade isn't cutting) and depending on the depth of the camber, this sets the "overhang" distance. In practice, I would guess 0.020" - 0.030" at least at the center, again depending on the depth (radius) of the camber. But I personally tend to more strongly camber plane blades...

John

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#40

Re: What is the title

Ron in Sterling, CT

of Matt Bickfords' book?

Thanks,

Ron

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#41

Re: Dimensioning:  Question about roughing planes

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi again Wiley,

Just a quick clarification - when I said "where, because of the camber, the blade isn't cutting" I meant that when I personally set up a plane, this is so.

I'm not powerful enough to push a fully engaged, 2" wide, strongly cambered plane blade through a piece of wood. Maybe cross grain hogging out, but certainly not with the grain. So, I tend to limit the blade protrusion from the sole so it cuts only at the center. Maybe others do this, I don't know...

John

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#42

Re: Dimensioning:  Question about roughing planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use a jack plane that I made in 1978. I have never measured the camber or the cap iron distance. If there is too little camber, the corners will dig in, which will make the plane hard to push. If there is too much camber, a full width shaving will be too deep for comfort so you end up making just a narrow cut. Ideally you want to adjust the camber so that you get nearly full width for the depth of cut you normally use.

I suppose that one could find an ideal camber if he were constantly working the same timber, but that does not fit with the real world. So the camber is sort of a compromise between what is ideal for white pine and what is ideal for persimmon. And you want the depth of cut to be something that will not wear you out in just a few minutes. There are costs (like lack of intimacy) that come with having a fleet of jack planes for different timbers, and I think historically many workers used but one.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#43

Re: What is the title

Patrick Chase

https://lostartpress.com/products/mouldings-in-practice

He'll happily sell you the planes, too, at msbickford.com. A fair bit of the book content is dispersed throughout his "Big Pink" blog.

TL;DR - A set of rabbets, hollows, rounds, side rounds, and snipe bills can cut basically any moulding profile imaginable. The trick is to rough in a "rectangular approximation" of the profile, then use the hollows/rounds to refine.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#44

Do you profile your cap irons?

Patrick Chase

Do you profile your Jack's cap iron to "follow" the camber of the iron, or leave it straight and set it back far enough to avoid overlapping the corners?

I do the latter, mostly because I don't want to compromise mating at the leading edge of the cap iron (if you camber avcap iron then its corners may lift up a bit due the the undercut on the cap iron mating surface).

My most aggressively configured Jack has ~0.06" of camber, which in turn means that the minimum cap iron setback is at least that much in the center. It doesn't seem to buy me all that much in that configuration.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#45

Re: Do you profile your cap irons?

david weaver

It won't matter if it overlaps the corner, because the cap will never be below the sole of the plane and never in the cut.

Anyone who gives you advice to clip the corners of a cap iron should be told to keep that to themselves. It happens from time to time, though, including from some "experts" who make videos (like the kind that come in a plastic case).

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#46

Re: Dimensioning:  Question about roughing planes

david weaver

Wiley, as a matter of practice, somewhere around 2 times as far as the thickest shaving I intend to take or a little more, unless you have really easy going or only cross grain work, and then you can set the cap iron back as far as you'd like. The shavings don't show any influence from the cap either way.

Only really nasty stuff requires the cap to be set close on the jack. Quartered curly cherry comes to mind (I can only think of twice that I've had to do it).

I do work the try plane with the cap engaged, and it's set so that it straightens out about the thickest shaving I'll take in a given piece of wood.

There is quite a bit of extra resistance when setting the cap iron on the jack close, I guess because of the stiffness of the shavings, or I'd do it more often because it does eliminate surprises. Even given that, it does reduce risk and effort vs. the fight that occurs if you try to jack plane something like that without setting the cap close. Nothing adds effort like having to make something twice.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#47

Re: Do you profile your cap irons?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have rounded the cap iron to follow the camber since 1976. Peter Nicholson, writing in 1812, also used this method. I find it reassuring when my method coincides with historical practice. Sometimes it is after decades of use that I find a technique I have used is affirmed in this manner.

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#48

Re: Do you profile your cap irons?

david weaver

I just heard a record scratch!!

Re: Whelan planemaking book?

#49

Re: Do you profile your cap irons?

david weaver

Ok, now I'm in data acquisition mode given this, Warren. I certainly wouldn't criticize a pro being a doofus amateur.

So, my question is this. Do you profile the jack cap, also, like a gutter plane (but perhaps less severe) or is this only try plane and smoothing plane?

My thoughts on this have been that as the shaving thins near the edge of an iron, the fact that the cap iron is closer is probably beneficial. But at those thinner parts, the chip may not be thick enough to matter, so it may not make any real difference either way.

I have bought about 40 planes, I guess, most of them english (I don't still have them all, I was just looking at various planes and various cap irons) and only one plane has had a modification like this, and unfortunately for me, it was the leading corner on a badger plane cap iron). I choose mostly english stuff because it's usually much closer to condition of the last pro user than stuff in the US. Actually, I don't have any good planes that I've bought locally. From time to time, I'm in your area but the tools that would've been there when you started are sparse thanks to Ebay. Even George used to come up your way (a 4+ hour trip) and loot the flea markets, but he said there's little there now. Not to say there's none, but little rather.