Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Posts

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#26

Re: I disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I could not find the most important attribute, namely bond hardness, in the description of that wheel. The last time I checked Lee Valley white wheels were a soft bond, and hence suitable for cool grinding. You will find that a 60 grit wheel makes metal go away rapidly. Use a very light touch. It will work fine, just use a light touch. I have a white 80 grit white wheel in a K bond (medium hardness) and I can't avoid burning when using it.

You will need a dressing stick. The "tee" shaped one listed below the wheel in the Amazon description is the one I use and I like it.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#27

Wood shop is not like a tool room

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I grind chisels and plane blades on a wheel with a crowned profile. The ability of the wheel to hold this shape is largely irrelevant and the exact crown profile is similarly irrelevant. I paid about $10 for a wheel dresser that works just fine and has lasted years. I rarely need to use it because my soft H wheel sheds grits at a rate where they are renewed continuously.

Grinding tool bits for metal work is another issue. Here the ability of the wheel to hold its shape can be essential, hence, the invention of the seeded gel (ceramic) particle.

On the matter of wood lathe tools I assisted a class with Bonnie Klein. There were 12 students and each had 4 tools. In between sessions she sharpened these 48 tools in a matter of a few seconds each. She used a typical 8" grinder and some variety of white wheel and the sparks flew. I don't know what technology could have improved her performance.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#28

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

Brian Holcombe

In any case two-three stone wheels and a CBN pays for itself. I agree with the crowned profile, my CBN is crowned.

Depending on the abrasive grit the wheel may or may not clog when you grind other than steel. So if you need to grind iron then your wheel is going to clog. I hardly grind anything laminated but I do on rare occasions where I have to fix something or if I get a new tool and the bevel is way off from where I want it.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#29

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

David weaver

My can wheel is flat. There's no need for it to be crowned like you'd want with a traditional wheel, it won't burn something easily, even if held flat and stationary. It has radius edges and was $125. I would never trade back. For grinding of soft stuff, I still have a coarse al-ox wheel on the other side of the grinder.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#30

Why boron nitride(and diamond) is cool

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This discussion sent me off on a quest to understand how these wheels work. It is not clear that they offer any advantage for grinding the stuff we grind, the way we grind it, over diamond. The inexpensive coated diamond products the lapidary folks use may be a source of good grinding.....but I digress.

According to scientific studies on this matter, boron nitride grinds cool mainly because the abrasive point penetrates the steel better than aluminum oxide (ditto for diamond by the way). By penetrating it mills off a chip with less of the plowing that generates lots of frictional heat from a particle that just dents the surface. Of secondary importance is its high conductivity relative to aluminum oxide, which conducts heat away from the abrasive particle.

As long as these wheels stay sharp they will grind cool. Like anything there are ways to make them of higher or lower quality, with more or less grits to do the work.

Along the way I found out why pink aluminum oxide wheels are better for grinding hardened steel. They are a significantly harder particle as well as more friable to expose new sharp edges than white aluminum oxide. .

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#31

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

Gary B.

I bought a $10 diamond dresser off of Amazon a while ago, that I never used. Tonight I found in buried in a drawer, and dressed my existing grey 60 grit wheel. Wow what a difference! I was able to grind two irons and several chisels without burning them, through a light touch. When the blade was warm to the touch, I'd rotate in another and let it cool down. No water quench.

Dressing certainly did make a mess. But if it saves me from buying a wheel now, I'll wait and consider a CBN later.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#32

Thank you!

Brian Holcombe

Makes sense, thanks for doing the research.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#33

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

David weaver

That's my experience with gray and brown hard wheels and a cheap diamond t dresser. Mine are 46- the coarser the better. If I hadn't gotten a cbn wheel, I'd have gone back to that. The only cheap friable wheels I saw were 7", and the 6" wheels were bankrupters.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#34

A dandy book available

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Grinding Technology" by Malkin and Guo I only found parts of it on line and the book price was more than I was willing to pay. It has a section devoted to boron nitride grinding. The picture of the boron nitride wheel surface is impressive. Lots of sharp pointies to dig into metal and mill out a chip. Makes one think that there could be a market for boron nitride files.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#35

Grinding theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A sharp hard particle will penetrate the steel and mill off a chip. The chip will carry away the heat generated by the work of milling the chip. A dull particle will just plow across the steel and heat it by friction. Dressing exposes new sharp edges. A soft bond sheds dull grits to accomplish the same end. Boron Nitride and diamond stays pointy much longer.

Diamond has an interesting chemical property. If the steel being ground does not have much carbon, the steel elements steal carbon from the diamond to make metal carbides. This chemistry corrodes away the sharp diamond edges. But, if the steel is high carbon like the steel we use for our tools, the carbides are already formed and the corroding away of the diamond is lessened. Boron Nitride does not suffer this disadvantage.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#36

Re: A dandy book available

Brian Holcombe

They do already have BNC plates, used similarly to diamond plates but with the exception that they can be used on steel without accelerated failure like a diamond plate does.

This is to my understanding, I do not have first hand experience with the plates, only the wheels.

I'm tempted to try one, I have a worn out diamond plate that I use for Japanese tools when I need to remove more of an edge than normal wear (crumbly edge, etc).

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#37

Re: Get a plastic tub with a lid

David Bird

A few drops of bleach (and a lid) will keep the water as fresh as a swimming pool for months.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#38

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I grind chisels and plane blades on a wheel with a crowned profile. The ability of the wheel to hold this shape is largely irrelevant and the exact crown profile is similarly irrelevant.

Bill, go and use a CBN wheel, and then come back and discuss this further.

I am not suggesting that everyone gives up their white and pink wheels. I am stating that the CBN wheels are in a different league altogether, and you can have no idea of their advantages until you use one.

It is relevant when a wheel holds it profile and never requires dressing, since this means minimum set ups, and sharper, cooler and especially more predictable grinds.

The rule book changes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#39

Re: Wood shop is not like a tool room

Bruce Mack

Derek - I was reluctant to take my good irons and chisels to a grinder. For years I free-handed using back and forth movements with occasional side sharpening to try to remove the belly on the bevel as the angle crept up. After getting a 6" 3400 rpm grinder and replacing the white wheel with a 60 grit CBN from Joel (mostly to eliminate the vibration) I now have an easy way of establishing registration on the sharpening media and can readily alter bevel angles if wanted. It's fast beyond expectation with as you and others have affirmed.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#40

Re: Why boron nitride(and diamond) is cool

David Weaver

Pink stuff is the same as the stuff in purpose made surface grinder wheels?

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#41

Sailboats.....holes in the sea.....

roger lance

into which we pour money......or something like that.

I seem to get involved in things that eat money.....a sailboat.....a Corvette.....blondes (with nicknames like Bunny or Kitten).....and woodworking.

I'm one of those guys that bought those "HORRID" (that's not what people were calling them at that time) blue wheels.....now its a CBN wheel at $189.99/ea.

We just keep chasing the magic stick......

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#42

Re: Sailboats.....holes in the sea.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I seem to get involved in things that eat money.....a sailboat.....a Corvette.....blondes (with nicknames like Bunny or Kitten).....and woodworking.....

We just keep chasing the magic stick......

Roger, this is not just another "must have" toy. For those that hollow grind, this is a game changer.

Oh, I did the sailing for 25 years, still doing the Corvette (except my wife refers to it as the Menoporsche), and still chase a blond (in my case, called Lynndy). :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#43

not a game changer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hollow grind just fine on my wheel, in fact any wheel that I have tried and I have tried many in demonstrations. Nothing heats like a thin Stanley blade and I would not have, and didn't have, any hesitation to hollow grind one on any wheel except the very hard wheels that come with grinders.

It is not that I don't believe how wonderful a boron nitride wheel is. I accept that this technology is the best way to grind a chisel. The issue is how much better is it than what I already do?

It is not a game changer because the only way it could be better than what I have is that it won't shed grits , an issue that isn't with me. I quickly grind a thin Stanley blade. How can it get better? I can do this grinding on a 7" pink surface grinder wheel that cost $15. I have done it with grit sizes that range from 120 to 60, 500 to 3600 rpm. Where is the potential improvement?

I will accept that if one doesn't know how to use a grinder the learning curve for the boron nitride is easy to climb. However, I have taught many to grind a Stanley blade on my grinder and everyone has succeeded in short order, except the lady that stuck her finger into the spinning 60 grit wheel to see if it was running. That didn't end well.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#44

Tailor made for old ladies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I will accept that if one doesn't know how to use a grinder the learning curve for the boron nitride is easy to climb. However, I have taught many to grind a Stanley blade on my grinder and everyone has succeeded in short order, except the lady that stuck her finger into the spinning 60 grit wheel to see if it was running. That didn't end well.

How many times must I tell you, Bill ... pink wheels are for the girls; blue for the boys :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#45

Re: Grinding theory

David Weaver

It's good Larry Williams isn't here. George said the same thing once that carbon migrates from the diamonds into the steel, and Larry had a fit.

I sort of miss the Williams-isms and the Hughes-isms.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#46

Re: not a game changer

David Weaver

The difference between cbn and other wheels is bigger than the difference between vintage and modern steels. It's not a skill level thing. Any coarse wheel is easy to grind with as long as someone has a wheel dresser.

I can get along with a cheap coarse wheel for maintenance grinding just fine, but cleaning up old tools and grinding new hardened irons or reshaping hardened irons is much easier with cbn and it doesn't present the wear issue that you get doing heavy grinding with a pink wheel.and if bought right, it'll be cheaper than pink wheels when all is said and done. I'll bet someone near the end of the line woodworking could probably sell their used cbn wheel for a fair amount, too. Maybe half of new.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#47

Re: Grinding theory

John in NM

Why have a fit over a well documented discovery that improves our knowledge of the world and of how to work efficiently?

I enjoy the light bulb turning on, sure beats sitting around and watching TV or scrolling through FB posts of what people had for lunch! Its one thing I like a lot about this forum, the depth of knowledge here from other fields that tie in to woodworking.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#48

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

William Duffield

We were discussing CBN wheels last night, after a friend decided, based on your recommendations in this thread to get one. You've almost convinced me, too.

However during the discussion, someone warned us that there are some materials that should never be ground on a CBN wheel, because they will ruin the wheel. Among these materials were Aluminum. Can anyone give me a list of verboten materials?

I also noted a couple more advantages of these wheels that were not mentioned specifically, and that might not therefore be obvious to everyone following this discussion:

These wheels never change diameter. This greatly simplifies any angle setting jigs you might want to build or buy.

A guard to prevent shrapnel from a disintegrating wheel from flying around the shop is not necessary. This gives your tools and jigs more flexible access to the wheel.

When you start the grinder, you don't need to walk away, out of the line of fire, while the wheel comes up to speed.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#49

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

David weaver

I would limit the wheel to hardened steel, or at least laminated irons. I wouldn't be surprised if soft metal pulled particles off of the wheels. Cheap wheels do heavy grinding on soft metals so well that I can't think of a good reason to subject the cbn wheel to them.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#50

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

roger lance

According to the product description of CBN wheels on Amazon: "Sharpening non-heat treated steel, aluminum or other soft metals will damage the CBN grinding wheel."