Re: Grinding theory of breakers
david weaver
Here's what I gathered from Larry's comments, bullet points so as to not be as long as necessary:
* double iron planes were more cheaply made planes (there is some room for squish with the double iron, but not that much, they still have to be made properly, but they do take seasonal adjustment better - usually needing none)
* the cap iron set distance is too hard to actually do (that's not true, we found that out - it's very easy to do by eye, but it would probably be difficult if you felt the need to measure it)
* the iron can only cut between the fingers on the wedge (meaning you have to camber the corners out of the cut) or the plane will clog. (that's also not true - I don't think Larry examined the design of the terminus of the fingers and the cap iron in combination close enough, or maybe he had low quality planes).
* all of the old single iron planes were preferred and used up (that was really reaching - we'd see the heavily used planes if they were ever sold in numbers)
Todd's contention was, and I know cap irons are cheap now, but they weren't originally (we can't view the cost of a cap iron through a current lens)...anyway, his contention was that from a blacksmithing standpoint, they are very costly to make. And they were, causing double iron planes to be about 50% more expensive than single irons in catalogs, and that never went away. It's not just that they were costly that makes them better. It's that they were costly and people with very little money chose them almost exclusively - despite the cost. Those things together are what todd was going for, and odds are that he's right.
George suggested that Larry found the cost of making double irons a problem. Larry gave an indirect answer, but I think some of that is relevant. To make a cap iron that would look reasonable in a plane with a 250 year-old look, it's still costly. In a plane that uses $75 of materials or a little less, spending an hour to or two to make a nice cap iron without being able to increase the cost of the plane is problematic. It also necessitates abutments terminating in the wear, and a bit more difficulty in getting everything clean inside the plane, as well as more potential for troubleshooting clogging. If you have a supply of identical cap irons, you can design that out and come up with something reliable. The other problem is when your main customer doesn't allow cap irons (the curators at wmsbg decided they weren't common enough and required craftsmen there to use single iron planes), as well as many customers needing a plane that is simple and requires less inclination - which is true of single iron when you don't know how to use a cap iron.
In terms of whether a cap iron is always better - of course not. Cross grain planing, they do nothing and can blow out the side of cut worse than without. Softwood planing that's all down grain, there's no reason to use them. Same with end grain - nothing there. Very thin shavings, same thing - no need for them if the shaving doesn't have enough strenght It's everything else that caused them to dominate.
re: the norris planes. I have three pre-war norris planes and a pre-war spiers, pre-war mathieson (2 of those - one is made by norris, though). They do work OK without the cap iron set. The implication is that they were great planes to smooth with without using the cap iron. The reality is that they were carefully made with super-high quality cap irons (Ward in the old ones, and a very good design either made by norris or sorby in later ones), and they work better with the cap iron than without - it just isn't discussed much. Norris could've made a single iron plane with a tight mouth more cheaply than they made theirs, but they very intentionally made the relief at the mouth filed so that the cap iron would work all the way down. And they paid the extra cost for expensive parallel double irons instead of cheaper single irons (and their customers did, too). Only the modern bevel down planes show up in numbers. A workman probably wouldn't have tolerated an infill plane that couldn't take a shaving thicker than 2 or 3 thousandths like is the case with the ideal single iron setup. They probably wouldn't have liked what those planes do with pine when they are high angle, either.
I have used all of the other types, yes. Continental, and a fair bit with the japanese planes. I can't say why I opted for western planes over japanese - both of them work fine with a cap, and if you are just looking for surface brightness, nothing beats a japanese plane. It probably has something to do with sharpening time and more difficulty in getting a dead flat surface or dead flat jointed edge with a japanese plane. Or sole wear with japanese planes and the need to tune often, seasonal movement, etc. I don't have anything against them and still have a couple of them, though. I think you've said it before, and others have -I don't buy into the idea that any of them are a good buy at $1,000 - the sweet spot seems to be around the same cost as US boutique planes, and a lot of the really cheap stuff in japan is still good - unlike the third world made metal planes.
I do like japanese natural stones with tools from anywhere, just as well as I like the washita. Vintage carbon steel loves japanese natural stones.