Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Posts

Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#1

Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Gary B.

I've been thinking about my sharpening routing lately. truth is, I'm not sharpening as often as I know I should because it's inconvenient, and stops my workflow. the tools of my current method include an 8" x 2" combination waterstone (1000/4000 grit) I purchased years ago from lee valley, and their green stuff, on MDF.

The trouble is I've stored the stone dry, as I didn't like the stagnant water situation when storing it wet. I tend to soak the stone before use for 10-15 min. So, when sharpening is needed, I'm out of the woodworking game for 20-25 min (soaking, then sharpening, flattening the stone and putting everything back). What are others doing with waterstones to make it faster?

I've been watching the diamond stone craze (Paul Sellers and others) and am envious of a method that would get me back to work in a few minutes. If diamonds really are that much better, then I'd consider moving to them.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#2

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

roger lance

If you find sharpening to be inconvenient; then, make it convenient for you.

I use waterstones. But, I have a plumbed wet sink and an adjoining sharpening station. Sharpening is convenient for me.....and touching up a blade is easy.

There are many examples of sharpening set-ups on YouTube that might work for you. Rob Cosman uses a diamond stone and a waterstone at his bench for example that is convenient, simple, and fast.....and doesn't require a sink.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#3

A hollow grind is the key. *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Gary

There are so many methods, and they all work. This is what works for me.

You don't need fancy equipment for sharpening (well, bar one item, which is optional. More in a while). What you do need is a strategy. My strategy is geared towards re-sharpening. This sound obvious, but there are many less efficient methods around. I am able to re-sharpen a chisel or plane blade somewhere between 30 - 60 seconds.

The basis of re-sharpening is a hollow grind. Furthermore, I grind right up to the edge of the bevel. This leaves very little to steel to hone, which is the reason why sharpening is so quick. Add to this, do not leave honing until the edge is clearly dull. A semi-sharp edge is quicker to re-fresh.

The absolute best grinding wheel is a CBN on a dry grinder (I use an 8" half-speed machine). I've been using these for a few years now, and they grind cool, and do not require any upkeep. I used a Tormek for a decade, but the dry grinder combination is many times faster and works almost a cool. CBN wheels will last decades. All you need is a 180 grit (I have an 80 grit as well for heavy steel removal).


The blade guide here is from the Tormek (and available as an accessory). I use it as it automates grinding angles, which is part of the system. It also aids in creating a smooth-edged hollow. This reduces steps in honing. I set up the hollow angle at the angle I plan to hone. I do all my honing freehand, and directly on the hollow. The hollow acts as a jig to balance the blade.

With this setup you can use just about any honing media. My preference is between two setups: either a Shapton Pro 1000, followed by a Sigma 6000 and 13000. Or followed by a Spyderco Medium and Ultrafine. I complete the honing with Lee Valley green compound on hardwood.

For all the media I need between 2-3 strokes only. Really, that's it.

This is an example of a honed chisel after an initial grinding. Note that no further grinding is needed for quite a long time. The microbevel remains "micro" through several sharpenings. At this stage it is possible to just hone with a 6000 and 13000.


Regards from Perth

Derek


Ultimate Grinding and Sharpening Setup

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#4

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

david weaver

Gary, you'd be very well served to track down a norton fine india or combination india stone, a good quality soft arkansas or cheap hard (like what Dan's calls hard, which isn't a black or trans, but a step lower than that in quality and much less price) and then to your loaded strop.

Grinding well opens the door to using anything. I use a single washita most of the time. It needs no maintenance other than wiping slough off of the stone from time to time, and when you get good with it, you can get a very good edge in about a minute (from a dull tool).

Washitas are a little harder to find and they're not new. You can go that avenue, but an india and a decent finer stone is inexpensive and extremely capable (you can sharpen anything with that combination, and you can sharpen carving tools, etc, on those if you ever choose to, which diamonds aren't that great for).

I posted a video recently just experimenting with A2 and V11 with a washita (which is supposed to be unable to sharpen them). I sharpen something three times in it and then plane to prove a point (that there is no lack of sharpness). While I make mention that I don't think V11 is good for the washita only, it is extremely easy to sharpen with an india and then the washita (substitute what dans calls "hard" for a low price and less hassle unless you want to trouble with finding an actual washita of some vintage and flatten it). Carbon steel (O1, vintage, whatever type) is less eventful than this. I'll apologize in advance for my videos being esoteric, disorganized, too long and not edited or produced, but the point is made in this one.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7HjCFphaNk

I wouldn't even go back to sharpening these two types of steel on waterstones, it would be a waste of time. You need no resources nearby to use oilstones (no water, etc) and they are ready regardless of shop temperature or time between uses. A good quality grind is all that's needed.

I have a little problem (overbuying) with stones and have played with just about everything out there - nothing is better in the context of actual use, unless you just can't get along with freehand use (I suspect you're able to freehand if you're using 8x2 stones).

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#5

Hollow grind...

John in NM

Then use whatever to hone. At that point it won't matter much, oilstone, waterstone, etc, it will be quick.

For diamond sharpening I dislike the bonded plates. Loose grit on cast iron is the way to go - hardest part of that is finding an iron plate.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#6

Re: A hollow grind is the key.

Gary B.

Derek,

Thanks for the great response. I read your article, and you make some great points. I do have a 6" grinder with the LV rest setup. It currrently has an 80 grit wheel on it (the original). I suppose I could upgrade to a Norton 3x wheel until I get something better.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#7

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Gary B.

Thanks for the response David! I just watched your video (and subscribed). I've never thought of oilstones, but after watching it, I like the ease of all of it. (and certainly the price over the DMT plates) I think I could set up the stones under my bench with a strop, and be back to work in short order.

were you using WD-40 as a lubricant?

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#8

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Todd Stock

Two stone system for most stuff. C/XC DuoSharp DMT and 4000/8000 Norton or Shapton equivalent. Waterstone gets flattened on the diamond stone's XC side. I grind at 25 deg, and generally don not regrind until the honed bevel is close to 1/3-1/2 way cross the face.

For a dull blade, I hone at 30 deg...the old edge gets knocked off with a swipe on the coarse side of the DMT, then directly to the 8000, which gets a mist of water (does not require soaking, but does not hurt it). Most edges can be rehoned quickly...60 seconds is not unusual if I don't dawdle.

For the once-in-lifetime back of blade flattening, 80/120/220 3M Gold on dead flat surface gets me to the point where I can finish with diamond on plates or sandpaper, then 4000/8000 stones.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#9

considering a wheel?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Visit the article I wrote in the Articles Section on wheel selection.

Personally, I regard the Norton 3X wheels as a marketing success. Norton has added a bit of their expensive seeded gel abrasive to an aluminum oxide wheel and marketed it successfully as a superior solution to sharpening woodworking stuff.

If you need the benefits of the seeded gel abrasive then buy a commercial seeded gel wheel. I think it might make sense for a turner that sharpens tool steel regularly. For the small amount of grinding someone sharpening chisels will experience, any soft bond aluminum oxide wheel will do nicely. It is greatly underappreciated that the wheel bond hardness is what sharpeners should focus on.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#10

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

david weaver

Yes, WD 40 in a trigger container. I don't like the aerosol cans - they blow a fine mist of WD 40 everywhere.

Light mineral oil is fine, too

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#11

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Gary and all,

To speed things up, the first thing is hollow grind, as others have mentioned. I do encourage you to read Bill T's article, because you already have a grinder and mainly need a softer wheel. Bill explains it all, including technique. Technique matters because you don't want to blue your irons or chisels.

The second thing to speed things up is to get to a primary burr 'right now', immediately. And in choosing your stones, you want to avoid lots of slurry and mess. With this in mind, I suggest a 1000ish fixed diamond stone, because it needs no charging, doesn't create a messy slurry you have to get off the side of your paw before you get back to work. I really, really like the Atoma 1200 to get an immediate primary burr, so you know there's no wear bevel hiding at the edge of the blade. And it's clean. I don't use diamond on Japanese steel, but do on anything else.

Once you have a primary burr, almost anything can be used for honing. If you're happy with what you have, use that. If you want to eliminate wet operations and stone flattening altogether, take David's advice and find a good oil stone. I use a 10,000g or 13000g water stone right after the Atoma, with only a water sprayer, which doesn't require plumbed water, but that road does lead to stone flattening, which may be a time waster for you. In which case David has one solution. Another might be Spyderco, but I have no experience with those.

Wiley

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

Jack Guzman from Maine

Gary I hollow grind and use diamond paste on cast iron for honing. Makes sharpening alot less of a chore. However,I still occasionally use my king water stones. I keep them in a covered plastic container and add bleach to the water. It helps keep it clear.---Jack

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#13

Grinder wheel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Gary, a 6" grinder is fine. I used one before I purchased the 8" about 10 years ago. It just creates a deeper hollow. My preference is a shallow hollow, which is one of the reasons I liked the Tormek (but the T is soooo slow).

Do not get those horrid blue 3X wheels! Not unless you like to wear a mask and enjoy cleaning up grit. The wheels are very friable - to keep grinding cool - and they shed all over the show.

Look, it's a new world now. The white, pink and blue wheels are OUT. CBN is IN :) There is a 6" version available for your grinder.

Many years ago, Joel wrote a wonderful article for FWW magazine on using a cambered wheel on the grinder. The aim was to reduce surface area and increase accuracy. It is still the method to use ... on a friable wheel. But the CBN does not need a cambered wheel. Get a FLAT CBN wheel with square edges (read my article why).

The advantage of the CBN wheel is that it is made of steel or hardened aluminium, and balanced at the factory. They run amzingly silently. The wheels are heavy and some machines may need a push to get the momentum going. My grinder is 1 hp. Once started, my wheels take 8 1/2 minutes to slow to a stop.

The wheels are electroplated with a layer of Cubic Boron Nitride. This is close to the hardness of diamond, but it does not wear (as diamond will do). The advantage here is that these wheels never need to be dressed. They never lose their size (and therefore all settings stay constant). And the wheels remain sharp ... well, they have been around some decades and early ones are still in daily use.

CBN has been used by turners for probably a decade. I am not sure why flat woodworkers have not heard of them. I discovered them about 2 1/2 years ago only, mentioned them on a couple of forums, and the responses came back indicating they were little known. Dave Weaver bought one after this, became a convert, and he will no doubt agree with what I write. Many are now turning onto these wheels. They are the future now.

The wheels are wideer than the vitreous wheels. About an 1 1/2" and straight/ flat. This allows one to present the blade to the wheel square on. There is very little heat created. You can burn an edge, but you need to be a real klutz to do so (I am half a klutz and have never burnt a blade).

A 180 grit wheel has the advantage of creating a smooth primary bevel. A vitreous wheel is best used at about 38 grit. Much higher than this and it creates too much heat. The smoother primary bevel reduces a step in honing - where often the first stone is use to straighten and smooth off the ragged edge. There are even finer grits available - up to 350 grit - however that will create heat and is really intended for turners with HSS chisels. I have a 80 grit wheel as well, but hardly use it.

Buy a CBN wheel, pay once, and then enjoy it for a very long time!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#14

Re: Grinder wheel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Derek,

Many thanks. This is the first real discussion I've seen (of course there's a lot I miss).

Wiley

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#15

Stones

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Gary, there are so many types of stones. I am far from an expert here. David is much more knowledgeable than I. However I can make a comment thta may help.

I use waterstones which use less water and stay harder longer than the older school or natural stones. There are a few around, but my chose is Shapton for the 1000 (fantastic 1000), and Sigma for the 6000 and 13000. These stones are great with abrasion-resistant steels.

However, the stones that are more likely to interest you are the Spyderco. These are ceramic. They are available in a Medium (about 2000-3000 grit) and a Ultra Fine (about 6000-8000 grit). This stones are HARD ... harder than oil stones! They do not wear, and their only upkeep is to scrub them every now and then. I use them with a spritz of water, but they may be used dry. They are clean stones.

I tend to finish on green compound, but the edge off the UF is good enough for most.

The only issue with these stones is that some may come will a very slight hump in the centre, as they are baked in manufacture. The hollow is removed with a coarse diamond stone, but thereafter they reman flat. My brown Medium was flat, but the white Ultra Fine needed a little levelling. Both have remained flat in the three years of use. I think of these stones as the oil stone of the waterstone world.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#16

I agree 100%..

david weaver

Chris Griggs found me a deal on a pink wheel long ago, and it was better than the brown one that I was using - much less dressing.

When I noticed the pink wheel losing diameter quickly and saw that the wheel that I liked (6" camel) was about $50 to replace, I followed derek's (and a few others') advice and found a bargain CBN wheel for $125. It has been nothing less than stellar. If it doesn't last at least a decade, I'll be surprised. I wouldn't be surprised if it lasted several decades.

I have my grinder backed into a corner so that it throws all of its grit into the corner, but all that gets thrown now is metal particles.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#17

Get a plastic tub with a lid

Kees

From reading your post it seems that you loose most time in soaking the stones. Just get a tub with a lid. Fill it with fresh water when you start working, or once a week, or whatever schedule you like and close the tub with the lid. Then you can perma soak your stones and only need to pull them out of the water when needed and they are ready to go. No stagnant water problem, because of the lid it will stay fresh a lot longer.

For flattening I had a bucket of water just outside of the shop. When you fill this bucket in the morning, it won't go stale during the day.

But oilstones relieved me of all these troubles and I like them a lot better. Especially in the winter :D

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#18

I disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"A vitreous wheel is best used at about 38 grit." I don't grind my lawn mower blades on something this coarse, or farm machinery. If anyone needs, for whatever reason, a 36 grit wheel to grind a chisel I can see why they would be motivated to find some other grinding media.

I have successfully demonstrated hollow grinding with all sorts of wheels except the black wheels that come with grinders, which are an exceptionally hard bond. The wheel I have used for years, which I had custom made, is a 120 grit pink aluminum oxide wheel, with an exceptional soft bond, H as I recall. I chose it to slow down the rate of grinding. If it ever wears out I will replace it with a 100 or 80 grit. At the time it cost about $30. It's only disadvantage is that it does shed grits, which is why I rarely have to dress it and it grinds cool, even at 120 grit. If I was to recommend a wheel , first I would have the prospective buyer check machine shop supply places (like MSC) for 1/2" x 7" surface grinder wheels. They are cheap and provided me an inexpensive way to evaluate wheel bond, particle size and composition. An 80 grit pink wheel in an H, I or J bond is a good place to start, for about $15. Such a wheel in an H or I bond will be too soft for lathe tools.

From my perspective the reason not to buy a Norton 3X wheel for woodworking tools is that they are too hard and don't shed grits enough.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#19

Re: I disagree

Brian Holcombe

A good diamond dresser is in itself more expensive than a CBN wheel. I have a rough grit (120?) CBN for grinding work I don't really use it on anything laminated unless I have to fix something but on the remaining full steel tools that I have I use it regularly.

My procedure is to remove the wear bevel first with a 600 grit stone, then remove the wire edge with a fine stone. Next I restore the hollow at 25 degrees then re-apply the final edge with a finish stone and again remove the wire edge. I use a dry cordovan strop to ensure that the edge is clean.

My sharpening of western irons is pretty quick, especially with the wheel.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#20

I disagree too

John in NM

There's nothing wrong with CBN wheels, but at $150 or so they are not going to be for everyone. The job can be done with a $50 bench grinder and the horrible stock wheels that come with them. It just gets easier and more pleasant the better the tools get.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#21

Re: I disagree

Gary B.

Hi Bill,

I spent some time this morning looking over your article, and trying to find a suitable wheel. I can't seem to find one that meets the specs you mention for sharpening that is a 6" wheel. The closest I've found so far is just a simple white norton.

Here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001DSZ364/_encoding=UTF8?coliid=IF9TWEK18OLDP&colid=2DOEC8FYHCFVQ

Does that work? or would you suggest something different?

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#22

Re: Grinder wheel

Gary B.

Derek,

Where have you found a 6" CBN? I haven't seen that size yet.

At one point I was a member of a turning club, and they had much the same setup as your pic above. (8" half speed) It was neat using it.

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#23

More than about cost.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

John, some will look at the cost (around the $200 mark) and say, "too expensive". That is a personal decision. On the other hand, when one asks, "what will make grinding easier, safer/cooler/less dust, and longer-lasting?", then the answer is a CBN wheel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help speeding up my sharpening routine

#25

Sure...

John in NM

As I said, there is nothing wrong with CBN.

One just has to remember that for some of us money is an influence on how we have to work. I have fairly easily learned to grind with a friable wheel and don't have overheating problems. Was it worth it for me? Yes, definitely. Others can determine whether it's worth it to them or not.