Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Posts

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#51

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I also noted a couple more advantages of these wheels that were not mentioned specifically, and that might not therefore be obvious to everyone following this discussion:

These wheels never change diameter. This greatly simplifies any angle setting jigs you might want to build or buy.

A guard to prevent shrapnel from a disintegrating wheel from flying around the shop is not necessary. This gives your tools and jigs more flexible access to the wheel.

When you start the grinder, you don't need to walk away, out of the line of fire, while the wheel comes up to speed.

Hi William

I did earlier mention the advantage of retaining the diameter. On my own set up, which uses the Tormek blade holder, this is an even larger advantage - as users of the Tormek will recognise. Set ups become predictable, and it is easier to touch up a hollow.

I did not mention that the wheel guards may be removed. Mine are, some like to retain them. In any event, they are now unnecessary - these wheels are not going to shatter or explode. This gives better visibility and also better access to the wheel itself.

As to the steel that should not be used, only unhardened steel is verboten. If one did use it accudentally, the simple fix is to grind hardened steel. This will remove the build up on the surface. The teeth are unlikely to be damaged.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#52

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

William Duffield

That's a good reason to retain one of my old white wheels, instead of going whole hog and buying two CBN wheels of different grits. I definitely don't want to try to find room in my shop for another grinder.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#53

Re: Grinding theory

david weaver

O.D.D. maybe! I know that in the past, when I didn't recognize that I was in a terrible mood, I could disagree with just about anybody on just about anything.

I recall a time or two that I said something that I thought Larry would agree with and got burned, anyway. But I'm sure I've done that to people, too.

The Todd-isms were different, but I liked those a lot! Like telling people who were excited about their new tool that the dealer saw them coming from a mile away!! Or his discussions with Larry about single and double irons where Larry would put up 3 or 4 pages of quasi-scientific stuff and Todd would respond with a reasonability statement a sentence long, like (paraphrased) "I don't think they'd have gone to the expense of making a cap iron if it wasn't better".

No matter what you do on the forums (or what you post on a video on youtube), you're guaranteed to have someone disagreeing with you, even if you're just telling them that you agree with them!

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#54

Re: not a game changer

TomD

+1

"The issue is how much better is it than what I already do?"

Or how much better than good enough. The grind is not the finished edge, so who cares how you get there: faster, safer, cleaner, etc... All better.

It's just nice to see they have finally babied up the entry fee enough that people will accept dry grinding. I remember the loose diamond wars around here, and suggesting dry grinding as a much faster operation.

Steel tends to come in two varieties: Easy to grind; hard to grind but can't be burned. You really have to wantonly abandon common sense to get into any trouble. I would suspect that a major advantage to the new wheels is that they just don't sound scary. And who needs that. The sounding scary thing is backed up with some really hideous potential outcomes.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#55

Re: Grinding theory

TomD

"I don't think they'd have gone to the expense of making a cap iron if it wasn't better".

That is supposed to be an intelligent statement on his part? I'd watch out for someone offering kool-aid, this is now full on cult.

What we need is a thread on all the meaningless nonsense that has been presented as the latest thing, and gobble up. Don't you guys look in the rear view mirror? Nonsense comes from all directions pretty much. But some of it rises to cult status, those are the gems. Disproves the whole "you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear" thingie.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#56

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

TomD

OK, that is why they blew me off in the store, because some of the edges I wanted to grind were mid-hard like some 4140. I knew it was something like that. Or carbide or HSS, but those are common in wood turning.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#57

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin your shop

TomD

"However during the discussion, someone warned us that there are some materials that should never be ground on a CBN wheel, because they will ruin the wheel. Among these materials were Aluminum. Can anyone give me a list of verboten materials?"

As you know, but someone may not, grinding aluminum can cause a serious fire. I do most serious grinding outside of the shop, so I am not to worried.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#58

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

TomD

"When you start the grinder, you don't need to walk away, out of the line of fire, while the wheel comes up to speed."

This is a major thing. Was wondering though, whether anyone has blown up a wheel, running at 1800 or less, and behaving sensibly. I never have. Having had bowls blow, I never want to see it. I don't stand in front of wheels when sharpening, which comes from wanting to the see the bevels, but has safety benefits also. Making knives, or blades I do stand in front, but it is always a belt machine in that case.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#59

Re: Grinding theory

David Weaver

Actually, it did seem like a pretty intelligent statement given the lack of disposable income in the late 1700s.

And it turned out to be correct whereas Larry's posts were full of elaborate assumptions that turned out not to be true.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#60

Re: CBN Wheel - How to Ruin One?

david weaver

I often wonder the same thing. Cutlers in the 18th century got killed with wheels, and I'm sure it's possible for someone to get hurt by a breaking wheel in a small grinder, but I've never seen anyone who actually has.

I think the odds are too low to worry about. BUT, it's a good idea to stand out of the arc of a wheel because you *can* feel grit and metal particles coming off of the wheel, and stuff embeds in eyes really easily, even on the rebound under glasses sometimes.

I got a very slow speed metal fragment (just a little non-sharp piece that looked like a grain of sand) in my eye a few years ago, and while it wasn't particularly catastrophic, I still had to go to the ER to get it removed. It stuck to the surface of my eye and embedded a little bit, right in the middle of the pupil. I could SEE it as a blurry spot. It came off of one of those bench top BELT sanders.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#61

Re: Grinding Wheels - How to Ruin Your Day

William Duffield

Here is a safety video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaoVqUpOrPs

I figure I'm not the only one who ever walks through my shop, so I have no control over what abuse might accidentally happen to a grinder wheel.

I often wonder how many tool accidents occur that we never hear about, either because whoever they happened to is no longer woodworking, no longer typing (or even no longer breathing) due to the accident. And in industrial settings, some management covers these things up because knowledge of the accidents is bad for business.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#62

Re: Grinding Wheels - How to Ruin Your Day

david weaver

I deal in numerical reasonability every day. Videos like the one you showed (I didn't watch the whole thing, admittedly) come to us via the internet. If 5 people a year have been harmed by 6 inch bench grinder wheels, it still isn't something worth being concerned about. More people would be hurt tripping on the steps going into the shop. But those 5 with the grinder injuries will end up on the internet and in a safety video because safety isn't just first now in corporate CYA education videos, it's first through 200th. Point I'm getting to is that when something is truly dangerous and occurs with some frequency, you will not have to extend outside of people that you have personally met to find someone affected by it.

I've never personally met someone who was hurt by a 6 or 8 inch bench grinder wheel, and I'm a little suspect of comparing folks who are sharpening woodworking tools vs. a work environment where low wage new employees are working unsupervised and sticking hardened steel pieces into a grinder with a guard, or setting the rest far away and jamming something in the wheel.

So, exploding wheels? Possible. Likely? Not as likely as a table saw injury, a bath tub fall, chisel laceration, hair in a drill press, tripping on your steps..... Or in my shop, not as likely as a powered strop shooting a sharp iron straight into the floor hard enough that it bounced all the way to the ceiling, or a pretty significant cut from accidentally touching the side of a running sanding belt.

The rules change when lots of other people are in your shop, but this one probably doesn't rise to the level of concern for most woodworkers - especially if the front of the wheel is used and the rest is snugged tight to it.

(side story about steps - older lady lived across from me when I was a kid. She tripped on her step and got knocked out cold sometime before an ice storm - enough time before that she cooled off and the freezing rain froze to her. She had bushes in front of her side steps for privacy - nobody could see that she fell. The neighbor kid went to her house after the ice storm and found her on her steps - laying flat on her back and encased in almost an inch of ice. The state police took an unbelievable number of pictures of her, and since the snow had a layer of ice on top of it, the flash reflected probably half a mile - pictures after dark, of course - like lightning flashes).

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#63

Re: Grinding Wheels - How to Ruin Your Day

John in NM

I don't agree with the employer comment - grinder accidents tend to be too gory to "cover up", and I've yet to meet any professional shop hand who will tell the boss "no, I'll cover the med bills on this one, no need for your premiums to go up". Much more likely is home shop accidents being under reported, because many of us don't seek med care when we probably ought to.

To some degree, David has a point regarding grinder size, but they are still tools that are stealthily dangerous, because they don't seem especially aggressive.

Most accidents I've heard of are wheels coming apart through a number of mis-deeds, usually never dressing them so they get loaded and out of balance (can happen with steel even, but most commonly seen when grinding aluminum), or damaged by over tightening the nut. Less common is a too low speed wheel used on a high speed grinder - its actually a little hard to accidentally get a wheel that isn't rated for the bulk of grinders out there. One should also never use a wheel that's been dropped on the floor (usually they show evidence of it).

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#64

Re: Grinding Wheels - How to Ruin Your Day

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William, the incident that we usually associate with dry grinders is the wheel exploding. This is usually attributed to a flaw in the wheel, perhaps from it being dropped in manufacture, packaging or the shop. This is not going to occur with a CBN wheel. Guards may be left off for that reason, which would be a Big No No with vitreous wheels.

The second issue, which was a concern of mine, is the dust from the vitreous wheel. The Norton 3X wheels were the worst in this regard in my experience. They are designed to be friable (to remain cool) and they shed everywhere. CBN wheels do not shed this dust. Both machines do shed metal dust, however I was informed by a woodworker friend (whose day job was testing the air for dust and contaminates in surgeries) that the metal "dust" is not hazardous (the parts are too large to lodge in the lungs).

A third advantage of the CBN wheel relates to its lack of wear. The sharpening set up remains consistent, and this contributes to safety.

Of course, my mindset is about reasonably experienced woodworkers who are sensible about risks. Then again, the others do not read WoodCentral! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#65

Interesting...

Tony-Memphis

I used to work designing race car parts. Camshafts were our main product. We had probably a dozen grinders in the shop that used 17" wheels. Not sure what RPM they turned, but it was pretty fast. I worked there for around 8 years and I don't ever recall any wheels exploding. Not sure what the wheels were made of - been a long time. I do recall that the guy that sold us our diamond dressers REALLY liked us! I think we made him quite rich!

Grinding cam lobes was quite a science. A lot of effort into stopping/starting techniques and such. Our old style grinders required some finesse and skill. As measurement techniques got better, I could actually see the spot where the grinder left the lobe in some cases.

Tony

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#66

Re: Who knows someone injured..

david weaver

..by a grinding wheel that broke without being abused by something like a trapped tool due to setting a rest far off, dropped wheel, stabbing something hard in the side of a stone meant to be used on the edge, etc?

Or who has seen a wheel like that spontaneously explode themselves?

I don't know anyone.

I know several people who have removed fingertips in jointers, etc.

My move to the CBN had more to do with economy and convenience. I found with the pink wheels that I wished I'd had dust collection hooked to my grinder, and my grinder is close to my drill press, so when I'd use the drill press, I had to vacuum off the flotsam and jetsam.

I play it as safe as possible when it comes to table saws and chop saws, and wear safety glasses and stay out of the arc of the flying grit now, and never turn without safety glasses on a powered lathe (if I turned bigger stuff, it would be a face shield). That's where you will find yourself heading to the hospital in all likelihood.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#67

Read some metalworking forums...

John in NM

There are a fair number of firsthand accounts - one I remember was due to an angle grinder, and was a useful reminder to me to NOT throw away those pesky guards :D (I remove the guard when using sanding disks, and am now more diligent about putting it back for vitreous wheels).

The supposed cause in that case was overtightening the nut, causing damage to the disk -- it had happened to the guy twice and he said he was very careful about not dropping the grinder.

While I'm the first to be skeptical (as many here will remember :D ) I've seen enough reports of this to believe it. I don't turn on my grinder and walk away, but then mine has its full set of guards and the wheels get dressed now and then. Out of balance wheels are probably the greatest risk, but on 6-8 inch grinders even that is minimal.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#68

Re: Read some metalworking forums...

david weaver

Angle grinders are another thing entirely - a 15 amp 7 inch angle grinder is an extremely strong tool.

(and it can hurt you no problem without ever having a wheel break).

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#69

Re: Grinding theory of breakers

TomD

Doubtless considering the source, it was intelligent, just playing along. Yeah, it may have cost more, and it may have been better, but there are many situations where it is not better. It's an oversimplification. Where it fails is in the binary choice, for starters. I do remember reading that stuff, but don't recall whether Larry was claiming that there is no situation whatsoever where a breaker has any advantage, in anyone's hands, for any class of work. That is a possible contention, but a poor rhetorical stance, and not one I would want to defend. But whether the breaker's additional cost is evidence that there is no situation or even a wide range of situations, where a single blade is better, is taking on too much for the breaker side.

And what cost are we referring to? In it's cheapest form it is the cost of a few nails (contemporary historical). If the breakers leads one down the wormhole of metal bodies, screw adjusters and all that, maybe the cost is high, but there is no need for any of that, not even a screw.

Overall planes have generally become more costly and not in the least better, so there is that also. The general trend is not convincing. So in your case, David, you are good with Bailey, and wooden classic western planes having tried everything else? Is the most refined Norris evidence that the planes you seem to currently prefer are crap?

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#70

Re: Grinding Wheels - How to Ruin Your Day

TomD

I certainly take seriously the dangers, I was just curious how common the explosions are. I think the particulates issue is serious, though easy enough to extract. All around, sounds like a better product, and not expensive in the big scheme of things.

I think the whole friable wheel thing may be a bit of a scam. If one has any idea at all what one is doing around a wheel, there is no excuse for burning steel, and one should not choose a wheel on that basis. ridiculous with turning tools that are mostly unburnable. That said, it is so long since I replaced a wheel, that I don't recall which wheels are best for what steel. If ever I knew. A wheel that melts like ice cream seems an unlikely choice though. It also seems unlikely the hard wheels are right as they are designed to cut tool bits which are mostly friction reduced, so the idea is to get the heat way the heck up there, with the wheel at high speed. Making the right choice of machine and wheel helps a lot. I have never had cause to regret my choice of an 8" 1750 rig.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#71

Re: Grinding theory of breakers

david weaver

Here's what I gathered from Larry's comments, bullet points so as to not be as long as necessary:

* double iron planes were more cheaply made planes (there is some room for squish with the double iron, but not that much, they still have to be made properly, but they do take seasonal adjustment better - usually needing none)

* the cap iron set distance is too hard to actually do (that's not true, we found that out - it's very easy to do by eye, but it would probably be difficult if you felt the need to measure it)

* the iron can only cut between the fingers on the wedge (meaning you have to camber the corners out of the cut) or the plane will clog. (that's also not true - I don't think Larry examined the design of the terminus of the fingers and the cap iron in combination close enough, or maybe he had low quality planes).

* all of the old single iron planes were preferred and used up (that was really reaching - we'd see the heavily used planes if they were ever sold in numbers)

Todd's contention was, and I know cap irons are cheap now, but they weren't originally (we can't view the cost of a cap iron through a current lens)...anyway, his contention was that from a blacksmithing standpoint, they are very costly to make. And they were, causing double iron planes to be about 50% more expensive than single irons in catalogs, and that never went away. It's not just that they were costly that makes them better. It's that they were costly and people with very little money chose them almost exclusively - despite the cost. Those things together are what todd was going for, and odds are that he's right.

George suggested that Larry found the cost of making double irons a problem. Larry gave an indirect answer, but I think some of that is relevant. To make a cap iron that would look reasonable in a plane with a 250 year-old look, it's still costly. In a plane that uses $75 of materials or a little less, spending an hour to or two to make a nice cap iron without being able to increase the cost of the plane is problematic. It also necessitates abutments terminating in the wear, and a bit more difficulty in getting everything clean inside the plane, as well as more potential for troubleshooting clogging. If you have a supply of identical cap irons, you can design that out and come up with something reliable. The other problem is when your main customer doesn't allow cap irons (the curators at wmsbg decided they weren't common enough and required craftsmen there to use single iron planes), as well as many customers needing a plane that is simple and requires less inclination - which is true of single iron when you don't know how to use a cap iron.

In terms of whether a cap iron is always better - of course not. Cross grain planing, they do nothing and can blow out the side of cut worse than without. Softwood planing that's all down grain, there's no reason to use them. Same with end grain - nothing there. Very thin shavings, same thing - no need for them if the shaving doesn't have enough strenght It's everything else that caused them to dominate.

re: the norris planes. I have three pre-war norris planes and a pre-war spiers, pre-war mathieson (2 of those - one is made by norris, though). They do work OK without the cap iron set. The implication is that they were great planes to smooth with without using the cap iron. The reality is that they were carefully made with super-high quality cap irons (Ward in the old ones, and a very good design either made by norris or sorby in later ones), and they work better with the cap iron than without - it just isn't discussed much. Norris could've made a single iron plane with a tight mouth more cheaply than they made theirs, but they very intentionally made the relief at the mouth filed so that the cap iron would work all the way down. And they paid the extra cost for expensive parallel double irons instead of cheaper single irons (and their customers did, too). Only the modern bevel down planes show up in numbers. A workman probably wouldn't have tolerated an infill plane that couldn't take a shaving thicker than 2 or 3 thousandths like is the case with the ideal single iron setup. They probably wouldn't have liked what those planes do with pine when they are high angle, either.

I have used all of the other types, yes. Continental, and a fair bit with the japanese planes. I can't say why I opted for western planes over japanese - both of them work fine with a cap, and if you are just looking for surface brightness, nothing beats a japanese plane. It probably has something to do with sharpening time and more difficulty in getting a dead flat surface or dead flat jointed edge with a japanese plane. Or sole wear with japanese planes and the need to tune often, seasonal movement, etc. I don't have anything against them and still have a couple of them, though. I think you've said it before, and others have -I don't buy into the idea that any of them are a good buy at $1,000 - the sweet spot seems to be around the same cost as US boutique planes, and a lot of the really cheap stuff in japan is still good - unlike the third world made metal planes.

I do like japanese natural stones with tools from anywhere, just as well as I like the washita. Vintage carbon steel loves japanese natural stones.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#72

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Gary B.

David,

Thanks for the advice. As a follow up; I ended up buying a Soft and a Hard Arkansas (Dan's) through LV that I'm pretty happy with. It's great to sharpen something and get right back to work. It definitely takes a few more strokes, but the overall process is MUCH faster. I used 3 in 1 oil as a lubricant, because it's what I had on hand. I called Dan's and they said it'd be fine.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#73

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

david weaver

Glad to hear it, Gary. I think that's a very practical setup, it's practically fad proof and the stones will outlast you as long as you don't drop them on a hard floor.

(and it's quick with no faffing).