Thanks Patrick
Whelan planemaking book?
Posts
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#52Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Patrick Chase
Do you do anything special to ensure that the corners of the cap iron mate firmly?
The reason I ask is because the mating surface of the cap iron is typically undercut a bit, so if you just camber the leading edge and don't make any other adjustments, then in theory the corners will lift off by (camber_depth*tan(undercut_angle)).
I say "in theory" because the amount is fairly small. For example with 3 deg of undercut and 1/32" camber you would see ~1.5 mils of "lift" at the extreme corners, which may or may not be worth worrying about in a roughing plane that takes much thicker shavings than that.
Obviously you could fix it by investing some quality time with some marking grease and a slip or by taking the relief angle down as low as you dare, I'm just curious to know if you bothered.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#53Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
John Aniano in Central NJ
Patrick,
In the few times I've cambered the chip breaker, yes, you do have to deal with the "lift" as you called it. The chip breakers I dealt with weren't hardened steel, so I just used a hammer and tapped them from the top, convex curved surface over a piece of hard wood. This is much the same idea as demoed by Brian Holcombe a few months ago on his blog about getting a Japanese blade to have the proper hollow ura and sit straight by tapping out. In my case, once done tapping, you then assemble the blade and chip breaker (tightened down with the screw) and, looking from the sides, see where/if the ends are properly in contact with the blade. If not, gentle stoning of the chip breaker edges' underside taking care to keep the undercut, takes down the high spots. Test, correct and retest until the whole edge is in contact. Like I said, a bit of a pita, but you only do it once.
Just my $0.02...
John
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#54Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Patrick Chase
"Cap-iron ura-dashi" has a nice ring to it...
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#55Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I haven't brought a new plane into service since 1983, but you have the right idea here, Patrick. If you have a bevel on the cap iron that is rounded and not a flat angle, the way I do and the way Nicholson did, and if your cap iron also follows the radius of the edge of the plane iron, they way mine do and the way Nicholson's did, and if you undercut the cap iron so only the leading edge touches, the way mine does and almost certainly as Nicholson did also, then this undercut surface is not a flat plane.
And if you do this, your plane is sophisticated far beyond what Lee Valley or Lie Nielsen can imagine.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#56Nicholson
David weaver
I'm curious as to why Nicholson thought this was a necessary step. In order for the cap iron to be most mechanically effective, it needs to follow the sole of a plane rather than the camber of the iron. When it's relieved, the cap is then further from the point of the cut at the city's thinnest point, which is reverse of what you want. The thickest part of the cut is in the center, and thus the most critical, so the edges probably don't make a difference. As in, it won't hurt anything if you do it properly, but it doesn't have a mechanical chance to make a functional gain. I think Nicholson was off base on this one.
On a gutter plane, it would be essential to do it to follow the sole profile, though.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#57Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Brian Holcombe
This is very interesting. I've setup a number of radiused cap irons for my Japanese planes. It sounds quite complicated in theory but fairly easy in practice.
That said I have not radiused a cap iron for my bench planes, that I will have to give a try. I am always happy to find a place for improvement in my process.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#58Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
David weaver
It's not something I'd do just yet, it's a step backwards. More on this later when I have a computer instead of a phone. This is something Nicholson didn't understand correctly, or perhaps was taught incorrectly by someone.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#59Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
steve voigt
I'd advise you to try it first on a cap iron you don't care very much about. I tried this early on and found it to be a waste of time. Your mileage may vary, and if other folks have had success on this, good for them, but I won't be doing it again.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#60Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Patrick Chase
David, you seem to be assuming that the cap iron can never extend below the sole of the plane.
I don't think that's really a constraint. It's bad news if the cap iron *corners* project below the sole (because then they can end up "cutting solo" if they extend beyond the iron on either side) but there's no such constraint on the center of a cambered cap iron.
For powerful evidence to the contrary look no further than the Kato/Kawai video. Their most effective configuration used 0.1 mm of setback and a 0.1 mm cut. The setback is measured along the back of the iron, so in that configuration the cap iron was about 0.03 mm below the surface of the wood.
In short, if you camber the cap iron then the center can safely extend below the sole. Whether that's *necessary* is a different question that I feel less well equipped to answer. I can buy an argument that positioning the leading edge of the cap iron in the plane of the sole should give adequate cap-iron effect such that there's no need to go deeper. The ratio of shaving thickness to cap iron setback is sqrt(2)/2 ~= 0.7 in that configuration for a 45 deg bed, which I think we all know to be pretty good. It's the geometric equivalent of taking a 2.8 mil shaving with 4 mils of setback.
Furthermore, with a straight cap iron positioned in the plane of the sole the depth:setback ratio is constant across the entire cut, and I can see how one might argue that this is optimal.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#61Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Patrick Chase
I bought a small collection of extra cap irons a while back for my "classic" Veritas planes (the ones that use bent-sheet-metal cap irons) for exactly this sort of thing. I think I still have a few that haven't been experimented upon :-).
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#62(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#63(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#64Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
Brian Holcombe
Steve, the last thing I would do is scold you and was not what I wanted to do here. Please accept my apology for how my post was worded.
I've deleted my post, I should know better than to attempt to word my posts while attempted to secure a spare moment between chores on a Saturday.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#65Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
steve voigt
Thanks Brian. I'm sure I did not need to be so defensive about it. My apologies. This thread is making me a little short tempered; at least that's my excuse.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#66Re: Do you profile your cap irons?
david weaver
The plane is capable of putting the cap iron below the sole, though it will likely cause feeding problems.
The reality is, you'll never push the plane with the cap iron projected below the sole, or even at the sole itself.
Next time you're in the shop with a fore plane, set the cap iron at 5 thousandths and take a 7 thousandth thick shaving (which will represent about 5 thousandths of cut depth). That will be the cap iron set equal with the sole.
The cap iron doesn't need to match anything but the sole of the plane because you'll never use the plane with the cap iron below the sole, regardless of whether or not it can physically be moved to a position like that when it's not cutting.
That's precisely why matching a cap iron (or clipping the corners, or whatever you'd like to call it) isn't necessary. There is, perhaps, a chance that nicholson and others liked just having the corners clipped because it would lessen the chance of a feeding problem in a plane that has a setup problem. But in terms of tearout reduction of functionality, it doesn't matter how much the cap iron overlaps the corners of a cambered iron because you'll never be able to push the plane with the cap iron even with the sole. You might, perhaps, be able to do it with a 2 thousandth shaving, but that's not going to happen on an iron with much radius.
Give it a try.
Kato and Kawai is a bad illustration of what can be done hand planing because it doesn't give you an optimal set for hand tool work, and because the power of the machine results in things being shown that are not done with hand tools. That's OK for the video, though, because it was intended to help with the development of the super surfacer.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#67Reference: Peter Nicholson, 'The Mechanic's Compa
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi All,
If interested in Peter Nicholson's writings, and they are many, a start can be made at Google Books for free. Here is The Mechanic's Companion':
Not sure if this is the book Warren was talking about, but in the Joinery section, under Jack Planes, Nicholson does indeed say to make the ' cover iron' have a convexity (in plan view) that is 'concentric' with the cutting iron such that it sits an equal distance back from the cutting edge, all the way across. I mention this, because he isn't talking about clipping corners.
The book is also available through that South American River, at a price, for those so moved. BTW, This edition is 1845, but it's earliest edition by Nicholson, or partial edition (not sure which) goes back to 1812. Nicholson states he is following the general organization of Moxon, and seems to see himself as writing a sequel to Moxon.
Wiley
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#68Peter Nicholson plate XII, pages 91 to 93
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#69No worries
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#70Re: Reference: Peter Nicholson, 'The Mechanic's C
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Yes, that is the reference, Wiley. I used the the technique for over thirty years before I noticed it in Nicholson. Nicholson apprenticed as a cabinetmaker and worked as a journeyman in London in the late 18th century before moving on to become a mathematician and brilliant architect. As mentioned earlier, I am always tickled to find that I am on the same page with him.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#71Fun with math
Patrick Chase
I think you meant to suggest taking a 5 mil cut with a 7 mil setback (as opposed to the converse), as that would indeed put the cap iron even with the plane of the sole. I've done that, and there are certainly significantly increased planing forces, but it's workable and IMO sometimes the right answer.
A 7 mil cut with 5 mil setback would put the cap iron ~3.5 mm below the sole. As you say that would be problematic in several respects.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#72Where did the ball go?
david weaver
The important issue here is that you will never actually plane with the cap iron below the sole of the plane.
Let's go back to the numbers (I did intentionally suggest that you'll take a shaving thicker than the cap iron is set back, but we need a few assumptions to see why i said that).
Assume (though it's probably not quite right, but it's close) that:
*The set of the cap iron flush to the sole of the plane is 2^0.5 times the deepest depth of the cut in order for the cap iron to be flush with the sole (well, that part's not assumed - it's mathematically correct).
* assume also that the thickness of the shaving will be approximately 2^0.5 times the depth of cut at the deepest point (that's assumed, I'm sure it varies by wood and can sometimes be a little less).
That would yield a shaving thickness that is right around the same as the set of the cap iron (even though the wood removed is the cap iron set / sqrt(2). This, itself, is a losing proposition. In order to get good function out of a cap iron, there is a bit of space on the open back of the iron across which the chip travels before it meets the cap iron itself. that is why larry used to always go on and on about "beam" strength. That's the beam.
In simple terms, I'd say, if you really think cap set at the sole is practical (or especially below), then the next thing to do is to work a quantity of wood with the cap set below. At the very best with the cap set flush, the surface quality will be very poor. At the worst, you won't be able to push the plane (that will be the case with a jack or try plane). This is actually what I first did when I set a cap about a decade ago, and concluded it made the plane too hard to push and set it aside. Of course, I argued that with Warren (who else would have been arguing? Nobody else did at the time).
We set the cap back a little extra from the sole so that the shaving can be cut cleanly, and so that we are not smashing the wood fibers ahead of the cut, which is what will occur if the cap is set flush with the sole of the plane. The consequence of this smashing is a smashed looking surface - try white pine if you really want to see it. Warren could spot that in a second (shiny wood that has a rippled look because it was crushed), and so can I.
That is a very important point, because that's what leads to there being no need to trim the corners of a cap iron (well, except when there is a plane that does not have a flat sole like a gutter plane, but those cap irons come radiused from the maker) shy of the wood, and by clipping the corners, you are going counter to what you'd actually do to reduce tearout, which is to set the cap closer to the sole of the plane for a thinner cut.
Now, feeding (clogging is a term most people will probably use) in a wooden plane is something entirely different. If Nicholson would have contended that most feeding problems are in the corners (they are) in a plane that is not properly set up or tuned, certainly that could be a legitimate reason (maybe nicholson did - I haven't read it). I am out of context in that, because I worked hard - even as an amateur maker - to figure out what keeps a plane from having feeding problems at the corners without just completely opening up the wear area and eliminating it like a stanley plane done by incident. When I make a wooden plane, if it has a feeding issue, probably 90% of the time, it occurs at the corners, but I have gotten better at identifying what wear will go with what cap iron profile (for example, a long flat ward cap iron will be more forgiving, but an early rounded butcher cap iron with a lot of curve and spring - not so much. The wear angle needs to be steeper on an otherwise identical plane).
All of that is why this is at best a lateral move, but potentially worse. If the shavings at the (side) edges of a cut are so thin that they can't tear out, no harm done. But a lot of pointless work has been done to tune this, it can't be reversed (which may really not matter, especially in the case of someone like warren who is not going to put a plane down until it's completely worn out - my obsession with residual value and ability to reset doesn't apply). Warren is the first person who actually understands the cap who has mentioned this. I can't really argue that he shouldn't do it - why should I? I'm sure he's a better woodworker than me.
I would suggest that nobody else who is new should do it because they don't understand caps that well, and that of others can set their planes up correctly, they'll find no benefit from it. And in that, I'm quite sure (I'm an actuary, I never say 100% anything - but let's go 99.999%) if Nicholson thinks there is, I'm right and he's wrong.
I've got a bunch of work to do today, maybe I'll revisit this tonight. Do try the cap iron set below the sole, even a little bit.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#73Re: Reference: Peter Nicholson, 'The Mechanic's C
david weaver
Hi Wiley, can you cite the page? Not trying to start any arguments, just more or less in data acquisition (and i'm a terrible reader, both impatient and with poor comprehension!!).
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#74Re: Where did the ball go?
Brian Holcombe
I usually solve a feeding issue by ensuring that the blade is narrower than the cap iron at the cutting edge. It seems counter-intuitive to clip the corners of the cap-iron, which would exaggerate the issue in my experience.
With Japanese planes the cap iron overhangs the blade at the corners, it will create feeding issues if it does not do so.
Re: Whelan planemaking book?
#75Re: Where did the ball go?
david weaver
I think in finish cuts, it generally will be (the iron cutting a little narrower than the cap, or there will be tracks). I think most of us end up there, too, due to the fact that a plane just works better with camber than it does straight across.
I always leave my irons completely straight across when i first finish a plane to ensure good feed at the corners, but you can get a double iron wooden plane to clog if you skew it to the extreme. Fortunately, the double iron makes skewing unnecessary.
No clue if single iron planes do the same thing.
re: removing the corners, if the wear is truly planar, it will get you just a little bit of extra relief from the wear (extra space) to have the corners of the cap set back, but I'd rather solve the feed problem instead. It's usually pretty easy once the relationship between the cap iron shape and the wear is understood.
An old double iron plane is fairly simple, but subject to a lot of variation, so your plane, for example, fed well in my shop. But different types of wood, different types of use, and especially wood that is too junky to hold together well in terms of shavings - all of that could cause you to have a clog that I didn't have.
One of the things of genius for Leonard Bailey is coming up with a plane where all of this is essentially removed because there's no wear aside from a small sole thickness (and plenty of people have proven that you can get them to clog even with just the sole thickness, I guess). In infills, there is a thicker sole, but the infill makers understood what was going on and filed the front of the sole toward the bun (the total angle vs. the sole on the bed side is obtuse vs. being acute in wooden planes).



