Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

What makes the "handtool" look?

Posts

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#76

Re: Virtue?

Brian Holcombe

I find that hard to believe, in the way that you show your family member (nephew?) the way to build properly. I think there is more virtue in your work than you realize.

I that is likely better than to intentionally build something with a virtuous effort in mind.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#77

Re: Virtue?

John in NM

I have to agree with Bill - the idea that there is virtue in simply doing the job as well as possible is a little strange to me.

The reason is because virtue is a distinctly moral concept, whereas executing one's work as well as possible is simply the way to end up with the best possible result.

While one can argue that virtue and work ethic have some distinct similarities, to confuse the two is to risk cheapening virtue.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#78

Sorry, didn't read your post very well

Kees

So, here is a better reply.

I don't really have an argument, I a looking for a direction for my future endeavors. At the moment I am living the 17th century, with some cupboards, and a mirror later on, all for our bathroom. It's going to be a modern bathroom, with some of these ancient designs in it.

I really like this work, it speaks to me. I also like real antiques. But i don't think I will fill the entire house with medieval copies. So I am still at a loss what will be next.

I am looking for more life in my designs. I was wondering if handtools can be helpfull in this regard. It certainly seems to help in those antiques when you look at the details. It also certainly helps in blacksmith work, something I admire too, and in antique tools which I greatly amire. But I need a more thourough understanding of what handtools can deliver. And this discussion is very helpfull.

But it isn't a conclusion.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#79

Re: Affectation Vs. Artifact

TomD

Well, in all likelihood, for most of us, it is all affected. It takes a lifetime to develop a sincere personal style, if one wants to jump around a lot in the process there is virtually no hope that one will do anything other than pretend. The key to a style such as Yanagi referred to was to be unaware one was doing anything special. Women have nursed children for millions of years, but today it would be perfectly reasonable for the main thought going through one's head to be whether one was being virtuous in any of a dozen dictated ways. Virtue is a fine thing. But the person who said "the unexamined life isn't worth living" was an extremist of sorts.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#80

Re: Virtue?

david weaver

RTA furniture would do those things for less than the cost of materials for us.

If that doesn't suit, auctions are full of old stuff that needs only a little attention to be good to go for another 100 years.

I've got three pieces of RTA furniture in my house that I'd like to replace. I have to admit, they work just fine for what they are, and my wife is chief in charge of policing so that nothing ever gets a dent in our house (nothing would fare so well if I was to police that).

One of the pieces was $200 (it is, of course, utilitarian at best), and my wife would like me to replace it with something similar made of walnut. It's going to cost me at least a thousand dollars for the wood.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#81

Re: Virtue?

Todd Stock

Virtue: conformity to a standard of right; a particular moral excellence; a beneficial quality or power of a thing

Virtue Signaling: The conspicuous expression of moral values by an individual done primarily with the intent of enhancing that person's standing within a social group.

In this case, the OP's ask was: "As the caption says, it interests me to know how to enhance the design of a piece so it is OBVIOUSLY (emphasis added) made with hand tools. What makes it look like it didn't roll out of a machine shop?"

The key here is the judgement by the OP (and most of the rest of us) that handmade is superior to not-handmade (hence, "...enhance the design...") and what signals that superiority. In this context, virtue signaling is the adjustment of a design to emphasize some element which tells the audience that the object is possessing greater excellence (or virtue) as a consequence of its obviously handmade nature.

Virtue signaling comes out of general signaling theory, but it is an interesting way to look at choices in design, materials, and methods of execution.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#82

Re: Virtue?

Kees

This all goes a bit over my head. I don't think made with handtools IS better, I just LIKE it better. And I put a lot of work into it, it might just as well show that effort.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#83

David Pye's thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

David Pye (1914-1993), an English professor of design, argued that irregularities were inevitable when doing work guided by hand*, and that these irregularities were what made work attractive and human. He was writing in the late 60s, and was NOT a fan of extravagantly and deliberately irregular work - I believe his phrase was "lumpy pots and hairy shirts." In effect, he was arguing for doing work as well as possible while realizing that irregularities would be present.

I think adopting the practices of folks back when hand tools were how work got done is likely to be the best approach. Instead of cutting everything to a measure then putting it together, cutting everything to fit the next part over, for instance.

Myself, I like to see work with subtle signs that a hand, not a machine, made the piece, rather than something that screams, "Hand tool work!"

-------------

*You may be familiar with his distinction between "workmanship of risk," work guided by the craftsman's hand and skill; and "workmanship of certainty," work guided by jigs and fences that allow for no deviations.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#84

Re: David Pye's thoughts

David Weaver

That philosophy would be exactly what I meant when I said hand tool work generally has some life in it. And building to fit rather than building to measure is one of the best reasons to use hand tools.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#85

Further thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

His other statement that stuck with me was that this irregularity repeated at different scales - as you approached a building, for instance, you might see it initially as a slight difference between windows; but when you were close up, you would see it as a slight irregularity in a course of brickwork.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#86

Re: Further thoughts

Todd Stock

In other words, do the best work possible, and allow the nature of that work to speak to your intent.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#87

Re: David Pye's thoughts - Just not true though

TomD

At least up until recently the very finest machine tool work was the result of hand scraped work. I hear modern CNC users bandying around comments about accuracy from really pretty rough machines that are at the hand scraped level, and don't know the the truth of that. But till say the year 2000 it was certainly true that hand work was more accurate, more regular, than machine work.

Something pretty common like a bamboo fly rod is extremely accurate, particularly considering the incredible fact that the material is grass. Accuracy held to better than a thou. And pretty fast.

Pye actually created a a machine to make hand tool work in bowls more "risky". A bit of a brain twister to start with. But it allowed him to set the level of free cutting, and precision his work required. And doubtless the results were beautiful. But he also had a picture in one book of one of those cheap drinking glasses that look like the panes in the glass are configured of drips, or sometime bubbles. These are mass manufactured and have the "diversity" he wanted.

His theory, as I have said here before, reminds me of an extension of the idea in Existentialism of the Pour-soi and the En-soi. I once did an essay in Uni extending Weber along those lines. It's a cheap trick for a high mark. The Pour-soi is the idea of behaviour that is molded by an outside norm, while en-soi is from within. Neither is better than the other, though really you would guess they favour En-soi as more "authentic". But we need waiters and poets. Often the same person. And we need carefully made machines to allow us to create diversity in cutting bowls. Pye falls into the category of talking your way into good work when you have a university degree rather than deep skills. Basically the modern art approach. Would he really have been fascinated by his bowls if he been a top carver in a classical style.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#88

ICBM gyros

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

GE had a plant near where I grew up and in the plant they made the guidance system for the ICBM of that day. It consisted of three beryllium balls that spun to created a X-Y-Z gyroscope. I was told by the father of a friend who worked there that the balls were hand lapped to some boggling tolerance, and the ICBM could hit any football field targeted in Russia.

Weren't telescope mirrors hand lapped in past times.

Never heard of Pye but he seems to have been a better philosopher than engineer.

For most of man's history hand made furniture was a place to put your socks. Now we put our socks, well at least most of us, in furniture made in factories. In contrast, most hand made furniture has become an artist medium to express their creativity.

It is well to not confuse a place to put your socks with art, or art and engineering. What's important is different in each case.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#89

Pye

Brian Holcombe

His work looks pretty nice to me.

Hand made work has encompassed everything from 'a place to put your socks' to a more highly elaborate place to put your hoserie for quite a long time. I recall

a thread on ancient Egyptian woodwork that was highly elaborate.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#90

Visual vs. measurement

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

But Tom, hand scraped work is fascinating visually, because the marks left behind are so irregular/not patterned - as contrasted, for instance, with well-done, utterly symmetrical engine-turned panels.

And, if I'm fitting a door, I'll take a handplane over any machine/electrically powered tool I can think of; it lets me take a few thousandths off the top right corner of the door without the intense jigging that would be needed to accomplish that with a machine.

I think Pye was speaking not of the measurement issue but of how the work appeared.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#91

Confusion

CJ in MPLS

I am of the opinion that there need not be any confusion as between engineering and art. Yes I know that form follows function, but function need not limit form, so long as function is achieved. It is all on a continuum.

Bombe chests, cabriolet legs, and inlay are all artistic expressions of purely functional items. There is rarely a problem with making a useful item look good, though taste does factor into it. I do cringe when people 'age' furniture by beating it up with keys and the like.

BTW, the term 'beryllium balls' is now stuck in my head. Thanks for that.

Re: What makes the "handtool" look?

#92

Re: Confusion

John in NM

I don't think its confusion so much as rejection. I recall hearing an art grad student once disparagingly refer to another as "a good technician". To most engineers that is a compliment.

I don't know what the engineering version of rejecting art is, since I've never discussed it much with any. Perhaps it is simply ignoring it.

Woodworkers and furniture builders are some of the few people I've known who see the two fields as you do - one depending on the other in both cases. Perhaps that is what I like best about woodworkers :D